Best thermostatic mixing valve
I pick the Cash Acme HG110-D thermostatic mixing valve for a heater that also feeds a tub. For sweat unions, I pick the HG110-HX; for PEX, the Zurn ZW1017XL.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The short answer
Top pick: Cash Acme HG110-D. It’s listed to ASSE 1017 and 1070, so one valve at the heater can also cover a tub. Running PEX? Get the Zurn ZW1017XL. [1] [5]
On this page
- My picks
- Cash Acme HG110-D
- Cash Acme HG110-D
- Setting checker
- Cash Acme HG110-HX
- Cash Acme HG110-HX
- What a TMV does
- ASSE 1017 vs 1070
- Zurn ZW1017XL
- Zurn ZW1017XL
- Compare all three
- Tank temperature
- Where it goes and how
- Tankless heaters
- Under-sink valves
- Problems and fixes
- How I compare specs
- Checked and left out
- FAQ
- How I pick
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
My picks

Cash Acme HG110-D

Cash Acme HG110-HX

Zurn ZW1017XL
Check the current price and availability on Amazon before ordering.
Cash Acme HG110-D: one valve for the heater and the tub
Cash Acme HG110-D
3/4 in. thermostatic mixing valve (Heatguard 110-D LF) [1] [12]

Check the current price and availability on Amazon before ordering.
Pros
- Listed to ASSE 1017, 1069 and 1070, the only pick with a 1070 listing
- Check valves built into both inlets
- Rated to 230 psi, the highest here
- Five-year RWC warranty on Cash Acme mixing valves
- Factory set and locked at 120°F
Cons
- Needs the tank 27°F hotter than the setting, so 147°F for a 120°F outlet
- Top of the range is 130°F
- Amazon bullets on the threaded version are copied from the push-fit one
Buy it if
You want one valve at the heater that delivers 120°F to the whole house, including a tub, and you’ll set the tank hot enough for it. [1]
The Cash Acme HG110-D is my top pick because it’s the only valve here that can do two jobs. Cash Acme lists it to ASSE 1017, the standard for a valve at the heater, and to ASSE 1070, the standard for a valve that limits water at a fixture. It’s also listed to ASSE 1069 for gang showers. [1]
That matters for tubs. The IPC says a bathtub must have, or be supplied by, an ASSE 1070 device set to 120°F or less. A valve listed only to 1017 doesn’t meet that alone. With the HG110-D at the heater, one valve can supply the tub. Your inspector has the final word, so ask before you skip a valve at the tub. [8] [1]
Cash Acme ships it set and locked at 120°F, and you can adjust it from 85 to 130°F. The lock stops anyone from turning it above 120°F. Cash Acme says the stop may come out only for jobs outside ASSE 1070’s scope. Leave it in if the valve feeds a tub. [2] [1]
Here’s the catch most listings skip. Cash Acme’s instructions say the hot water feeding the valve should be at least 27°F hotter than the setting. For a 120°F outlet, that’s a 147°F tank. Set the tank at 140°F and the outlet may wander. The setting checker below does that math. [2] [14]
Both inlets have check valves built in, so hot water can’t push back into the cold line. Cash Acme puts stainless strainer screens in the inlets too. The body is lead-free DZR brass, rated to 230 psi, with a maximum flow of 14 gpm at a 50 psi pressure drop. [1] [2]
There are two genuine 3/4 in. versions on Amazon, both sold by Amazon. The 25523 has female threads, and the 24549 has SharkBite push-fit ends that take copper, PEX and CPVC. The 25523’s bullets say no tools or soldering, which is copied from the push-fit version. Threads still need sealant, used lightly; Cash Acme warns that too much can make the valve fail. [12] [2]
Will your tank setting work with each valve?
Enter your tank setting, your cold water temperature and the outlet you want. The checker tests each pick against its maker’s published limits.
The approach is the gap between the hot water feeding the valve and the setting. A thermostatic valve needs that headroom to hold its setting when someone opens a tap. Zurn asks for 20°F. Cash Acme asks for 27°F. [5] [2]
The last line is simple mixing math, ignoring heat lost in the pipes. It shows why a hot tank plus a mixing valve gives more usable hot water: part of every gallon is cold water from the main.
Cash Acme HG110-HX: sweat unions and a wide range
Cash Acme HG110-HX
3/4 in. thermostatic mixing valve, sweat connections (24514) [3]

Check the current price and availability on Amazon before ordering.
Pros
- Union connections on all three ports, so the body comes out without cutting pipe
- Outlet range reaches 176°F
- Check valves at both inlets as standard
- Rated to 230 psi and up to 20 gpm
- Five-year RWC warranty
Cons
- Listed to ASSE 1017 only, so a tub still needs a 1070 device
- Amazon bullets give the wrong range (85–130°F) and say no soldering
- Needs 27°F of approach under the installation instructions
Buy it if
You’re sweating copper at the heater and want unions on every port, or you need tempered water hotter than 130°F somewhere in the system. [3] [1]
Skip it if
You want one valve that also covers a tub. The HG110-D carries the ASSE 1070 listing. [1]
The HG110-HX is the Cash Acme valve I’d sweat in at a heater when I want to be able to service it later. Cash Acme builds it with union connections on all three ports. You sweat the tailpieces, then the body comes out by loosening three nuts, without cutting any pipe.
Cash Acme’s sheet calls it a heat-source valve. It’s meant to go in with the water heating source and send tempered water to the system, and it’s listed to ASSE 1017 and CSA B125.3. It isn’t listed to ASSE 1070, so it doesn’t cover a bathtub on its own. Pair it with a 1070 valve at the tub, or pick the HG110-D. [3] [1]
The range is the other difference. The HG110-HX adjusts from 85°F up to 176°F, where the HG110-D stops at 130°F. Cash Acme says that makes it a fit for heating systems or any job that needs reduced-temperature hot water. For a house, you’d still set it near 120°F. [3] [1]
It comes from the factory at 115 to 120°F. Cash Acme builds the adjuster tool into the knob, which keeps casual hands off the setting. Check valves at both inlets come standard. It’s rated to 230 psi, with flow from 1 to 20 gpm. [3] [4]
Watch the Amazon listing. Its bullets are copied from Cash Acme’s push-fit valves. They give an 85 to 130°F range and say the valve needs no tools, crimping, glue or soldering. Cash Acme’s own sheet says 85 to 176°F, and this one has sweat connections. I use the maker’s range and the actual sweat connection when choosing it. [12] [3]
Cash Acme warns not to heat the valve during installation. Sweat the tailpieces off the body, let them cool, then assemble. Cash Acme’s HG110-HX instructions require the hot supply to be at least 27°F above the setting. The fresh Amazon offer is new and sold by Amazon.com; stock can change. [4] [12]
What a thermostatic mixing valve does
It blends hot and cold water to one set temperature, and keeps it there when pressures and temperatures change.
Inside the valve, a thermostatic element sits in the mixed water. As the water warms, the element grows and slides a piston that lets in less hot and more cold. As it cools, it does the reverse. Caleffi’s sheet describes the same idea: the element keeps setting the right share of hot and cold.
The purpose is two things at once. The tank can store water hot enough to keep Legionella down, and the taps get water cool enough not to scald. Caleffi says hot water should be stored at 140°F or more for that reason, and advises limiting mixed water to 120°F. [7]
| Valve type | What it reacts to | Where it goes | Standard |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thermostatic mixing valve at the heater | Mixed water temperature | On the water heater’s outlet | ASSE 1017 [1] [5] |
| Temperature-limiting valve at a fixture | Mixed water temperature | Under a sink or before a tub | ASSE 1070 [1] [11] |
| Pressure-balancing shower valve | Hot and cold pressure | Inside the shower wall | ASSE 1016 [8] |
| Plain mixing valve (no thermostat) | Nothing; it’s a fixed blend | Hydronic and older systems | Not a scald device |
Mixing valve vs thermostatic mixing valve: every TMV is a mixing valve, but not every mixing valve is thermostatic. A thermostatic one corrects itself when supply temperatures or pressures change. Shower valves are a separate product, covered in pressure-balancing vs thermostatic shower valves.
ASSE 1017 vs 1070: which listing your job needs
The listing decides where a valve may legally go. It’s the first thing an inspector reads on the box.
The listing and certification descriptions below are the manufacturers’ published statements. I check the current instructions and local requirements before treating a heater valve as the protection for a fixture.
| Standard | What it covers | HG110-D | HG110-HX | Zurn ZW1017XL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASSE 1017 [1] [3] [5] | Valve at the hot water source, feeding the system | Listed [1] | Listed [3] | Listed [5] |
| ASSE 1070 [1] | Controls water at a fixture, like a tub or lavatory | Listed [1] | Not listed [3] | Not listed [5] |
| ASSE 1069 [1] | Gang showers where the bather can’t adjust | Listed [1] | Not listed [3] | Not listed [5] |
| CSA B125.3 [1] [3] [5] | Canadian plumbing fittings standard | Listed [1] | Listed [3] | Listed [5] |
| NSF/ANSI/CAN 372 [1] [3] [5] | Low lead in drinking water parts | Listed [1] | Listed [3] | Meets it [5] |
Listings from Cash Acme’s HG110-D sheet (rev. Feb 2026), its HG110-HX sheet, and Zurn’s ZW1017XL sheet (rev. Jan 2026), read Oct 22, 2026.
| Fixture (IPC 2024, Chapter 4) | Limit | Device the code names |
|---|---|---|
| Bathtub and whirlpool tub | 120°F [8] | ASSE 1070 device, field adjusted [8] |
| Shower and tub-shower valve | 120°F [8] | Valve with a max-temperature limit |
| Bidet | 110°F [8] | ASSE 1070 device [8] |
| Public hand-washing sink (tempered water) | Tempered | ASSE 1070 device [8] |
| Head shampoo sink, pedicure footbath | 120°F [8] | ASSE 1070 device [8] |
These are common IPC fixture limits, not every permitted design. The 2024 IPC also permits qualifying ASSE 1082 or 1084 water heaters for specified applications. Combination tub/shower valves follow their own section. I verify the complete adopted code and installation before choosing the protection. [8] [9]
Zurn spells out the trap on its own sheet. It says the ZW1017XL should never go at the point of use where someone could change its setting, and that a point-of-use device must be the ASSE 1070 kind. A 1017 valve at the heater doesn’t replace the tub’s 1070 device. [5]
Your town adopts its own code, often the IPC or UPC with changes. Check yours before you plan on one valve doing two jobs.
Zurn ZW1017XL: PEX ends and the lowest approach
Zurn ZW1017XL
Zurn Wilkins 34-ZW1017XL2PEX1C Aqua-Gard thermostatic mixing valve, 3/4 in. [12] [5]

Check the current price and availability on Amazon before ordering.
Pros
- Needs only 20°F of approach, so a 140°F tank holds 120°F
- Two PEX barb tailpieces and one copper sweat tailpiece with union nuts
- Published accuracy of ±4°F
- Highest flow published here: 18 gpm at 45 psi drop
- Inlet strainers and check valves included
Cons
- Listed to ASSE 1017 only, and Zurn says never at the point of use
- Rated to 145 psi, the lowest here
- Zurn’s warranty is 12 months, and you ship the valve back
Buy it if
Your heater is piped in PEX, your tank sits at 140°F, and you want a valve that holds 120°F at that setting. [5] [14]
Skip it if
Your house pressure runs high without a reducing valve, or you want one valve to cover a tub. Pick the HG110-D.
The Zurn ZW1017XL is the pick for a PEX job at the heater. This kit, 34-ZW1017XL2PEX1C, comes with two PEX barb tailpieces and one copper sweat tailpiece, plus union nuts. Amazon’s listing says inlet strainers and check valves are included, and it’s sold by Amazon.
It has the smallest approach of the three. Zurn asks for 20°F between the hot supply and the setting, where Cash Acme asks for 27°F. That means a tank at 140°F can hold a steady 120°F outlet. With the HG110-D, you’d want 147°F. If you don’t want to run the tank hotter, that’s the reason to buy the Zurn. [5] [2] [14] [1]
Zurn publishes the tightest accuracy of the picks, ±4°F, and the highest flow, 18 gpm at a 45 psi pressure drop. The outlet adjusts from 95 to 131°F. The hot supply can run from 120 up to 195°F. The body is low-lead cast bronze, and the checks and guide tube are NORYL plastic. [5]
Zurn is blunt about where it belongs. The ZW1017XL is a point-of-source valve. Zurn says it should never be installed at the point of use where someone could change it, and that it must be used with an ASSE 1070 device at the fixture. Plan on a separate valve at the tub. [5]
Two limits matter to my choice. It’s rated to 145 psi of inlet pressure, where the Cash Acme valves take 230 psi, and Zurn caps the pressure difference between the hot and cold inlets at 15 psi. Zurn’s warranty runs 12 months from purchase, and you return the valve freight prepaid for repair or replacement. [5] [1] [6]
Zurn’s sheet adds two setup tips I follow. Put a shutoff and a thermometer on the tempered line. Mount the valve below the heater’s hot outlet line, so a clogged screen can’t send full-hot water through. To set it, pop off the green cap and turn the flats with a wrench; clockwise lowers the temperature.
All three valves side by side
| Pick | Photo | Best for | Listings | Outlet range | Approach | Max pressure | Short pros / cons | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash Acme HG110-D | ![]() | Heater that feeds a tub | 1017, 1069, 1070 [1] | 85–130°F [1] | 27°F [2] | 230 psi [1] | Covers a tub / Needs 147°F tank [14] | Check it on Amazon |
| Cash Acme HG110-HX | ![]() | Sweat copper, unions | 1017 [3] | 85–176°F [3] | 27°F (installation instructions) [4] | 230 psi [3] | Three unions / Listing errors | Check it on Amazon |
| Zurn ZW1017XL | ![]() | PEX at the heater | 1017 [5] | 95–131°F [5] | 20°F [5] | 145 psi [5] | Holds 120°F at 140°F / 12-month warranty [5] [14] [6] | Check it on Amazon |
How hot to set the tank with a mixing valve
The valve lets you store water hotter than you’d ever want at a tap. The maker’s approach tells you how much hotter.
Why go hotter at all? Caleffi’s sheet gives the two numbers that drive it. Stored water should be at least 140°F to keep Legionella down. Mixed water above 120°F burns fast: partial burns in about 30 seconds at 130°F, and about 5 seconds at 140°F. Caleffi says the time can drop by half or more for children and older adults. [7]
So the tank runs hot and the valve brings the tap water down. Cash Acme ships its valves set with a 150°F hot supply. With a 147°F to 150°F tank, the HG110-D has its full 27°F of headroom at a 120°F setting. [2] [14] [1]
Hotter storage costs a little more in standby heat, but you get more 120°F water per tank, as the setting checker shows. A 50-gallon tank at 150°F, mixed with 55°F water, stretches to about 73 gallons at 120°F before pipe losses. [14]
You’re adding a mixing valve and want Legionella control plus more hot water per tank.
A tank at 140°F with no mixing valve sends scald-temperature water to every tap. [7]
Where a mixing valve goes and how it’s piped
A heat-source valve sits on the water heater’s hot outlet, with a cold branch run to it.
When to call a plumber: I would have a qualified plumber size, install and commission this safety valve, especially with hotter storage, recirculation or a tub. Do not raise a heater setting until the mixing and fixture protection have been verified with a thermometer.
- 1Shut off the heater and the water
Turn the heater off or to pilot, close the cold supply, and open a hot tap to drop the pressure.
- 2Flush the lines before the valve goes in
Cash Acme calls poor flushing the most common cause of trouble. Zurn says flush both lines completely first.
- 3Run hot to H and cold to C
Hot from the heater outlet goes to H, a cold branch goes to C, and the mixed port feeds the house.
- 4Keep heat and extra sealant off the valve
Sweat tailpieces off the body. Cash Acme warns that heat damages the internals and too much thread sealant can make it fail.
- 5Mount it below the hot outlet line
Zurn says this keeps a clogged screen from sending full-hot water through. Add a shutoff and thermometer on the mixed line.
- 6Set it with a thermometer at a tap
Run the nearest fixture, read the temperature, adjust, then lock or cap the valve. Set 120°F or less where a tub is fed. [8]
Want the dishwasher to get full-hot water? Cash Acme’s diagram tees the dishwasher off the hot line before the valve. Check your dishwasher’s manual first; many heat their own water now.
On a recirculating system, the return piping changes. Caleffi’s sheet shows a bypass valve and a return valve that set how much warm return water flows back to the tank. For pumps, see hot water recirculating pumps.
Hotter storage means more expansion too. If your system has a check valve or reducing valve at the meter, it needs an expansion tank.
Do you need a mixing valve on a tankless heater?
Usually not for Legionella, because a tankless heater doesn’t store water. People still add one when the heater is set high for a hydronic coil or a commercial load. Caleffi warns that its 5231 series, the version it designs for water heaters with storage, may deliver fluctuating mixed temperatures on an instantaneous heater. [7]
Low flow is the other issue. Cash Acme lists a 0.5 gpm minimum for the HG110-D, and Zurn lists 0.5 gpm. A tankless heater has its own minimum flow to fire. Check both numbers before you put a valve in front of one. [1] [5]
Comparing heaters first? See tankless water heater brands.
Under-sink and point-of-use mixing valves
A small ASSE 1070 valve under one sink or at one tub is a different product from the heater valves above. [11]
You only need to limit one fixture, like a lavatory in a public restroom or a single tub.
You want the whole house tempered and the tank stored hot for Legionella control.
A small valve is sold for under a sink. It should say ASSE 1070 for that job. [11]
Two genuine ones on Amazon: the Cash Acme HG145, 3/8 in. compression (see it on Amazon), with built-in checks, and the Watts USG-B-M2 Under Sink Guardian (see it on Amazon), with a tamper-resistant locking nut and built-in checks. I keep them separate because they do a different job from the heater valves. [12] [11]

$121.88 [13]
Price as of Nov 15, 2026, 5:30 AM EST

$73.19 [13]
Price as of Nov 15, 2026, 5:30 AM EST
Mixing valve problems and what causes them
Cash Acme calls its valve a safety valve and says to check it at least once a year. [2] Zurn requires annual inspection. [6]
| What you see | Likely cause (Cash Acme’s list) | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Can’t reach the temperature you want | Supply temperatures out of range, hot and cold reversed, blocked strainers | Check the tank setting, swap the lines, clean the screens |
| Temperature drifts over time | Blocked strainers or swinging supply pressures | Clean the strainers; add pressure-reducing valves |
| Full hot or full cold at the tap | Valve set wrong, lines reversed, or water crossing between inlets | Reset it; clean or replace the check valves |
| No flow from the valve | Hot or cold supply off, or blocked strainers | Restore the supply and recheck the setting |
| Hot water shows up in the cold line | Fouled check valves | Clean the checks |
| Valve is noisy | Water moving too fast, or a valve too small for the flow | Lower the pressure; check the sizing |
Cash Acme says to check the temperature each year at the same tap used when it was set. If it’s more than 5°F off, work down the list above. Seasonal changes in cold water temperature can move the outlet a little, so a small winter drift is normal. [2]
Hard water is the usual enemy. Scale builds on the strainers and the piston. Caleffi makes its sliding parts from an anti-scale plastic for that reason. On any valve, clean the inlet screens at the yearly check.
How I compare the specifications
I compare ASSE application, included check valves, warranty terms, pressure limits and whether the listing matches the exact connection type. I do not compare headline flow figures as if they were measured at the same pressure drop. My choice starts with the installation, then the manufacturer’s limits.
Valves I checked and left out
| Valve | What held it back | What it does well |
|---|---|---|
| Honeywell AM101-US-1LF | No ASSE 1070 listing on Resideo’s sheet; 150 psi maximum pressure [10] [8] | Cv 3.9, the highest flow factor in this comparison [10] [7] |
| Caleffi MixCal 521509A | No inlet checks (the AC version has them); Caleffi’s warranty excludes products not bought from Caleffi | ±3°F tolerance and a 200 psi rating [7] |
| Watts LFMMV | Only a few left from third-party sellers at my read | Common at supply houses |
| Cash Acme HG160, HG145; Zurn ZW1070XL; Watts USG | Point-of-use valves, a different job | ASSE 1070 at one fixture [15] [11] |
Thermostatic mixing valve questions
What is a thermostatic mixing valve?
It’s a valve that blends hot and cold water to one set temperature and holds it as supply pressures and temperatures change. At a water heater, it lets the tank store hot water while the taps get about 120°F. [1]
What is the purpose of a mixing valve on a water heater?
Two things: you can store water at 140°F or more, which Caleffi says keeps Legionella down, and the house still gets safer water near 120°F. It also stretches each tank, because cold water makes up part of every gallon. [7]
What is the difference between a mixing valve and a thermostatic mixing valve?
A plain mixing valve holds a fixed blend. A thermostatic one has an element that senses the mixed water and corrects itself, so the temperature holds when someone flushes a toilet or the tank cools.
Where is a thermostatic mixing valve located?
A heat-source valve sits on or near the water heater, on the hot outlet with a cold branch run to it. A point-of-use valve sits under a sink or before a tub. Zurn says to mount its heater valve below the hot outlet line.
What temperature should a mixing valve be set to?
Do I need a mixing valve for a tub?
How hot does the water heater need to be with a mixing valve?
How often should a thermostatic mixing valve be checked?
At least once a year. Cash Acme calls it a safety valve and says to recheck the temperature at the same tap used to set it. Zurn requires annual inspection, testing and cleaning.
How I pick and why you can trust it
I compared three water-heater valve families and checked six Amazon listings, including the two point-of-use alternatives. I use the Cash Acme and Zurn specification and installation sheets for connection sizes, outlet ranges, pressure limits and commissioning requirements.
Why trust me
I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia. I choose these valves by pipe connection, manufacturer specifications and whether the installation also supplies a tub. I check the exact model and connection before choosing a valve.
How I pick
- I compare the application and published limits before choosing a valve.
- Listings, ranges, pressures and warranties from each maker’s sheet, checked against the Amazon listing.
- Every pick is new, genuine and in stock, sold by Amazon at my read.
- I compare the application and published limits before choosing a valve.
- Code limits come from the 2024 IPC; your local code may differ.
- Use the Amazon button for the current price and availability.
Sources
- Cash Acme, HG110-D specification sheet (Rev 2.0), cashacme.com. Saved text: evidence/d-spec.txt. Official source
- Cash Acme, HG110-D installation instructions IS291 Rev C, cashacme.com. Saved text: evidence/d-install.txt. Official source
- Cash Acme, HG110-HX specification sheet (Rev 2.0), cashacme.com. Saved text: evidence/hx-spec.txt. Official source
- Cash Acme, HG110-HX installation instructions I0469 Rev A, cashacme.com. Saved text: evidence/hx-install.txt. Official source
- Zurn Wilkins, ZW1017XL specification sheet (Rev K), zurn.com. Saved text: evidence/zurn-spec.txt. Official source
- Zurn Wilkins, ZW1017XL installation and warranty sheet ISZW1017XL (Rev F), zurn.com. Saved text: evidence/zurn-install.txt. Official source
- Caleffi, MixCal 521 series technical brochure 01050/23.1 NA, caleffi.com. Saved text: evidence/caleffi.txt. Official source
- IPC fixture temperature limits, from Ohio Administrative Code 4101:3-4-01 (Ohio Plumbing Code) and Municipal Code of Chicago 18-29-424.3 and 18-29-424.5. Saved excerpts: evidence/ipc-fixture-limits.txt. Official source
- Georgia Department of Community Affairs, current state minimum standard codes (International Plumbing Code, 2024 Edition, with Georgia Amendments). Saved text: evidence/georgia-dca-codes.txt. Official source
- Resideo (Honeywell Home), AM101-US-1LF product data. Saved text: evidence/honeywell-am101-lf.txt. Official source
- Watts, LFUSG-B-M2 engineering specification ES-LFUSG-B-M2. Saved text: evidence/watts-usg.txt. Official source
- Amazon listing features and offers for the six valves on this page, read on Amazon on November 15, 2026.
- Amazon prices from the price feed generated November 15, 2026, 5:30 AM EST. Saved record: evidence/prices-feed.json.
- Mixing math worked from the maker approach figures in sources 2, 4 and 5 and the setting checker defaults on this page. Saved record: evidence/calculations.txt.
- Cash Acme, HG145 specification sheet, cashacme.com. Saved text: evidence/hg145-spec.txt. Official source

