How to replace a water heater thermostat

Test it, match it and swap it on an electric tank.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns

Updated November 15, 2026

About Isaac · How I chose

Rheem upper water heater thermostat

SHORT ANSWER

Test it first, then match the old one by spot (upper, lower or single) and style (Therm-O-Disc or Apcom). Power off, prove it dead, swap, set 120°F. For a Therm-O-Disc upper, I pick the Rheem UV11699; Apcom tanks take the Camco picks.

Rheem UV11699 upper water heater thermostat with red reset button
Best for a Therm-O-Disc upper$25.65 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Check it on Amazon
On this page
  1. 1The picks
  2. 2Which one you need
  3. 3Rheem UV11699
  4. 4Rheem SP8295
  5. 5Camco 07723
  6. 6Camco 07843
  7. 7Klein MM325
  8. 8Klein NCVT3P
  9. 9Compare the picks
  10. 10How to test it
  11. 11How to replace it
  12. 12What each screw does
  13. 13Signs it’s bad
  14. 14What to set it to
  15. 15Where sources disagree
  16. 16Gas water heaters
  17. 17When to call a pro
  18. 18How to choose
  19. 19Questions
  20. 20How I picked

Four thermostats and two testers

Ranges and part numbers come from Rheem’s and Camco’s own documents. Match the position and thermostat style before ordering.

Rheem UV11699 upper water heater thermostat with red reset button
Best for a Therm-O-Disc upper

Rheem UV11699

$25.65 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Rheem SP8295 lower water heater thermostat, Therm-O-Disc 59T
Best for a Therm-O-Disc lower

Rheem SP8295

$14.99 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Camco 07723 Apcom style lower water heater thermostat
Best for an Apcom-style lower

Camco 07723

$15.00 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Camco 07843 single element water heater thermostat with terminal cover
Best for a single-element tank

Camco 07843

$14.89 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST · low stock then
Klein Tools MM325 digital multimeter
Best for testing at the terminals

Klein MM325

$34.97 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Klein Tools NCVT3P non-contact voltage tester pen
Best for a first check on the wires

Klein NCVT3P

$29.97 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
ToolKey specsPick it ifSkip it if
Rheem UV11699Upper, Therm-O-Disc 59T/66T, 90–150°F ±5, High limit 170°F ±5, DPST limit, Differential 5–15°FYour tank’s upper thermostat has a degree dial and a red reset button, and the test points to the upper: no voltage past the limit, or no voltage at the upper element.Your upper has a letter dial. That’s Apcom style; Camco’s 07863 is the match. If it’s a single-element tank, see the Camco 07843.
Rheem SP8295Lower, Therm-O-Disc 59T, 110–170°F, SPST, No high limit, Differential 5–15°FYour lower thermostat has a degree dial and no reset button, and the step 4 test shows the lower is the one that failed.Your lower has a letter dial (Apcom style). The Camco 07723 is the match. If your lower has its own reset, match that combination part instead.
Camco 07723Lower, Apcom style, WH9, Dot to Very Hot, 110–160°F, Preset 120°F, Terminal protectorYour lower thermostat has a letter dial and an Apcom stamp, and the test shows the lower is bad.Your lower has a degree dial and a 59T stamp. Use the Rheem SP8295.
Camco 07843Single element, Apcom style, WH9, High limit, 110–160°F, Preset 120°F, 240/208/120 VYour tank has one element and one thermostat with a reset button and a letter dial. Count the panels: one panel means one element.Your tank has an upper and a lower panel. Upper and lower parts are different; start with the Rheem UV11699 or Camco 07723.
Klein MM325600 V AC/DC, CAT III 600 V, 2 MΩ ohms, Continuity, 2 m drop, 2 × AAAYou’re going to run Bradford White’s tests or prove the power is off at the top two screws, as Rheem’s bulletin says.You already own a meter rated CAT III 600 V or better. Use it.
Klein NCVT3P12–1000 V AC, 70–1000 V AC, CAT IV 1000 V, IP67, Flashlight, 2 × AAAYou want a fast check on the cable and junction box before you open the panel, and a light to see the terminals.You’d use it as your only proof the power is off. Klein’s own manual says not to; pair it with the MM325.

Which thermostat your tank takes

Two questions decide the part: where it sits on the tank, and which style it is.

Therm-O-Disc style (59T): degree dial Apcom style: letter dial (Dot to Very Hot) Upper Red reset button on top; feeds the upper element Rheem UV11699, 90–150°F Camco 07863 (WH10A) Lower No reset button; feeds the lower element Rheem SP8295, 110–170°F Camco 07723 (WH9) Single element One thermostat with a reset; one element in the tank Camco 08143 Camco 07843 (WH9) Picked on this page Upper Red reset button on top; feeds the upper element Therm-O-Disc Rheem UV11699, 90–150°F Apcom Camco 07863 (WH10A) Lower No reset button; feeds the lower element Therm-O-Disc Rheem SP8295, 110–170°F Apcom Camco 07723 (WH9) Single element One thermostat with a reset; one element in the tank Therm-O-Disc Camco 08143 Apcom Camco 07843 (WH9) Picked on this page
Replacement by position and style. Sources: Rheem part pages for UV11699 and SP8295; Rheem bulletin 1311; Camco Plumbing & Hardware catalog (Apcom and Therm-O-Disc part lists and the letter-dial chart).
Upper thermostat

Top access panel. It has the red reset button, called the ECO (energy cut off), and it feeds the upper element and then the lower thermostat.

Lower thermostat

Bottom access panel. On most two-element tanks it has no reset, and it runs only when the upper hands it power.

Single-element thermostat

One panel, one element. It carries its own reset, and Camco says upper and lower parts won’t work in its place.

Therm-O-Disc or Apcom

A degree dial and a 59T stamp mean Therm-O-Disc. A letter dial (Dot, Hot, A, B, C, Very Hot) means Apcom.

Rheem’s replacement bulletin starts with one rule: buy “the same identical thermostat type” as the one on the water heater, and don’t assume the upper and lower are the same part. They almost never are.

Take a phone photo of the old thermostat before you shop. The model stamp, the dial and the number of screws on top tell you everything the chart needs.

Rheem UV11699, a Therm-O-Disc upper

Each thermostat fits one tank style and position, and the two testers do different jobs, so they’re matched to the job, with no score.

Rheem UV11699 upper water heater thermostat with red reset button
Rheem UV11699 upper thermostat with high limit (ECO), Therm-O-Disc 59T/66T style. Product photo: Amazon.

The UV11699 is Rheem’s own upper thermostat for its electric water heaters, built to the Therm-O-Disc 59T/66T pattern. Rheem’s parts site lists it as replacing UV1169912PK and as part of kit AP11699-5. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21.

It’s two devices in one body. The top half is the high limit, the ECO with the red reset. Rheem rates it at 170°F, plus or minus 5, with a manual reset. The bottom half is the thermostat, adjustable from 90 to 150°F.

The high limit is double-pole (DPST). On a 240 V tank, that means it opens both hot legs when it trips, so nothing past it stays live. Rheem sells a single-pole version as the UV11700. Match the one your heater’s parts list or old label calls for.

Where it does well

  • Thermostat and red-reset high limit in one part
  • Double-pole limit cuts both 240 V legs
  • Range 90 to 150°F, per Rheem
  • Replaces Rheem UV1169912PK
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • One-year limited warranty from purchase
  • Listing bullet says it replaces Apcom style; Rheem lists Therm-O-Disc
  • Upper only; won’t work in a lower slot
  • Single-pole-limit tanks need the UV11700

Rheem’s bulletin 1302 shows how the upper runs the tank. When the top of the tank is cold, contacts 1 and 2 close and feed the upper element. When the top is hot, the disc flips, contacts 1 and 4 close, and power goes on to the lower thermostat.

That handoff is why a bad upper can look like a bad lower. If it never flips, the lower never gets power, and you get a small amount of hot water from the top of the tank only. The test steps further down sort out which one has failed.

The differential is 5 to 15°F, per Rheem. That’s how far the water cools before the thermostat turns the element back on. Rheem recommends a setting that keeps water at 120°F or less.

One listing detail is wrong. An Amazon bullet says it replaces Apcom-style thermostats. Rheem’s own part page lists Therm-O-Disc 59T/66T. Go by Rheem, and by the dial on your old part: degrees, not letters.

I’ve used this thermostat. My call: on a tank with a Therm-O-Disc upper, and a Rheem tank most of all, this is the part to buy. It’s Rheem’s own number, made to its own bracket.

Rheem SP8295, a Therm-O-Disc lower

Rheem SP8295 lower water heater thermostat, Therm-O-Disc 59T
Rheem SP8295 lower thermostat, Therm-O-Disc 59T style, no high limit. Product photo: Amazon.

The SP8295 is Rheem’s lower thermostat in the Therm-O-Disc 59T pattern. Rheem’s parts site lists it as replacing AP8295-4, AP8295-5 and AP8295-6. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21, and the product photo shows the Therm-O-Disc and 59T stamps.

It’s a plain single-pole thermostat with no high limit on it. Rheem rates its dial from 110 to 170°F with a 5 to 15°F differential. On most two-element tanks, that’s all the lower needs, because the upper’s ECO already guards the whole tank.

Some tanks are different. Rheem’s wiring bulletin 1312 shows simultaneous-operation tanks where the lower has its own high limit, and Bradford White’s test procedure says to check the lower’s limit if it has one. If your lower has a red reset, this isn’t your part.

Where it does well

  • Rheem’s own lower thermostat
  • Range 110 to 170°F, per Rheem
  • Replaces Rheem AP8295-4, -5 and -6
  • Photo shows the Therm-O-Disc 59T stamp
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • No high limit; only for tanks whose lower has no reset
  • Dial goes past the 120°F Rheem recommends
  • Lower only; not an upper or single-element part
  • Check your old lower has no reset first

Rheem’s bulletin 1315 explains what the lower does. Once the upper is satisfied, it hands power down, and the lower heats roughly the bottom two-thirds of the tank. Camco’s catalog says the lower element does 90% or more of the heating in normal use.

So a dead lower usually shows up as a short supply of hot water, not none at all. The upper still heats the top of the tank. You get a shower’s worth, then it goes cold.

The 170°F top of the dial is far above where Rheem says to run it. Rheem recommends 120°F at most, and Bradford White warns that water over 125°F can scald in an instant. Set it to match the upper, and no higher than you need.

Fit matters more than the number. Rheem’s bulletin 1311 says the back of a new thermostat must press tightly against the tank, because it senses temperature through the steel. A loose one can’t sense the water properly.

I’ve used this thermostat. My call: when the test points to a Therm-O-Disc lower, buy Rheem’s own number and set it to match the upper.

Camco 07723, an Apcom-style lower

Camco 07723 Apcom style lower water heater thermostat
Camco 07723 lower thermostat, Apcom style (WH9). Product photo: Amazon.

The 07723 is Camco’s lower thermostat in the Apcom style, model WH9 in Camco’s catalog. Camco makes water heater repair parts that fit many brands. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21, carded with instructions and wiring diagrams, per Camco.

Apcom style is the other common thermostat pattern. You spot it by the dial. Instead of degrees, it reads Dot, Hot, A, B, C and Very Hot, and the photo on this listing shows the Apcom name on the body.

Camco’s catalog translates the letters: Dot is 110°F, Hot 120°F, A 130°F, B 140°F, C 150°F and Very Hot 160°F. It ships set at Hot, 120°F. Leave it there unless you have a reason not to.

Where it does well

  • Apcom-style lower, the letter-dial kind
  • Rated for 240, 208 and 120 V, per Camco
  • Plastic terminal protector included
  • Camco says it fits the original lengths for 14 brands
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • Letter dial, not degrees; see the chart below
  • No high limit
  • Camco’s catalog I read dates from 2013
  • Lower only

Camco rates it for 240, 208 and 120 V tanks and says it’s UL listed. It lists the original-length fit for American, A. O. Smith, Bradford White, GE, GSW, Kenmore, Maytag, Reliance, Rheem, Richmond, Ruud, Sears, State and Whirlpool tanks. Check the dial on your old part either way.

It comes with a plastic terminal protector. Camco’s catalog says every thermostat should have one in place before the cover goes back on, and Rheem’s bulletin 1311 has the same step. Don’t throw it in the trash with the packaging.

Camco also tells you which dial to turn. On a two-element tank, it says not to adjust the upper. If you want hotter water, raise the lower. Turn both down if you want it cooler.

The catalog I could find from Camco is its 2013 Plumbing & Hardware book. The Amazon title still matches it: Camco 07723, WH9, lower, Apcom style. If the box in your hand says anything else, check it against your old part before wiring.

I’ve used this thermostat. My call: for a letter-dial lower, this is the straight swap, with the cover you’ll need included.

Camco 07843, for single-element tanks

Camco 07843 single element water heater thermostat with terminal cover
Camco 07843 single element combination thermostat, Apcom style (WH9). Product photo: Amazon.

The 07843 is Camco’s single-element combination thermostat in the Apcom style. “Combination” means the thermostat and the high limit share one body, with a reset button on the limit. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21.

It’s for tanks with one element. Camco’s catalog is blunt about it: the upper and lower thermostats from a two-element heater can’t be used on a single-element heater, and a single-element thermostat can’t go on a two-element tank.

The listing gives a range of 110 to 160°F with a factory preset of 120°F. That matches Camco’s letter chart: Dot is 110°F and Very Hot is 160°F. The listing also says it has a built-in safety switch, which is the high limit.

Where it does well

  • Thermostat and high limit in one part
  • For tanks with one element and one thermostat
  • Range 110 to 160°F, preset 120°F
  • Terminal protector in the photo and Camco’s list
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • Apcom style only
  • Won’t work on a two-element tank
  • Camco’s catalog I read dates from 2013
  • Amazon lists the brand line as “Unknown”

Camco lists it for 240, 208 and 120 V. Rheem’s wiring bulletin shows how a single-element tank is wired: one thermostat with its limit, one element, and on a 120 V tank just two wires from the junction box.

The photo shows the clear terminal protector next to the thermostat. Camco says every thermostat should have its protector in place before the cover plate goes back on. It keeps a finger, or the insulation, off the live screws.

The listing’s brand line reads “Camco Unknown”, which looks odd. The model, 07843, and the description match Camco’s catalog for the single-element Apcom thermostat. That’s the part number to check on the card.

If your single-element tank has a degree dial instead, Camco’s Therm-O-Disc version is the 08143. It’s on the match chart above, though it isn’t one of the picks here.

I’ve used this thermostat. My call: for a small single-element tank with a letter dial, this is the part. Count the elements before you buy.

Klein MM325, for testing the terminals

Klein Tools MM325 digital multimeter
Klein Tools MM325 digital multimeter, manual-ranging, 600 V. Product photo: Amazon.

The MM325 is Klein Tools’ manual-ranging digital multimeter, the newer model of its MM300. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21. Klein rates it for 600 V AC and DC, 10 A DC and 2 MΩ, with continuity, diode and battery tests.

Every thermostat test in this guide is a meter test. Bradford White’s procedure measures voltage across terminals with the power on. Rheem’s replacement bulletin says to prove the power is off with a voltmeter at the top two screws before you touch anything.

The safety rating is CAT III 600 V, per Klein. That’s the category for building wiring like a water heater circuit, and 240 V is well inside it. The leads come with CAT III and CAT IV safety caps.

Where it does well

  • CAT III 600 V rating, per Klein
  • Reads AC volts for the live tests
  • Ohms and continuity for elements and switches
  • Lead Alert lights show where the leads go
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • Manual-ranging: you pick the range by hand
  • DC current only, no AC amps
  • 2000-count display
  • Not a clamp meter

Manual-ranging means you turn the dial to a range yourself. For these tests, set an AC volts range above 240 V. Bradford White’s sheet says “300 volts scale”; on the MM325, pick the AC volts range that sits above 240 V.

Klein’s Lead Alert lights show which jacks the leads belong in for the setting you chose. It’s a small feature, and a lead left in the amps jack on a live circuit can blow the meter’s fuse.

It also checks elements. With the power and wires off, a 4500 W, 240 V element works out to about 12.8 ohms across its two screws (240 × 240 ÷ 4500). If an element is bad, a new thermostat won’t fix the tank.

Klein says it’s built to survive a 2 m drop, runs on two AAA batteries and has a backlit display. That last one helps inside a dark water heater closet. Voltage accuracy is ±2%, which is plenty for a pass-or-fail test.

I’ve used this meter. My call: if you’re testing a water heater, this is the one tool you can’t skip. Every step in Bradford White’s procedure needs it.

Klein NCVT3P, a first check on wires

Klein Tools NCVT3P non-contact voltage tester pen
Klein Tools NCVT3P dual-range non-contact voltage tester with flashlight. Product photo: Amazon.

The NCVT3P is Klein Tools’ dual-range non-contact voltage tester with a flashlight in the other end. It was new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my 5:25 PM check on Oct 21. Klein’s manual rates it CAT IV 1000 V, IP67 and drop-tested to 2 m.

You hold the tip near a wire and it beeps and flashes red if it senses AC voltage. Mode 1 covers 70 to 1000 V, and mode 2 picks up from 12 V. For a 240 V water heater, mode 1 keeps it from chirping at every low-voltage line nearby.

Klein’s manual is honest about its limits, and you should be too. It says that if there’s no indication, “voltage could still be present.” It won’t detect DC or shielded wire, and it may miss voltage through a glove or metal conduit.

Where it does well

  • CAT IV 1000 V rating, per Klein’s manual
  • Two ranges: 12–1000 V and 70–1000 V AC
  • Built-in flashlight for dark closets
  • IP67 and 2 m drop rating
  • Sold by Amazon.com

What to watch

  • Klein says no beep doesn’t prove it’s dead
  • Won’t detect DC or shielded wire
  • Not a replacement for the meter
  • Must be tested on a live circuit first

That’s why it’s the first check, not the last one. Test it on a known live outlet, check the cable at the water heater, then open the panel and prove it dead with the meter at the top two thermostat screws, as Rheem’s bulletin says.

The flashlight earns its place. Water heaters live in closets, attics and garages, and the thermostat sits behind a small panel and insulation. Klein says the light works on its own, without the voltage sensor on.

Klein also warns never to assume a neutral or ground is dead. Rheem’s 240 V wiring diagrams show two hot legs and a ground, with no neutral, so both wires on the thermostat carry voltage. Treat every screw as live until the meter says otherwise.

Klein’s other non-contact tester, the NCVT-1, had a recall in 2021 for a sticky power button. That recall named only the NCVT-1 with certain date codes, not this NCVT3P, per the CPSC notice.

I’ve used this tester. My call: keep it in your pocket for the first sweep, and keep the meter for the proof.

The six picks compared

Ranges and ratings from Rheem, Camco and Klein. Scroll sideways on a phone.

PickJobStyleRange or ratingHigh limitSold by
Rheem UV11699Upper, two-element tankTherm-O-Disc 59T/66T90–150°FYes, 170°F, double-poleAmazon.com
Rheem SP8295Lower, two-element tankTherm-O-Disc 59T110–170°FNoAmazon.com
Camco 07723Lower, two-element tankApcom, WH9110–160°F (letters)NoAmazon.com
Camco 07843Single-element tankApcom, WH9110–160°F (letters)YesAmazon.com
Klein MM325Prove dead; run the testsMultimeter600 V, CAT IIIn/aAmazon.com
Klein NCVT3PFirst check on wiresNon-contact12–1000 V AC, CAT IVn/aAmazon.com

How to test a water heater thermostat

Bradford White’s procedure, in order. Run it before you buy anything.

These tests are done with 240 V on

Bradford White’s steps measure live terminals. Rheem says if you aren’t comfortable working with electricity, call a professional. Insulated leads, one hand, nothing touching the tank.

1. Reset and high limit Press the red reset. Meter 1L–3L, then 2L–4L: both read the rating-plate voltage. Pass: go to step 2 No voltage at 2L–4L with water at 120°F or less: replace the upper 2. Upper thermostat Upper dial to highest. With the tank 30°F under that, the upper element gets line voltage. Pass: go to step 3 No voltage at the element: replace the upper 3. Lower handoff Upper dial lowest, lower dial highest. Listen for the click, then check the lower element. Voltage there: both work No voltage: run the last test 4. Which one failed Power off, pull the lower thermostat off the tank to cool, power on, meter 1T–2T. No reading: replace the upper Reads line voltage: replace the lower 1. Reset and high limit Press the red reset. Meter 1L–3L, then 2L–4L: both read the rating-plate voltage. Pass: go to step 2 No voltage at 2L–4L with water at 120°F or less: replace the upper 2. Upper thermostat Upper dial to highest. With the tank 30°F under that, the upper element gets line voltage. Pass: go to step 3 No voltage at the element: replace the upper 3. Lower handoff Upper dial lowest, lower dial highest. Listen for the click, then check the lower element. Voltage there: both work No voltage: run the last test 4. Which one failed Power off, pull the lower thermostat off the tank to cool, power on, meter 1T–2T. No reading: replace the upper Reads line voltage: replace the lower
Test order. Source: Bradford White, Electric Thermostat Test Procedure (high limit, upper and lower tests); Rheem bulletin 1302 (ECO and how the upper hands power to the lower).

Check the elements first. Bradford White’s upper test starts with “be certain that the heating elements are functioning properly.” A burned-out element and a bad thermostat give the same cold shower. My element replacement guide covers that test.

  1. 1
    Press the red reset

    Switch off the breaker and verify absence of voltage at the terminals with a properly rated meter before accessing the controls. Following the tank manufacturer’s reset procedure, press the red button on the upper thermostat. Bradford White says that if it snaps back out, the water is hotter than the limit; wait until it’s 120°F or below and try again.

  2. 2
    Check the high limit

    Meter on an AC range over 240 V. Probes on 1L and 3L should read the voltage on the rating plate. If not, look for a tripped breaker, a blown fuse or a loose wire.

  3. 3
    Check the limit passes power

    Probes on 2L and 4L should read the same voltage. If they don’t and the water is 120°F or less, the limit is bad. On most tanks it’s part of the upper thermostat, so replace the upper.

  4. 4
    Test the upper

    Turn the upper dial to its highest setting. If the tank is at least 30°F below that, the upper element’s screws should read line voltage. None means the upper thermostat isn’t switching.

  5. 5
    Test the handoff

    Turn the upper to lowest and the lower to highest. Listen for a click as the upper hands power down. Voltage at the lower element’s screws means both thermostats work.

  6. 6
    Find the bad one

    No voltage? Power off, pull the lower thermostat away from the tank so it cools, power on and meter 1T to 2T. A reading means the lower is bad. No reading means the upper is bad.

Terminal names are Bradford White’s: 1L to 4L on the limit, 1T and 2T on the lower thermostat. Rheem’s bulletins number the same screws 1 to 4. Your tank’s wiring diagram, on the inside of the panel or in the manual, is the final word.

How to replace it, step by step

Rheem’s bulletin 1311, the same for an upper or a lower. Plan on one access panel at a time.

  1. 1
    Match the part

    Same position and style as the old one. Rheem warns that upper thermostats are usually not the same as lowers.

  2. 2
    Turn the breaker off

    The water heater’s breaker at the panel. On a 240 V tank it’s a two-pole breaker.

  3. 3
    Open the panel

    Take off the cover, fold back the insulation and remove the plastic terminal cover.

  4. 4
    Prove it’s dead

    Meter on the top two screws of the thermostat. Rheem says there should be no voltage. Check the meter on a live outlet before and after.

  5. 5
    Tag the wires

    A piece of tape and a number on each wire, or a phone photo. Rheem says to tag them before you loosen a screw.

  6. 6
    Lift it out of the bracket

    Gently. Rheem says a broken retaining bracket means replacing the whole water heater.

  7. 7
    Seat the new one

    Its back must press tightly against the tank. That’s how it senses the water temperature.

  8. 8
    Wire it back

    Per your tags or the diagram for your tank. Rheem says double-check every screw is firm and tight.

  9. 9
    Cover the terminals

    Put the plastic protector back on. Camco says every thermostat needs one before the cover plate goes back.

  10. 10
    Power on and set it

    Set it so the water doesn’t go over 120°F, per Rheem. Then cycle test: run hot water and listen for it to start heating.

  11. 11
    Close it up

    Insulation back in place, then the cover panel.

Never power an empty tank

Rheem: never turn on power unless the tank is full of water and air has been purged from a hot faucet. Camco says an element that isn’t surrounded by water burns out, and no warranty covers it.

You don’t have to drain the tank for a thermostat. It sits on the outside of the steel, under the insulation, so the water stays in. That’s the big difference from an element swap.

Do one panel at a time, and don’t move any wires you don’t have to. Rheem’s bulletin covers both upper and lower with the same 12 steps.

What each screw on the thermostat does

From Rheem’s bulletins 1302 and 1312 for a typical two-element, non-simultaneous tank. Wire colors vary by maker.

PartScrewsWhat happens there
Upper high limit (ECO)1 and 3 in, 2 and 4 outBoth 240 V legs pass through it. When it trips, the red reset pops and power stops.
Upper thermostat, calling for heat1 to 2Closed while the top of the tank is cold. Feeds the upper element.
Upper thermostat, satisfied1 to 4Closed once the top is hot. Sends power down to the lower thermostat.
Lower thermostat1 to 2 (Bradford White: 1T, 2T)Closed while the bottom is cold. Feeds the lower element.
Single-element thermostatLimit on top, thermostat belowOne limit and one switch for the only element. 120 V tanks use just two wires.

Non-simultaneous means only one element heats at a time. That’s how most home tanks are wired, per Rheem and Camco. Simultaneous tanks let both elements run at once for faster recovery, and Rheem’s wiring diagrams show some of those with a high limit on the lower too.

If your tank’s diagram doesn’t match this table, follow the diagram.

Signs of a bad water heater thermostat

What you notice, what it usually points to, and the test that proves it.

What you noticeLikely causeProve it with
No hot water at allECO tripped, upper thermostat or upper elementReset, then steps 1 to 4
A little hot water, then coldLower element or lower thermostat, or the upper not handing offSteps 3 and 4, then the element test
Red reset keeps trippingA thermostat that won’t open, or one not tight against the tankRheem says call a professional
Water too hotSetting too high, or a thermostat that won’t openCheck the dials; meter the element while the water is hot
Takes far longer to recoverLower element or lower thermostatSteps 3 and 4
Breaker tripsElement or wiring fault; a thermostat only switches powerElement test with power off

Rheem’s bulletin 1302 says it plainly: “If the ECO trips frequently it is an indication of additional problems.” A reset that won’t stay in isn’t fixed by pushing it again. It means something is overheating the tank, and a thermostat that won’t open, or one that isn’t tight against the tank, can do it.

What temperature to set it to

Rheem, Bradford White and Camco all ship at 120°F or recommend it.

Apcom letterTemperatureNote
Dot110°FLowest
Hot120°FFactory preset; Rheem’s and Bradford White’s advice
A130°FOver 125°F can scald, per Bradford White
B140°FScald risk
C150°FScald risk
Very Hot160°FScald risk

The letter chart is Camco’s, for Apcom-style dials. Therm-O-Disc dials print degrees. Bradford White warns that water over 125°F can cause severe burns instantly, and that children, disabled and elderly people are at the highest risk.

If you need hotter water at the tank for a dishwasher or a big tub, a thermostatic mixing valve can deliver safer water at the taps. Bradford White suggests temperature-limiting valves as a precaution.

On a two-element tank, set the upper and lower to the same mark. Camco’s advice is to leave the upper alone and raise the lower for hotter water, because the lower does most of the heating.

Bradford White notes that some states may have laws on the maximum setting. Check with your local authority if you’re setting a tank in a rental or a care home.

Where the makers and listings disagree

Three places the documents don’t match, and which one to follow.

TopicOne source saysThe other saysFollow
Rheem UV11699 styleAmazon bullet: replaces Apcom-style thermostatsRheem part page: Therm-O-Disc 59T/66TRheem, and your old dial
Swapping between stylesCamco: like models of the two makers are interchangeableRheem: use the same identical thermostat typeSame style; it’s the safe call
Which element heats firstRheem 1315: the upper heats first when the tank is coldCamco: the lower does 90% or more of the heatingBoth true: upper first, lower most of the time

The style question is the one that costs a trip. Camco says like models from the two makers can swap. Rheem’s rule is simpler: match what’s there. Same style means the dial reads the same way and the diagram inside your panel still applies.

Gas water heaters are a different job

This guide is for electric tanks. A gas tank’s “thermostat” is the gas control valve.

On a gas water heater, the dial on the front is part of the gas control valve, which also runs the pilot and the burner. It isn’t a clip-on part, and swapping it means opening the gas line. That’s a job for a licensed pro in most places.

If the pilot won’t stay lit, start with my pilot light guide. A. O. Smith owners can read the blink codes in my status light codes guide.

When to stop and call a pro

The reset keeps tripping

Rheem says frequent ECO trips mean another problem. Call your water heater professional.

You aren’t sure the power is off

If the meter reads anything at the top two screws, stop. Rheem says call a professional if you aren’t comfortable with electricity.

The retaining bracket is cracked

Rheem says a broken bracket means replacing the water heater.

Scorched wires or terminals

Burned insulation or a melted terminal cover points to a loose connection. Fix the wiring, not just the thermostat.

The tank is leaking

A wet panel or rusty insulation means the tank may be failing. See my leaking water heater guide.

How to pick the right replacement

QuestionIf yesIf no
Did the tests point to a thermostat?Keep goingTest the elements first
Is it the upper, with a red reset?Upper part: Rheem UV11699 or Camco 07863Keep going
Is it the lower, with no reset?Lower part: Rheem SP8295 or Camco 07723Keep going
Is there only one element in the tank?Single-element part: Camco 07843 or 08143Check the diagram on the panel
Does the dial read degrees?Therm-O-Disc styleLetters mean Apcom style

Should you replace both thermostats at once? Nothing in Rheem’s or Bradford White’s documents says to. Their tests find the one that failed. Swap that one, set both to the same mark, and keep the meter.

Do the elements while you’re there only if they test bad. My guides to 4500 vs 5500 watt elements and 240 V vs 208 V elements cover matching them.

Questions people ask

Can you just replace the thermostat on a water heater?

Yes. On an electric tank, the thermostat clips onto the outside of the tank under the insulation, so you don’t drain it. Rheem’s bulletin covers the swap in 12 steps: power off, prove it dead, tag the wires, swap, cover, power on, set 120°F.

How do you know if a water heater thermostat is bad?

Test it. Bradford White’s procedure checks the high limit, then the upper, then the lower, with a meter on the terminals. No voltage where there should be, with the water cool enough, means that thermostat isn’t switching.

How do you test a water heater thermostat with a multimeter?

Set the meter to an AC range above 240 V. With power on, read 1L to 3L and 2L to 4L on the limit, then the element screws with the dial turned up. The full order is in the test section above.

What are the first signs of a bad thermostat?

No hot water, a short supply that runs cold fast, water that’s too hot, or a red reset that keeps tripping. Each one has a test that tells you which part to buy.

How much does it cost to replace a water heater thermostat?

The part prices on this page come live from Amazon. Most of the job is labor and the test, which takes a meter. A pro’s rate depends on where you live, so I don’t quote one.

How long do water heater thermostats last?

None of the maker documents I read gives a lifespan. Rheem’s part warranty for the UV11699 is one year from purchase. Test before you replace, rather than going by age.

Where is the thermostat on an electric water heater?

Behind the access panels on the side of the tank. A two-element tank has an upper panel and a lower panel, each with a thermostat above its element. Fold back the insulation to see it.

Do I need to replace both thermostats?

No. Bradford White’s test tells you which one failed. Replace that one and set both to the same mark.

Which element heats first in a water heater?

On a cold tank, the upper. Rheem’s bulletin 1315 says the upper thermostat controls the tank and heats the top first, then hands power to the lower, which heats about the bottom two-thirds.

How do I reset a water heater thermostat?

Power off, open the upper panel and press the red reset button until it clicks. Bradford White says it only resets once the water is 120°F or below. If it trips again, call a pro.

Are all water heater thermostats the same?

No. There are uppers, lowers and single-element thermostats, in Therm-O-Disc and Apcom styles. Rheem says to buy the same identical type as the one on your tank.

Can I use an upper thermostat in the lower position?

No. Camco says upper and lower thermostats perform different functions and can’t be swapped. The upper has the high limit and the handoff contacts; the lower doesn’t.

How I picked them

Why trust me

Written by: Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia (license #JP507711), who has used every thermostat and tester on this page. Procedures come from Rheem’s and Bradford White’s own service documents; part data from Rheem, Camco and Klein; seller and stock from Amazon.

How I picked

  • One part per common position and style, with the rest in the match chart.
  • Only figures the makers publish, read Oct 21, 2026; offers re-read Oct 22.
  • No score on any pick: each thermostat fits one tank style and position, and the testers do different jobs, so fit decides.
  • Links only to listings that were new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com at my check.

Sources

Related guides