Bathroom sink stopper not working

Find your stopper type, then fix it from under the sink.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

On this page
  1. Find the cause
  2. Reconnect the rod
  3. Reset the height
  4. Replace the rod
  5. Lock the stopper in
  6. Remove the stopper
  7. Clicker stoppers
  8. Parts
  9. Which part
  10. Myths
  11. Call a plumber
  12. FAQ
  13. How I wrote it

Quick answer

A stopper that won’t stay up or won’t seal usually has a problem under the sink. The pivot rod slipped out of the strap, broke or needs its height reset. No lift rod? It’s a clicker: unscrew it, clean it and check it still clicks.

Moen 11985 replacement pivot rod for a bathroom sink drain
If the rod snapped: Moen 11985 pivot rod$6.72 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Check it on Amazon

What your stopper is doing and why

Match what you see to a row, then jump to the fix it points to.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1 Lift rod and knob 2 Strap with holes and screw 3 Spring clip 4 Pivot rod 5 Pivot rod nut 6 Stopper loop 7 Stopper 8 Drain body and tailpiece 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1 Lift rod and knob 2 Strap with holes 3 Spring clip 4 Pivot rod 5 Pivot rod nut 6 Stopper loop 7 Stopper 8 Drain body
Under a lift rod pop-up: lift rod, strap and screw, spring clip, pivot rod and its nut at the back of the drain body, and the stopper loop the rod passes through. Drawn from Moen’s 96497 parts sheet and Kohler’s K-7114 guide.
What you seeMost likely causeGo to
You pull the lift rod and nothing happensPivot rod off the strap, or brokenReconnect or replace the rod
Stopper won’t stay up, drops back downSpring clip gone, or the strap screw has slippedReconnect and reset height
Stopper closes but water still drains outHeight off, worn seal, or a free-floating stopperReset height, then new stopper
Stopper lifts out in your handLoop set alongside the rod, not on itLock the stopper in
Stopper stuck closed, won’t liftRod off the strap, or hair packed around the stemGet it out from below
Drip at the back of the drain bodyLoose pivot rod nut or worn seal behind itPivot rod nut and seal
Push stopper won’t click or won’t stay downDirty or worn clickerService the clicker
Drains slowly with the stopper openHair wrapped on the stopper stemPull it and clean it

Start by looking behind the faucet. A thin rod with a knob that you pull up means a lift rod pop-up. No rod, and a cap you press, means a clicker. The two fail in different ways and use different parts.

A toe-touch or lift-and-turn stopper is a tub design. If that’s what you have in a sink, the bathtub drain stopper guide covers how those come apart.

Lift rod pop-up

A knob behind the faucet, a strap with holes under the sink and a horizontal pivot rod into the back of the drain.

Clicker (push to close)

No lift rod. Press the cap once to close, press again to open. Kohler says never pull on the cap to open it.

Vandal-resistant pop-up

Kohler’s K-7114 guide runs the rod through a hole in the stopper rod, so the stopper can’t be lifted out from the top. You have to loosen the pivot nut first.

Fix a stopper that won’t move or won’t stay up

These steps follow Moen’s fix for a pop-up drain that won’t open or close properly, with Kohler’s numbers for the height.

Used a chemical drain cleaner? Ask before you open anything. If drain cleaner may still be in the bowl, tailpiece or trap, don’t loosen the pivot nut or push a tool in: the liquid can splash onto your hands and eyes. Put on eye protection and rubber gloves, follow the cleaner’s label, and call a licensed plumber if you can’t flush it out safely.

  1. 1
    Clear the cabinet and lay a towel down

    Water sitting in the tailpiece can run out when you move the pivot nut.

  2. 2
    Find the pivot rod

    It’s the horizontal rod going into the back of the drain body, held by a metal or gray plastic pivot rod nut. Moen says you can unscrew the nut to look at the rod. If it’s snapped, go to the next section.

  3. 3
    Check the lift rod in the strap

    The lift rod drops through the strap, the metal piece with a row of holes. Its strap screw holds the height. Make sure the rod is in the strap and the screw is snug.

  4. 4
    Put the pivot rod back through the strap

    Slide the pivot rod through one of the strap holes and hold it with its spring clip. Moen’s rods carry the clip on the rod itself.

  5. 5
    Open the stopper all the way

    Push the pivot rod down so the stopper is fully up. Kohler’s K-7114 guide sets that open gap at about 3/8 in. (1 cm).

  6. 6
    Set the knob height

    Loosen the strap screw, slide the lift rod so its knob clears the faucet (Moen) or sits about 1/2 in. (1.3 cm) above the lift rod hole (Kohler K-7114), then tighten the screw.

  7. 7
    Test it with water

    Close it, fill the bowl and wait a minute. If it leaks down, move the pivot rod to the next strap hole and try again.

Hand-snug the pivot rod nut only. If it still drips once it’s snug, a worn seal behind it is the usual suspect, and a new rod kit with its own seal may fix it. A drip there can also come from the ball, the nut or the drain body, so a kit isn’t a sure fix.

Fix a stopper that closes but won’t hold water

If the bowl drains with the stopper down, the stopper isn’t sitting on its seat. Delta puts it plainly: a lift rod set wrong can stop the stopper sealing at all. So reset the height first, using the steps above.

Try the strap hole one step higher or lower on the pivot rod. Each hole changes how far the stopper travels. You want it fully down when the knob is up, and about 3/8 in. open when the knob is down.

Still leaking with the height right? Pull the stopper and look at the rubber seal under its cap. A flattened or split seal won’t hold. That’s when a new stopper, or Moen’s plug and seat, makes sense.

Stopper open Kohler K-7114: lifts about 3/8 in. (1 cm) 3/8 in. Knob height K-7114: about 1/2 in. (1.3 cm) up 1/2 in. Moen: set it so the knob clears the faucet Stopper open Kohler K-7114: lifts about 3/8 in. (1 cm) 3/8 in. Knob height K-7114: about 1/2 in. (1.3 cm) up 1/2 in. Moen: set it so the knob clears the faucet
Kohler K-7114 set-up numbers: stopper opens about 3/8 in. (1 cm); lift rod knob about 1/2 in. (1.3 cm) above its hole.

How to replace a broken pivot rod

Buy the rod made for your drain. Pivot rods differ in length and ball position by brand.

  1. 1
    Find the brand

    Look at the faucet. The drain usually came in the faucet box, so the faucet brand tells you which rod fits.

  2. 2
    Take off the spring clip

    Squeeze the clip and slide the pivot rod out of the strap.

  3. 3
    Unscrew the pivot rod nut

    Hold a towel under it. Pull the old rod straight out of the drain body.

  4. 4
    Fit the new rod

    Moen’s parts sheet lists the pivot rod seat, washer and nut that go on the rod. Put them on in the same order the old ones came off.

  5. 5
    Catch the stopper loop

    Feed the rod into the drain body so it passes through the loop or hole on the stopper’s stem. On Kohler’s regular set-up the rod sits under the stopper rod instead.

  6. 6
    Hand-tighten the nut

    Snug it, then clip the rod back into the strap and set the height as above.

Moen says the faucet’s installation sheet shows the exact layout for each model. If you still have yours, check it against these steps.

Why your stopper comes out when you lift it

Locked in Rod goes through the loop The rod pulls it down to seal Lifts out Loop sits alongside the rod Water weight holds it down Locked in Rod goes through the loop The rod pulls it down to seal Lifts out Loop sits alongside the rod Water weight holds it down
Delta: rod through the stopper’s loop locks it in; rod alongside the loop lets it lift out.

Delta’s support article explains it. If the horizontal rod goes through the loop at the bottom of the stopper, the stopper is locked in. If the loop sits beside the rod, the stopper lifts straight out.

Both are allowed. A free stopper relies on the weight of the water to seal. A locked one is pulled down by the rod, as long as the lift rod is set right.

My call: lock it in if anyone in the house pulls the stopper out to clean it and forgets to put it back right. Leave it free if you pull hair off it every week.

How to remove a sink stopper, even a stuck one

Lift it straight up first. If it won’t come, it’s held by the rod, so you free it from below. If anyone poured in a chemical drain cleaner, read the warning above first.

  1. 1
    Try the top

    Open the stopper and lift. If the loop sits alongside the rod, it comes out.

  2. 2
    Go under the sink

    Put a towel down and find the pivot rod nut at the back of the drain body.

  3. 3
    Unscrew the nut

    Moen says the nut can be unscrewed to get at the rod. Turn it by hand if you can.

  4. 4
    Pull the pivot rod back

    Slide it out an inch or so. That frees the stopper’s loop.

  5. 5
    Lift the stopper out

    It should come straight up now. Hair on the stem is why many ‘stuck’ stoppers won’t move.

  6. 6
    Clean and put it back

    Pull the hair, rinse the stem, drop it back in and feed the rod through the loop. Tighten the nut by hand.

Stone, glass or vessel sink and the stopper won’t budge? Don’t lever against the bowl. That’s the one case where I’d call a plumber before forcing it.

If hair is the problem past the stopper too, a plastic barbed tool reaches the tailpiece without taking anything else apart. The slow-draining sink guide covers clogs further down.

Fix a push stopper that won’t click

These steps follow Kohler’s clicker drain service guide.

  1. 1
    Open the stopper

    Press and release so the cap is up. Kohler warns never to pull the cap to open it.

  2. 2
    Unscrew the cap

    Turn the cap counterclockwise. The cap and seal come off, and the clicker may come with them.

  3. 3
    Remove the clicker

    If the clicker stayed in the drain, turn it counterclockwise to take it out.

  4. 4
    Clean every part

    Wipe dirt and hair off the cap, seal, clicker and the inside of the drain body.

  5. 5
    Test the clicker

    Push it together in your hand. It should click open and click closed. If it doesn’t, replace the clicker.

  6. 6
    Thread it back finger tight

    Kohler says finger tight only. Don’t put a wrench on it.

A clicker that’s cracked, or a drain body that’s corroded, is a whole-drain job. The pop-up drain assemblies guide compares complete drains, including Kohler’s Clicker with overflow.

Repair parts that fit common sink drains

Six parts cover the fixes above. Prices come from Amazon with the time they were read.

Moen 11985 pivot rod
Best for Moen 50/50 drains

Moen 11985 pivot rod

$6.72 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Delta RP12517 horizontal rod
Best for Delta pop-ups

Delta RP12517 rod

$17.99 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Danco 88532 universal ball rod with three balls
Best for unknown drains

Danco 88532 ball rod

$7.62 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Delta RP5648BN brushed nickel drain stopper
Best for a worn Delta stopper

Delta RP5648BN stopper

$17.99 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Moen 10709 chrome drain plug and seat
Best for a worn Moen plug

Moen 10709 plug and seat

$14.15 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Reference (not linked): shown for comparison only

Drain Weasel, 5 wands

Links go to listings sold by Amazon.com.

PartKey specsPick it ifSkip it if
Moen 11985 pivot rodPart 11985, for Moen 50/50 drains, 1-year limited warrantyYour Moen faucet’s rod snapped or the seal behind the nut drips.Your drain is another brand. The ball spacing differs.
Delta RP12517 rodPart RP12517, Delta calls it the horizontal rod, chromeYour Delta pop-up rod broke or is corroded.Your faucet is a Moen or Kohler.
Danco 88532 ball rod3 ball sizes: 15, 17 and 18.3 mm, 2 cone washers, no nut or clipYou can’t tell the brand and want one rod that fits most drains.You need a new nut or clip too. They aren’t in the pack.
Delta RP5648BN stopper1-1/4 x 4 in., cap 1.35 in., length 4.2 in., brushed nickelYour Delta stopper’s seal is worn and the height is already right.Your drain finish is chrome or another brand.
Moen 10709 plug and seatPart 10709, plug and seat together, chrome, 1-year warrantyYour Moen plug won’t seal even with the height set.The pivot rod is the problem, not the plug.
Drain Weasel, 5 wands (Reference (not linked): shown for comparison only)Model DWPSK5A, 18 in. wands, reusable handle——

Other parts I checked

American Standard’s 066118-0070A pivot rod is made for its Seva faucets and comes with an o-ring, clip, ball and bushing. It’s a text link here: American Standard 066118-0070A.

For a whole new drain, putty goes under the new flange. Oatey 31177 plumber’s putty is a common choice for that. Kohler’s K-7114 guide calls for putty or another sealant under the flange.

Which part do you need?

ProblemPartWhole drain?
Rod snappedPivot rod for your brandNo
Drip at the pivot nutPivot rod kit with seal, or seal and washerNo
Stopper seal wornStopper or plug and seatNo
Clicker won’t clickClicker cartridge, or the whole clicker drainSometimes
Drain body cracked or corrodedComplete pop-up drainYes
Flange leaks into the cabinetReseal with putty, or a new drainSometimes

Moen traces most of these problems to the pivot rod or its adjustment, so start there. Swap the whole drain when the body is cracked, the threads are gone or the finish has worn through.

Things people try that don’t fix it

What people tryWhat happens
Cranking the pivot rod nut tightIt squashes the seal and can crack a plastic nut. Moen’s sheet shows a seal and washer under it; hand-snug is enough.
Pulling a clicker cap to open itKohler warns against it. It can damage the clicker.
Chemical cleaner for a stuck stopperA chemical won’t free a stopper held by the rod, and it leaves caustic liquid in a drain you then have to open. Pull the stopper and clean it.
Buying a whole new drain firstMoen names the pivot rod and its adjustment as the usual cause. Check those first.

When to call a licensed plumber

The drain body or tailpiece leaks

A crack or corrosion below the pivot nut won’t stop with tightening.

Water in the vanity from the wall

That’s a trap or drain arm connection, not the stopper.

Stone, glass or vessel sink

If the drain is seized in the bowl, forcing it can crack the sink.

Questions people ask

Why won’t my bathroom sink stopper stay up?

On a lift rod drain, the pivot rod has usually slipped out of the strap or the strap screw has slipped. Clip the rod back in and reset the height. On a clicker, clean and test the clicker; replace it if it won’t click.

How do I fix a pop-up sink plug that’s not working?

Check the pivot rod under the sink first. Moen says the cause is a broken pivot rod or the pivot rod and lift rod adjustment. Replace a broken rod, or reset the height with the strap screw.

How do I remove a bathroom sink stopper?

Lift it straight up. If it won’t come, loosen the pivot rod nut under the sink, pull the rod back an inch and lift the stopper out.

My sink stopper came out. How do I put it back?

Drop it into the drain with its loop facing the back, where the pivot rod enters. Pull the rod back, line up the loop, then push the rod through it and hand-tighten the nut.

Can I replace a sink stopper myself?

Yes. A stopper or pivot rod swap needs no shut-off and takes hand tools. Match the part to your faucet brand.

Are pop-up stoppers universal?

No. Stem length, loop position and cap size differ by brand. Universal stoppers and Danco’s three-ball rod fit many drains, but the brand’s own part fits best.

How I put this together

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, licensed Georgia plumber (license #JP507711). The steps and numbers come from Moen, Kohler and Delta documents read on Oct 22, 2026.

How I pick

  • Repair parts only, matched to the maker’s part number.
  • Genuine branded parts.
  • No scores: these parts do different jobs, so they’re listed as a kit.

Sources

  • Moen, “Pop-up drain assembly not closing or opening properly” (solutions.moen.com, updated Sep 13, 2020).
  • Moen, Illustrated Parts 96497/96107 lavatory waste assembly (Acc-42, rev. 8/92).
  • Kohler, Installation Guide, Pop-Up Drain K-7114, K-7126 (1041498-2-C).
  • Kohler UK, Pop-up Clicker Drain Installation and User Guide 7124W-A (1074769-W2-A).
  • Kohler, Clicker Drain with Overflow K-RH1274364 product page.
  • Delta Faucet, “Install a drain stopper so the stopper is removable” (support.deltafaucet.com, Jan 14, 2026); RP12517 product page.
  • Amazon product listings for every stopper named on this page, read Oct 27, 2026.

Related guides