Best gas tankless water heater

For the best gas tankless water heater, I start with Rinnai RX160iN. I choose RXP160iN for planned recirculation and RX130iN for smaller winter demand.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns

Updated November 15, 2026

Rinnai RX160iN gas tankless water heater
Rinnai RX160iN. Product photo from Amazon.

The short answer

Choose Rinnai RX160iN when winter demand fits its curve. Pick RXP160iN for planned recirculation, or RX130iN for smaller demand. Have a qualified installer confirm capacity, gas supply and venting before purchase.

Rinnai RX160iN gas tankless water heater
Top pick: Rinnai RX160iN$1,442.70 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Check RX160iN on Amazon
Find my heater fit

Find your heater fit

Choose the conditions your installer has confirmed.

This finder cannot replace measured demand, the exact model curve or an in-person installation check. The rounded curve readings leave no allowance for site changes.

The gas tankless picks

RX160iN and RXP160iN share a 160,000 BTU/h maximum input. RXP160iN adds an internal pump; RX130iN suits a smaller checked load. Choose by the winter curve and the return-pipe layout. [1]

The RXP160 internal pump can reduce distribution delays with an approved return layout. It does not increase burner capacity. RX160 and RXP160 both list a 160,000 BTU/h maximum input. [1]

Best for whole-house use without a pump

Rinnai RX160iN

RX160iN gas tankless water heater
$1,442.70
Check RX160iN on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST

Pros

  • 160,000 BTU/h maximum input
  • 0.97 UEF in the RX specification
  • 9.0 GPM maximum in the RX sheet
  • Indoor or approved outdoor configuration

Cons

  • No built-in recirculation pump
  • Needs a compliant condensate drain
  • Winter output falls below maximum flow
15,000 to 160,000 BTU/h0.97 UEF9.0 GPM maximum120 VAC, 60 HzNo internal pump

Buy it if

Your winter-demand calculation fits the RX160 curve and the house does not need a built-in pump.

Skip it if

Your demand exceeds its curve, or your return layout calls for internal-pump recirculation.

The RX160iN is my starting pick for a whole-house installation where the winter load fits and an internal pump is unnecessary. Rinnai’s RX specification lists 15,000 to 160,000 BTU/h input, 0.97 UEF and a 9.0 GPM maximum. Those are model-specific figures, rather than a family-wide maximum transferred to every heater. [1]

At an 80°F temperature rise, the RX160 curve shows about 4.0 GPM when rounded to roughly 0.5 GPM. The example below needs 4.25 GPM for two assumed showers plus a hot-only tap. That exceeds this approximate output, so reduce overlapping use or have a professional assess a different capacity. [calculation]

The base RX160 has no internal recirculation pump. A short pipe run with an acceptable wait may not need one. If your problem is a long wait at a distant bathroom, identify the return route first. A larger burner does not remove cooled water already sitting between the heater and that bathroom.

Rinnai’s sheet allows indoor installation or outdoor installation with its approved outdoor vent cap. It lists direct-vent and room-air arrangements, subject to the installation manual. Your installer must select the permitted materials and route. An old tank heater’s vent cannot be approved simply because it reaches the same outside wall.

The RX160 also needs a compliant condensate drain and the specified 120 VAC, 60 Hz supply. Keep the condensate path separate from pressure relief discharge. Outdoor placement still needs a freeze plan for exposed pipes and drains. The cabinet’s protective functions do not establish protection for every external valve. [1]

My call: choose the RX160 after the winter-demand and installation checks pass. Its larger burner gives more output than the RX130 at the same rise, but the extra capacity is useful only for demand the household actually has. Leave gas setup and commissioning to a qualified professional under Rinnai’s instructions.

Sources: Rinnai RX sheet, RXP sheet, installation manual.

The tradeoff: There is no built-in recirculation pump; confirm acceptable wait times and winter capacity.

Best for planned recirculation

Rinnai RXP160iN

RXP160iN gas tankless water heater
$1,685.60
Check RXP160iN on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST

Pros

  • Built-in recirculation pump
  • 160,000 BTU/h maximum input
  • 0.97 UEF in the RXP specification
  • Dedicated-return and crossover layouts documented

Cons

  • Does not cover the combined cold-inlet example
  • Pump needs a suitable return route
  • Amazon listing does not itemize carton contents
15,000 to 160,000 BTU/h0.97 UEF9.0 GPM maximumInternal recirculation pumpSmart-Circ controls

Buy it if

The RXP160 curve covers your actual load and a qualified installer has designed the recirculation return path.

Skip it if

Your demand exceeds the RXP160 curve, or you have no use for a recirculation loop.

Pick the RXP160iN when distribution delay is the problem and its burner meets the household’s demand. Rinnai’s RXP sheet lists 15,000 to 160,000 BTU/h input, 0.97 UEF and 9.0 GPM maximum flow. The internal pump distinguishes it from the base RX160, whose maximum input and UEF match these figures. [2]

A built-in pump needs a return path. Rinnai describes a dedicated return line or a crossover arrangement with a thermal bypass valve. Have the installer identify the route and served fixtures on the plumbing plan. A bathroom beyond the circulating loop can still have a wait even when the pump is operating correctly.

Rinnai’s RXP specification lists the heater, wall mounting bracket, vent screens, screws and thermal bypass valve as included contents. That is the manufacturer’s package description. The Amazon listing does not itemize the carton, so seller-specific inclusion of those loose parts is unverified. The pump itself is part of the RXP model.

Smart-Circ learns hot-water use patterns to activate recirculation. Dedicated-return and crossover modes have different setup requirements in the manual. Ask for the selected mode and control method in the handover notes. A Wi-Fi capability claim does not establish that an optional remote-control module is included with this Amazon offer.

At an 80°F rise, the RXP160 sheet’s curve is about 4.0 GPM, rounded to roughly 0.5 GPM. That covers the illustrative 3.25 GPM two-shower demand before site adjustments, but falls below the example’s 4.25 GPM demand with an added tap. A pump cannot fill that heating-capacity gap. [calculation]

My call: use the RXP160 for a planned recirculation system whose winter load fits its curve. Check indoor venting or the approved outdoor configuration, plus condensate and freeze protection. Choose the pump for the pipe layout and the burner for the measured load. Both decisions need to pass before the heater is selected.

Sources: Rinnai RX sheet, RXP sheet, installation manual.

The tradeoff: The built-in pump needs a suitable return path and adds no burner capacity.

Best for smaller demand

Rinnai RX130iN

RX130iN gas tankless water heater
$1,264.20
Check RX130iN on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST

Pros

  • 130,000 BTU/h maximum input
  • 0.97 UEF in the RX specification
  • Same listed cabinet dimensions as RX160
  • Indoor or approved outdoor configuration

Cons

  • Lower winter output than the other picks
  • No internal recirculation pump
  • Not enough for the cold-inlet two-shower example
15,000 to 130,000 BTU/h0.97 UEF7.1 GPM maximum120 VAC, 60 HzNo internal pump

Buy it if

A smaller measured simultaneous load fits the RX130 curve at your winter temperature rise.

Skip it if

Your required load resembles the two-shower cold-inlet example, or needs an internal pump.

The RX130iN is the smaller-demand pick, with 15,000 to 130,000 BTU/h input, 0.97 UEF and a 7.1 GPM maximum in Rinnai’s RX sheet. It is useful when the actual simultaneous load is modest. A small floor plan alone does not establish that load; a single high-flow tub can change the sizing decision. [1]

The RX130 curve shows about 3.0 GPM at an 80°F rise, rounded to roughly 0.5 GPM. My two-shower example needs 3.25 GPM of hot water under those conditions. Treat that as insufficient on this approximate comparison. The 7.1 GPM maximum is not evidence that the same two showers fit in winter. [calculation] [1]

For a household that uses one fixture at a time, build a separate demand worksheet rather than borrowing the two-shower result. Measure the fixture flow and establish the coldest inlet temperature. A warm-weather test at the kitchen sink does not describe the burner load of a winter shower with a running hot-water tap.

The RX130 is not physically smaller than the RX160 in the specification table. Both use the listed 18.5-inch width, 25.8-inch height and 11.4-inch depth. Selecting the lower input does not solve a wall-clearance problem. Service access, vent routing and a usable condensate path remain part of the installation assessment. [1]

Like the base RX160, the RX130 has no internal recirculation pump. An acceptable wait on a short distribution run may suit that arrangement. A distant fixture with a planned return loop raises a separate pump question. Do not trade away required winter output just to match a smaller input number.

My call: choose RX130 only after its own curve passes the household’s demand check. Rinnai allows indoor or approved outdoor installation, with the required vent arrangement and electrical supply. A qualified installer must still assess gas sizing and freeze protection. Lower burner input changes the supply assessment; it does not remove professional installation requirements.

Sources: Rinnai RX sheet, RXP sheet, installation manual.

The tradeoff: There is no built-in recirculation pump; confirm acceptable wait times and winter capacity.

Compare the three picks

The RX160 and RXP160 have the same maximum input. The RXP160 provides an internal pump; RX130 serves a smaller checked load. These are different jobs, rather than interchangeable bathroom-count ratings.

Heater and useMaximum inputUEFPump and trade-offMaximum flow in maker sheetBuy link
Rinnai RX160iN gas tankless water heater Rinnai RX160iN
Whole-house use without a pump
160,000 BTU/h [1] 0.97 [1] Same input as RXP160
No internal pump
9.0 GPM [1] RX160 on Amazon
Rinnai RXP160iN gas tankless water heater Rinnai RXP160iN
Planned recirculation
160,000 BTU/h [1] 0.97 [1] Internal pump
No burner-capacity gain over RX160
9.0 GPM [1] RXP160 on Amazon
Rinnai RX130iN gas tankless water heater Rinnai RX130iN
Smaller demand
130,000 BTU/h [1] 0.97 [1] Smaller-load option
Lowest winter output here; no internal pump
7.1 GPM [1] RX130 on Amazon

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Maximum input is fuel energy entering the appliance. UEF is a standardized efficiency metric. Use the plotted model-specific curve for winter output rather than multiplying these two figures.

Will this heater fit your replacement?

Use this matrix before choosing an RX or RXP. A stop condition means the installation needs an answer before the purchase, even when the heater itself appears suitable.

CheckRX160iN / RX130iNRXP160iNStop until this is answered
Winter capacityUse the exact RX160 or RX130 curve at the required riseUse RXP curve at the required riseMeasured simultaneous hot-water demand exceeds the applicable curve, or curve selection is unresolved
RecirculationNo built-in pumpInternal pump; return arrangement still neededNobody has identified the return path or compatible control method
Indoor ventApproved system in RX/RXP manualApproved system in RX/RXP manualOld vent material, route or termination has not been checked against this heater
Outdoor placementApproved outdoor configuration requiredApproved outdoor configuration requiredCap, termination clearances or freeze plan are missing
CondensateCompliant separate drain routeCompliant separate drain routeNo approved disposal route or protection for exposed drain sections
Electric power120 VAC, 60 Hz [1] 120 VAC, 60 Hz [1] Grounded supply and power-loss freeze plan are unresolved
Service and waterWater-quality check and service accessWater-quality check and service accessNo access to isolate/service the unit, or water is outside maker limits

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

A tank-to-tankless replacement often changes the venting job. Do not assume a tank heater’s existing connector, chimney route or combustion-air supply is approved for an RX. Ask for the proposed intake and exhaust system by name, not merely its pipe diameter.

An existing tankless installation also needs a model-specific check. A wall bracket and familiar-looking connections do not establish compatibility with the RX or RXP. The manual’s requirements for the new appliance remain the deciding reference even when the old unit was made by Rinnai.

RX when no return system is planned

The non-pump model makes sense once winter capacity and installation checks pass. A short distribution run may give its lack of a built-in pump little practical downside.

RXP when the return route is documented

Ask the installer to mark the return pipe or approved crossover point on the plumbing plan and identify the control mode.

Neither before gas and vent checks

Rinnai requires trained, qualified installation. Leave fuel setup, combustion checks and vent approval to that professional; do not adjust the internal gas valve.

How much hot water will it supply in winter?

Temperature rise is the heater outlet temperature minus the incoming water temperature. The same house asks more of the burner when its inlet water gets colder.

70°F inlet50°F rise50°F inlet70°F rise40°F inlet80°F rise70°F inlet50°F rise50°F inlet70°F rise40°F inlet80°F rise
Illustrative arithmetic at a 120°F heater outlet. This chart shows required rise, not the RX or RXP capacity curve.

Rinnai’s RX specification 100000883 plots separate RX160 and RX130 curves; RXP specification 100000884 plots RXP160. The readings below are rounded to roughly 0.5 GPM from those model lines. They are approximate graph readings, not output calculated from burner input or UEF. [calculation]

Both sheets limit these curves to incoming water at 70°F or colder. Rinnai notes that maximum flow varies with set temperature, temperature rise and altitude. A qualified installer must confirm the applicable conditions and current document revision for the actual installation. [calculation]

Inlet at 120°F outletTemperature riseRX160iN approximate outputRXP160iN approximate outputRX130iN approximate output
70°F50°F [calculation]About 6.0 GPM [calculation]About 6.0 GPM [calculation]About 5.0 GPM [calculation]
50°F70°F [calculation]About 4.5 GPM [calculation]About 4.5 GPM [calculation]About 3.5 GPM [calculation]
40°F80°F [calculation]About 4.0 GPM [calculation]About 4.0 GPM [calculation]About 3.0 GPM [calculation]

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Sources: Rinnai RX specification 100000883 and RXP specification 100000884, water-flow curves on page 2. Read the RX160i, RX130i and RXP160i lines respectively. Approximate readings are rounded to about 0.5 GPM, not guaranteed installed performance. [calculation]

What you knowWhat it tells youWhat it does not tell you
160,000 / 160,000 / 130,000 BTU/hThe respective RX160 / RXP160 / RX130 maximum burner inputsThe GPM available at every rise
0.97 / 0.97 / 0.97 UEFThe respective published efficiency metricsHow quickly a distant shower receives hot water
9.0 / 9.0 / 7.1 maximum GPMThe respective maker-sheet maximum flowsAn all-weather simultaneous fixture count
Measured winter rise plus the exact curveWhether demand fits that modelWhether the house’s gas and vent systems are adequate

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Separate shower flow from heater flow

A shower mixes hot and cold water. Count the hot portion when comparing demand with the heater curve; count any other simultaneous hot-water use separately.

For this example only, assume two showers each use 2.0 GPM of mixed water at 105°F, with a heater outlet of 120°F. These are selected inputs, not measured fixture flows or recommended control settings. Actual shower valves, pipe losses and water temperatures can change the result. [calculation]

At a 40°F inlet, the hot fraction is (105 − 40) ÷ (120 − 40), or 0.8125. Two showers total 4.0 GPM mixed, so their heater demand is 4.0 × 0.8125 = 3.25 GPM. The heater must deliver that hot flow at an 80°F rise. [calculation]

Assumed inletHeater rise at 120°F outletHot share of 105°F mixed waterTwo 2.0 GPM showers: heater demand
70°F50°F [calculation]35 ÷ 50 = 70% [calculation]2.80 GPM [calculation]
50°F70°F [calculation]55 ÷ 70 ≈ 78.6% [calculation]About 3.14 GPM [calculation]
40°F80°F [calculation]65 ÷ 80 = 81.25% [calculation]3.25 GPM [calculation]

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Formula: hot flow = mixed flow × (mixed temperature − inlet temperature) ÷ (heater outlet temperature − inlet temperature). Simplified steady-state mixing; excludes distribution losses. It is not a verified RX/RXP performance result.

If a separate tap takes an assumed 1.0 GPM entirely from the hot line during those cold-inlet showers, the combined heater demand becomes 4.25 GPM. That extra flow is an example input, not a typical tap rating. [calculation]

At an 80°F rise, RX160 and RXP160 each show about 4.0 GPM; RX130 shows about 3.0. The example’s 4.25 GPM combined demand exceeds all three rounded readings. None passes this combined-load example. Reduce overlapping use or ask the installer to assess a different heating capacity. [calculation]

The two showers alone need 3.25 GPM. That is below the RX160 and RXP160 rounded outputs, but above RX130’s approximately 3.0 GPM. Use actual flows and site conditions before selecting any of the three; a change in fixture overlap can change the result. [calculation]

A tub fill scheduled after the showers need not be counted as simultaneous shower demand. A bath that must fill while both showers run does. The installer needs that distinction before selecting a model or discussing a larger system.

Calculate the hot portion of shower demand

Example: 4.0 GPM mixed needs 3.25 GPM hot at an 80°F rise. [calculation]

Formula: hot flow = mixed flow × (mixed temperature − inlet temperature) ÷ (outlet temperature − inlet temperature). Simplified steady-state mixing excludes pipe losses and other hot-water uses. These inputs illustrate arithmetic, not recommended control settings. Sizing reference.

Check the gas supply before the model

The RX and RXP need a fuel-supply assessment for the installed system. A fitting size on the heater is not proof that the existing branch can serve it.

Question for the installerEvidence to requestWhy it matters
Can the meter and branch serve the heater with other loads?Gas-load and pipe-sizing assessment for the actual routeAssess the selected 160,000 or 130,000 BTU/h heater alongside other connected appliances [1]
Which fuel will be configured?Correct fuel selection and commissioning recordSmart-Sense fuel flexibility does not remove professional setup
Does inlet pressure meet the manual under operation?Professional pressure verificationPipe appearance alone cannot verify operating supply
Is the appliance correctly commissioned?Completed maker checklist and combustion checksA running burner by itself is not a full installation check

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

The RX specification lists a 3/4-inch gas connection. It also discusses smaller supply-line compatibility under specified conditions. Do not turn either statement into a blanket pipe-sizing instruction. Route length, fittings and other appliance loads belong in the qualified installer’s calculation. [1]

Rinnai describes natural gas and propane support through Smart-Sense. That feature is a commissioning capability, not homeowner permission to switch fuels. The installer must confirm the fuel configuration and follow the manual. Do not adjust the appliance’s internal gas valve to chase a flow or temperature complaint.

Underside of a Rinnai RXP160iN cabinet showing the hot, cold and gas connections and a drain port
The RXP160’s underside in Rinnai’s listing images: hot, cold and gas connections, plus a drain port. Product photo: Amazon.
If you smell gas

If you smell gas, leave the building. Do not light appliances, touch electrical switches or use any phone inside the building. From a neighbor’s phone, call the gas supplier and follow its instructions. If the supplier cannot be reached, call the fire department.

Carbon monoxide alarms

Rinnai recommends a carbon monoxide (CO) alarm in the hallway near bedrooms in each sleeping area. Its manual says to check batteries monthly and replace them annually. Follow local alarm requirements as well.

Keep the intake and exhaust approved

A gas appliance needs the specified combustion-air and exhaust route. Have a qualified professional inspect it; do not block a termination or improvise a vent repair.

Plan the vent and condensate as separate jobs

Condensing design affects the exhaust system and produces condensate that must be disposed of correctly. An RX or RXP needs both paths planned before its wall position is settled.

PathWhat the RX/RXP plan must establishMistake to avoid
Intake and exhaustApproved materials, equivalent route length and termination clearancesReusing an old vent because its diameter looks right
Condensate drainCorrosion-resistant route and disposal complying with local requirementsEnding a drain where it can freeze or discharge improperly
Condensate pump, if neededSuitable pumped route where gravity drainage is unavailableChoosing the heater location before checking the drain elevation
Pressure relief dischargeIts own safe, code-compliant discharge arrangementJoining it to the condensate line or plugging a discharge

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Rinnai condensing tankless heater mounted on a basement wall with its vent pipes running up between the joists
An indoor RX-style install from Rinnai’s listing images: intake and exhaust run up through the joists. Your installer still sets the route and terminations. Product photo: Amazon.

The Rinnai manual specifically separates condensate drainage from pressure relief discharge. They solve different problems. Ask the installer to identify both on the proposed layout. A wall drawing with only intake and exhaust pipes leaves out part of the installation.

Condensate treatment is also a site question. Local disposal rules determine what the installation needs. Do not assume every drain destination accepts untreated condensate. Have the installer document the compliant disposal route and service requirements; neither the RX nor RXP’s efficiency rating settles that question.

Rinnai’s outdoor configuration differs from its indoor vent arrangement. This does not mean every indoor vent accessory is removed and the heater can be placed anywhere. Location clearances, electrical protection and exposed-water protection remain part of the outdoor configuration. Confirm those points before choosing a wall.

Decide whether you need recirculation

The RXP addresses water that cools in the distribution pipes between uses. It does not remove the need to size the burner for the fixtures that run together.

Household situationUseful questionDirection
Long wait at a distant bathroomIs there a dedicated return or approved crossover plan?Consider RXP after the route and controls are specified
Short pipe run with an acceptable waitWhat problem would a pump solve here?RX may fit without an internal pump
Hot water cools when other fixtures runDoes measured demand exceed available flow at winter rise?Check capacity before treating this as a pump problem
Daily routine variesWhich control method suits actual occupancy?Have the installer explain Smart-Circ and compatible control options

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

A dedicated return gives circulated water a separate path back. A crossover arrangement uses an approved connection between the hot and cold sides. The RX/RXP manual gives different setup requirements for those configurations. Ask which layout is planned and how it affects cold-water behavior at the crossover fixture.

Smart-Circ learns usage rather than promising immediate hot water at every faucet at all times. A branch beyond the circulating loop can still hold cooled water. Have the installer mark which fixtures the loop serves so the expected benefit is tied to the pipe layout rather than to a feature name.

Wi-Fi capable and pump included are different claims. The RXP has the internal pump; remote-control capability may involve separate compatible hardware. The maker’s specification separates standard equipment from optional controls.

Rinnai’s RXP sheet lists the standard package contents. The Amazon listing does not itemize the carton, so loose-part inclusion in that offer is unverified; a photo does not resolve it.

Protect outdoor pipes through freezing weather

Rinnai’s freeze protection depends on electrical power. The manual also warns that the heater’s protection does not protect all external piping and valves.

ExposureWhat to planWho confirms it
Heater installed outdoorsApproved outdoor configuration, allowed location and maker freeze requirementsQualified installer
Exposed supply and service valvesProtection specifically for the external plumbingInstaller using locally suitable methods
Condensate route outsideProtection and routing that prevent a frozen discharge pathInstaller under maker and local requirements
Cold-weather power lossWritten maker-based draining or protection planInstaller before the first freezing outage

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

A gas burner does not make the RX or RXP independent of electricity. The specified power supply operates the appliance and supports its protective functions. If outage resilience is part of the reason for replacing a tank, discuss the actual electrical requirement before assuming gas tankless will keep operating.

Ask for a winter handover plan before the first cold spell, including who handles shutdown and draining when needed. Rinnai’s maintenance precautions require electrical disconnection, gas shutoff and water isolation. Do not open a hot, pressurized heater to improvise a freeze drain. Repairs and maintenance, including draining, belong to a trained and qualified professional under Rinnai’s instructions.

If the heater or exposed piping has frozen, Rinnai says not to operate it. The manual calls for closing gas and water valves and turning off power, followed by checks after thawing. Arrange professional inspection rather than repeatedly trying to run a frozen appliance or applying an open flame.

Rheem and Navien specifications compared

These are neutral comparisons of manufacturer specifications. Only the RX and RXP are purchase picks here.

Comparison subjectManufacturer specificationModel distinction
Rheem RTGH-84DVLN-3157,000 BTU/h; 0.93 UEF; 4.6 GPM at 67°F rise in the cited RTGH sheet [6] Natural-gas -3 model; separate from the propane -3 and older -2 [6]
Rheem RTG-95DVLN-3Non-condensing model in the RTG sheetRTG non-condensing series differs from RTGH condensing series
Navien NPE-240A2ComfortFlow combines a buffer tank and recirculation pumpCondensing heater with integrated recirculation

Sources: Rheem model sheets and Navien specifications.

Rheem’s 4.6 GPM at a stated 67°F rise is more useful for a particular load than an unexplained maximum-flow claim. It still cannot be compared fairly with an RX number taken at an unspecified rise. Put both units at the same conditions before deciding which provides enough winter water. [6]

Navien describes the NPE-240A2’s ComfortFlow system as a combination of buffer tank and recirculation pump. The RX160iN has no built-in pump and the RXP160iN includes one. Those are manufacturer-described configuration differences; this comparison does not establish a measured delivery-time ranking.

Keep the broader two-brand question separate from the RX-versus-RXP choice. My Navien versus Rinnai comparison covers that decision. The three purchase options here differ in burner input as well as pump configuration. Each still needs its own winter-demand and installation assessment.

Where listings and maker documents disagree

Use the exact model’s maker documents for specifications, and keep unresolved differences visible. Do not silently combine a favorable number from one revision with another model’s accessories.

ItemListing or webpageMaker documentHow to use the evidence
RX199iN maximum flow (neutral comparison)Earlier Amazon title and Rinnai webpage: 11.1 GPM [calculation] RX sheet: 11.0 GPM; 199,000 BTU/h; 0.98 UEF; no internal pump [1] Larger-burner specification reference only
RXP199iN maximum flow (neutral comparison)Earlier Amazon title and Rinnai webpage: 11.1 GPM [calculation] RXP sheet: 11.0 GPM; 199,000 BTU/h; 0.98 UEF; internal pump [2] Larger-burner specification reference only
RX pump capabilityRecirculation capability can sound like included hardwareRX sheet lists an optional internal-pump conversion; RXP sheet describes its integrated pumpBase RX160 and RX130 have no internal pump
RXP160 package contentsAmazon listing does not itemize the cartonRXP specification 100000884 lists a thermal bypass valve and mounting hardware as included [calculation] Maker package description only; exact seller carton contents unverified

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Plan for water quality and service access

The RX/RXP manual requires annual inspection by a trained, qualified professional. Water conditions also affect cleaning needs, so maintenance belongs in the buying decision.

Before purchaseWhat to recordReason
Check supply-water qualityHardness and other results against maker limitsA flushing appointment does not by itself correct unsuitable water
Leave access for serviceClearances and reachable isolation pointsThe heater needs inspection and maintenance after mounting
Agree on cleaning requirementsMaker procedure and interval suited to conditionsDo not borrow another brand’s flushing schedule
Keep purchase and install recordsExact model, serial, receipt and commissioning informationWarranty terms depend on the applicable coverage and installation conditions

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Rinnai’s water-quality table lists total hardness up to 200 mg/L and pH 6.5 to 8.5. Those are limits in the manual, not a promise that every supply within them needs identical treatment or cleaning. Compare the full water-quality table with actual results and have the installer explain any treatment recommendation. [1] [3]

Service access needs usable space, not just permission to mount the cabinet between obstacles. Ask whether the service valves and drain points remain reachable after shelving or a pipe cover is installed. A pump-equipped RXP still needs routine appliance maintenance; recirculation is not a cleaning function.

Rinnai requires repairs and maintenance by a trained and qualified professional. Before service, that professional must let hot parts and water cool, disconnect electrical power, shut off gas, isolate the water and relieve pressure under the maker’s procedure. Gloves and safety glasses protect against hot water and injury. Do not open a hot, pressurized heater.

Warranty coverage is not a prediction of appliance life. Check the current warranty for the exact model, application and installation, including any registration or operating-hour conditions. Keep the dated receipt. Avoid comparing a headline heat-exchanger term with another maker’s entire-appliance coverage as though those were the same promise.

How to choose for your house

Bring a demand worksheet and an installation plan to the same decision. A heater that meets only one of those requirements is not ready to select.

  1. Describe the simultaneous demand

    List the fixtures that must run together and their actual flows. Separate mixed shower flow from hot-only uses, then establish the coldest expected inlet temperature.

  2. Ask for the exact curve point

    Have the installer match the selected RX160iN, RXP160iN or RX130iN output to that temperature rise. Do not accept a maximum GPM label as the whole sizing calculation.

  3. Have the installer check fuel and venting

    Rinnai requires trained, qualified installation and commissioning. The assessment needs gas sizing and an approved combustion-air/exhaust route before any gas work begins.

  4. Choose the pump around the pipe layout

    Use RX for a suitable installation without an internal-pump requirement. Use RXP when a dedicated-return or approved crossover arrangement and control method are specified.

  5. Confirm drain, power and service needs

    Document the condensate route, separate relief discharge, grounded electrical supply and annual-service access. Include an outdoor freeze and outage plan when applicable.

  6. Match the order to the approved model

    Read RX versus RXP and every suffix. Confirm heater versus accessory, current New availability and included contents before purchasing the exact linked item.

If the gas, vent or winter-demand assessment rules out all three picks, pause the heater purchase. That is a useful result of the planning work. Changing fixture overlap or considering a different system belongs with the installer’s sizing discussion, not with an unsupported promise that any gas tankless heater will cover the house.

Keep equipment selection separate from the installation estimate. Ask which vent parts, valves and drain work the installation includes, along with any electrical or permit requirements. My tankless installation cost guide explains the broader scope; no product-price assumptions are needed to identify those tasks.

Questions about gas tankless water heaters

Common questions about whole-house selection, winter flow and the RX/RXP difference.

What is the best gas tankless water heater for a whole house?

RX160iN is my starting pick when its winter curve fits; RXP160iN suits planned recirculation at the same maximum input. RX130iN serves smaller checked demand. None is a universal house-size recommendation. Confirm output at winter temperature rise and have a qualified installer approve the gas supply, vent route and drain.

How many showers can an 11.1 GPM heater run?

The maximum-flow headline cannot establish that. Use actual simultaneous hot-water demand at the required temperature rise. Two assumed 2.0 GPM showers at 105°F need 3.25 GPM of 120°F hot water with a 40°F inlet, before other use or losses. At that 80°F rise, the rounded readings are RX160 4.0 GPM, RXP160 4.0 and RX130 3.0; confirm installed conditions separately. [calculation]

What is the difference between Rinnai RX and RXP?

The base RX160iN has no internal recirculation pump; RXP160iN includes one. Both list 160,000 BTU/h maximum input, 0.97 UEF and 9.0 GPM maximum flow in their respective Rinnai sheets. The pump changes the distribution arrangement, not the listed burner capacity. [1]

Will recirculation give instant hot water at every tap?

No general promise follows from the RXP pump. Delivery depends on the return layout, controls and pipe branches serving each fixture. The manual describes dedicated and crossover modes. Ask the installer which taps the planned loop serves and what wait can remain outside that loop.

Can a gas tankless water heater work without electricity?

The RX and RXP require electrical power; the specified appliance supply is 120 VAC, 60 Hz. Rinnai also ties freeze protection to power. If outages matter, have a qualified professional establish an approved protection plan rather than assuming the gas connection makes either heater independent of electricity. [calculation] [1]

Can the RX160iN, RXP160iN or RX130iN go outdoors?

Rinnai allows these heaters outdoors in its approved outdoor configuration. The installer must also satisfy placement clearances and protect exposed piping and the condensate route. The cabinet’s freeze protection does not cover all external valves and pipes, and a freezing power outage needs a separate plan.

Is Rheem RTG-84XLN-1 the same as RTG-84XLN-3?

Treat them as different exact models. RTG-84XLN-1 and RTG-84XLN-3 are distinct model identifiers. Specifications and accessory compatibility for the -3 do not establish the older -1 model’s specifications. A suffix is part of the appliance identity, not an interchangeable name. [1] [3]

Does a condensing heater need a drain?

The RX/RXP manual requires compliant condensate disposal. It specifies corrosion-resistant drainage and separates condensate from pressure relief discharge. Have the installer establish the drain route, any required neutralization and freeze protection. An outdoor cap does not remove condensate from the installation plan.

Can I replace a tank heater with tankless myself?

Rinnai requires trained, qualified installation and service. A replacement needs fuel sizing, combustion-air and exhaust checks, plus compliant water, drain and electrical connections. Have a qualified professional do the gas and vent work. Rinnai also reserves repairs and maintenance for a trained and qualified professional, with cooling, electrical/gas/water isolation and pressure precautions under its procedure.

How often does a Rinnai gas tankless heater need maintenance?

The RX/RXP manual requires annual inspection by a trained, qualified professional. Cleaning needs depend on water quality and operating conditions. Follow this model’s instructions rather than transferring a Rheem interval or assuming a pump removes scale. Keep the service record with the model and serial information.

Are the picks covered by the 2025 Rinnai recall?

The cited June 2025 CPSC notice concerns specified i-Series Plus boilers rather than RX or RXP tankless water heaters. The November 15, 2026 search for these picks found no applicable active recall. Check the exact model and serial against current notices before installation; a brand search alone is not unlimited clearance.

How I choose

Why I recommend these models

I’m Isaac Daniels, and I’m responsible for these recommendations. The RX/RXP distinctions come from Rinnai’s specification, installation manual and model pages. I separate model-specific source facts from conditional buying judgments and show the winter-capacity differences.

How I chose

I compared three exact heater models, their pump arrangements and installation requirements. I re-read the Amazon listings on Nov 15, 2026, 12:47 PM EST for genuine model identity, New condition and stock: RX160, RXP160 and RX130 are all branded Rinnai, new and in stock on Amazon.

I compare the actual model specifications below rather than assigning a score. The water-mixing example is arithmetic with stated assumptions, not a measured heater test. CPSC recall evidence was checked for model relevance. Product photos come from Amazon from the Amazon listings.

Selection checkHow it changes the recommendation
Winter heating capacityRequire the matching maker curve; no fabricated flow result or bathroom count
Pump and return pathRX without a built-in pump; RXP for designed internal-pump recirculation
Installation fitGas, approved vent, condensate, electricity and freeze requirements must all be addressed
Offer identityRecommend only exact genuine Rinnai models, new and in stock in the Amazon listing check of Nov 15, 2026, 12:47 PM EST

Sources: RX specifications and curves, RXP specifications and curves, installation requirements. Sizing examples use the stated assumptions.

Sources