Best pipe dope

Three thread sealants scored on their makers’ data sheets: which pipe they’re rated for, pressure, potable water and when you can turn the water on.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns

RectorSeal T Plus 2 pipe thread sealant, 1/4 pint brush-top can
Product photo: Amazon

The short answer

Get RectorSeal T Plus 2 (10.0): rated for PVC, CPVC and ABS as well as metal, potable water, and you can turn the water on right away.

Best for metal and plastic threads alike
RectorSeal T Plus 2. $8.78 at Amazon.
Best for seeing coverage on the thread
Oatey Great Blue. $15.53 at Amazon.
Best for metal pipe and fuel lines
RectorSeal No. 5. $8.77 at Amazon.
RectorSeal T Plus 2 pipe thread sealant, 1/4 pint brush-top can
Top pick: RectorSeal T Plus 2$8.78 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon (opens in a new tab)
Not sure? Use the sealant matcher

The three pipe dopes I’d buy

  1. RectorSeal T Plus 2 pipe thread sealant, 1/4 pint brush-top can

    Product photo: Amazon

    Best for metal and plastic threads alike

    RectorSeal T Plus 2

    Pipe thread sealant with PTFE, 1/4 pint brush-top can, 23631

    Buy it if
    You work on mixed metal and plastic threads, especially CPVC or ABS, and want to turn the water back on right away.
    Skip it if
    You want a sealant whose color shows your coverage at a glance. Great Blue is blue.
    Full specs and my take
  2. Oatey Great Blue pipe joint compound, 8 ounce brush-top can

    Product photo: Amazon

    Best for seeing coverage on the thread

    Oatey Great Blue

    Pipe joint compound, 8 fl oz brush-top can, 31262

    Buy it if
    You want a non-hardening compound with the widest plastic list and a color you can see on the thread.
    Skip it if
    You need to pressurize a line the moment it’s made up and want that in writing. T Plus 2’s sheet says so.
    Full specs and my take
  3. RectorSeal No. 5 yellow pipe thread sealant can

    Product photo: Amazon

    Best for metal pipe and fuel lines

    RectorSeal No. 5

    Buy it if
    You thread steel, iron, brass or copper, including fuel oil and gasoline lines, and want the industry standard.
    Skip it if
    Any of the threads are ABS or CPVC.
    Full specs and my take

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Which pipe dope for your pipe and line?

Any of the three. All three list metal pipe and potable water. T Plus 2 lets you pressurize right away.

Built from the materials and service lists on each data sheet. Your fitting maker’s instructions and local code come first.

Pipe dope isn’t one product. Each sealant’s data sheet lists the pipe materials and the fluids it’s rated for, and the biggest trap is plastic: RectorSeal’s own No. 5 sheet says not to use it on ABS or CPVC, while its T Plus 2 sheet lists both. Read the sheet for the can in your hand.

Tape or dope, or both? My Teflon tape vs pipe dope vs putty guide covers that choice. This page is only about choosing the dope.

How the three compare on my spec score

T Plus 210Great Blue9.2RectorSeal No. 59.0010T Plus 210Great Blue9.2RectorSeal No. 59.0
PlumbingPicks spec score out of 10, from RectorSeal data sheets and Oatey’s product page read Oct 23, 2026. It is not a customer rating.

The checks are what you need to know before you brush it on: whether it’s rated for plastic pipe, its liquid and gas pressure ratings, whether it’s certified for drinking water, whether you can pressurize right away, and whether the listing is the maker’s product.

All three pass the pressure and potable-water checks. They separate on plastics and on how soon the line can go into service.

Each pick, in detail

Best for metal and plastic threads alike

Pipe thread sealant with PTFE, 1/4 pint brush-top can, 23631

RectorSeal T Plus 2 pipe thread sealant, 1/4 pint brush-top can
Product photo: Amazon
$8.78 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon (opens in a new tab)

Prices and availability are accurate as of the time shown and may change.

Spec score: 10 of 10. How it is scored

Plastic pipe rating
10 of 10
Liquid pressure
10 of 10
Gas pressure
10 of 10
Potable water (NSF 61)
10 of 10
Immediate service
10 of 10
Listing match
10 of 10

T Plus 2 is the one can that handles almost every thread on a residential job. It scored 10.0.

RectorSeal’s data sheet calls it a non-hardening sealant with PTFE plus synthetic fibers in a resin base. It lists iron, galvanized and stainless steel, brass, copper, aluminum, polyethylene, reinforced fiberglass, PVC, ABS, PPSU and CPVC, including FlowGuard Gold. That’s a 10 on plastics.

Pressure ratings are up to 10,000 psi for liquids and 2,000 psi for gases, both 10s. It’s rated for hot water to 203°F.

It’s non-toxic per NSF Standard 61 and certified to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61, listed with CSA, and certified against IAPMO PS-36 for PE, PVC, CPVC and ABS. Potable water is a 10.

The standout feature: the sheet says piping may be placed into service immediately. No waiting for a cure on a water line. A 10.

Instructions from the sheet: stir, wipe threads clean, apply to male threads only up to 1-1/4 in. pipe and to both male and female threads on larger pipe, then join per ANSI standards.

Other numbers: 0 g/L VOC, a flash point above 300°F, non-flammable, a 2-year shelf life, and it won’t dry out in the can. RectorSeal lists natural gas and LP gas vapor at a 125 psi maximum from −40 to 125°F under ANSI LC 7-2009. Not for oxygen.

The PTFE and fibers do two jobs: they fill gaps in imperfect threads, and RectorSeal says the low friction allows tighter joint makeup with lower torque. It also breaks out easily without galling, seizing or damaging threads, which matters when you come back to a valve years later.

Its service list goes well past water: compressed air, natural gas, LP gas, heating oils, hydraulic oils, refrigerants and dilute acids and caustics, so one can covers most of a residential mechanical room.

My call: the default can for a plumber’s truck.

Pros

  • Lists PVC, CPVC, ABS, PPSU and PE as well as metal
  • Up to 10,000 psi liquids, 2,000 psi gases
  • NSF/ANSI/CAN 61; piping can go into service immediately
  • Non-hardening; 0 g/L VOC

Cons

  • White, so coverage is harder to see
  • Not for oxygen
  • Gas listing tops out at 125 psi vapor
PTFE + fibers10,000 psi liquid2,000 psi gasNSF 610 g/L VOC

Buy it if

You work on mixed metal and plastic threads, especially CPVC or ABS, and want to turn the water back on right away.

Skip it if

You want a sealant whose color shows your coverage at a glance. Great Blue is blue.

Best for seeing coverage on the thread

Pipe joint compound, 8 fl oz brush-top can, 31262

Oatey Great Blue pipe joint compound, 8 ounce brush-top can
Product photo: Amazon
$15.53 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon (opens in a new tab)

Prices and availability are accurate as of the time shown and may change.

Spec score: 9.2 of 10. How it is scored

Plastic pipe rating
10 of 10
Liquid pressure
10 of 10
Gas pressure
10 of 10
Potable water (NSF 61)
10 of 10
Immediate service
5 of 10
Listing match
10 of 10

Great Blue is the classic blue can. It scored 9.2.

Oatey’s product page says it seals threaded connections on metal and plastic pipe up to and including 2 in., and lists PVC, CPVC, ABS, polyethylene, polypropylene, iron, steel, copper and brass threads. That’s the widest plastic list here, a 10.

It withstands up to 10,000 psi on liquids from −50 to 500°F and up to 3,000 psi on gases from −50 to 400°F, per Oatey. Both 10s, and the highest gas rating of the three.

Oatey says it’s certified to NSF, IAPMO and CSA, and describes it as flexible, non-hardening and non-toxic. Potable water is a 10.

It lost points on immediate service: Oatey’s page doesn’t say when the line can be pressurized, so it’s a 5. On a gas line, allow the cure time the local inspector expects before the pressure test.

Oatey lists lines carrying water, natural gas (not oxygen), steam, air, caustics and dilute acids. The uniform, smooth consistency brushes on evenly, and Oatey calls it low odor with easy cleanup.

The blue color is the practical edge: you can see at a glance whether every thread is covered, which helps on overhead or dim work.

Oatey sells Great Blue in four sizes; this listing is the 8 fl oz brush-top can, catalog 31262. The 1 fl oz and 4 fl oz sizes are handy for a homeowner’s drawer, and the brush in the lid is the right size for 1/2 to 1 in. threads.

Because it’s non-hardening, it stays pliable in the joint, which helps on lines that see vibration or heat cycles, like a boiler or water heater connection. Oatey also recommends it for steam lines.

Oatey’s 2 in. limit is worth noting for anyone threading larger pipe; above that, use a sealant whose sheet covers the size.

My call: a strong all-round can, especially for apprentices learning to see full coverage.

Pros

  • Lists PVC, CPVC, ABS, polyethylene and polypropylene
  • 10,000 psi liquids; 3,000 psi gases
  • Certified to NSF, IAPMO and CSA
  • Blue color shows coverage

Cons

  • Oatey’s page gives no immediate-service rule
  • For threads up to 2 in.
  • Not for oxygen
Non-hardening10,000 psi liquid3,000 psi gas−50 to 500°FUp to 2 in.

Buy it if

You want a non-hardening compound with the widest plastic list and a color you can see on the thread.

Skip it if

You need to pressurize a line the moment it’s made up and want that in writing. T Plus 2’s sheet says so.

Best for metal pipe and fuel lines

RectorSeal No. 5 premium pipe thread sealant, 25631

RectorSeal No. 5 yellow pipe thread sealant can
Product photo: Amazon
$8.77 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon (opens in a new tab)

Prices and availability are accurate as of the time shown and may change.

Spec score: 9.0 of 10. How it is scored

Plastic pipe rating
6 of 10
Liquid pressure
10 of 10
Gas pressure
10 of 10
Potable water (NSF 61)
10 of 10
Immediate service
8 of 10
Listing match
10 of 10

No. 5 is the yellow can RectorSeal calls the standard of the industry. It scored 9.0.

The data sheet calls it a soft-setting, slow-drying sealant of inert fillers in an oleoresinous base. Its liquid rating is the highest here, up to 12,000 psi; its gas rating is 2,600 psi, below Great Blue’s 3,000 psi. Tens on both.

It’s non-toxic per NSF Standard 61-G and 372, UL classified, listed under the Uniform Plumbing Code (IAPMO file 1282) and with CSA. Potable water is a 10.

It lost the most on plastics. The sheet lists PVC and polyethylene but says plainly: do not use on ABS or CPVC. That’s a 6, and it’s the reason T Plus 2 replaced No. 5 on many plumbers’ trucks.

Immediate service is limited: the sheet allows natural gas and water lines up to 2 in. and 100 psi to go into service right away, and says to call RectorSeal for cure times on anything else. An 8.

Where No. 5 shines is fuel. It lists diesel fuel oil, gasohol and gasoline, leaded and unleaded, along with natural gas, heating oils and refrigerants. Its gas listing is 125 psi max from −40 to 125°F, vapor only, for pipe up to 1-1/4 in.

Other numbers: brushable from 20 to 140°F, 317 g/L VOC, a flash point of 150°F, and a 2-year shelf life. Apply to male threads only up to 1-1/4 in., both threads on larger pipe.

RectorSeal calls it economical because it takes only a small amount, and says it reduces friction for tighter makeup and protects threads. The yellow color is easy to spot on black iron.

My call: still my pick for metal fuel-oil and gasoline work; keep it off ABS and CPVC.

Pros

  • Up to 12,000 psi liquids, 2,600 psi gases
  • Lists gasoline, gasohol and diesel fuel oil
  • NSF 61-G & 372; UL classified; IAPMO and CSA listed
  • Immediate service on water and gas to 2 in. at 100 psi

Cons

  • Do not use on ABS or CPVC, per RectorSeal
  • Soft-setting, slow-drying
  • 317 g/L VOC
Oleoresinous12,000 psi liquid2,600 psi gasNSF 61-GYellow

Buy it if

You thread steel, iron, brass or copper, including fuel oil and gasoline lines, and want the industry standard.

Skip it if

Any of the threads are ABS or CPVC.

The three side by side

PickSpec scorePhotoABS / CPVCLiquid / gas psiImmediate serviceColorShort pros / consBuy
RectorSeal T Plus 210.0T Plus 2Yes / yes10,000 / 2,000YesWhiteWidest use / Hard to seeCheck it on Amazon
Oatey Great Blue9.2Great BlueYes / yes10,000 / 3,000Not statedBlueMost plastics / No service ruleCheck it on Amazon
RectorSeal No. 59.0No. 5No / no12,000 / 2,600Water and gas to 2 in., 100 psiYellowFuel lines / No ABS or CPVCCheck it on Amazon

Sources: RectorSeal T Plus 2 and No. 5 product data sheets; Oatey Great Blue product page (oatey.com). Ratings are the sealant’s; the pipe and fittings have their own pressure limits, which govern.

Plastic threads: where sealants differ most

MaterialT Plus 2Great BlueNo. 5
PVCYesYesYes
CPVCYes (incl. FlowGuard Gold)YesNo
ABSYesYesNo
PolyethyleneYesYesYes
PolypropyleneNot listedYesNot listed
PPSUYesNot listedNot listed

Plastic fitting makers often have their own rule on top of the sealant’s: some ask for a specific compatible paste, and some say never to combine tape and paste on plastic threads. My tape-vs-dope guide quotes Spears’ rules for PVC threaded fittings.

On a plastic female fitting, go easy on torque. A tapered male thread wedges into a plastic female like a splitting wedge; a little too much and the fitting cracks, sometimes days later.

Pipe dope on gas lines

SealantGas rating on the sheetNotes
T Plus 22,000 psi gases; ANSI LC 7-2009 listing 125 psi max, −40 to 125°F, natural and LP gas vaporUse on steel, galvanized, iron, brass, copper, aluminum
No. 52,600 psi gases; ANSI LC 7-2009 listing 125 psi max, −40 to 125°F, natural gas vaporListing covers pipe up to 1-1/4 in.
Great Blue3,000 psi gases from −50 to 400°FLists natural gas lines; not oxygen

For gas work, read the ANSI LC 7-2009 listing on the two RectorSeal sheets, not just the headline psi: it limits gas use to 125 psi, vapor only. Follow your local fuel gas code on which sealants are allowed, and pressure-test the system after any change.

None of these is for oxygen. My pipe threading machine guide covers cutting clean threads for gas pipe.

How soon you can turn the water or gas on

SealantWhen the line can go into service
T Plus 2Immediately, per RectorSeal
No. 5Immediately for natural gas and water up to 2 in. and 100 psi; ask RectorSeal for other cure times
Great BlueNot stated on Oatey’s page

Non-hardening and soft-setting compounds seal by filling the thread gaps, not by curing hard, which is why they can go into service fast. A soft set also means the joint breaks out years later without galling the threads, which both RectorSeal sheets point out.

How to apply pipe dope

  1. Stir the can

    Both RectorSeal sheets say to stir before using.

  2. Clean the threads

    Wipe off cutting oil, dirt and old sealant.

  3. Coat the male thread

    On pipe up to 1-1/4 in., male threads only; on larger pipe, both male and female, per RectorSeal.

  4. Skip the first thread

    Leave the first thread bare so no dope pushes into the pipe.

  5. Join to the right makeup

    Hand-tight, then wrench turns to normal makeup; RectorSeal says join per ANSI standards.

  6. Wipe the excess

    No. 5’s sheet says to wipe excess sealant from joints.

More dope isn’t a better seal. A thin, full coat that fills the thread valleys is the goal. A glob just squeezes into the pipe or onto the outside.

Need to thread the pipe first? See pipe threading oil for cutting clean threads.

Handling, VOC and storage

SealantVOCFlash pointShelf life
T Plus 20 g/LAbove 300°F; non-flammable2 years
No. 5317 g/L150°F; vapors combustible2 years
Great BlueNot on Oatey’s pageNot on Oatey’s pageNot on Oatey’s page

Keep the lid tight; T Plus 2’s sheet says it won’t dry out in the can, and No. 5 is slow-drying. Wear gloves, since dope is hard to get off skin, and ventilate in tight spaces with a solvent-based compound like No. 5.

Where pipe dope belongs, and where it doesn’t

JointPipe dope?Why
Tapered pipe threads (NPT): nipples, valves, fittingsYesThe taper plus sealant makes the seal
Gas piping threadsYes, if your code allows the productAll three list natural gas
Compression fittingsNoThe ferrule seals; dope on the threads does nothing
Flare fittingsNoThe flare face seals metal to metal
Supply line nuts with rubber cones or washersNoThe washer seals; dope can degrade some rubbers
Garden hose threadsNoThe hose washer seals
Union facesNoThe ground seat or gasket seals; dope only on the threaded pipe ends

Many leaks with dope on them are joints that never needed it: a compression nut smeared with compound, or a supply line with dope on the threads and a hardened washer inside. Dope seals tapered threads. Straight threads with a washer or ferrule seal somewhere else.

My MIP vs FIP and NPT fittings guide explains which threads are tapered.

Pipe dope mistakes that cause leaks

  1. Dope on dirty or oily threads

    Fresh-cut threads carry cutting oil; wipe them clean first, as both RectorSeal sheets say.

  2. Backing a joint off to line it up

    Turning a made-up joint backward can break the seal. Tighten forward only within the fitting maker’s makeup limits; Spears, for example, says 1–2 turns beyond finger tight for its plastic threaded joints and not to over-tighten.

  3. Using No. 5 on CPVC or ABS

    RectorSeal’s own sheet forbids it; use T Plus 2 or Great Blue.

  4. Pressurizing too soon

    Check the sheet’s service rule; No. 5 allows immediate service only up to 2 in. and 100 psi.

  5. Dope inside the pipe

    Leave the first thread bare so compound doesn’t push into the bore and onto a valve seat.

  6. Old, separated compound

    Stir it; a can past its 2-year shelf life on the RectorSeal sheets is worth replacing.

Backing off is a common mistake: a tapered joint that’s made up, then turned back a quarter turn to aim a valve handle, can weep later. Plan the makeup so the last turn lands where you need it. If it won’t line up within the fitting maker’s makeup limits, don’t force it further: take it apart, clean both threads and start again with fresh dope.

Checked and left out

SealantScoreWhat held it backWhat it does well
RectorSeal Tru-Blu (31631)6.7Its data sheet lists no psi rating and doesn’t list ABS or CPVCVibration-resistant; good for refrigeration and compressor lines
Gasoila Soft-SetNot scoredNo maker data sheet found to check its ratingsWidely sold; listings describe a PTFE paste

How to choose in four questions

QuestionIf yesIf no
Any ABS or CPVC threads?T Plus 2 or Great BlueNext question
Fuel oil or gasoline lines?No. 5Next question
Need the line back in service right away?T Plus 2Next question
Want to see coverage easily?Great BlueT Plus 2

Questions people ask

What is the best pipe dope?

On my spec score, RectorSeal T Plus 2 (10.0): rated for metal and PVC, CPVC and ABS, NSF 61, and lines can go into service immediately.

Can pipe dope be used on PVC?

All three here list PVC. For CPVC and ABS, use T Plus 2 or Great Blue; RectorSeal says not to use No. 5 on them.

Is pipe dope safe for drinking water?

These three list potable water. T Plus 2 is certified to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61, No. 5 to NSF 61-G and 372, and Great Blue to NSF.

Can I use pipe dope on gas lines?

All three list natural gas. Follow your local gas code and pressure-test after.

How long does pipe dope take to dry?

T Plus 2 can go into service immediately. No. 5 can for water and gas up to 2 in. and 100 psi.

Do I put pipe dope on male or female threads?

Male threads only up to 1-1/4 in. pipe, and both on larger pipe, per RectorSeal.

Can I use tape and pipe dope together?

Some makers allow it on metal; some plastic fitting makers forbid it. See my tape vs dope guide.

Is RectorSeal No. 5 OK on CPVC?

No. RectorSeal’s sheet says do not use No. 5 on ABS or CPVC.

How I picked these

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia . Every rating here comes from RectorSeal’s data sheets and Oatey’s product page, read Oct 23, 2026. Where I add my own advice, it’s labeled as my call.

How I pick

  • Only brush-on pipe thread sealing compounds with published maker data.
  • Each card’s spec score comes from the six checks below. All three score 7.0 or higher.
  • Thread tape is a different kind of product, covered in my tape vs dope guide.

The spec score, check by check

Six checks, one sixth each, 0 to 10, averaged to one decimal. The score reads makers’ published data; buyers’ opinions play no part in it.

Check (weight)How it’s scored
Plastic pipe rating (1/6)Lists PVC, CPVC and ABS 10; PVC and PE without ABS listed 7; excludes ABS and CPVC 6
Liquid pressure (1/6)Published 10,000 psi or more 10; not published 5
Gas pressure (1/6)Published 2,000 psi or more 10; not published 5
Potable water (1/6)NSF 61 or NSF certification stated 10; potable water listed without certification 8
Immediate service (1/6)Immediate service without limits 10; with limits 8; not stated 5
Listing match (1/6)10 when the Amazon product matches the maker’s
TotalAverage of the checks, to one decimal
SealantPlasticLiquidGasPotableServiceListingScore
T Plus 210101010101010.0
Great Blue101010105109.2
No. 561010108109.0
Tru-Blu (left out)75585106.7

Sources

  1. RectorSeal, T Plus 2 pipe thread sealant product data sheet (rectorseal.bynder.com).
  2. RectorSeal, No. 5 premium pipe thread sealant product data sheet (copy hosted by WebstaurantStore).
  3. RectorSeal, Tru-Blu vibration resistant pipe thread sealant product data sheet (copy hosted by Elliott Electric).
  4. Oatey, Great Blue pipe joint compound product page (oatey.com): read Oct 23, 2026.
  5. Amazon product listings for every product named on this page, read October 27, 2026.
  6. Spears Manufacturing, threaded joint assembly guidance (1–2 turns beyond finger tight, avoid backing up, do not over-tighten): parts.spearsmfg.com/sourcebook/SELECTIOND_SLECTIOND_SELEJMTC.pdf, read October 27, 2026.