Is the basin staying?
If the basin is sound and big enough, buy a bare pump and reuse it. If there’s no pit yet, or the old basin is cracked or too small, the Liberty P382LE41 replaces the whole thing.
The best sewage ejector pump depends on the basin, discharge and required flow. A sewage ejector pump sits in a sealed basin under the basement floor and lifts the bathroom’s waste up to the sewer line. I’d start with the Zoeller M267, and I’d take the Liberty LE51A when the job needs more flow or the basin is shallow.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure
Updated November 15, 2026

Top pick: Zoeller M267 Waste-Mate, for a bathroom basin you’re keeping that’s at least 18 in. across and 30 in. deep. [1]
It’s the only ejector pump here with its float switch built in, where a tethered float can hang up on the pump or the pit. [1] [2] The downside: it moves 85 GPM at 10 ft of head, and Liberty lists 118 for the LE51A. [1] [7]
I compared ten models using maker manuals and spec sheets.
The documents are Zoeller’s technical data sheets, installation instructions and sizing worksheet, and Liberty’s specification sheets, sales sheets and installation manual.

Product photo: Amazon.
For a bathroom basin you’re keeping, this is my first choice.

Product photo: Amazon.
For a job that needs more flow, or a shallower basin, this is the one to get.

Product photo: Amazon.
For a new pit, this one brings the basin, cover, pump and float in one piece.

Product photo: Amazon.
For a house where more than toilet paper gets flushed, this is the grinder.
Maker figures from each model’s own documents. Flow is listed at a total head, because at shut-off head the flow is zero.
| Model | Type and discharge | Float switch | Flow and shut-off head | Basin | Motor | Purchase |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zoeller M267 Waste-Mate | Zoeller calls it a sewage ejector pump. [3] Maker spec: passes 2 in. spherical solids, with a 2-inch NPT discharge. [1] | Built into the pump: Zoeller lists an integral float-operated mechanical switch. [1] Maker spec: on at 12 in., off at 4 in. [1] | Maker spec: 115 GPM at 5 ft, 85 at 10 ft and 45 at 15 ft, with a 20.5 ft shut-off head. [1] Zoeller’s sales sheet says up to 128 GPM and 21.5 ft in its bullets, above a table that matches the technical sheet. [4] | Maker spec: 18 x 30 in. minimum for one pump. [1] | Maker spec: 1/2 hp, 115 V, 9.4 amps. [1] | Check price on Amazon for Zoeller M267 Waste-Mate |
| Liberty Pumps LE51A | Liberty calls it a submersible sewage pump. [6] Maker spec: handles 2 in. solids, with a 2-inch FNPT discharge. [7] | Tethered: Liberty lists a wide-angle float switch on a piggyback plug. [7] [8] Maker spec: on at 14 in., off at 6 in. [8] | Maker spec: 141 GPM at 5 ft and 118 GPM at 10 ft. [6] [7] Liberty’s specification gives a 24 ft shut-off head, and its sales sheet says 25 ft maximum head. [6] [7] | Maker spec: at least 18 in. across and 24 in. deep. [8] | Maker spec: 1/2 hp, 115 V, 12 amps. [6] | Check price on Amazon for Liberty Pumps LE51A |
| Liberty Pumps P382LE41 | Liberty calls it a simplex sewage system, shipped completely assembled. [9] Maker spec: a pump that handles 2 in. solids, with a 2 in. discharge. [9] [11] | Tethered: a wide-angle piggyback float on Liberty’s QuickTree, which comes out through the access cover without pulling the pump. [9] [10] Liberty prints no on and off levels for the assembled system. | Liberty’s system sheet sends you to its LE-Series literature for pump performance. [9] Maker spec for the LE40-Series pump: 125 GPM at 5 ft, with a 21 ft shut-off head. [11] | It brings its own basin: 41 gallons, 24.38 in. across and 24 in. tall on Liberty’s drawing. [9] [10] Its 4 in. inlet is molded into the side, centered 14.75 in. above the base. [8] [10] | Maker spec: 4/10 hp, 115 V, 12 amps. [11] [9] | Check price on Amazon for Liberty Pumps P382LE41 |
| Zoeller Shark M807 | Zoeller calls it a residential grinder pump. [12] Maker spec: a 1-1/4 inch NPT discharge and a 440C stainless steel cutter and plate. [12] | Built into the pump: Zoeller lists an integral float-operated mechanical switch. [12] Maker spec: on at 13 in., off at 5-3/4 in. [12] | Maker spec: 45 GPM at 5 ft, 42 at 10 ft, 35 at 20 ft and 27 at 30 ft, with a 55 ft shut-off head. [12] | Zoeller recommends a pit 18 in. or larger in diameter, and prints no minimum depth. [13] Its drawing shows the pump 17-1/4 in. tall, and its product page lists a 14 in. shipping height. [12] [15] | Maker spec: 1 hp, 115 V, 11 amps. [12] | Check price on Amazon for Zoeller Shark M807 |
Buy a sewage ejector pump when the bathroom sits below the sewer line, so its waste has to be lifted. If the fixtures drain downhill on their own, you don’t need one.
Skip all three ejector picks if anything besides toilet paper goes down that toilet. That house needs the grinder, unless it drains to a septic tank, and the makers’ own wording is under How to choose.
With a basin you’re keeping, start with the Zoeller M267, and take the Liberty LE51A for more flow or a basin under the Zoeller minimum. For a new pit, the Liberty P382LE41 brings the basin with it.
For groundwater, see the sump pump guide. If cutting concrete is the sticking point, read the upflush comparison before you rent a rotary hammer.
Enter the basin or the hole, the pipe run and the circuit. It checks all four picks against the makers’ figures.
Use this checker to narrow the choices, then have a qualified plumber confirm total head, venting, electrical supply and local requirements. Keep wipes and sanitary products out of every toilet, including one served by a grinder.
How it figures head: Zoeller’s worksheet adds friction head, static head and any sewer pressure to get total dynamic head. [5] Sewer pressure is left at zero here, which fits a line that drops into a gravity sewer.
For a 2 in. line it counts 5.2 ft of pipe for each elbow, 17.2 ft for the swing check valve and 1.4 ft for the gate valve, then charges 1.10 ft of head per 100 ft of plastic pipe. [5] Steel pipe has more friction, and Zoeller lists it in a separate column.
It then asks each pump for the minimum flow the worksheet sets for your pipe size, at that head. [5] Between the heads a maker prints, and from the last one up to shut-off, it draws a straight line, and it calls anything under twice the needed flow a close call.
For a new pit it measures your hole against Liberty’s drawing of the tank, plus the extra width Liberty recommends around it. [10] [8]
Check your measurements against the maker’s guide for the pump you choose: Zoeller’s installation instructions and Liberty’s installation manual are both listed in Sources.
Measure across the inside of the basin and from its floor to the underside of the cover, then compare both with the Basin column.
Zoeller’s general installation sheet also draws an 18 x 24 in. basin and notes that larger depths may be required. [2] For the 267, go by its own sheet, which sets the deeper minimum. [1] For a new pit, Liberty recommends a hole at least 8 in. wider than the tank, bedded and backfilled with pea gravel or washed crushed stone, never sand or native soil. [8]
The pump has to start before the water climbs into the inlet pipe. Measure from the basin floor up to the bottom of the inlet, and compare that with the on level in the Float switch column.
Liberty’s manual says the float shouldn’t sit directly under the inlet or in the path of incoming water. [8] Zoeller wants the pump level and the float mechanism clear of the basin’s sides before it starts. [2] [13]
Zoeller requires a basin cover on every installation, and gas-tight seals to contain gases and odors. [2] [13] Liberty says the basin must be completely sealed and properly vented under local health and plumbing codes. [8]
Liberty calls for a check valve, then a gate valve after it so the check valve can be cleaned or the pump pulled. [8] Zoeller says that with a check valve in the line, a vent hole of about 3/16 in. must be drilled in the discharge pipe below the check valve and the pit cover, to purge trapped air. [2] [13] For the grinder, Zoeller also calls for a check valve and a union in the discharge line. [13]
If the basin is sound and big enough, buy a bare pump and reuse it. If there’s no pit yet, or the old basin is cracked or too small, the Liberty P382LE41 replaces the whole thing.
Size it by the flow the pump makes at your total head, not by horsepower.
Zoeller’s worksheet counts a bathroom group of a lavatory, a tub or shower and a toilet as 6 fixture units. [5] It sets a minimum of 21 GPM for a 2 in. discharge pipe and 46 GPM for a 3 in. pipe, and the pump has to make that flow at your calculated head. [5] The checker above runs those numbers for all four picks.
Mostly electric shock and sewer gas. Here’s each warning and who gives it.
Electric shock and fire
Sewer gas
Health and injury
Digging a new pit
Flooding and what gets flushed
The Zoeller M267 is my first pick for a basement bathroom, because its float switch is integral to the pump and needs no external control. [1] Liberty’s LE51A is the better buy when the job needs more flow, since Liberty lists more water at the same head. [7] [1]
Zoeller and Liberty Pumps are the two I’d look at, and each backs the pumps on this page with a three-year warranty. [2] [13] [8] [10] Zoeller counts the 267’s three years from the date of purchase and the Shark grinder’s from the date of manufacture. [2] [13] Zoeller’s warranty on the 267 covers a pump bought from an authorized seller, and it requires proof of purchase. [2] Liberty’s manual says to keep the dated sales receipt for warranty. [8] Both makers also publish a manual and flow figures for the exact model, and those are what you size the job with.
The Amazon listing data for Liberty LE51A and P382LE41 says two years, while Liberty’s current LE50 and Pro380 specifications say three years. I use the current manufacturer documents here. Confirm the applicable warranty and seller eligibility before ordering.
An ejector pump, unless something besides toilet paper gets flushed.
Zoeller says its grinder is meant to grind normal sewage with reasonable quantities of disposable diapers, sanitary napkins, paper towels and cleaning wipes. [13] It doesn’t recommend a grinder pump in any part of a septic system. [13] So I’d treat the grinder as protection against what gets flushed by mistake, and keep wipes out of the toilet either way.
It’s the sealed basin set into the basement floor that the bathroom drains into and the pump sits in.
Liberty says the basin for sewage must be sealed and vented to meet health and plumbing code requirements. [8] The Basin column in the table has the minimum size for each pump.
No, and Zoeller says why: dewatering and effluent sump pumps are not designed for use in pits handling raw sewage. [2] The ejector and sump pump comparison covers the difference.
Every three months: Zoeller says to inspect and test the system at least that often. [2] [13] Liberty’s quarterly list covers free float switch movement and check valve operation. [8]
Yes, 267-0001 is Zoeller’s item number for the 115 V automatic Model 267 with the snap-action switch and a 10 ft cord. [3] Zoeller’s parts list names the automatic 115 V pump the M267. [14] In the same way, 807-0001 is its item number for the 115 V automatic Model 807 with the snap-action switch and a 15 ft cord, which its data sheet lists as the M807. [15] [12]
Zoeller says pump installation and servicing should be done by a qualified person, and the electrical circuits by a qualified licensed electrician. [2] [13] For the Shark grinder, it says repair and service belong to an authorized Zoeller service station. [13] Liberty says all installation, maintenance and wiring shall be done by qualified personnel, and that licensed electrical personnel should be present the first time the breaker is energized. [8]
Call a plumber to cut a new pit, to tie the basin into the vent or the sewer line, or when the discharge pipe is smaller than the pump’s outlet. Call one when the checker above says none of the four fits, and when the basin holds standing sewage and the pump won’t run.
I compared ten models. Four are the picks above, and six are close variants or rivals.