Water Heater Pilot Light Won’t Stay Lit? Fix the Thermocouple
If your water heater pilot light won’t stay lit, I start with the lighting label and the sensor type before choosing a replacement part.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns
Updated November 15, 2026 · About Isaac · How I chose

The short answer
A failed thermocouple can make a pilot go out when you release the knob, but that symptom alone does not prove which part failed. I follow the heater’s lighting label first and arrange service if the pilot still will not hold. [1]
- Smell gas
- Leave the building. Call the gas supplier from outside; if unreachable, call the fire department. Do not light anything or operate switches. [1]
- Pilot goes out on release
- Check the symptoms, then have the correct sensor and pilot assembly diagnosed.
- Need a replacement part
- Match the heater’s parts list. Lead length alone does not establish compatibility.
Find the safe next step
I use this check to separate an emergency from a relighting question. It cannot diagnose a gas valve or replace the heater’s manual and an in-person check.
Keep sealed burner doors closed. Never bypass a sensor, thermal switch or other safety device.
First, Relight It the Right Way
Before I condemn a part, I check whether the lighting sequence was followed. The waiting period, ignition method, hold time and status-light pattern come from the instructions attached to that exact heater. A general guide cannot replace them.
If you smell gas
Do not attempt to relight the heater. Leave the building without operating electrical switches or using a phone inside. Call the gas supplier from outside, and follow its directions. If you cannot reach the supplier, call the fire department. [1]
- 1
Read the model and serial number from the data plate without opening the burner compartment. Find the matching manufacturer manual and lighting label.
- 2
Check the label’s safety warnings first. Do not relight with a gas odor, a suspected venting problem, a carbon monoxide alarm or evidence of flooding.
- 3
If the label permits homeowner relighting, follow its OFF, waiting, PILOT and ignition sequence exactly. Do not force a control knob or add an open flame where the label specifies a built-in igniter.
- 4
Use the label’s hold time and status-light instructions. If the pilot will not stay lit after the permitted attempts, turn the control OFF as directed and call a qualified service technician or the gas supplier.
The A. O. Smith manual linked below gives its own lighting and stop instructions. Its timing and light pattern apply to the covered models, rather than every gas water heater. [1]
Why the Pilot Will Not Stay Lit
I separate a pilot that never catches from one that catches and then dies. The second symptom can involve a thermocouple or thermopile, but weak pilot fuel flow, drafts, combustion-air problems and a control fault can also interrupt operation. The symptom tells me what to inspect; it does not establish how often a part fails.
| What you see | What needs checking | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Pilot dies when the knob is released | Lighting sequence, pilot flame and sensor circuit | Follow the label once within its retry limit, then arrange diagnosis |
| Weak, yellow or unstable pilot flame | Pilot assembly, gas supply and combustion air | Have a qualified technician inspect it; do not enlarge the orifice |
| Pilot goes out in gusts | Drafts, venting and combustion air | Arrange a venting check; keep air openings clear |
| Correct new sensor, same failure | Connections, pilot output, safety devices and gas control | Have the complete system tested before replacing more parts |
Source for the symptom categories: A. O. Smith’s pilot-light troubleshooting overview and the covered model’s troubleshooting chart. [2] [1]
A thermocouple heated by the pilot helps keep the gas safety circuit operating. A damaged sensor or a flame that does not heat it properly can interrupt that circuit. I look for the model’s specified flame pattern through its viewing window; I do not use a universal flame-contact measurement for every burner.
Match the part before buying
The existing guide names the Resideo (Honeywell) CQ100A1013 24-inch thermocouple. I keep that model here as a compatibility reference. Before ordering, I check the heater’s approved replacement-parts list, the sensor type, mounting arrangement and connection, then the lead length. A thermopile is a different component.[3]

Product photo: Amazon
For a confirmed compatible thermocouple replacement
Honeywell CQ100A1013 24-inch Universal Thermocouple
CQ100A1013
- Buy it if
- The heater’s approved parts list calls for this thermocouple and a qualified technician has confirmed the fault. The lead is 24 inches. [3]
- Skip it if
- The heater uses a thermopile, needs a different pilot assembly or has an unidentified ignition system.
- The tradeoff
- The correct lead length alone does not establish a fit. Check the sensor connection and mounting arrangement against the heater’s manual.
$15.99 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST · low stock thenCheck Honeywell CQ100A1013 on Amazon (opens in a new tab)New; limited stock when checked. Confirm the package quantity on the listing before ordering.
| Named part | Resideo CQ100A1013 replacement thermocouple[3] |
|---|---|
| Lead length | 24 inches, per Resideo[3] |
| Intended application | Compatible gas furnaces, boilers and water heaters; confirm the heater’s parts list |
| Installation | Qualified professional, per the manufacturer’s warning |
| Buying decision | Confirm the exact replacement assembly with the heater manufacturer before ordering |
Source: Resideo’s CQ100A1013 product page. [3]
I would choose a confirmed compatible thermocouple for a diagnosed thermocouple fault. I would skip it for a thermopile system or an unidentified sealed burner assembly. The tradeoff is straightforward: a short lead and familiar model name do not make a part universal for every heater.
How to Replace the Thermocouple
I treat replacement as gas-appliance service, rather than a beginner repair. Resideo warns that this part should be installed by a qualified professional. The heater’s manual controls burner removal, seals, connection torque, leak testing and the return-to-service checks. [3]
- 1
Identify the approved sensor or complete pilot assembly for the exact model. Confirm whether opening the sealed burner compartment requires a replacement gasket or other specified parts.
- 2
Have the qualified technician shut down and isolate the heater using its manual. There is no universal three-nut removal procedure for all heaters.
- 3
The technician removes and refits the assembly using the manufacturer’s service directions. Sensor positioning, routing and connection tightening follow those directions, without a generic extra quarter turn.
- 4
Before the heater is returned to use, the technician performs the specified gas-leak, burner, flame, safety-device and venting checks. A quick household-soap check is not a substitute for that service procedure.
Do not bend a sensor into an assumed position, drill a pilot opening or bypass a safety switch to keep a flame burning. If the manual does not authorize the work, stop and arrange service.
When It Is Not the Thermocouple
A pilot that still drops out with a correctly specified new sensor needs a wider diagnosis. I would have the technician check pilot output, connections, the safety circuit and the gas control before buying another component. A gas valve replacement is a service job, not a guess based on one symptom. [1]
Some heaters use a thermopile and an electronic gas control; others use electronic ignition without a continuously burning pilot. FVIR means flammable vapor ignition resistant. It does not, by itself, tell you whether the heater has a thermocouple or thermopile. The model’s manual and replacement-parts diagram settle that question.
My thermocouple vs thermopile vs flame sensor guide explains the distinction. If your heater has a status light, record its exact flash pattern and use its own manual first. The A. O. Smith status-light guide and Bradford White status-light guide can help you find the right topic.
If the heater is cold for another reason, start with no hot water troubleshooting. When repeated repairs make replacement worth considering, compare water-heater replacement costs and water-heater options.
When to Call a Pro
I call for qualified service when the pilot fails after the label’s permitted relighting attempts, the burner compartment needs opening, the ignition system is unidentified or the gas control is suspected. Draft-related outages, soot, damaged venting or an unstable flame also need inspection before more relighting attempts. [1]
A gas odor or a carbon monoxide alarm is an emergency: leave the building and call for help from outside. Do not stay beside the heater trying to troubleshoot it. A flooded heater must be evaluated under the manufacturer’s instructions before it is operated again.
Water around the heater needs a separate diagnosis. A leaking tank generally calls for replacement, while a plumbing connection or relief-valve discharge may have another cause. I distinguish those before making a replacement decision. See gas vs electric water heaters if replacement is confirmed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why will not my water heater pilot light stay lit?
A failed thermocouple or thermopile is one possible cause, alongside pilot fuel-flow, airflow, draft and control problems. I check the lighting label and ignition type before choosing parts. A pilot that dies on release is a symptom, rather than proof of a specific failed component. [1]
How much does it cost to replace a thermocouple?
The total includes the correct part, diagnosis and labor. A sealed burner assembly or complete pilot kit can change the scope. I ask for a model-specific quote rather than treating the price of a loose thermocouple as the whole repair cost.
Can I replace a water heater thermocouple myself?
I recommend qualified service. Resideo’s installation warning calls for a qualified professional, and the heater may need model-specific seals, tightening instructions and safety checks. Reading the lighting label is different from disconnecting gas-bearing burner connections. [3]
Should I keep holding the pilot button longer?
Only for the time the heater’s label specifies. Do not hold it indefinitely or defeat its release. If the pilot will not remain lit after the allowed attempts, follow the label’s OFF and service instructions. [1]
How I chose the next steps
I kept the original guide’s questions and section sequence, then checked the gas-safety instructions against A. O. Smith’s model manual and the named replacement part against Resideo’s product page. The first decision is whether relighting is safe; the next is whether the heater uses the part being considered.
I do not replace the older Robertshaw 1980-024 reference with another product on name alone. The heater manufacturer’s approved parts and the exact diagnosis come first. The finder directs a next step; it does not certify a repair or select a gas valve.
Sources
- A. O. Smith residential FVIR gas-water-heater installation and use manual, lighting, emergency instructions, troubleshooting and service requirements. Model-specific directions apply only to the models covered.
- A. O. Smith pilot-light overview, possible causes and the instruction to defer to the heater’s label and manual.
- Resideo CQ100A1013 product page, 24-inch thermocouple application and qualified-installation warning.
