Water heater element replacement

Find the failed element, test it and swap it the way A. O. Smith’s manual says.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

On this page
  1. Tools for the job
  2. Which part failed?
  3. Upper vs lower element
  4. How to test an element
  5. The ECO reset button
  6. How to replace it
  7. Don’t dry-fire it
  8. Leaks after the swap
  9. Buying the right element
  10. Upper and lower parts
  11. Common mistakes
  12. Hard water and lime
  13. Element or new heater?
  14. Safety
  15. FAQ
  16. How I pick

Quick answer

Runs out fast? Usually the lower element. No hot water at all? The upper element or its reset button. A good one reads 5 to 25 ohms; swap a bad one with a 1-1/2 inch socket.

Camco 09951 chrome-plated 1-1/2 inch water heater element socket
Key tool: Camco 09951 element socket$24.98 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Check it on Amazon

Tools for the job

Camco 09951 chrome-plated 1-1/2 inch water heater element socket
Best for taking the element out

Camco 09951 socket

$24.98 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Klein Tools NCVT3P orange and black non-contact voltage tester pen
Best for proving the power is off

Klein NCVT3P tester

$29.97 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Klein Tools MM325 orange digital multimeter with a rotary dial
Best for reading element ohms

Klein MM325 meter

$34.97 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Rheem SP10869MM 4500-watt fold-back screw-in water heater element with a red terminal block
Best for Rheem, Ruud and Richmond tanks

Rheem SP10869MM

$31.35 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Camco 02583 4500-watt fold-back screw-in water heater element
Best for most other brands

Camco 02583

$12.85 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
ToolKey specsPick it ifSkip it if
Camco 09951 element socketChrome-plated steel, fits a standard 1/2 in. drive, made for screw-in hex bushing elementsYou have a 1/2 in. ratchet or breaker bar and want a socket made for the element nut.Your tank uses a bolted flange element. That’s a different part.
Klein NCVT3P testerNon-contact, 12–1000 V or 70–1000 V ranges, LED and beep, built-in flashlightYou want to confirm both power wires are dead before you touch a screw.You already own a working non-contact tester.
Klein MM325 meterManual ranging, 600 V AC/DC, resistance to 2 MΩ, Lead-Alert LEDs, backlightYou need to read the element in ohms, which A. O. Smith’s test calls for.You own any meter that reads resistance.
Rheem SP10869MM240 V 4500 W, stainless, low watt density, 1 in. NPSM screw-in, 13.44 in. longYour data plate says 240 V and 4500 W and the tank is a Rheem family brand.The plate says 5500 W or 208 V. Match the plate.
Camco 02583240 V 4500 W, low watt density, 1 in. NPSM, gasket 06822 included, UL listedYour plate says 240 V and 4500 W and the tank is one of the many brands Camco lists.You want stainless. The Camco sheath is plated copper.

I’ve used each of these. Pick the element by the data plate on the tank, not by the old element. Wattage and voltage are covered in 4500 vs 5500 watt elements and 240V vs 208V elements.

More socket choices, including long-handle wrenches, are in water heater element wrenches.

Which part failed? Check your symptom

Pick what you see. Then, if you’ve metered the element, enter the data plate and the reading.

  1. Test the lower element first. A. O. Smith says it does most of the work, so it usually wears out before the upper one.
  2. If it reads good, suspect the lower thermostat, a thermostat set low, or a mixing valve in the faucet.
  3. Check one more faucet. If only one tap is lukewarm, the problem is that tap, not the heater.

A 4500 W element at 240 V should read about 12.8 ohms. 12.8 ohms is inside A. O. Smith’s 5 to 25 ohm range, so this element tests good. ohms. Enter your reading to check it.

Meter the element with the breaker off and both wires off its screws. The expected value is volts squared divided by watts, the same figures in Rheem’s element bulletin. A. O. Smith treats 5 to 25 ohms as good.

What you seeMost likely part (A. O. Smith’s list)Other causes to rule out
No hot water at allUpper element, tripped ECO, or upper thermostatNo power at the heater; a hot-side leak bigger than the tank can keep up with
Hot water runs out fastLower element, or more rarely the lower thermostatThermostats set low; a mixing valve in the faucet; a melted dip tube; low supply voltage
New heater, never got hotUpper element burned out by a dry fireHot and cold connections swapped; no power
Water far too hot, relief valve dumps hot waterA shorted elementA failed thermostat, or one not tight to the tank
Lukewarm at one faucet onlyNot the heaterA failed mixing valve in that faucet or shower

Why the lower element usually fails first

Most tanks have two elements, each with its own thermostat. On non-simultaneous wiring, only one heats at a time.

Junction box: test both power wires hereUpper thermostat, red ECO reset buttonUpper element: no hot water at allLower thermostatLower element: runs out fastIt does most of the work (A. O. Smith).Drain valve: hose here to empty the tank Junction boxtest both wiresUpper thermostatred ECO buttonUpper elementno hot water at allLower thermostatLower elementruns out fastDrain valvehose hereNot to scale.
Where each part sits on a two-element tank, from A. O. Smith’s electric heater guide. Not to scale.

Cold water enters near the bottom, so the lower element sits in the coldest water and runs the most. A. O. Smith says it plainly: the lower element does most of the work, so it usually wears out before the upper one. When it quits, the top of the tank still heats, so you get a short shower instead of none.

The upper element is different. Bradford White’s thermostat test says the upper thermostat switches power to the lower one once the top of the tank is hot. If the upper element dies, the top never gets hot, the hand-off never happens, and the water goes cold. That’s why no hot water at all points up, not down.

Rheem’s bulletin 1302 names the two setups. Non-simultaneous means only the upper or the lower element heats at one time. Simultaneous means both can heat together, for faster recovery. Bradford White’s parts book lists both versions for its double-element tanks.

How to test a water heater element with a meter

The test takes five minutes, and you don’t drain anything to do it.

  1. 1
    Turn the breaker off

    Use the water heater’s own breaker or pull its fuses. Rheem lists 25 A for a 4500 W heater and 30 A for 5500 W at 240 V.

  2. 2
    Prove the power is off

    Open the junction box on top and hold the tester to both power wires. A. O. Smith says they’re usually black/black or black/red.

  3. 3
    Open the access panel

    Remove the upper or lower panel, fold the insulation back, and unclip the plastic cover. Test the thermostat’s top screws again.

  4. 4
    Take both wires off the element

    A reading with the wires on can show you the rest of the circuit instead of the element.

  5. 5
    Read across the two screws

    Set the meter to ohms and touch one lead to each screw. A good element reads 5 to 25 ohms on A. O. Smith’s guide.

  6. 6
    Compare with the data plate

    Use the table below, or the checker above. OL or a reading near zero means the element is done.

Element on the plateShould read aboutDraws about
3500 W at 240 V16.5 ohms14.6 A
3800 W at 240 V15.2 ohms15.8 A
4500 W at 240 V12.8 ohms18.8 A
5500 W at 240 V10.5 ohms22.9 A
4500 W at 208 V9.6 ohms21.6 A
5500 W at 208 V7.9 ohms26.4 A
1500 W at 120 V9.6 ohms12.5 A

Values from Rheem Technical Service Bulletin 1305, read Oct 22, 2026. A 208 V element is a different part from a 240 V one, even at the same watts.

A meter only reads the coil inside. An element can read good and still leak at its gasket or be caked in lime, so look at it once it’s out. If both elements read good and the water is still cold, move on to the ECO button and the thermostats.

Thermostat tests and parts are in water heater thermostat replacement. A thermostat swap doesn’t need a drained tank; an element swap does.

When the red reset button is the real problem

You hear a click when you press it

The ECO had tripped. A. O. Smith says that usually means an element or thermostat let the tank overheat, so test both.

No click

The ECO wasn’t tripped. A. O. Smith says the upper thermostat is next to check.

It keeps tripping

Leave the power off. A. O. Smith says not to turn it back on until the overheating cause is found and fixed.

The ECO, or energy cut-off, is the red button on the upper thermostat. It shuts off both elements if the water gets too hot. Press it with the power off, the same way you’d test an element, because the screws next to it carry line voltage when the breaker is on.

How to replace a water heater element, step by step

These are A. O. Smith’s steps, in order. Allow about two hours afterward for the tank to heat.

  1. 1
    Power off, then test it

    Breaker off. Open the junction box and confirm both wires are dead with a non-contact tester.

  2. 2
    Cool the water

    Run a hot faucet until the water runs cool. A. O. Smith warns you can be scalded draining a hot tank.

  3. 3
    Drain the tank

    Hose on the drain valve, cold supply off, drain open, and a hot faucet open to let air in. Drain at least below the element.

  4. 4
    Unscrew the old element

    Take the wires off and back it out with an element socket. A. O. Smith says a beveled mechanic’s socket may slip.

  5. 5
    Clean and fit the new one

    Wipe the tank threads, check the plate matches, and put a drop of dish soap on the new gasket so it doesn’t tear.

  6. 6
    Refill before any power

    Close the drain, open the cold supply with a hot faucet open, and let it run full for at least three minutes.

  7. 7
    Check for leaks

    A drip at the element means tighten more. If it won’t stop, drain again and replace the gasket.

  8. 8
    Wires, covers, power

    Tighten both wires, refit the cover, insulation and panel, close the junction box, and turn the breaker on.

The socket size is 1-1/2 inches on standard screw-in elements, and the element threads are 1 inch NPSM with 11-1/2 threads per inch, per Rheem’s listing for the SP10869MM. Turn counterclockwise to remove. The first turn takes real force on an old element, so brace the tank with your other hand.

A. O. Smith’s steps drain the tank for either element. Draining also lets you see how much sediment comes out. If you’re in there anyway, it’s the time to look at the anode too.

Anode steps and sizes are in water heater anode rod replacement.

The three-minute refill that saves the new element

A dry fire is power reaching an element that isn’t under water. The element burns out in seconds. A. O. Smith calls it a common installation mistake, says it almost always explains a burned-out upper element on a new heater, and doesn’t cover it under warranty.

The fix is to bleed every bit of air out first. With a hot faucet open, let the water run full for at least three minutes before the breaker goes on. Sputtering at the faucet means air is still in the tank. Keep it running until the stream is smooth.

MomentWhat to doWhy
Before you drainBreaker off and tapedSomeone flipping it on mid-job burns the element out
While refillingHot faucet open, cold supply onAir leaves through the faucet as the tank fills
Tank seems fullRun hot water full for 3 minutesA. O. Smith’s step to clear the last air from the top
After power onWait about two hours for hot waterA. O. Smith’s typical heat-up time

If the new element leaks

What you seeLikely causeFix
Slow drip at the element threadsGasket not fully seatedTighten a little more with the socket
Drip won’t stop with tighteningGasket pinched, rolled or tornDrain below the element, pull it, fit a new gasket
Water around the gasket, old threads look roughDebris or old gasket stuck in the tank openingClean the threads with a rag before refitting
Water from the top of the tankNot the elementCheck the pipe connections and the relief valve

The gasket is what seals, not the threads. That’s why A. O. Smith calls for a drop of dish soap on the gasket: it helps the rubber turn without tearing as you tighten. Bradford White sells the element gasket on its own (part 223-34019-00), so you don’t need a whole element to fix a torn one.

Water coming from the relief valve pipe is a separate problem. See T&P relief valve replacement.

How to buy the right replacement element

The data plate on the tank decides it. The old element’s stamp can be worn off or wrong.

CheckWhere to find itWhy it matters
VoltageData plate on the tankRheem rates its 240 V 4500 W element at 3,380 W on 208 V, about a quarter less
WattageData plate on the tankRheem sizes the breaker and wire by total watts, so more watts can overload them
Mount styleLook at the old elementMost are 1 in. screw-in; older and some brands use a bolted flange
Length and shapeOld element; tank sizeCamco says its fold-back 02583 needs a tank at least 13 in. across
Watt densityElement boxCamco says low watt density cuts lime buildup in hard water

Bradford White’s parts book lists an Adapt-a-flange kit for tanks that take a flange element when you want to use a screw-in one. That’s a conversion, so match the plate and the kit before you buy.

Replacing both elements at once is your call. If one failed from lime and the other looks the same, swapping both saves draining the tank twice. Element choices by wattage are in 4500 vs 5500 watt elements.

Upper and lower elements are usually the same part

PartUpperLowerSource
Heating element (Bradford White 240 V 4500 W)415-48642-00415-48642-00Listed as qty 2 on its double-element models
Element gasket223-34019-00223-34019-00Same gasket for each element
ThermostatUpper thermostat with ECOLower thermostatDifferent parts (A. O. Smith, Bradford White)

On a standard two-element tank, the two elements match. Bradford White’s parts book gives one element number with a quantity of two. So you can buy one element for either spot, or two if you want to change both.

The thermostats are where people get caught. A. O. Smith notes the upper and lower thermostats are different, and only the upper one carries the red ECO button. If testing points to a thermostat, take a photo of it before you order.

Mistakes that ruin a new element

MistakeWhat happensDo this instead
Power on before the tank is fullThe upper element dry-fires and burns outRun hot water full for 3 minutes first
Buying by the old element’s stampWrong voltage or wattage for the tankRead the data plate on the tank
Thread tape instead of the gasket prepNot in A. O. Smith’s steps; the rubber gasket makes the sealClean threads and a drop of dish soap on the gasket
A beveled mechanic’s socketIt slips and rounds the hexUse an element socket or wrench
Loose wires on the element screwsA poor connection at a 240 V terminalTighten both wires; A. O. Smith says to make sure every connection is tight
Testing with the wires still onThe meter reads the circuit, not the elementTake both wires off before you meter

The dry fire is the big one. It burns out a brand-new element in seconds, and A. O. Smith doesn’t cover it under warranty. Tape the breaker off while you work so nobody turns it on halfway through the refill.

Hard water: replace a limed element, don’t clean it

Lime builds on elements as a crust and as loose sediment in the bottom of the tank. A. O. Smith says that in most cases it’s easier and cheaper to replace a lime-encrusted element than to scrape it. In very hard water, it says to pull and check the elements every time you drain the tank.

A. O. Smith’s schedule is a drain and flush after the first six months, then at least once a year. If the tank won’t drain because sediment has packed the bottom, it says to have a qualified person use a de-liming agent made for drinking water.

Replace the element if

It reads outside 5 to 25 ohms, or it’s caked thick with lime.

Flush the tank too if

You see sand or chips in the drain water, or the lower element keeps failing.

Replace the heater instead if

The tank itself leaks. No element or gasket fixes a rusted-through tank.

Replace the element or the whole water heater?

SituationUsually the better moveWhy
One element tests bad, tank is dryReplace the elementA single part and an hour’s work
Element failed on a new heaterReplace the element, refill properlyA dry fire is a fill problem, not a bad tank
Water leaks from the tank body or bottom seamReplace the heaterThe tank can’t be repaired
Elements keep failing in hard waterReplace the element; flush and consider a softenerLime is the cause, not the heater

If you land on a new heater, start with water heaters. Warranty terms vary by maker and model, so read your data plate’s model number against the maker’s warranty before you buy parts for an almost-new tank.

Safety notes before you start

Never work on it live

Most heaters run on 240 V. A. O. Smith warns an energized circuit can kill. Test both wires every time.

Hot water burns

Run the hot water cool before you open the drain.

After two weeks unused

A. O. Smith warns of hydrogen gas. Run a kitchen hot faucet for a few minutes first, with no flame nearby.

If any of this is past your comfort level, A. O. Smith says to have a qualified person do it. Your local code may also require a licensed electrician or plumber for any wiring changes.

Water heater element questions

Can you replace a water heater element yourself?

Yes, if you can shut off and test a 240 V circuit, drain the tank and use a socket. A. O. Smith’s manual lays out the steps for homeowners and says to call a qualified person if you’re not comfortable.

How do you tell if a water heater element is bad?

Turn the power off, take the wires off the element, and read across its two screws in ohms. A. O. Smith treats 5 to 25 ohms as good. A 4500 W, 240 V element should read about 12.8 ohms.

Which element goes bad first, upper or lower?

Usually the lower. A. O. Smith says it does most of the work, so it wears out first. A dead lower element gives you some hot water; a dead upper element gives you none.

Can I replace a water heater element without draining the tank?

A. O. Smith’s steps drain the tank, and that’s how I’d do it. You need the water below the element at least, and a fresh fill lets you bleed the air before power goes back on.

What size socket is a water heater element?

1-1/2 inches on standard screw-in elements. A. O. Smith says a regular socket may work but is often beveled and can slip, which is why element sockets exist.

How long does a water heater take to heat after a new element?

A. O. Smith says it may take about two hours for the tank to heat up once the power is back on.

Should I replace both elements at the same time?

Not required. If the second one reads 5 to 25 ohms and isn’t caked in lime, it can stay. Swapping both saves a second drain if they’re the same age.

What does a bad water heater element look like?

Often you can’t tell by looking. Heavy lime crust is the sign A. O. Smith names, and it says replacing a limed element beats cleaning it. Otherwise trust the meter: outside 5 to 25 ohms means replace.

Are the upper and lower water heater elements the same?

Usually yes. Bradford White lists one element part number with a quantity of two on its double-element tanks. The thermostats differ, though: only the upper one has the ECO reset button.

How much does it cost to replace a water heater element?

Doing it yourself, you pay for the element and maybe a socket; see today’s prices in the tools above. A plumber adds labor, which varies by area.

How I pick and why you can trust it

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia. I’ve used each tool listed here. The steps follow A. O. Smith’s published manual, and the ohm values come from Rheem’s own bulletin.

How I pick

  • Tools are the ones the maker’s steps call for: a tester, a meter, an element socket and the right element.
  • They’re different kinds of tools, so they aren’t scored against each other.
  • Every tool is new, genuine and sold by Amazon at our read.
  • Specs come from the listings and the makers’ documents.
  • Recalls checked on CPSC: none for these elements, and Klein’s 2021 tester recall covers a different model.
  • Prices come from Amazon’s API with the time they were read.

Sources

  • A. O. Smith, Residential Electric Water Heater Installation Instructions and Use & Care Guide (March 2021): troubleshooting, maintenance, replacing the heating element, read Oct 22, 2026.
  • Rheem, Technical Service Bulletin 1305, Heating Element Properties: voltage, amps and ohms; recovery; circuit breaker, read Oct 22, 2026.
  • Bradford White, Residential Electric Replacement Parts List 238-51382-00 (July 2025) and electric thermostat test instructions, read Oct 22, 2026.
  • Rheem, Technical Service Bulletin 1302, upper and lower thermostat operation (simultaneous and non-simultaneous), read Oct 22, 2026.
  • Klein Tools, NCVT-3P instruction manual and MM325 product page: kleintools.com, read Oct 21–22, 2026.
  • U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, recall search for water heater elements, Camco and Klein Tools; 2021 Klein NCVT-1 recall notice: cpsc.gov, read Oct 22, 2026.
  • Brand-written Amazon listing text for every product named on this page: read through Amazon’s product data, Oct 22, 2026.
  • Google results for “water heater element replacement” and its People also ask questions: seen Oct 22, 2026. Search volumes from Semrush, Oct 22, 2026.

Related guides