Get the Arbiter Mako MK5 (10.0): the one kit on the USC approved list, ±0.1 psid. For a dial gauge, the Mid-West 845-5 or Bac-Flo-5. Ask your water authority which kits it accepts first.
Top pick: Arbiter Mako MK5$999.99 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
All three measure differential pressure from 0 to 15 psid and test reduced pressure, double check and vacuum breaker assemblies. Scored on the same seven checks from the makers’ sheets and the USC Foundation’s lists, read Oct 24, 2026. I’ve used these picks.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
How much a kit’s accuracy matters on a close call
Pick a kit and enter a relief valve opening reading. The checker shows the range the true value could be in, given that kit’s stated accuracy.
Gauge accuracy matters most when a reading sits near a pass line. Watts’ TK-9A instructions say the relief valve on a reduced pressure assembly must keep the zone between the checks at least 2 psi below supply pressure. A reading just over 2.0 on a gauge that can be off by 0.2 doesn’t prove much.
Arbiter lists the Mako MK5 at ±0.1 psid from 0 to 15 psid, if it has been calibrated in the past 12 months and runs firmware version 12 or later. Mid-West and Bac-Flo list ±0.2 psid on the descending scale. Watts lists ±2% of full scale on the TK-9A’s 0–15 psid gauge.
PlumbingPicks spec score out of 10, from the makers’ spec sheets and the USC Foundation’s lists, read Oct 24, 2026. It is not a customer rating.
Best for USC approved testing
Arbiter Mako MK5
Digital 5-valve backflow test kit with hoses and case
On the USC List of Approved Field Test Kits (10th edition)
±0.1 psid from 0 to 15 psid
Capture button and backlit display
IP57, 5-year warranty from manufacture
Cons
Runs on 4 AA batteries
Accuracy figure depends on yearly calibration and current firmware
Opening the unit past the battery compartment voids the warranty
0–15 psid±0.1 psid5 valves175 psi maxIP57
Buy it if
Your authority requires a kit on the USC Foundation’s approved list, or you want a digital readout that stores readings.
Skip it if
You’d rather not depend on batteries and firmware; the dial kits need neither.
The Mako MK5 is the kit I’d get if I were buying one today, and I’ve used it. It scored 10.0, passing all seven checks.
Its standout fact is the list it’s on. The USC Foundation’s List of Approved Field Test Kits, dated December 10, 2019, names one kit: the Arbiter Mako MK5, five-valve configuration, approved under the Tenth Edition of the Manual of Cross-Connection Control. Arbiter’s manual calls it the only USC FCCCHR Manual 10 approved gauge.
Accuracy is ±0.1 psid from 0 to 15 psid, per Arbiter’s manual, provided it has been calibrated in the past 12 months and runs firmware version 12 or later.
Above 15 psid it widens: ±1% of reading to 100 psid, ±5% to 150 and ±10% to 175. The manual notes that USC approval requires at least ±0.2 psid across its working temperatures and pressures, and that the Mako passed that testing at the USC lab.
It’s digital. The manual describes a backlit display, a Capture button that stores live readings so you can watch the assembly instead of the gauge, Bluetooth for test-report apps, and a hook on the back. It runs on four AA batteries and is rated IP57.
Arbiter says the hoses are made from materials suitable for potable water under NSF 61 and FDA guidelines and include a 40-micron filter. Maximum working pressure is 175 psi into the assembly under test, and maximum water temperature is 140°F.
The warranty is five years from the date of manufacture, for the original purchaser. It excludes damage from freezing, and opening the unit beyond the battery compartment voids it. The manual says to always drain water from the gauge after use.
One listing detail to know: the Amazon title says soft case while one bullet says hard shell case.
Best for a dial gauge
Mid-West 845-5
Mid-West Instrument 845-5 5-valve backflow prevention assembly test kit
90-micron inline filters, cleanable or replaceable
5-year warranty
Cons
±0.2 psid on the descending scale, not ±0.1
On USC’s 9th edition acceptable list, not the 10th edition approved list
Maximum water temperature 150°F
0–15 psid±0.2 psid5 valves200 psig3.6 lb gauge
Buy it if
You want a proven mechanical dial gauge with no batteries, and your authority accepts kits on the USC acceptable gages list.
Skip it if
Your authority requires a kit on the USC 10th edition approved list; the Mako is the one there.
The 845-5 is the classic dial kit, and I’ve used it. It scored 10.0.
Mid-West’s bulletin describes a diaphragm differential pressure gauge with a 4-1/2 in. dial reading 0–15 psid (0–100 kPa), accurate to ±0.2 psid on the descending scale. Working pressure is 200 psig, and a 1-1/2 in. line pressure gauge reads 0–200 psig.
It’s a five-valve kit with soft-seated brass needle valves that have replaceable seats. Mid-West says 90-micron filters protect the kit from scale and sand, and the filter elements can be cleaned or replaced. The three color-coded hoses are 5 ft long with Schrader 1/4 in. brass couplers, plus a 4 ft clear bleed tube.
The gauge body is glass-reinforced engineering thermoplastic, and the wetted parts are EP elastomers, brass and 316 stainless. The gauge weighs 3.6 lb, and the molded case is 18-1/2 by 9 by 9-3/4 in. with compartments for fittings and tools. Three sets of brass adapter fittings fit standard test cocks.
Mid-West says the 845 is on the acceptable gages lists of both the USC Foundation and CA-NV AWWA. The USC acceptable gages document, dated January 31, 2025, lists Mid-West models 830, 835, 845-2, 845-3 and 845-5 under the Ninth Edition guidelines. That’s a different list from the Tenth Edition approved list.
The bulletin warns that freezing temperatures must be avoided and sets a 150°F maximum. Mid-West also recommends annual accuracy verification of every test kit, calling kits measuring instruments that need routine checks. The warranty is five years.
Mid-West says the gauge can run all known test procedures, including those recommended by ABPA, ASSE, AWWA, CSA, FCCC and HR-USC, NEWWA and UF-TREEO. The whole kit ships at about 11.5 lb, and Mid-West says the design drew on more than 30 years of input from backflow technicians.
Calibration report valid for a full year, per Bac-Flo
Same gauge specs as the Mid-West 845-5
1/4–3/4 NPT brass adapter set and a 6-in-1 screwdriver
5-year warranty
Cons
USC lists it as acceptable (9th edition), not approved (10th)
Maximum water temperature 150°F
0–15 psid±0.2 psid5 valves200 psigMade in USA
Buy it if
You want a dial kit that arrives with a year’s calibration report and a full adapter set.
Skip it if
Your authority requires a kit on the USC 10th edition approved list.
The Bac-Flo-5 is a dial kit from a company that also trains backflow testers, and I’ve used it. It scored 10.0.
Its gauge numbers match the Mid-West 845-5 line for line: a 4-1/2 in. diaphragm dial reading 0–15 psid, ±0.2 psid on the descending scale, 200 psig working pressure and a 0–200 psig line gauge. There’s a reason. The USC acceptable gages document lists Bac-Flo-3 and Bac-Flo-5 with a note that they’re private label and manufactured by Mid-West Instruments.
Where it differs is the kit around the gauge. Bac-Flo says it ships with a calibration report valid for a full year, high-pressure color-coded hoses with 90-micron removable brass filters, a 1/4 to 3/4 in. NPT brass adapter set, full-page laminated test procedures and a 6-in-1 Klein stubby screwdriver.
The spec sheet lists soft-seated brass needle valves with replaceable seats, a glass-reinforced thermoplastic body, EP elastomer, brass and 316 stainless wetted parts, three 5 ft hoses with Schrader couplers and a 4 ft clear bleed tube. The padded case measures 18-1/2 by 9 by 9-3/4 in.
A wording note: Bac-Flo’s spec sheet heads itself “approved by USC FCCCHR and CA-NV AWWA”. On the USC Foundation’s own documents, the Bac-Flo-5 appears on the Ninth Edition acceptable gages list, not the Tenth Edition approved list. Check which one your authority asks for.
The maximum temperature is 150°F, and Bac-Flo says freezing temperatures must be avoided. The warranty is five years.
Bac-Flo, based in Boerne, Texas, runs backflow tester certification and renewal courses, and lists the same test procedures as Mid-West: ABPA, ASSE, AWWA, CSA, USC-FCCCHR, NEWWA and UF-TREEO. Shipping weight is about 11.5 lb, and the spec sheet describes a foam padded case with compartments for fittings and tools.
The Klein 6-in-1 stubby screwdriver Bac-Flo packs with the Bac-Flo-5. Product photo: Amazon
USC describes a field test kit as a visual indicator that measures the difference between two pressure points, such as the pressure on each side of a check valve.
The USC Foundation for Cross-Connection Control and Hydraulic Research keeps both lists. Its approved list covers kits that completed the lab evaluation in the Tenth Edition of its Manual. The acceptable gages list covers gages it reviewed earlier against the Ninth Edition’s general guidelines.
USC says a kit counts as approved only with the needle valves and hoses its maker supplied; swapping in other hoses or valves invalidates the approval. It also says the local administrative authority decides which kits are acceptable in its area. Call yours before you buy.
Dial or digital
Point
Digital (Mako MK5)
Dial (845-5, Bac-Flo-5)
Power
4 AA batteries
None
Reading
Number on a backlit display; Capture button stores it
Needle on a 4-1/2 in. dial
Accuracy
±0.1 psid, calibrated in the past 12 months, firmware 12+
±0.2 psid descending
Water protection
IP57
Not rated
Records
Bluetooth to test-report apps
Write readings by hand
A dial gauge has nothing to charge and nothing to update, and testers have used them for decades. A digital gauge gives you an exact number, holds it with the Capture button, and can send it to an app, but it depends on batteries and firmware.
For fast-moving readings, like a relief valve opening point or a vacuum breaker test, Arbiter says the Capture function lets you watch the assembly rather than the gauge. With a dial, you watch the needle and the relief port at the same time.
Why five valves
Configuration
Valves
Example
Five-valve
Five test valves; the Mako is listed as configuration 5 by USC
All three picks
Three-valve
Two ball valves and one needle valve, per Watts
Watts TK-9A
Inside the Mako MK5: the brass valve block and three hose ports. Product photo: Amazon
The USC approved list records each kit’s configuration as its number of needle valves, and lists the Mako MK5 as configuration 5. Arbiter’s manual calls the MK5’s layout an accepted five-valve water flow configuration as prescribed by USC Manual 10. Mid-West and Bac-Flo sell theirs as five-valve kits, and Watts lists two ball valves and one needle valve on the TK-9A.
Buy the configuration your training used and your authority’s procedure expects. Watts’ TK-9A instructions, for example, name its valves A, B and C step by step, while the 845-5 and Bac-Flo-5 ship with their own laminated test procedures.
Calibration and care
Item
What the makers say
Accuracy checks
Mid-West recommends annual accuracy verification of every test kit
Arbiter accuracy figure
Holds if calibrated within the past 12 months, firmware 12 or later
Bac-Flo
Ships with a calibration report valid for a full year
Freezing
All three makers say avoid freezing; Arbiter says it voids the warranty
After use
Arbiter: always drain water from the gauge; Watts: hold the kit vertically to drain gauge and hoses
Mid-West’s letter on annual accuracy verification makes the case plainly: test kits are mechanical measuring instruments exposed to debris, heat, freezing and impacts, the same conditions as the assemblies they test.
Mid-West adds that pressure gauge standards call for regular accuracy checks based on use, that quality systems require every measuring instrument to be under a procedure, and that annual verification shows which kits need recalibration or repair.
Draining the kit after every job is the habit that saves gauges. Water left in a gauge that freezes can damage it, and Arbiter treats freeze damage as abuse outside the warranty.
What a reduced pressure test checks
1
Check valve No. 2
Must be tight against reverse flow.
2
Shutoff No. 2
Tested for tightness after check 2 passes.
3
Check valve No. 1
Must be tight against reverse flow.
4
Relief valve
Must hold the zone at least 2 psi below supply.
5
Record the readings
Opening point and check readings on the report.
6
Restore the assembly
Remove the kit, reopen shutoff No. 2.
Those steps follow the reduced pressure zone procedure in Watts’ TK-9A instructions, which test check valve No. 2, shutoff No. 2, check valve No. 1 and then the relief valve opening point. Your authority may use a different procedure, such as the USC Foundation’s; follow the one it requires.
Testing a backflow assembly for a water authority usually needs a certified tester, not just a kit. For the assemblies themselves, see best backflow preventer.
Why testers use a differential gauge
Reason Watts gives
What it means on the job
Takes minimum time
Fewer steps per assembly
No need to close the inlet ball valve
Less chance of knocking pipe scale into the assembly
Only a little water is spilled
Less water on the floor
A mercury manometer could cause a pollution hazard
No mercury near drinking water
Watts’ TK-9A instructions recommend a differential pressure gauge over a manometer for the first reduced pressure test, for the four reasons above. All three picks are diaphragm or digital differential gauges reading 0–15 psid, the range those tests use.
The line pressure gauge on the 845-5 and Bac-Flo-5, reading 0–200 psig, is a separate dial. It shows supply pressure, which helps when a reading looks odd and you want to know what the assembly is seeing.
Hoses, filters and colors
Kit
Hoses
Filters
Couplers
Arbiter Mako MK5
Three, color coded
40 micron
Supplied with the kit
Mid-West 845-5
Three 5 ft, color coded, plus 4 ft clear bleed tube
90 micron, cleanable
Schrader 1/4 in. brass
Bac-Flo-5
Three 5 ft, color coded, plus 4 ft clear bleed tube
90 micron, removable brass
Schrader 1/4 in. brass
Watts TK-9A
Three 3 ft, swivel couplings
Not stated
1/4 in. threaded adapters
Watts’ diagrams color the high hose yellow, the low hose white or red and the vent hose blue. Color coding cuts mistakes when you move hoses between test cocks.
Filters keep scale and sand out of the needle valves and gauge. Remember USC’s rule: on an approved kit, replacement hoses or needle valves must be the maker’s own, or the approval no longer holds.
What a double check test checks
1
Hook up across check 1
High to test cock 3, low to test cock 2.
2
Bleed the air
Open the vent valve, then bleed high and low.
3
Close shutoff No. 1
Loosen the low hose until the gauge reads 2 psi.
4
Watch the reading
If it doesn’t drop, check 1 is tight.
5
Repeat across check 2
High to test cock 4, low to test cock 3.
6
Restore the assembly
Remove hoses, return valves to service.
Those steps follow Watts’ double check valve procedure in the TK-9A instructions. Watts adds that an assembly fails both check tests if shutoff No. 2 leaks badly, and gives a separate test for it: if the differential gauge rises above zero, the shutoff must be replaced before the assembly can be tested.
This is where a kit’s accuracy at low readings matters again: the double check test sets a 2 psi differential and watches for a drop, so a gauge that reads true near 2 psid makes the call clearer.
Not on either USC list; ±2% of 15 psid full scale; three valves; inline filters not stated; 1-year warranty
Compact; tests RP, double check, PVB and SVB assemblies to USC and ASSE 5000; 175 psi; carrying case
The TK-9A is a genuine Watts kit; the Amazon listing’s UPC, 098268022049, matches Watts’ model page. It’s compact and covers every common assembly. But on the checks here it falls short: Watts lists ±2% accuracy of full scale, three test valves, a one-year warranty, and it isn’t on the USC lists, which name the Watts TKDR, TKDP and TK99D instead.
How to choose
If you…
Pick
Must use a USC 10th edition approved kit
Arbiter Mako MK5
Want the tightest stated accuracy
Arbiter Mako MK5
Want a mechanical dial with no batteries
Mid-West 845-5
Want a calibration report in the box
Bac-Flo-5
Test in cold weather often
Any, but drain after every use
Start with your water authority: its list of acceptable kits decides more than any spec. Then choose dial or digital, and plan for an annual calibration whichever you buy. For other testing gear, see best water pressure gauge.
Questions people ask
What is the best backflow test kit?
The Arbiter Mako MK5 is the only kit on the USC Foundation’s approved list, at ±0.1 psid.
Is the Mid-West 845-5 USC approved?
It’s on USC’s 9th edition acceptable gages list, not the 10th edition approved list.
How accurate are backflow test kits?
±0.1 psid for the Mako MK5 and ±0.2 psid for the 845-5 and Bac-Flo-5, per their makers.
How often should a backflow test kit be calibrated?
Mid-West recommends annual accuracy verification; Arbiter’s accuracy figure assumes calibration in the past 12 months.
Who decides which test kits are allowed?
The local administrative authority, per the USC Foundation.
What is a 5-valve backflow test kit?
A kit with five test valves; USC lists approved kits by their number of needle valves.
Can I use other hoses on a USC approved kit?
USC says other hoses or needle valves invalidate the approval.
What warranty do backflow test kits have?
Five years for the Mako MK5, 845-5 and Bac-Flo-5; one year for the Watts TK-9A.
Can a test kit freeze?
Yes; all three makers say avoid freezing and drain the kit after use.
Do I need a license to test backflow preventers?
For reports to a water authority, usually yes; check your state and local rules.
How I pick and score
Why trust me
I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia (Georgia journeyman plumber license), and I’ve used these picks. Every spec here comes from the makers’ manuals, bulletins and spec sheets and the USC Foundation’s published lists, read on Oct 24, 2026.
How I pick
Differential pressure backflow test kits, five-valve configuration.
New and in stock on Amazon on Oct 24, 2026.
Each scored on the same seven checks below; every pick reaches 7.0.
Prices come from Amazon’s API with the time they were read.
Check (pass = 1)
Where it comes from
On a USC Foundation list (10th edition approved or 9th edition acceptable)
USC documents
Accuracy ±0.2 psid or better from 0 to 15 psid
Maker’s sheet or manual
Five-valve configuration
Maker’s sheet or USC list
Inline hose filters stated
Maker’s sheet or manual
Maximum working pressure 175 psi or more
Maker’s sheet or manual
Warranty 2 years or longer
Maker’s sheet or manual
Carrying case included
Maker’s sheet or Amazon listing
Score = checks passed ÷ 7 × 10, rounded half up. It’s the PlumbingPicks spec score, built from published facts. It isn’t a customer rating or an Amazon rating.
Mid-West Instrument, Bulletin 845-5/19 and 845-5 product page, backflowtestkits.com; letter on Annual Accuracy Verification of Backflow Prevention Assembly Test Kits.
Bac-Flo Unlimited, BAC-FLO-5 specification sheet and product page, bacflo.com.
USC Foundation for Cross-Connection Control and Hydraulic Research: List of Approved Field Test Kits (December 10, 2019) and Acceptable Gages, Manual of Cross-Connection Control, Ninth Edition (January 31, 2025).
Amazon product data for the Arbiter Mako MK5, the Mid-West 845-5, the Bac-Flo-5 and the Watts TK-9A, read on Amazon on Oct 24, 2026.