Best for 60 to 80 gallon heaters
Amtrol ST-12
The ST-12 is the bigger in-line Therm-X-Trol, and I’ve used it. Amtrol’s submittal lists it at 4.4 gallons, 11 inches across and 15 inches tall, about 9 pounds shipping weight, with the same 3/4-inch male connection as the ST-5. [2] The Amazon listing names it as part 141N43.
It shares its paperwork with the ST-5: the seven-year warranty, the sizing chart, the polypropylene liner, the stainless connection, the NSF/ANSI 61 diaphragm and the InSight cap. [1] [2]
Where it differs is reach. Amtrol gives it a maximum acceptance factor of 0.73, against 0.45 for the ST-5. [2] Times the tank volume, that’s up to about 3.2 gallons of expanded water against about 0.9 for the ST-5. On the 140°F chart it gets every 60 and 80 gallon row. [1]
On Amtrol’s 160°F chart it covers 40 gallon heaters at 80 psi, 50 gallons at 60 to 80 psi, 60 gallons at any pressure and 80 gallons up to 60 psi. At 180°F it covers 40 to 50 gallons at any pressure, 60 gallons up to 60 psi and 80 gallons at 40 psi. Past that, Amtrol’s chart moves to the floor-standing ST-25V. [1]
Weight matters on the install. Amtrol says the tank should hang water-connection up for best performance. If you mount it inverted or sideways, Amtrol says the body of the tank must be fully and rigidly supported to hold its entire weight when full of water. [1] A full ST-12 holds more water than a full ST-5, so strap it.
Like the ST-5, it ships at 50 psi and must be set to your cold supply pressure with the tank empty of water. [1] [2] Amtrol says adjustments to the precharge must be done at ambient temperature only. [1]
Amtrol lists these tanks for residential potable water systems only, with a 200°F limit, and says not to use them on a system with ASME-rated vessels. [1] Bigger commercial jobs go to Amtrol’s stand models and its sizing tools. [1]
When the sizer below lands between the two, my pick is the ST-12, the one with more acceptance.
Check price on Amazon for Amtrol ST-12