One-piece vs two-piece toilet

Four real toilets, two of each, compared on what the piece count actually changes.

American Standard Town Square S one-piece toilet with skirted sides
American Standard Town Square S one-piece toilet with skirted sides. Product photo: Amazon.

The short answer

One-piece if you clean often and have help carrying it: the Town Square S. Two-piece if it goes upstairs or you set it alone: the Champion PRO.

Best one-piece for easy cleaning → Town Square S

Best two-piece for stairs → Champion PRO

Best one-piece for a big flush valve → Champion 4

Best two-piece with a light bowl → TOTO Drake

Check it on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.

Two of each, side by side

Two one-piece and two two-piece toilets, all elongated, all 12 in. rough-in. All four were new and in stock on Amazon on Oct 23, 2026, and each scores 7.0 or higher.

How the four compare on my spec score

Five checks from each maker’s product page and spec sheet, equal weight. The piece count isn’t one of them; it’s a fit choice, covered below.

Town Square S (1-pc)9.6Champion PRO (2-pc)9.4Champion 4 (1-pc)9.0TOTO Drake (2-pc)7.4010Town Square S (1-pc)9.6Champion PRO (2-pc)9.4Champion 4 (1-pc)9.0TOTO Drake (2-pc)7.4
PlumbingPicks spec score out of 10, from American Standard’s product pages and TOTO’s spec sheet, read Oct 23, 2026. It is not a customer rating.

The top one-piece and the top two-piece land within two tenths of each other. That’s the honest result: the piece count doesn’t make a toilet better. Water use, trapway, seat, warranty and height do, and those are set by the model.

The TOTO Drake scores lowest because TOTO prints a 1-year warranty on its sheet and ships it without a seat. It earns its place with the lightest single piece to carry of the four.

Each toilet, in detail

What each maker publishes, what the piece count means for that model, and where each one lost points.

Best one-piece for easy cleaning

Town Square S (one-piece)

American Standard Town Square S 2851A104 one-piece chair-height elongated toilet, 1.28 gpf, with seat

American Standard Town Square S one-piece toilet with skirted sides
Product photo: Amazon

2851A104.020, white

Check it on Amazon
9.6Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Water use10
Trapway size8
Seat in the box10
Warranty10
Accessible height10

Pros

  • One piece with skirted sides to wipe
  • 1.28 gpf, WaterSense certified
  • Slow-close seat in the box
  • Lifetime china warranty, 10 years on parts
  • 16½ in. chair height, ADA compliant

Cons

  • 107 lb in one piece, per Amazon’s item data
  • 2⅛ in. trapway, smaller than the Champions
  • Trim style may not suit a plain bath
One-piece1.28 gpf3 in. flush valve2⅛ in. trapwaySeat included12 in. rough-in

Buy it if

You want the easiest toilet to keep clean, and someone can help you carry it in and set it.

Skip it if

You’re setting it alone up a flight of stairs. Take the Champion PRO two-piece.

The Town Square S is the one-piece I’d pick, and I’ve used it. Tank and bowl are one casting, and the sides are skirted, so there’s no seam between tank and bowl and no exposed trapway curve to clean around.

American Standard rates it at 1.28 gpf and WaterSense certified, about 20% less water than a 1.6 gpf toilet. It uses a 3 in. flush valve, a 2⅛ in. trapway and a PowerWash rim, with the EverClean antimicrobial surface on the china.

The bowl is 16½ in. high, chair height, and American Standard calls it ADA compliant. With the included slow-close seat, the page lists 18¾ in. to the top of the seat.

Its warranty is the best of the four: lifetime on the chinaware, 10 years on the mechanical parts and 1 year on the seat.

Where it lost points: the 2⅛ in. trapway is smaller than the 2⅜ in. on both Champions, so it scored 8 on that check. The style is detailed, with crown-molding lines that match the rest of American Standard’s Town Square S collection.

Now the one-piece trade-off. Amazon’s item data puts it at 107.1 lb, in one carton, with nothing to grip but smooth china. My call: plan on two people for the carry and the set.

Setting a one-piece means lowering the whole weight onto the wax ring in one go. There’s no setting the bowl first and adding the tank after. My toilet replacement guide walks through the set.

American Standard also sells a skirted two-piece Town Square S, so the same look comes in either design if your stairs end up deciding it.

My call: if the bathroom is on the main floor and you clean it weekly, this is the toilet. Skirted sides and no tank seam save you time every week for years.

Best two-piece for stairs

Champion PRO (two-piece)

American Standard Champion PRO 211AA104 two-piece chair-height elongated toilet, 1.28 gpf, seat sold separately

American Standard Champion PRO two-piece toilet with a separate tank
Product photo: Amazon

211AA104.020, white

Check it on Amazon
9.4Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Water use10
Trapway size10
Seat in the box7
Warranty10
Accessible height10

Pros

  • Tank and bowl come apart for the carry
  • 1,000 g MaP score, per American Standard
  • 4 in. flush valve, 2⅜ in. trapway
  • 1.28 gpf, WaterSense certified
  • 10-year warranty, ADA compliant

Cons

  • Seat sold separately
  • Tank-to-bowl gasket and bolts to install and maintain
  • Seam between tank and bowl to wipe
Two-piece1.28 gpf4 in. flush valve2⅜ in. trapwayNo seat12 in. rough-in

Buy it if

The toilet goes upstairs, you’re setting it alone, or you want the biggest trapway here at 1.28 gpf.

Skip it if

You want a seat in the box and no seam to clean. Take the Town Square S.

The Champion PRO is the two-piece I’d pick, and I’ve used it. American Standard gives it a 1,000 g MaP score, which it calls the highest rating possible, and says it flushes a bucket of golf balls in one go.

It does that at 1.28 gpf, WaterSense certified, through a 4 in. flush valve and a 2⅜ in. fully glazed trapway. Those are the largest valve and trapway on this page, at the lower water use.

The two-piece build is why it’s my stairs pick. The tank and bowl are separate pieces, so you carry the bowl, then the tank. Amazon’s item data puts the whole toilet at 100.6 lb; American Standard doesn’t print the split.

You pay for that with a joint. A two-piece has a tank-to-bowl gasket and bolts, and a seam where the tank sits on the bowl. My tank-to-bowl gasket guide lists the parts by brand when that gasket ever weeps.

Where it lost points: the seat is sold separately, so it scored 7 on that check. American Standard lists its Champion slow-close seat, 5321A65CT, as the matching option.

The rest is strong. It’s chair height, 17 in. including a seat, ADA compliant, with a metal trip lever and a metal-shank fill valve. American Standard backs it with a 10-year warranty and calls it a trade-exclusive model.

My call: buy the seat with it. A toilet without a seat on install day means a second trip.

American Standard’s page offers it in white, bone and linen, all at the same 12 in. rough-in, so it fits the spacing most older toilets use.

If you’re weighing it against a one-piece, the flush and water use are the same or better here. You’re choosing the carry over the seam.

Best one-piece for a big flush valve

Champion 4 (one-piece)

American Standard Champion 4 2034.314 one-piece chair-height elongated toilet, 1.6 gpf, with seat

American Standard Champion 4 one-piece elongated toilet
Product photo: Amazon

2034.314.020, white

Check it on Amazon
9.0Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Water use7
Trapway size10
Seat in the box10
Warranty10
Accessible height8

Pros

  • 4 in. flush valve, the industry’s largest per American Standard
  • 2⅜ in. fully glazed trapway
  • Slow-close seat in the box
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • One piece, no tank seam

Cons

  • 1.6 gpf, more water than the 1.28 gpf picks
  • 115 lb in one piece, per Amazon’s item data
  • No ADA statement on its page
One-piece1.6 gpf4 in. flush valve2⅜ in. trapwaySeat included12 in. rough-in

Buy it if

You want a one-piece with the Champion flush and 1.6 gpf is allowed where you live.

Skip it if

Your state or code limits toilets to 1.28 gpf, or you want the lightest carry. Check before you order.

The Champion 4 is the one-piece for someone who wants the Champion flush without a tank seam, and I’ve used it. American Standard calls it virtually clog-free.

It shares the Champion PRO’s 4 in. flush valve, which American Standard says is the largest in the industry, and a 2⅜ in. fully glazed trapway. Every one is factory flush tested, per the page.

The difference is water. It’s rated at 1.6 gpf, not 1.28, so it scored 7 on water use. Some states and local codes require 1.28 gpf or less on new installs. My call: check yours before you order this one.

It’s chair height at 16½ in. to the rim, and 18 7/16 in. with the included slow-close seat. Its page talks about chair-height comfort but doesn’t call it ADA compliant the way the Town Square S and Champion PRO pages do, so it scored 8 on that check.

The seat comes in the box, along with a chrome trip lever and bolt caps. The warranty is a 10-year limited.

It’s also the heaviest single piece here: Amazon’s item data says 115 lb. That’s 8 lb more than the Town Square S, in a single smooth casting.

Like the Town Square S, it’s elongated with a 12 in. rough-in, so it drops into the same space most toilets leave behind.

So the one-piece trade-off is sharpest on this model. You get the cleaning ease and the big flush, and you need a plan for the carry. My call: two people, a dolly to the bathroom door, and the old toilet out before the new one comes in.

Compared with its two-piece cousin, the PRO, it uses more water and weighs more, but it comes with a seat and has no tank joint to wipe or reseal.

Best two-piece with a light bowl

TOTO Drake (two-piece)

TOTO Drake CST776CSFG two-piece elongated Universal Height toilet, 1.6 gpf, Tornado Flush, seat sold separately

TOTO Drake two-piece elongated toilet in Cotton White
Product photo: Amazon

CST776CSFG#01, Cotton White

Check it on Amazon
7.4Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Water use7
Trapway size8
Seat in the box7
Warranty5
Accessible height10

Pros

  • 62 lb bowl and 32 lb tank, per TOTO
  • Tank sold alone as ST776SA
  • Tornado Flush with CeFiONtect glaze
  • Universal Height, ADA with the lever on the approach side
  • Works at 8 psi flowing

Cons

  • 1-year limited warranty on TOTO’s sheet
  • Seat sold separately
  • 1.6 gpf
Two-piece1.6 gpfTornado Flush2⅛ in. trapwayNo seat12 in. rough-in

Buy it if

You’re carrying it up tight stairs alone, and you want the lightest pieces of any toilet here.

Skip it if

You want a long warranty in writing. TOTO’s sheet says one year.

The TOTO Drake is the two-piece with the lightest pieces, and I’ve used it. TOTO’s spec sheet gives shipping weights of 62 lb for the bowl and 32 lb for the tank. Those are the only split weights any maker here prints.

That makes it the easiest toilet on this page to carry up a flight of stairs alone. You set the 62 lb bowl on the wax ring, then bolt the 32 lb tank on top.

It also shows the two-piece repair advantage in writing. TOTO lists the tank and cover as their own part, ST776SA, and the bowl as C776CEFG. Crack a tank and you replace a tank, not the whole toilet.

The flush is TOTO’s Tornado Flush at 1.6 gpf, with a 2⅛ in. trapway and TOTO’s CeFiONtect glaze, which TOTO says keeps waste from sticking to the china. TOTO lists a minimum flowing pressure of 8 psi.

It’s Universal Height, and TOTO says it’s ADA compliant when installed with the trip lever on the approach side. It meets ASME A112.19.2/CSA B45.1 and is cUPC certified.

Where it lost points: TOTO’s sheet prints a one-year limited warranty, so it scored 5 on that check. The seat is sold separately, which scored 7. And at 1.6 gpf it scored 7 on water use.

My call: check your water rules, as with the Champion 4. And buy TOTO’s matching elongated seat with it.

TOTO makes the Drake with CeFiONtect glaze in Cotton, Bone, Colonial White and Sedona Beige; this listing is Cotton White, color code #01.

It clears my 7.0 floor at 7.4. For the specific job of getting a toilet up tight stairs without help, nothing here beats a 62 lb heaviest piece.

One-piece vs two-piece, factor by factor

What the piece count changes, and what it doesn’t. The Ahead column says which design wins on each line.

FactorOne-pieceTwo-pieceAhead
CleaningNo tank-to-bowl seam; skirted sides on the Town Square SSeam where the tank sits on the bowlOne-piece
Leak pointsNo tank-to-bowl gasket or boltsGasket and bolts between tank and bowlOne-piece
Heaviest piece to carry107 to 115 lb, one carton62 lb bowl (TOTO); tank separateTwo-piece
Setting it aloneWhole weight onto the wax ring at onceBowl first, tank afterTwo-piece
Replacing a cracked partWhole toiletTank or bowl alone (TOTO ST776SA)Two-piece
Seat in the boxBoth of mine include oneNeither of mine doesOne-piece (these models)
Flush and water use1.28 or 1.6 gpf by model1.28 or 1.6 gpf by modelEven
HeightChair height on bothChair or Universal Height on bothEven
Rough-in12 in. on both12 in. on bothEven
PickPhotoTypeSpec scoreWaterTrapwaySeatWarrantyBuy
Town Square STown Square SOne-piece9.61.28 gpf2⅛ in.IncludedLifetime china, 10 yr partsCheck it on Amazon
Champion PROChampion PROTwo-piece9.41.28 gpf2⅜ in.Separate10 yrCheck it on Amazon
Champion 4Champion 4One-piece9.01.6 gpf2⅜ in.Included10 yrCheck it on Amazon
TOTO DrakeTOTO DrakeTwo-piece7.41.6 gpf2⅛ in.Separate1 yrCheck it on Amazon

Weights: Amazon’s item data for the American Standard models (the makers’ pages don’t print weight); TOTO’s spec sheet for the Drake’s bowl and tank.

Which one can you get into the bathroom?

The biggest real difference is weight in one piece. Tell it the route, who’s carrying, and your water rule.

Either design works; pick on cleaning

With a second person and no stairs, a 107 to 115 lb one-piece is a normal carry. The Town Square S is my one-piece pick; the Champion PRO if you want the bigger trapway.

Route and helpMy callPick
No stairs, two peopleEither; choose on cleaningTown Square S or Champion PRO
Straight stairs, two peopleOne-piece is fineTown Square S (107 lb)
Stairs with a turn, two peopleLean two-pieceChampion PRO
Any route, aloneTwo-pieceTOTO Drake (62 lb bowl) or Champion PRO
Must be 1.28 gpfEither designTown Square S or Champion PRO
Champion 4 (1-pc)115 lbTown Square S (1-pc)107 lbChampion PRO (2-pc)100.6 lb totalTOTO Drake bowl (2-pc)62 lbChampion 4 (1-pc)115 lbTown Square S (1-pc)107 lbChampion PRO (2-pc)100.6 lb totalTOTO Drake bowl (2-pc)62 lb
Heaviest piece you carry, on a 120 lb scale. One-piece weights from Amazon’s item data; TOTO’s spec sheet gives the Drake’s bowl and tank separately. American Standard doesn’t print the Champion PRO’s split, so its bar is the whole toilet, in gray.

Where the one-piece really wins: cleaning and leaks

The seam and the gasket are the two real one-piece advantages.

SpotOne-pieceTwo-piece
Tank-to-bowl seamNoneA gap to wipe where the tank sits on the bowl
Tank-to-bowl gasketNoneA rubber gasket that can harden and weep
Tank boltsNoneTwo bolts with washers through the bowl
Trapway sidesSkirted on the Town Square SNot described as skirted on either page
SurfaceEverClean on both American StandardsEverClean (Champion PRO), CeFiONtect (TOTO)

A slow tank-to-bowl leak shows up as water on the floor behind the toilet, or a tank that slowly empties. It’s a two-piece-only problem, and it’s a cheap gasket, but it’s one more thing.

My call: if you’ve ever chased a drip behind a toilet, you’ll appreciate a one-piece. If you never have, the gasket isn’t a reason to skip a two-piece. My toilet leaking at the base guide helps you tell the gasket from the wax ring.

Where the two-piece really wins: carrying and repairs

Separate pieces mean lighter carries and replaceable parts.

SituationOne-pieceTwo-piece
Cracked tank lidLid only (both)Lid only (both)
Cracked tankWhole toiletTank only, e.g. TOTO ST776SA
Cracked bowlWhole toiletBowl only, e.g. TOTO C776CEFG
Flapper, fill valve, handleSame parts inside the tankSame parts inside the tank
Replacing the wax ringLift the whole toiletLift the bowl; tank can stay on

Inside the tank, both designs use the same kind of flapper and fill valve, so day-to-day repairs are the same. The difference is only when china breaks.

My call: a cracked tank is rare, but a dropped lid or an overtightened tank bolt can do it. On a two-piece it’s a tank. On a one-piece it’s a toilet.

Flush power is set by the model

Both Champions share a 4 in. valve and 2⅜ in. trapway, one-piece or two.

Water use is set by the model

Each design comes at 1.28 or 1.6 gpf. Check your local rule.

Height is set by the model

All four are chair or Universal Height; standard height exists in both designs.

Rough-in is set by the model

All four are 12 in. Measure yours before you order.

Seat isn’t always in the box

Both of my one-pieces include one; both two-pieces don’t. Check each listing.

Weight is the real catch

107 to 115 lb in one piece is a two-person carry.

Measure the rough-in before you buy either kind: wall to the center of the closet bolts. My rough-in guide shows how. And if the toilet’s going in a small room, my round vs elongated guide and comfort height guide cover the other two choices.

How to choose in four questions

QuestionIf yesIf no
Is the bathroom up stairs and you’re alone?Two-piece: TOTO Drake or Champion PROKeep going
Do you clean the bathroom often and hate the tank seam?One-piece: Town Square SKeep going
Must it be 1.28 gpf?Town Square S or Champion PROAny of the four
Do you want a seat in the box?Town Square S or Champion 4Champion PRO, plus its seat

My call for most homes: the Town Square S on a main floor, the Champion PRO up stairs. Same maker, same water use, and they score within two tenths of each other. The piece count is about your stairs and your cleaning habits.

Questions people ask

Is a one-piece or two-piece toilet better?

Neither flushes better because of the piece count. A one-piece is easier to clean and has no tank-to-bowl gasket; a two-piece is easier to carry and lets you replace the tank or bowl alone.

What are the disadvantages of a one-piece toilet?

Weight in one piece: 107 to 115 lb for the two on this page, per Amazon’s item data. A cracked tank means a new toilet.

Are one-piece toilets worth it?

If you clean often and have help carrying it, yes. My top one-piece, the Town Square S, also includes a seat and a lifetime china warranty.

Do one-piece toilets leak less?

They have no tank-to-bowl gasket or tank bolts, which removes one leak point. The wax ring under the toilet is the same on both.

Can one person install a one-piece toilet?

It’s hard. You lower the whole weight onto the wax ring at once. My call: get a second person, or choose a two-piece.

How much does a two-piece toilet weigh?

TOTO lists the Drake’s bowl at 62 lb and tank at 32 lb. The Champion PRO is 100.6 lb total per Amazon’s item data.

Do one-piece toilets flush better?

No. Flush is set by the valve and trapway. Both Champions have a 4 in. valve and 2⅜ in. trapway whether one-piece or two.

Do two-piece toilets come with a seat?

Neither of mine does. Both one-pieces here include a slow-close seat.

What toilet do most plumbers recommend?

For me, it’s the model’s flush, water use and height first, then the piece count for your stairs. The Town Square S and Champion PRO are my two picks.

Do plumbers recommend dual flush toilets?

That’s a separate choice from the piece count; my single vs dual flush guide covers it. All four here are single flush.

Can you replace just the tank on a two-piece toilet?

Yes. TOTO lists the Drake’s tank and cover as part ST776SA.

Is a skirted toilet the same as a one-piece?

No. Skirted means the sides hide the trapway. The Town Square S is both one-piece and skirted.

How I picked these

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia, and I’ve used all four picks. In my 7 years of experience, these are the products I’d install. Every spec here comes from American Standard’s product pages and TOTO’s spec sheet, read Oct 23, 2026, with weights from Amazon’s item data where the makers don’t print one. Where I add advice of my own, it’s labeled as my call.

How I pick

  • Two one-piece and two two-piece toilets from well-known makers, all elongated and 12 in. rough-in, new and in stock on Amazon, checked through Amazon’s product data the same day. Each listing was matched to the maker’s model number.
  • Facts from each maker’s product page and spec sheet first.
  • Each card’s spec score comes from the five checks below. All four score 7.0 or higher. The piece count isn’t scored.
  • CPSC recall search for American Standard and TOTO toilets.

The spec score, check by check

Each check scores 0 to 10 and counts one fifth. It’s my score from maker documents, not a customer rating.

Check (weight)How it’s scored
Water use (⅕)10 for 1.28 gpf or less; 7 for 1.6 gpf
Trapway size (⅕)10 for 2⅜ in. or larger; 8 for 2⅛ in.; 6 for smaller
Seat in the box (⅕)10 when the maker includes a seat; 7 when it’s sold separately
Warranty (⅕)10 for 10 years or more; 7 for 2 to 9 years; 5 for 1 year
Accessible height (⅕)10 when the maker states ADA compliance; 8 for chair height without that statement; 6 for standard height
TotalAverage of the checks, to one decimal
PickWaterTrapwaySeatWarrantyHeightScore
Town Square S10 (1.28)8 (2⅛)1010 (lifetime china)10 (ADA)9.6
Champion PRO10 (1.28)10 (2⅜)710 (10 yr)10 (ADA)9.4
Champion 47 (1.6)10 (2⅜)1010 (10 yr)8 (chair)9.0
TOTO Drake7 (1.6)8 (2⅛)75 (1 yr)10 (ADA)7.4

Sources

  1. American Standard, Town Square S One-Piece 1.28 gpf Chair Height Elongated Toilet with Seat (2851A104) product page and specifications. Read Oct 23, 2026.
  2. American Standard, Champion 4 One-Piece 1.6 gpf Chair Height Elongated Toilet with Seat (2034.314) product page and specifications. Read Oct 23, 2026.
  3. American Standard, Champion PRO Two-Piece 1.28 gpf Chair Height Elongated Toilet Less Seat (211AA104) product page and specifications. Read Oct 23, 2026.
  4. TOTO, Drake Two-Piece Toilet 1.6 GPF CST776CSF(G) specification sheet SS-02004. Read Oct 23, 2026.
  5. Amazon item data (weight, model, warranty fields) for every toilet named on this page, read through Amazon’s product data, Oct 23, 2026.
  6. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recall search for American Standard and TOTO toilets: Oct 23, 2026.
  7. Google results for “one piece vs two piece toilet”: seen Oct 23, 2026. Search volumes, Oct 23, 2026.