Best hot water recirculating pumps

Five pumps, matched to whether your house has a return pipe.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links go to listings sold by Amazon.com.

On this page
  1. The picks
  2. Which pump fits your house
  3. Kits, no return pipe
  4. Watts 500800
  5. Grundfos Comfort
  6. Circulators
  7. Taco 006-BC4-PNP
  8. Taco 003-SC4-1PNP
  9. Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC
  10. Compare the circulators
  11. How a recirculating pump works
  12. Sizing the pump to your loop
  13. What you still need to buy
  14. Why the cold tap runs warm
  15. Timers and running time
  16. Tankless water heaters
  17. Warranties
  18. Where sources disagree
  19. How to choose
  20. Installing one
  21. Questions
  22. How I picked

Quick answer

Have a return pipe? The Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC, shown here for reference, has shutoff and check valves built in and 9.84 ft of head. No return pipe on a tank heater? Look at the Watts 500800 kit instead. None of these is linked on this page. Tankless? Read your heater’s manual first.

Reference (not linked): Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC Shown for comparison only.

Three circulators for a return pipe

Specs come from Grundfos’ and Taco’s submittals. No return pipe? The two sensor-valve kits are further down.

Reference (not linked)

Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC

Shown for comparison only.

Reference (not linked)

Taco 006-BC4-PNP

Shown for comparison only.

Reference (not linked)

Taco 003-SC4-1PNP

Shown for comparison only.

Which pump fits your house?

One question about your pipes sorts these five into two groups.

Does a separate return pipe run from the far end of the house back to the heater? Look at the heater for a third pipe coming back to it, often with a check valve on it. No: one hot pipe to each fixture Tank heater, gas or electric A sensor-valve kit: Watts 500800 or Grundfos Comfort 595916. Pump on the heater’s hot outlet, valve under the farthest sink. Tankless heater Not these kits. Watts says its kit doesn’t work with tankless. Start with your heater’s own recirculation instructions. Yes: size the pump to the loop Up to 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe, out and back Taco 003-SC4-1PNP. Taco designs the 003 for 3 gpm at 3 ft of head. 200 to 400 ft of ¾ in. pipe Taco 006-BC4-PNP, up to 11.5 gpm and 9.5 ft of head. Stainless, with shutoff and check valves built in Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC, up to 9.84 ft of head. Does a separate return pipe run from the far end of the house back to the heater? Look at the heater for a third pipe coming back to it, often with a check valve on it. No: one hot pipe to each fixture Tank heater, gas or electric A sensor-valve kit: Watts 500800 or Grundfos Comfort 595916. Pump on the heater’s hot outlet, valve under the farthest sink. Tankless heater Not these kits. Watts says its kit doesn’t work with tankless. Start with your heater’s own recirculation instructions. Yes: size the pump to the loop Up to 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe, out and back Taco 003-SC4-1PNP. Taco designs the 003 for 3 gpm at 3 ft of head. 200 to 400 ft of ¾ in. pipe Taco 006-BC4-PNP, up to 11.5 gpm and 9.5 ft of head. Stainless, with shutoff and check valves built in Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC, up to 9.84 ft of head.
From Watts IOM-WQ-500800, the Grundfos Comfort System manual, Taco 101-066 and Grundfos’ UP15-29 sheet.

Most houses have one hot pipe from the heater to each fixture and nothing coming back. For those, a pump alone can’t make a loop, so Watts and Grundfos pair the pump with a sensor valve under the farthest sink. The valve lets cooled water from the hot line cross into the cold line and flow back to the heater.

Some houses were built with a third pipe that runs from the far end of the hot line back to the heater. That’s a dedicated return. With one, you skip the valve and pick a circulator sized to the loop. Taco gives the sizing in plain feet of ¾ in. pipe, which is why two Taco sizes are on this list.

Kits for houses with no return pipe

These move water back through your cold line, so they publish no head or flow and aren’t scored against the circulators.

Reference (not linked)

Watts 500800 kit

Shown for comparison only.

Reference (not linked)

Grundfos Comfort 595916

Shown for comparison only.

Watts 500800 kit for a tank heater

This listing bundles Watts’ 500800 recirculation system with a second sensor valve kit. The second kit is the part Watts says you may need on a branched hot line.

The pump bolts onto the hot outlet of your water heater with the ¾ in. female fitting and gasket already on it, and it pumps toward the house. Watts’ manual says to keep the pump and its cord off the flue pipe of a gas or oil heater, and not to mount the motor shaft vertical.

The sensor valve goes under the sink farthest from the heater. When the hot line cools, the valve opens and the pump pushes that water across into the cold line and back to the heater. When warm water reaches the valve, it closes.

Where it does well

  • No return pipe needed
  • Hoses, adapters and washers in the box
  • Second sensor valve for a branched line
  • Timer with quarter-hour tabs and ON, OFF, TIMER

What to watch

  • Doesn’t work with tankless heaters
  • Indoor use only
  • 140°F maximum water temperature
  • Timer loses time in a power outage
  • 1-year warranty from shipment

Watts’ test for the valve is simple. Shut the cold stop, open the cold faucet, and the flow should slow to a drip in about a minute. That water should be about 90°F, give or take 4°F. Watts says to replace the valve if it’s over 100°F.

The box has the sink parts: the valve, two 3⁄8 in. compression to ½ in. flex hoses, two adapters, two rubber washers and two screws. Watts says not to put tape or pipe dope on the valve threads.

The timer has a 24-hour ring with quarter-hour tabs and a three-way switch: TIMER, ON and OFF. Watts suggests running it from 30 minutes before the first shower to 15 minutes after the last. After a power outage, you reset the time by hand.

The label on the pump reads 140°F maximum and “Mfg. by Grundfos Pumps.” Watts adds the same warning Grundfos does: it isn’t an anti-scald device, and you may get some warm water from the cold tap at that sink.

Grundfos Comfort 595916 kit

The Comfort System is Grundfos’ own pump-and-valve kit, part 595916.

The layout matches the Watts kit. A Grundfos UP15 pump goes on the heater’s hot outlet with its ¾ in. female fitting and gasket, shaft horizontal, pumping toward the house. An under-sink thermal bypass valve goes at the farthest faucet.

The box is lighter than the Watts. Grundfos lists the pump with timer and line cord, the valve, two mounting screws and the manual. You supply two ½ in. NPT × 3⁄8 in. compression flex hoses and two ½ in. NPT × ½ in. NPT flex hoses.

Where it does well

  • 24 months from installation
  • 150°F maximum with cord and timer
  • ANSI/NSF 61 and IAPMO listed
  • Valve can mount to the wall

What to watch

  • Four flex hoses not included
  • Not an anti-scald device
  • Timer loses time in a power outage
  • Indoor use only

The reason to pick it is the warranty. Grundfos covers the original user for 24 months from installation, as long as that’s within 30 months of manufacture. Watts covers its kit for one year from the date of original shipment.

Grundfos lists 150°F as the maximum water temperature for the UP15 with line cord and timer. Its timer runs on 115 to 120 V, switches 16 A, and sets in 15-minute steps with the same TIMER, ON and OFF switch the Watts uses.

Grundfos also says this isn’t an anti-scald device, and you may find some warm water in the cold line at the sink with the valve. It runs off quickly once you open the cold tap. A branched hot line may need more than one valve.

The manual’s valve check is the same one Watts uses: shut the cold stop, open the cold tap, and the flow should taper to nothing as hot water reaches the valve.

Pumps for a dedicated return pipe

Reference (not linked)

Taco 006-BC4-PNP circulator with timer

Taco 006-BC4-PNP, bronze, ½ in. sweat, analog timer

Pros

  • Taco sizes it for 200 to 400 ft of ¾ in. pipe
  • Replaceable cartridge, field serviceable
  • 24-hour analog timer, 15-minute steps
  • 6 ft cord installed at the factory
  • UL listed

Cons

  • No flow check built in
  • ½ in. sweat ends mean soldering
  • Indoor use only
  • Aquastat sold separately
0 to 11.5 gpm0 to 9.5 ft head1/40 hp, 0.52 A125 psi maximum40 to 220°F fluidBronze, ½ in. sweat

The 006-BC4-PNP is Taco’s Plumb n’ Plug circulator in bronze with ½ in. sweat ends and an analog timer.

Taco’s submittal 101-066 says the 005 and 006 Plumb n’ Plug pumps are designed for systems using 200 to 400 ft of ¾ in. pipe. That’s the whole loop, out on the hot line and back on the return.

The 006 moves up to 11.5 gpm and up to 9.5 ft of head. Head is the resistance of the pipe and fittings in feet of water; a longer loop has more of it. Taco lists 1/40 hp and 0.52 A at 115 V.

The timer is a 24-hour analog clock with 15-minute on and off steps, and the 6 ft line cord comes installed. Taco says the timer is meant to run the pump at peak times, like early morning and early evening.

If you’d rather keep the loop warm around the clock, Taco sells an optional aquastat that holds the water between 95°F and 115°F. It isn’t in this box.

Taco recommends isolation valves, pipe insulation and flow checks with these pumps. This model has no flow check built in; Taco’s IFC versions do. A flow check keeps water from drifting through the loop while the pump is off.

Inside, Taco uses a stainless steel cartridge with a ceramic shaft and carbon bearings. The cartridge holds all the moving parts, so you can swap it rather than cut out the pump. The casing is bronze, rated to 125 psi and 220°F.

Reference (not linked)

Taco 003-SC4-1PNP circulator with timer

Taco 003-SC4-1PNP, stainless, union, analog timer

Pros

  • Designed for 3 gpm at 3 ft of head
  • Taco says that cuts erosion and noise
  • Stainless steel casing
  • Union connections, no soldering at the pump
  • 24-hour analog timer

Cons

  • Loops up to 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe only
  • Lowest head here, 4.5 ft
  • No flow check built in
  • Listing ships in 4 to 5 days
0 to 7 gpm0 to 4.5 ft head1/40 hp, 0.45 A125 psi maximum40 to 220°F fluidStainless, union

The 003-SC4-1PNP is the smaller Taco Plumb n’ Plug: stainless steel casing, union connections and an analog timer.

Taco calls the 003 ideal for recirculation loops. Its design point is 3 gpm at 3 ft of head, and Taco says that helps reduce erosion, corrosion and noise in the piping. Use it for systems up to 200 total feet of ¾ in. pipe, supply and return.

Bigger isn’t better here. Taco’s own sizing notes for its SmartPlus pumps warn that an oversized pump can cause high-velocity noise and erosion corrosion. A short loop doesn’t need the 006’s 9.5 ft of head.

The numbers: up to 7 gpm and up to 4.5 ft of head, 1/40 hp, 0.45 A at 115 V. Like the 006, it handles fluid from 40°F to 220°F at up to 125 psi.

The stainless casing and union ends are the other difference. Taco makes bronze casings in sweat versions and stainless in threaded, union and flanged versions. Unions let you take the pump off without cutting pipe.

The analog timer and its 6 ft cord match the 006: a 24-hour clock with 15-minute on and off steps. Taco’s optional aquastat for constant circulation fits here too.

Inside, it matches the 006: a stainless steel cartridge, a ceramic shaft, carbon bearings, EPDM O-rings and gaskets, and a non-metallic impeller. The cartridge holds the moving parts, so a worn one can be swapped without cutting the pump out.

This model has no built-in flow check, so add one on the return as Taco recommends, along with isolation valves and insulation.

Reference (not linked)

Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC circulator (59896777)

Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC, product no. 59896777

Pros

  • Built-in isolating and non-return valves
  • AISI 304 stainless housing
  • Highest head here, 9.84 ft
  • 145 psi rating

Cons

  • 87 W maximum input
  • 1¼ in. NPSM union threads, not sweat ends
  • Needs a dedicated return pipe
  • 104°F maximum room temperature
  • Title says ½ hp; the sheet says 0.121 hp
Up to 20.7 gpmUp to 9.84 ft head87 W, 0.75 A, 115 V145 psi maximum150°F max with cord and timer5⅞ in. port to port

This is Grundfos’ UP15-29SUC/TLC, product number 59896777. Pick the new offer if a used one shows up. Grundfos rates the pump for 145 psi and liquid from 35.6 to 230°F, but its Comfort manual sets 150°F for UP15 pumps with a line cord and timer, which this one has. Treat 150°F as the limit.

The housing is AISI 304 stainless steel. Grundfos’ sheet lists the pump with built-in isolating and non-return valves. That’s the shutoff and the check valve a Taco PNP needs you to add on the pipe.

It has the most push of the three circulators: up to 9.84 ft of head and 20.7 gpm. It also draws the most, with a maximum power input of 87 W and 0.75 A at 115 V. Grundfos rates the motor’s output at 0.121 hp, well under the ½ hp in Amazon’s title.

The connections are 1¼ in. NPSM union threads, 5⅞ in. port to port. Plan the union tailpieces for your pipe size before you shut the water off.

Grundfos calls it a canned rotor pump. The motor and pump are one unit with no shaft seal, and the bearings are ceramic and carbon, lubricated by the water. The impeller is composite PES.

The liquid range on the sheet is 35.6°F to 230°F, with 145 psi maximum and a 104°F limit on the air around it. Grundfos’ Comfort manual sets 150°F for UP15 pumps with a line cord and timer, so I’d treat 150°F as the limit here.

The Amazon listing includes the line cord and timer. The Amazon listing for the Grundfos 595916 spells out TLC as timer and line cord.

The three circulators compared

From the makers’ manuals and submittals. Scroll sideways on a phone.

PickSpec scoreFitsMax headMax flowControlValves in the boxSold byBuy
Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC9.5Return loops, valves built in9.84 ft20.7 gpmTimer and cordShutoff and check built in—Reference (not linked)
Taco 006-BC4-PNP8.8Loops of 200 to 400 ft9.5 ft11.5 gpm24 h analog timerNo flow check—Reference (not linked)
Taco 003-SC4-1PNP8.0Loops up to 200 ft4.5 ft7 gpm24 h analog timerNo flow check—Reference (not linked)

The two kits above move water through your cold line, so they don’t list head or flow and aren’t in this table. The three circulators need a loop and are sized by it.

How a recirculating pump works

Both kinds do the same job: they move cooled water back to the heater so hot water is waiting at the tap.

Sensor-valve kitCirculator on a return pipe
Where the pump goesOn the heater’s hot outletOn the hot supply pumping away from the heater, or on the return pumping toward it
How water gets backThrough a valve under the farthest sink, into the cold lineThrough its own return pipe
What controls itTimer, plus the valve closing as the water warmsTimer, or Taco’s optional aquastat
Side effectSome warm water in the cold line at that sinkCold line stays cold
Extra partsFlex hoses (Grundfos); none extra for WattsFlow check, isolation valves, insulation

Without a pump, the water sitting in the hot pipe cools between uses. When you open the tap, that cooled water has to run out before hot water arrives. A recirculating pump keeps it moving on a schedule, so the wait is short.

The water you used to run down the drain while waiting stays in the pipes instead.

Taco’s SmartPlus manual shows the two places a circulator can sit on a return system: on the hot supply right after the heater, pumping away from it, or on the return line, pumping toward it. Either way, the arrow on the pump body points the way the water should go. A flow check stops the loop from running backward when the pump is off.

How much pump your loop needs

Head and flow from Grundfos’ and Taco’s sheets, with Taco’s loop-length sizing.

Maximum head (ft) Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC 9.84 ft Taco 006-BC4-PNP 9.5 ft Taco 003-SC4-1PNP 4.5 ft Maximum flow (gpm) Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC 20.7 gpm Taco 006-BC4-PNP 11.5 gpm Taco 003-SC4-1PNP 7 gpm Taco’s sizing: 003 for loops up to 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe, out and back; 006 for 200 to 400 ft. The Watts and Grundfos sensor-valve kits publish no pump curve in their manuals. Maximum head (ft) Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC 9.84 ft Taco 006-BC4-PNP 9.5 ft Taco 003-SC4-1PNP 4.5 ft Maximum flow (gpm) Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC 20.7 gpm Taco 006-BC4-PNP 11.5 gpm Taco 003-SC4-1PNP 7 gpm Taco’s sizing: 003 for loops up to 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe, out and back; 006 for 200 to 400 ft. The Watts and Grundfos sensor-valve kits publish no pump curve in their manuals.
From Grundfos’ UP 15-29 SUC/TLC sheet and Taco submittal 101-066 (06/08/25).

Measure the loop: the hot line from the heater to the last fixture, plus the return back to the heater. Taco gives a clean cutoff in ¾ in. pipe: the 003 up to 200 ft, the 005 and 006 from 200 to 400 ft.

Every elbow, tee and valve adds resistance, so a loop with lots of fittings acts longer than its tape measure says.

Loop, supply plus returnTaco’s pickMax headWhy
Up to 200 ft of ¾ in.Taco 003-PNP4.5 ftDesign point 3 gpm at 3 ft cuts erosion and noise
200 to 400 ft of ¾ in.Taco 005 or 006-PNP8.5 to 9.5 ftMore head for the longer pipe run
Over 400 ft or bigger pipeNot on this pageAsk a plumber to size it from the pump curves

Taco’s warning runs one way: don’t oversize. Its SmartPlus sizing notes say an oversized pump can cause high-velocity noise and erosion corrosion in the piping, and they assume about 1 gpm through the loop at no more than 3 ft per second.

The Grundfos UP15-29 tops the chart at 9.84 ft, but the reasons to buy it are the stainless build and the built-in valves.

What’s in the box and what you still buy

From each maker’s parts list. This is the list to take to the supply house.

PickIn the boxYou still need
Watts 500800 kitPump with timer, sensor valve, 2 flex hoses (3⁄8 in. compression to ½ in.), 2 adapters, 2 washers, 2 screws; plus a second valve kit in this bundleUsually nothing; a grounded outlet near the heater
Grundfos Comfort 595916UP15 pump with timer and cord, thermal bypass valve, 2 screws2 × ½ in. NPT × 3⁄8 in. compression hoses, 2 × ½ in. NPT × ½ in. NPT hoses
Taco 006-BC4-PNPPump with analog timer and 6 ft cordFlow check, isolation valves, solder and fittings for ½ in. sweat
Taco 003-SC4-1PNPPump with analog timer and 6 ft cordFlow check, isolation valves, union fittings
Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLCPump with line cord and timer, per the listingUnion tailpieces for 1¼ in. NPSM

Both kits need a grounded 115 to 120 V outlet near the heater. The circulators plug in the same way.

If you’re soldering the Taco 006’s ½ in. sweat ends, our solder and flux guide covers solder and flux for copper water lines. For the unions on the Taco 003 and the Grundfos, our copper union guide explains the parts.

Watts’ troubleshooting page adds one more part: the pump’s connections use a standard ¾ in. hose gasket, which it says to replace from time to time. Watts also notes you may need dielectric unions where dissimilar metals meet. Our dielectric union vs brass nipple guide explains the choice.

Why the cold tap runs warm with a sensor valve

Both kit makers warn about this. Here’s what’s normal and what isn’t.

What you noticeWhat it meansWhat to do
Cold tap at the valve sink starts lukewarmNormal: the valve sends cooled hot water through the cold lineLet it run a moment; both makers say it clears quickly
Valve test water is about 90°F ±4°FNormal, per WattsNothing
Valve test water is over 100°FValve has failed, per WattsReplace the sensor valve
Hot at one end of the house, not the otherBranched hot lineAdd a second valve at the far end of the other branch
Water never gets above 96°FHeat loss in the pipe, or heater set lowCheck pipe insulation first; change the heater setting only within the heater maker’s guidance, with a mixing valve where scalding is a risk
Pump runs and nothing changesTimer off, wrong time, or AM/PM set wrongReset the ring to the current time; check the switch

Watts and Grundfos both print the same line: this is not an anti-scald device. The valve protects nothing; it only decides when water crosses over.

If scalding is the worry, that’s a mixing valve’s job. Our thermostatic mixing valve guide covers how one caps the temperature at the tap.

Watts says uninsulated pipe or long runs on a concrete slab may need a second valve, or two valves side by side to raise the flow. Insulating the hot line is the other fix. Our pipe insulation guide covers the options.

How the timers work and how long to run them

Every pick here runs on a plug-in timer. The details differ a little.

PickTimerStepsSwitchAfter a power outage
Watts 500800 kit24 h dialQuarter hourTIMER, ON, OFFReset the time
Grundfos Comfort 59591624 h dial, 16 A15 minTIMER, ON, OFFReset the time
Taco 006-BC4-PNP24 h analog15 minTimerNot stated
Taco 003-SC4-1PNP24 h analog15 minTimerNot stated
Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLCTimer and cord, per listingNot in the sheetNot in the sheetNot stated

Watts and Grundfos give the same starting schedule: run the pump from 30 minutes before the first shower until 15 minutes after the last. If you still wait, Watts says start 15 to 30 minutes earlier.

Taco’s digital RECIRC models keep their settings on a battery for up to 3 months; the analog Plumb n’ Plug models on this page don’t list that.

Grundfos UP15-29 at 87 WkWh a daykWh a year
Running 24 hours2.09762
Timer, 4 hours a day0.35127
Timer, 2 hours a day0.1764

That table is arithmetic on Grundfos’ maximum power input of 87 W, so it’s the most the pump can draw, not a meter reading. Multiply by your power rate to see the cost. The point holds for every pump here: a timer cuts the run hours, and the run hours drive the bill.

If you have a tankless water heater

Tankless heaters change the answer. Start with the heater, not the pump.

SourceWhat it says about recirculation
Watts IOM-WQ-500800This kit does not work with tankless water heaters
Grundfos Comfort System manualDoesn’t address tankless; ask Grundfos before you try it
A.O. Smith ATI-310CX3 manualRecirculation with an external pump and a crossover valve
A.O. Smith tankless warranty 100287496Shorter coverage with an uncontrolled recirculation pump; no coverage past 300 starts a day
Rheem RTG spec sheetRTG-R models have recirculation built in; pump kit sold separately

A tankless heater only fires when water flows past a minimum rate. Rheem’s RTG sheet, for example, lists 0.4 gpm to start. A sensor-valve kit built for a tank heater isn’t designed around that, and Watts says outright that its kit won’t work.

Some tankless heaters build the pump in; others give their own piping for an outside pump.

The warranty is the other reason to read the manual first. A.O. Smith shortens coverage when a recirculation pump runs without a control, and excludes heaters that start more than 300 times a day. Our A.O. Smith vs Rheem comparison and Navien vs Rinnai comparison cover recirculation by model.

What each maker’s warranty covers

From the warranty text in each manual. Two of the five have one in the document we read.

PickLengthStartsNotable limits
Watts 500800 kit1 yearDate of original shipmentNo professional install charges; not if moved; US and Canada only; call 1-800-752-5582 first
Grundfos Comfort 59591624 monthsDate of installation, within 30 months of manufactureOriginal user only
Taco 003 and 006 PNPNot in submittal 101-066Ask Taco or the seller
Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLCNot in the CAPS sheetAsk Grundfos or Amazon

Watts’ warranty also excludes damage from improper installation against its printed instructions, freezing, water pressure spikes and adverse water. It needs a potable municipal or well supply, and repaired or replacement parts carry 90 days or the rest of the original term, whichever is longer.

Where the sources disagree

Places where a listing and the maker’s document don’t line up, and what I went by.

TopicOne source saysThe other saysGo by
UP15-29 motor sizeAmazon title: ½ hpGrundfos sheet: 0.121 hp output, 87 W inputThe Grundfos sheet
UP15-29 temperatureGrundfos sheet: 35.6 to 230°F liquidGrundfos Comfort manual: 150°F for UP15 with cord and timer150°F with the cord and timer
Watts valve closing pointAmazon page: closes at 98°FWatts manual: about 90°F ±4 at the testThe manual; replace over 100°F
Grundfos 595916 powerAmazon title: 25 WGrundfos manual: not statedNot used on this page
Taco SmartPlus modelAmazon listing: 003-IQB4Taco submittal 101-154: 006-IQB4 onlyNot linked here

The SmartPlus row is why it isn’t a pick. Taco’s SmartPlus learns your hot water use over 7 days and runs around it, which is a good feature. The only Amazon listing names a model Taco’s submittal doesn’t, so I left it out.

Which pump fits your plumbing?

QuestionIf yesIf no
Is there a return pipe back to the heater?A circulator: Taco or Grundfos UP15-29A sensor-valve kit: Watts or Grundfos Comfort
Is the heater tankless?Your heater’s own recirculation setupAny pick that fits your pipes
Is the loop under 200 ft of ¾ in. pipe?Taco 003-SC4-1PNPTaco 006-BC4-PNP
Do you want hoses in the box?Watts 500800 kitGrundfos Comfort works too
Do you want the check valve inside the pump?Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLCA Taco plus a flow check
Does the far end branch two ways?A second sensor valve; this Watts bundle has oneOne valve is enough

With a tank heater and no return pipe, start with the Watts kit. If you aren’t sure what heater you should have in the first place, our best water heater guide and tank vs tankless guide cover that choice.

If the wait is at one sink only, a pump may be more than you need. Our under-sink water heater guide covers point-of-use heaters, and our instant hot water dispenser guide covers near-boiling taps for the kitchen.

Installing a recirculating pump

From Watts’, Grundfos’ and Taco’s instructions.

Shut off gas or power first

Watts: turn off the breaker for an electric heater, or the gas for a gas heater, before you start.

Keep it off the flue

Both kit makers say the pump and its cord must not touch the vent pipe of a gas or oil heater.

Fill before you plug in

Watts and Grundfos: fill the system and purge the air before the pump runs.

Follow the arrow

The arrow on the pump body points the way the water should flow, away from the heater on the hot outlet.

No tape on the valve

Watts and Grundfos both say no tape or pipe dope on the sensor valve threads.

Use a grounded outlet

Watts and Grundfos ship a grounding plug; Watts says to follow the National Electrical Code.

The kit steps start the same way: close the cold supply to the heater, open a hot tap in the house to drain the hot lines, then drain the rest at the heater’s valve. Mount the pump on the hot outlet, reconnect, and let the water run until the air is out.

Our expansion tank guide covers the other part you’ll see on that cold line.

Watts and Grundfos both want the pump shaft horizontal. Taco’s submittal shows its allowed mounting positions, with one marked OK only above 20 psi. If the heater won’t heat after the work, our no hot water troubleshooting guide walks through the usual causes.

Questions people ask

What’s the best hot water recirculating pump?

For a tank heater with no return pipe, the Watts 500800 kit with a sensor valve under the farthest sink. With a return pipe, the Taco 006-BC4-PNP for loops of 200 to 400 ft of ¾ in. pipe, or the Taco 003-SC4-1PNP up to 200 ft.

Do I need a return line for a recirculating pump?

No. The Watts and Grundfos Comfort kits use a sensor valve under the farthest sink to send cooled water back through the cold line. Circulators like the Taco and Grundfos UP15-29 need a dedicated return pipe.

Why is my cold water warm after installing a recirculating pump?

A sensor-valve kit sends cooled hot water through the cold line at the valve sink. Watts and Grundfos both say this is normal and clears quickly. If the valve test water is over 100°F, Watts says replace the valve.

Does a recirculating pump work with a tankless water heater?

Not the Watts kit; Watts says it doesn’t work with tankless heaters. Some tankless models have recirculation built in or give piping for an outside pump. Check your heater’s manual and warranty first.

Where does a recirculating pump go?

For the Watts and Grundfos kits, on the water heater’s hot outlet, pumping toward the house, with the valve at the farthest sink. Taco shows a return-line circulator on the hot supply after the heater or on the return, pumping toward it.

How long should a recirculating pump run?

Watts and Grundfos suggest from 30 minutes before the first shower until 15 minutes after the last. If you still wait, Watts says start it 15 to 30 minutes earlier.

Does a recirculating pump use a lot of electricity?

It depends on the pump and the hours. The Grundfos UP15-29’s maximum input is 87 W, so at most 2.09 kWh a day running nonstop and about 0.35 kWh on a 4-hour timer.

What size recirculating pump do I need?

Taco sizes by loop length in ¾ in. pipe: the 003 for up to 200 ft, supply plus return, and the 005 or 006 for 200 to 400 ft. Taco warns that oversizing causes noise and erosion.

Do I need a check valve with a recirculating pump?

On a return loop, yes. Taco recommends flow checks with its Plumb n’ Plug pumps, and its IFC models have one built in. The Grundfos UP15-29SUC has built-in isolating and non-return valves.

Is a recirculation pump an anti-scald device?

No. Watts and Grundfos both say their systems are not anti-scald devices. A thermostatic mixing valve is the part that limits temperature at the tap.

What happens to the timer after a power outage?

On the Watts and Grundfos Comfort kits, the timer stops keeping time. Turn the ring until the arrow points to the current time again.

Is the Watts kit the same as the Grundfos Comfort System?

The layout is the same, and Watts’ label says its pump is made by Grundfos. The differences are the box and the warranty: Watts includes hoses and gives 1 year; Grundfos needs hoses and gives 24 months.

How I picked them

How I picked

I split the picks by plumbing: two sensor-valve kits for houses with no return pipe and three circulators for houses with one, sized by Taco’s loop lengths.

Specs come from Watts’, Grundfos’ and Taco’s manuals and submittals. The Laing AutoCirc was left out for low stock, the APCOM UT1 for lack of a maker document, and the Taco SmartPlus because its listing’s model number doesn’t match Taco’s. The three circulators carry a spec score from four checks shown below; the two kits don’t.

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia (license #JP507711). Every number on this page comes from a named maker document listed below, and nothing is copied from Amazon reviews.

The spec score, check by check

Each check scores 0 to 10 and counts one quarter. It’s our score from Grundfos’ and Taco’s published figures, not a customer rating or a flow test. Only the three circulators are scored; the two sensor-valve kits work through the cold line and publish no head, so they aren’t.

Size the pump to your loop first: Taco puts the 003 on loops up to 200 ft and the 006 on 200 to 400 ft.

Check (weight)How it’s scored
Reach (¼)Maximum head from the maker’s sheet: 10 for 9 ft or more; 8 for 6 to 8.9 ft; 7 for 4 to 5.9 ft
Valves (¼)10 when shutoff and check valves are built into the pump; 6 when you add a flow check and isolation valves on the pipe
Timer (¼)10 for a 24-hour timer with 15-minute steps described in the maker’s submittal; 8 for a timer named in the model but not described in the maker’s sheet
Pressure (¼)Maximum working pressure from the maker: 10 for 145 psi or more; 9 for 125 to 144 psi
TotalAverage of the checks, to one decimal
PickReachValvesTimerPressureScore
Grundfos UP15-29SUC/TLC10108109.5
Taco 006-BC4-PNP1061098.8
Taco 003-SC4-1PNP761098.0

Sources

  • Watts, Hot Water Recirculation System Model 500800 installation and operation manual, IOM-WQ-500800
  • Grundfos, Comfort System hot water recirculation system installation and operating instructions
  • Grundfos, UP 15-29 SUC/TLC submittal data, product no. 59896777 (Grundfos CAPS)
  • Taco, Plumb n’ Plug domestic hot water circulators submittal 101-066 (effective 06/08/25)
  • Taco, SmartPlus instruction sheet 102-516 and submittal 101-154
  • A.O. Smith, ATI-310CX3 installation manual 2000610429 and tankless warranty 100287496
  • Rheem, RTG and RTGR tankless spec sheet RH-RTG-RTGR-SS
  • Xylem, Laing Thermotech autocirc brochure (checked; pick not linked)
  • U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recall search, Oct 21, 2026: no recalls for these kits or circulators
  • Images read Oct 21, 2026.

Related guides