240V vs 208V water heater element

Watts, amps and the right element for your plate.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns

Updated November 15, 2026

About Isaac · How I chose

Rheem screw-in water heater element

Quick answer

On 208V, a 240V element makes about 75% of its watts; Rheem lists its 4500W at 3380W. A 208V element on 240V can exceed the plate’s wattage. For a 240V, 4500W screw-in plate, my pick is the Rheem SP10869MM, if your maker’s parts list agrees.

Rheem SP10869MM 240V 4500W screw-in water heater element
240V 4500W screw-in: Rheem SP10869MM$31.35 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Check it on Amazon
On this page
  1. 1The picks
  2. 2208V element on 240V
  3. 3Rheem SP10869MM
  4. 4Rheem SP10869PH
  5. 5Rheem SP17618AM
  6. 6Camco 02583
  7. 7Side by side
  8. 8Output on 208V
  9. 9Why output drops
  10. 10Read the rating plate
  11. 11Breaker and wire
  12. 12Recovery on 208V
  13. 13Heat pump heaters
  14. 14Replacing an element
  15. 15Check it with a meter
  16. 16Common mistakes
  17. 17Questions
  18. 18How I pick

Four elements, matched to the rating plate

All four are 240V screw-in elements. On 208V each makes about three quarters of its 240V wattage, which is how dual-rated heaters are meant to run.

The swap that causes trouble: a 208V element on 240V

Bradford White’s parts list shows why. Each 208V copper element shares its part number with a bigger 240V element.

Labeled 208 Vthe wattage it makes on 208 V Same part numberBradford White copper element Labeled 240 Vwhat it makes on 240 V, amps 4500 W at 208 V208 V element 415-42544-12one part, two labels 6000 W at 240 V25.0 A on 240 V 4000 W at 208 V208 V element 415-42544-16one part, two labels 5500 W at 240 V22.9 A on 240 V 3500 W at 208 V208 V element 415-42544-08one part, two labels 4500 W at 240 V18.8 A on 240 V 3000 W at 208 V208 V element 415-42544-14one part, two labels 4000 W at 240 V16.7 A on 240 V 2500 W at 208 V208 V element 415-42544-06one part, two labels 3500 W at 240 V14.6 A on 240 V On 240 V, a 208 V element runs at its 240 V wattage.Rheem TSB 1305 recommends 25 A and 10 AWG for 4500 W, and 35 A and 8 AWG for 6000 W. Part numbers: Bradford White 238-51382-00, page 13 (copper elements). Amps: Rheem TSB 1305. Check local electrical codes. Each Bradford White copper element part numberis printed under both labels. Part 415-42544-12 4500 W at 208 V208 V label 6000 W at 240 V25.0 A on 240 V Part 415-42544-16 4000 W at 208 V208 V label 5500 W at 240 V22.9 A on 240 V Part 415-42544-08 3500 W at 208 V208 V label 4500 W at 240 V18.8 A on 240 V Part 415-42544-14 3000 W at 208 V208 V label 4000 W at 240 V16.7 A on 240 V Part 415-42544-06 2500 W at 208 V208 V label 3500 W at 240 V14.6 A on 240 V 208 V element on a 240 V supplyIt runs at its 240 V wattage. Rheem TSB 1305recommends 25 A and 10 AWG for 4500 W,and 35 A and 8 AWG for 6000 W. Parts: Bradford White 238-51382-00, page 13.Amps: Rheem TSB 1305. Check local electrical codes.
From Bradford White electric parts list 238-51382-00, page 13 (copper elements), and Rheem TSB 1305, read Oct 20, 2026.

Read the chart by row. Bradford White’s 208V, 4500W copper element and its 240V, 6000W element are one part, 415-42544-12. Its Incoloy list on page 12 does the same, with part 415-42545-19 for both.

So a “208V 4500W” element on a 240V circuit makes 6000W. Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 25.0 amps for 6000W at 240V, against 18.8 amps for 4500W. Its recommended breaker is 35 amps with 8 AWG copper for 6000W, and 25 amps with 10 AWG for 4500W.

The danger is going past what the heater is approved for. A. O. Smith’s manual for its 120V point-of-use heaters says replacement elements must be the same voltage and no greater wattage than the rating plate. Its main care guide says to check the data plate for the correct wattage and voltage.

An element built only for 208V has a second problem. Rheem’s TSB 1306 says that when an element gets more than its design voltage, “the element will burn out.”

The picks, one at a time

Best for 240V 4500W screw-in plates

Rheem SP10869MM

240V 4500W stainless steel resistored low watt density element

SP10869MM, 240V 4500W, 1 in. screw-in
$31.35
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
9.5Spec scoreHow it’s scored
208V output printed10
Sheath10
Watt density10
Dry fire build8

Pros

  • Rheem lists its 208V output: 3380W
  • Low watt density stainless steel sheath
  • Fold-back shape, 13.44 in. flange to tip
  • 1 in. NPSM screw-in, 11-1/2 threads per inch
  • Match the rating plate before ordering

Cons

  • Only for 240V 4500W or dual-rated plates
  • Plates marked 208V only need a 208V element
  • No wrench or gasket listed in the features
SP10869MM240V 4500W3380W on 208VLWD13.44 in.1 in. NPSM

Buy it if

Your plate says 240V and 4500W per element (or a dual-rated Rheem lists 3380W on 208V), the heater takes a 1 in. screw-in element, and the heater maker’s parts list approves this part, or its length and mounting, for your model.

Skip it if

The plate says 208V only or lists a different wattage, or the heater doesn’t take a 1 in. screw-in element. Match the plate and parts list instead.

This is the element I’d buy for a heater whose plate says 240V and 4500W and that takes a 1 in. screw-in element. Rheem’s listing prints both numbers you’ll see in the field: 4500W at 240V and 3380W at 208V. Those match the 4500W row of Rheem’s TSB 1317 exactly.

It’s a low watt density (LWD) element with a stainless steel sheath, folded back on itself. Rheem lists 13.44 in. from flange to tip, a .316 in. element diameter and 1 in. NPSM threads at 11-1/2 per inch. Rheem’s other screw-in elements and Camco’s list the same thread.

On a dual-rated Rheem heater wired to 208V, this is still the right part. TSB 1317 says Rheem’s residential electric heaters are rated for both voltages. You’ll get 3380W and about 16 gallons an hour at a 90°F rise, instead of 21 on 240V.

Check the plate before you order. A. O. Smith’s care guide tells owners to check the data plate for the correct wattage and voltage. If yours says 208V only and 4500W, the heater was built with 208V elements, and this one would give you about a quarter less heat than the plate promises.

On a meter it should read close to 12.8 ohms, the figure Rheem’s TSB 1305 gives for a 4500W, 240V element. That’s inside A. O. Smith’s 5 to 25 ohm range for a good element. A reading near 9.6 means a different part: TSB 1305 lists 9.6 ohms for both a 208V, 4500W and a 240V, 6000W element.

Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 18.8 amps for this element at 240V. On 208V that falls to about 16.3 amps (3380W divided by 208V, my math), so a circuit already sized correctly for the heater carries less current than it does at 240V.

Why this pick: it’s Rheem’s own 4500W screw-in element, the listing gives its 208V output in plain numbers.

Best for 5500W rating plates

Rheem SP10869PH

240V 5500W stainless steel resistored medium watt density element

SP10869PH, 240V 5500W, 1 in. screw-in
$22.29
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
9.0Spec scoreHow it’s scored
208V output printed10
Sheath10
Watt density8
Dry fire build8

Pros

  • Rheem lists 4130W on 208V
  • Cold resistance printed: 10.50 ohms
  • Watt density drops from 113 to 85 on 208V
  • Stainless steel, fold-back, 13.47 in.
  • Match the rating plate before ordering

Cons

  • Medium watt density, not low
  • Only for 5500W or dual-rated plates
  • Rheem recommends a 30 A breaker for 5500W at 240V
SP10869PH240V 5500W4130W on 208VMWD10.50 ohms13.47 in.

Buy it if

Your plate says 240V and 5500W, or it’s a dual-rated Rheem heater on 208V that lists 4130W.

Skip it if

Your plate says 4500W. A bigger element than the plate allows is the mistake A. O. Smith warns against.

Pick this one only when the plate says 5500W. Rheem’s listing gives a full set of numbers: 5500W at 240V, 4130W at 208V, and a cold resistance of 10.50 ohms. Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 10.5 ohms for a 5500W, 240V element.

It also shows something most listings leave out: watt density at each voltage. Rheem lists 113 watts per square inch at 240V and 85 at 208V. On 208V the sheath puts out about a quarter less heat per square inch of surface.

At 240V it’s a medium watt density (MWD) element. That’s a step up in surface heat from the low density SP10869MM. It’s a stainless steel fold-back, 13.47 in. from flange to tip, with the same 1 in. NPSM thread as Rheem’s other screw-in elements.

Rheem’s own listing note says to use Rheem replacement parts on Rheem heaters for best results. If your heater is another brand and its plate says 5500W, check that maker’s parts list first. Bradford White, for example, lists its 240V 5500W copper element as part 415-42544-16.

Mind the breaker. Rheem’s TSB 1305 recommends a 30 amp breaker and 10 AWG copper for a 5500W heater at 240V, and says to check local codes. Never put this element in a heater whose plate says 4500W just to get faster recovery; A. O. Smith says no greater wattage than the plate.

The 208V math works the same way as for any element. Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 22.9 amps for 5500W at 240V; on 208V it’s about 19.9 amps (4130W divided by 208V, my math). Recovery at a 90°F rise drops from 25 to 19 gallons an hour, per TSB 1317.

Why this pick: Rheem’s own 5500W element, with its 208V wattage and cold ohms printed.

Best for dry-fire resistance

Rheem SP17618AM

240V 4500W stainless steel dry fire resistant low watt density element

SP17618AM, 240V 4500W, 1 in. screw-in
$46.50
Check it on Amazon
low stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
10Spec scoreHow it’s scored
208V output printed10
Sheath10
Watt density10
Dry fire build10

Pros

  • Listed dry fire resistant
  • Both ratings printed: 4500W and 3380W
  • Low watt density stainless steel
  • Fit list covers Rheem and many other brands
  • Match the rating plate before ordering

Cons

  • The listing doesn’t say how long it survives dry
  • 13.75 in. long, a bit longer than the SP10869MM
  • Still needs a full tank before power
SP17618AM240V 4500W208V 3380WLWDDry fire resistant13.75 in.

Buy it if

Your plate says 4500W at 240V, or 3380W at 208V, and you want an element built to resist dry firing.

Skip it if

The shorter SP10869MM is what your parts list calls for, or your plate lists a different wattage.

This is Rheem’s 4500W element with one extra claim: the listing calls it dry fire resistant. Dry firing means power reaches the element before it’s under water. A. O. Smith’s care guide warns that skipping the refill and air purge “can cause the upper heating element to burn out.”

The ratings are the same as the SP10869MM. Rheem’s listing says 208V 3380W and 240V 4500W, the same pair TSB 1317 gives. It’s a low watt density stainless steel element, 13.75 in. from flange to tip, with 1 in. NPSM threads.

The fit list is the broadest of the Rheem picks. Besides Rheem’s own OEM fit for Rheem, Ruud, Richmond, Vanguard and General Electric, the listing says it fits most Kenmore, A. O. Smith, Bradford White, Craftmaster, Lochinvar, Mor-Flo, Reliance, State and Whirlpool heaters that use screw-in elements.

Don’t read “dry fire resistant” as dry fire proof. The listing doesn’t give a time, a temperature or a test. Fill the tank and run a hot faucet first, exactly as A. O. Smith’s steps say: at least three minutes of full flow, then power on.

The listing calls it an OEM genuine factory authorized part, and its brand field reads Rheem. On a meter it should read near 12.8 ohms, like any 4500W, 240V element in Rheem’s TSB 1305.

On 208V it makes 3380W, so recovery at a 90°F rise falls from 21 to 16 gallons an hour, per Rheem’s TSB 1317. Next to the SP10869MM it’s 0.31 in. longer, at 13.75 in. against 13.44 in., and both use the same 1 in. NPSM thread.

Why this pick: same plate match and same 208V output as my top pick, plus a listed dry fire resistant build. A full tank before power is still the rule.

Best for hard water in other brands

Camco 02583

240V 4500W screw-in fold-back low watt density element

02583, 240V 4500W, 1 in. screw-in
$12.85
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
8.3Spec scoreHow it’s scored
208V output printed7
Sheath8
Watt density10
Dry fire build8

Pros

  • Low watt density, which Camco says reduces lime buildup
  • UL listed for the US and Canada
  • Gasket #06822 included
  • Long fit list across brands
  • Match the rating plate before ordering

Cons

  • No 208V wattage in the listing
  • Plated copper sheath, not stainless
  • Limited 1-year warranty
02583240V 4500WAbout 3380W on 208VLWD13 in. min. tankUL listed

Buy it if

Your plate says 240V and 4500W, the heater takes a 1 in. screw-in element and isn’t a Rheem, and you have hard water.

Skip it if

You want the 208V wattage printed by the maker. The Rheem picks list it; Camco doesn’t.

Camco’s 02583 is the non-Rheem pick for a 240V, 4500W plate. It’s a low watt density fold-back element, and Camco’s listing says that design “reduces lime deposit buildup” in hard water areas. Camco says it fits most replacements of the same wattage and voltage.

Camco doesn’t print a 208V figure. The physics doesn’t care about the brand, though. Using Rheem’s TSB 1306 formula, any 4500W, 240V element makes 75.111% on 208V, or about 3380W. That’s my math, not Camco’s, and it matches Rheem’s table.

Construction is different from the Rheem picks. Camco lists a 1 in. NPSM carbon steel bushing, a rubber gasket (#06822) and plated copper tubing. It needs a tank at least 13 in. across, so measure a compact or unusual heater before you order.

The fit list is long: American, A. O. Smith, Bradford White, Craftmaster before 1991, GE, certain GS Wood models, Kenmore, Lochinvar, Maytag, Mor-Flo, Reliance, Rheem, Richmond, Rudd, Sears, State and Whirlpool, plus heaters made after 1994. Still check your plate’s voltage and wattage first.

Camco says the element is UL listed for the US and Canada and carries a limited 1-year warranty, so keep the receipt. On a meter, a 4500W, 240V element should read near 12.8 ohms, per Rheem’s TSB 1305.

On 208V it would draw about 16.3 amps (3380W divided by 208V, my math), down from the 18.8 amps Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists at 240V. Camco also sells an ultra low watt density 5500W element, the 02933 in its LimeLife line, for 5500W plates in hard water.

Why this pick: a UL listed low watt density element with its gasket included, sold by Amazon.com and in stock on Oct 20 and Oct 22, for owners of other brands who want lime resistance.

All four elements side by side

Ratings come from the makers’ listings and Rheem’s bulletins. Scroll sideways on a phone.

PickSpec scorePhotoPlate it matchesOn 240VOn 208VDensitySheathShort pros / consBuy
Rheem SP10869MM
240V 4500W screw-in
9.5Rheem SP10869MM240V 4500W4500W3380WLWDStainless steel208V output listed / No gasket listedCheck it on Amazon
Rheem SP10869PH
5500W plates
9.0Rheem SP10869PH240V 5500W5500W4130WMWDStainless steelOhms listed / Medium densityCheck it on Amazon
Rheem SP17618AM
Dry-fire resistance
10Rheem SP17618AM240V 4500W4500W3380WLWDStainless steelDry fire resistant / No time givenCheck it on Amazon
Camco 02583
Hard water, other brands
8.3Camco 02583240V 4500W4500WAbout 3380W (my math)LWDPlated copperUL listed / No 208V figureCheck it on Amazon

Green marks a strength and amber marks a limit. LWD: low watt density. MWD: medium watt density. Camco lists a minimum tank diameter, not an element length.

What a 240V element puts out on 208V

Rheem’s TSB 1317 lists the 208V output for each common size. Every one lands at about 75% of the 240V rating.

3000W element on 208V2255W3500W element on 208V2630W3800W element on 208V2855W4500W element on 208V3380W5000W element on 208V3755W5500W element on 208V4130W6000W element on 208V4500W3000W element on 208V2255W3500W element on 208V2630W3800W element on 208V2855W4500W element on 208V3380W5000W element on 208V3755W5500W element on 208V4130W6000W element on 208V4500W
From Rheem Technical Service Bulletin 1317, Dual Voltage Rating on Residential Electric Water Heaters, read Oct 20, 2026. Bar lengths are on a 6000W scale.
Element rating at 240VOutput on 208VRecovery at 240VRecovery at 208V
3000W2255W14 GPH10 GPH
3500W2630W16 GPH12 GPH
3800W2855W17 GPH13 GPH
4500W3380W21 GPH16 GPH
5000W3755W23 GPH17 GPH
5500W4130W25 GPH19 GPH
6000W4500W27 GPH21 GPH

Recovery is gallons per hour at a 90°F temperature rise, as Rheem’s TSB 1317 states it. Rheem says the dual rating doesn’t cover 120V point-of-use heaters or units built for 208V only; read your rating label for those.

Rheem’s bulletin says its residential electric water heaters are dual rated for 240V and 208V single phase. So a Rheem heater wired to 208V isn’t broken or wrong. It’s running at its lower rating, and the label shows both numbers.

What you lose is speed. A 4500W element on 208V heats about 16 gallons an hour at a 90°F rise instead of 21. A full tank still gets hot. It just takes longer to come back after a long shower.

Why a 240V element loses a quarter of its heat on 208V

An element is a fixed resistance. Power rises and falls with the square of the voltage, so a 13% lower voltage costs about 25% of the heat.

Element ratingOhmsAmps at 240VAmps on 208VWatts on 208V
3500W at 240V16.514.6 A12.6 A2630W
4000W at 240V14.416.7 A14.4 A3004W
4500W at 240V12.818.8 A16.3 A3380W
5500W at 240V10.522.9 A19.9 A4130W
6000W at 240V9.625.0 A21.6 A4500W

Ohms and 240V amps from Rheem TSB 1305. Amps on 208V are watts on 208V divided by 208 (my math), and watts on 208V are from TSB 1317 except 4000W, which is my math from Rheem’s TSB 1306 formula.

Rheem’s TSB 1306 gives the formula: the new voltage squared over the design voltage squared. For 208V on a 240V element, that’s 43,264 over 57,600, or 75.111%. Rheem’s own example is a 5500W element that delivers 4131W on 208V.

The current drops too. A 4500W, 240V element on 208V pulls about 16.3 amps instead of 18.8. Lower voltage across the same resistance means less current, not more, on a circuit already sized correctly for the heater.

TSB 1306 ends with a caution: Rheem “does not recommend the down-rating of electrical heating elements.” Its example is a 240V element supplied with 208V.

TSB 1317 covers Rheem’s own heaters. It says Rheem’s residential electric heaters are dual rated for 240V and 208V, with both ratings on the label. Follow the label on your heater.

Read the rating plate before you buy

A. O. Smith’s care guide says the heater’s electrical requirements are on its data plate. Find what yours says, then use the row that matches.

What the plate saysWhat’s in the heaterWhat to buy
240V, 4500W240V 4500W elementsA 240V 4500W element your heater’s parts list approves, such as the Rheem SP10869MM for many screw-in heaters
240V 4500W and 208V 3380WDual-rated; 240V elementsThe same approved 240V 4500W element, at either voltage
240V, 5500W240V 5500W elementsA 240V 5500W element your heater’s parts list approves, such as the Rheem SP10869PH
208V only, with a wattage208V elements, built for 208VA 208V element of that exact wattage from the heater’s maker
120V120V elements; A. O. Smith lists 120V from 6-gallon up to some 50-gallon tanksA 120V element of the plate’s wattage, per the model’s element spec
Two wattages for two elements, or “simultaneous”Different upper and lower elements, or both heating at onceExactly what each line lists; check the model’s element spec and wiring diagram

From Rheem TSB 1317, A. O. Smith’s residential electric use and care guide (100341465), its 2.5-gallon point-of-use manual (185834-000) and its element availability sheet (AOSTD63000), read Oct 20, 2026.

Copy the model number, voltage and wattage before you shop. If the plate lists a voltage and a wattage you don’t see among my picks, buy that exact rating, not the closest one.

A plate that says 208V only means the heater was built for 208V. A. O. Smith’s availability sheet shows 208V offered as its own input, from 1 kW up to 6 kW depending on the tank. Rheem makes 208V-only elements such as the SP10872NL, a 208V, 5000W copper element; its Amazon listing showed low stock on Oct 20.

Breaker and wire size at 208V and 240V

Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists breaker and copper wire size by the heater’s total wattage. The numbers are for a heater rated at that voltage.

Heater wattageBreaker at 208VBreaker at 240VWire at 208VWire at 240V
3000W20 A20 A12 AWG12 AWG
4000W25 A25 A10 AWG10 AWG
4500W30 A25 A10 AWG10 AWG
5000W30 A30 A10 AWG10 AWG
5500W35 A30 A8 AWG10 AWG
6000W40 A35 A8 AWG8 AWG

Single phase rows from Rheem TSB 1305, page 2, copper wire per NEC Table 310-16 at 75°C, read Oct 20, 2026. Rheem’s bulletin opens with a reminder to check all local electrical codes before changing wiring.

Read the 208V column as a heater built for 208V at that wattage. A 4500W heater rated at 208V pulls 21.6 amps, per TSB 1305, and the table lists a 30 amp breaker for it.

A 240V, 4500W heater running on 208V is a different case. It only makes 3380W and draws about 16.3 amps, less than on 240V. That helps only if the circuit was sized correctly to begin with. A. O. Smith says to check the voltage, wire size and breaker rating and type against the data plate.

A. O. Smith’s spec text for its residential electric heaters says element operation “shall be double element, non-simultaneous” unless ordered differently. Only one element heats at a time, so a heater with two 4500W elements is a 4500W heater on the plate.

Simultaneous wiring is the exception. A. O. Smith says to make sure the breaker is big enough for the higher current when you order it. Wiring changes belong to an electrician.

How much slower a tank recovers on 208V

Rheem’s TSB 1306 gives the recovery formula: element watts divided by 2.42 times the temperature rise, worked out at 50, 70 and 90°F.

Element50°F rise70°F rise90°F rise
4500W on 240V37.2 GPH26.6 GPH20.7 GPH
4500W element on 208V (3380W)27.9 GPH20.0 GPH15.5 GPH
5500W on 240V45.5 GPH32.5 GPH25.3 GPH
5500W element on 208V (4130W)34.1 GPH24.4 GPH19.0 GPH

My math from Rheem’s TSB 1306 formula, read Oct 20, 2026. TSB 1305’s recovery table rounds the 4500W row to 37, 27 and 21 GPH. A. O. Smith’s recovery table lists 20.5 GPH for 4.5 kW at a 90°F rise.

The rise is how much the heater warms incoming water. Water coming in at 50°F and heated to 120°F is a 70°F rise. In winter, colder supply water means a bigger rise and slower recovery.

On 208V, a 4500W element loses about 6.6 gallons an hour at a 70°F rise. If that’s not enough, moving up to a 5500W heater is a question for the maker and an electrician. The plate decides what elements it can take.

A. O. Smith lists “low supply voltage” as one cause of not enough hot water. If your plate says 240V but your building has 208V, that can explain slower recovery. It doesn’t prove the elements are good; the same list includes a bad lower element, so test before you buy.

Heat pump water heaters are a different story

Dual rating is a feature of plain electric tanks. Heat pump models differ by generation, so the manual for your exact model decides.

Heater type208V allowed?What the maker says
Rheem residential electric tankYes, dual ratedTSB 1317: rated for 240V and 208V single phase
A. O. Smith residential electric tankYes, if ordered for 208VAOSTD63000 lists 208V inputs by tank size
A. O. Smith 120V point-of-useNo, one voltage onlyManual 185834-000: use only the voltage on the plate
A. O. Smith Voltex heat pump, 2012 manualNoManual 318257-002, April 2012: 240 VAC, 25 amp; “DO NOT use a 208 VAC service”
A. O. Smith Voltex Hybrid Electric, 2026 catalogYesCatalog AOSRB80000, October 2026: “208/240 VAC 60Hz capable”

From the documents named in each row, read Oct 20, 2026. Check your own heat pump model’s manual; I read A. O. Smith’s 2012 Voltex manual and its October 2026 catalog.

The 75% figure comes from Rheem’s bulletins on plain resistance elements. A. O. Smith’s April 2012 Voltex manual says twice that the service must be 240 VAC and not 208 VAC. Its October 2026 catalog lists the current Voltex Hybrid Electric line as 208/240 VAC capable.

If your building supplies 208V and you’re shopping for a heat pump model, read its installation manual for the voltage before you buy. My heat pump water heater guide covers the models.

Replacing an element, the A. O. Smith way

These steps follow A. O. Smith’s residential electric use and care guide. If you’re not comfortable working on it, A. O. Smith says to have a qualified person do it.

  1. Shut off the power

    Turn the power off at the breaker or remove the fuses.

  2. Prove it’s off

    Open the junction box and check the power wires with a non-contact tester, tested on a known live circuit before and after. Klein warns that no indication doesn’t prove no voltage, so A. O. Smith’s service handbook confirms with an AC voltmeter. If you can’t be sure the power is off, stop and call a qualified person.

  3. Cool the water

    Open a hot water faucet and let it run until the water is cool, to reduce the risk of scalding.

  4. Drain the tank

    Connect a garden hose to the drain valve, turn off the cold supply, and drain the tank. An open hot faucet helps it drain.

  5. Remove the old element

    Remove the access panel, insulation and thermostat cover, disconnect the element wires, and unscrew the element with an element wrench.

  6. Check the new one

    Check the new element’s voltage and wattage against the data plate before it goes in.

  7. Install the element

    Clean the threads with a rag. Fit the new element with its rubber gasket, put a drop of dish soap on the gasket, and tighten with an element wrench. Leave the power wires off.

  8. Refill and purge

    Close the drain valve, open the cold supply and keep a hot faucet open. Let the hot water run full for at least three minutes, until the tank is completely full.

  9. Check for leaks, then wire it

    Check the new element for leaks. If one won’t stop with tightening, drain the tank and check the gasket. Only when there are no leaks, replace the power wires, make sure the connections are tight, and put back the thermostat cover, insulation, access panel and junction box cover.

  10. Power back on

    Restore power. A. O. Smith says it may take two hours for the tank to heat.

ToolPhotoWhyBuy
Camco 09951 element socket
1/2 in. drive
Camco 09951 element socketA. O. Smith says regular 1-1/2 in. sockets are often beveled and may slip. Camco’s fits standard hex bushing elements.Check it on Amazon
Klein NCVT3P voltage tester pen
12 to 1000V AC
Klein NCVT3P non-contact voltage testerA. O. Smith’s steps call for a non-contact tester. Klein lists CAT IV 1000V and two ranges. It can show voltage, but no light doesn’t prove the wires are dead; confirm with a voltmeter. It can’t tell 208V from 240V. Klein’s 2021 recall covered NCVT1-family testers, not this one.Check it on Amazon

Step 8 matters most for a new element. A. O. Smith says failing to run water until all the air is out can burn out the upper element. More on the whole job in my element replacement guide and element wrench picks.

Check an element’s resistance with a meter

With power off and the wires removed, a multimeter across the two terminals reads the element’s resistance. Rheem’s TSB 1305 says what each size should read.

ReadingA 240V element ofA 208V element of
About 16.5 ohms3500WNot listed (about 2630W on 208V)
About 14.4 ohms4000W3000W
About 12.8 ohms4500WNot listed (about 3380W on 208V)
About 12.4 ohmsNot listed3500W
About 10.8 ohmsNot listed4000W
About 10.5 ohms5500WNot listed (about 4130W on 208V)
About 9.6 ohms6000W4500W

From Rheem TSB 1305’s voltage, amps and ohms table, read Oct 20, 2026. Where a resistance has no rating at one voltage, the wattage in parentheses is from TSB 1317.

A. O. Smith’s guide says a good element in its heaters reads between 5 and 25 ohms. That range doesn’t fit every element: Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 28.8 ohms for a 208V, 1500W element. Compare your reading with the figure for your element and follow your maker’s test steps.

Within range, the number narrows down the part, but it can’t prove the voltage: 9.6 ohms is both a 208V, 4500W and a 240V, 6000W element.

Use it to catch a wrong part. A 4500W element for a 240V heater should read near 12.8 ohms. One that reads 9.6 would make about 6000W on 240V.

A normal reading across the terminals doesn’t rule out a grounded element. A. O. Smith’s heat pump service handbook checks each terminal against the element flange or tank shell; any reading short of infinite means replace it.

Two readings show up in both columns. A 14.4 ohm element is a 4000W part at 240V or a 3000W part at 208V; check the label and the plate to know which job it’s doing.

Mistakes with 208V and 240V elements

Six ways an element swap goes wrong, and what the makers say to do instead.

A 208V element in a 240V heater

Bradford White’s 208V, 4500W copper element is its 240V, 6000W part. In a 4500W, 240V heater it makes 6000W and draws 25.0 amps instead of 18.8, more than the plate allows.

A bigger element for faster recovery

A. O. Smith says no greater wattage than the rating plate. A bigger element runs the heater past its approved wattage and draws more current. Whether the circuit can carry it is for an electrician to check.

Blaming the element for slow recovery on 208V

A 240V element on 208V makes 75% of its rating by design. A. O. Smith lists low supply voltage as a cause of not enough hot water, along with a bad lower element. Test before you replace.

Power on before the tank is full

A. O. Smith says to run a hot faucet at full flow for at least three minutes first, or the upper element can burn out.

Assuming any 240V appliance runs on 208V

A. O. Smith’s April 2012 Voltex manual says “DO NOT use 208 VAC,” while its 2026 catalog lists newer Voltex units as 208/240 capable. Check the manual for your exact model.

Skipping the voltage check

A. O. Smith’s steps call for a non-contact tester on the power wires before you touch them, even with the breaker off.

Questions people ask

Will a 240V heating element work on 208V?

Yes, at about 75% of its rated watts. Rheem’s TSB 1317 lists a 4500W element at 3380W on 208V and a 5500W element at 4130W. The tank still gets hot; it recovers more slowly.

Can a 240V water heater run on 208V?

Rheem says its residential electric heaters are dual rated for 240V and 208V, with both ratings on the label. That doesn’t cover 120V point-of-use heaters or units built for 208V only, and A. O. Smith’s April 2012 Voltex heat pump manual says not to use 208V.

What does a 4500W element put out on 208V?

About 3380W, per Rheem’s TSB 1317 and the Rheem SP10869MM listing. At a 90°F rise that’s about 16 gallons an hour of recovery instead of 21.

Can I put a 208V element in a 240V water heater?

Not unless the plate lists it. Bradford White’s 208V, 4500W copper element is the same part as its 240V, 6000W element, so in a 4500W, 240V heater it makes 6000W and draws 25.0 amps instead of 18.8. An element rated only for 208V can burn out on 240V, per Rheem’s TSB 1306.

Are 208V and 240V elements interchangeable?

Not freely. A 240V element on 208V runs at a lower output, which dual-rated heaters allow. A 208V element on 240V makes more than its 208V wattage, which can exceed what the heater is approved for. Match the rating plate.

Are water heaters 208V?

Some are. A. O. Smith offers its residential electric heaters with 208V inputs, and Rheem’s residential tanks are dual rated. The rating plate says which voltage and wattage yours is built for.

Do I need a bigger breaker for 208V?

Not for a 240V heater on a correctly sized circuit running at 208V; the element draws less current. A heater built for 208V at 4500W pulls 21.6 amps and Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists a 30 amp breaker for it. Wiring changes belong to an electrician.

How can I tell if my element is 208V or 240V?

Read its label and match it to the plate. A meter helps but can’t settle it alone: Rheem’s TSB 1305 lists 12.8 ohms for a 4500W, 240V element, and 9.6 ohms for both a 4500W, 208V element and a 6000W, 240V element.

Why is my water heater slow to recover on 208V?

A 240V element on 208V makes about a quarter less heat. A. O. Smith lists low supply voltage as a cause of not enough hot water. Check that the element reads in its normal range before replacing it.

Does a 240V element last longer on 208V?

None of the makers’ documents I read says so. Rheem’s listing for the SP10869PH shows its watt density dropping from 113 to 85 watts per square inch on 208V, so the sheath puts out less heat per square inch.

How I picked them

Why trust me

Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia (license #JP507711), owns PlumbingPicks and is responsible for this page. Ratings, amps, ohms and part numbers here come from Rheem’s technical service bulletins, A. O. Smith’s manuals and spec sheets, Bradford White’s parts list and the makers’ Amazon listings, named below. Numbers I worked out myself are marked as my math.

How I pick

  • One element per common rating plate: 4500W, 5500W, 4500W with dry-fire resistance, and a non-Rheem 4500W for hard water.
  • Each pick is a genuine branded 240V screw-in element whose listing matches the maker’s rating. Three list their 208V output; for the Camco I calculated it with Rheem’s TSB 1306 formula.
  • New and in stock, sold by Amazon.com, checked on Amazon on Oct 20, 2026 at 09:14 EDT. Rechecked Oct 22, 2026 at 02:06 EDT: three still sold by Amazon.com, and the SP10869PH back-ordered, so its card stays with the price hidden.
  • Left out: a Rheem 4500W listing whose title and features disagreed on watt density, a Rheem 208V element that showed low stock on Oct 20, and generic 208V elements with no maker documents.
  • The spec score checks whether the 208V wattage is printed, the sheath metal, the watt density and a dry fire resistant build. The right wattage is still the one your plate lists.
  • CPSC recalls searched for water heater elements, heating elements, Rheem, Camco, Reliance, Eastman, voltage testers and Klein since 2018: none for these products.

The spec score, check by check

All four elements are 240V screw-in elements, so they get the same four checks from the Rheem and Camco listings and Rheem’s bulletins, averaged to one decimal. Every pick has to reach 7.0.

The score doesn’t override your rating plate. Buy the wattage the plate lists first. Among elements with that rating, the score shows which one prints its 208V output and resists lime and dry firing.

Check (weight)How it’s scored
208V output printed (¼)10 = the maker or listing prints the element’s wattage on 208V; 7 = not printed, worked out with Rheem’s TSB 1306 formula
Sheath (¼)10 = stainless steel; 8 = plated copper
Watt density (¼)10 = low watt density (LWD); 8 = medium (MWD)
Dry fire build (¼)10 = listed as dry fire resistant; 8 = not listed, so the tank must be full before power, as with any element
TotalAverage of the checks, to one decimal
Pick208V output printedSheathWatt densityDry fire buildScore
Rheem SP10869MM, 4500W10101089.5
Rheem SP10869PH, 5500W1010889.0
Rheem SP17618AM, 4500W1010101010
Camco 02583, 4500W781088.3

Sources

Related guides