Plumber’s putty vs silicone

Which one each fixture calls for, what the makers say, and how to apply each one.

Oatey 31177 stain-free plumber’s putty, 9 ounce tub
Oatey 31177 stain-free plumber’s putty, 9 ounce tub. Product photo: Amazon.

The short answer

Follow the fixture’s sheet. Otherwise: putty under metal drain flanges, stain-free putty on stone, 100% silicone on ABS, acrylic blends and rims. Neither on threads or toilets.

Best for metal drains and faucets → Oatey 31170 putty

Best for granite, marble and quartz → Oatey 31177 stain-free

Best for ABS, rims and tub edges → GE Advanced Silicone K&B

Best for running a clean silicone bead → Dripless ETS2000

Check it on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.

Putty or silicone for your fixture?

Pick the job and what the parts are made of. The checker applies Oatey’s compatibility rules.

Use regular plumber’s putty, unless the strainer’s sheet says otherwise.

Oatey lists sink basket strainers on metal, porcelain and PVC as putty jobs, and Kohler’s strainer guide calls for a ring of putty under the flange.

Rules from Oatey’s current putty guide. The fixture maker’s sheet always wins.

The checker leans hard on materials because that’s where the mistakes happen. Putty and silicone both seal a flange well. The trouble starts when oil-based putty meets stone, or any putty meets ABS plastic, which Oatey says it can degrade.

For thread sealants, tape and dope, see Teflon tape vs pipe dope vs putty. This page is only about setting fixtures.

Two putties, a kitchen and bath silicone and a gun

Keep both kinds of putty and one tube of silicone, and you can set almost any fixture. In my 7 years of experience, these are the products I’d install.

Oatey 31170 plumber’s putty, 3 pound tub
Product photo: Amazon

Oatey 31170 putty

Best for metal drains and faucets

Check it on Amazon
Oatey 31177 stain-free plumber’s putty, 9 ounce tub
Product photo: Amazon

Oatey 31177 stain-free

Best for granite, marble and quartz

Check it on Amazon
GE Advanced Silicone kitchen and bath caulk, clear cartridge
Product photo: Amazon

GE Advanced Silicone K&B

Best for ABS, rims and tub edges

Check it on Amazon
Dripless ETS2000 yellow composite caulk gun
Product photo: Amazon

Dripless ETS2000 gun

Best for running a clean silicone bead

Check it on Amazon
ItemKey specsPick it ifSkip it if
Oatey 31170 putty3 lb; soft, pliable fixture-setting compound; compatible with stainless fixtures; meets Mil Spec TT-P-1536AYou set metal drains, strainers and faucets on porcelain, steel or PVC.The surface is stone, or any part is ABS.
Oatey 31177 stain-freeOil-free; for granite, marble, quartz/sandstone and Corian; no wait; 1-year shelf lifeThe sink or counter is natural stone or solid surface.A part is ABS. Oatey’s sheet says not for ABS.
GE Advanced Silicone K&B100% silicone, clear, 10 fl oz; water ready in 30 minutes per GE; neutral cure, low odorThe part is ABS or an acrylic blend, or you’re sealing a rim or tub edge.You’ll want the fixture out again soon. Cured silicone has to be cut off.
Dripless ETS2000Composite, 12:1 thrust, dripless retracting rod, rotating barrelYou need a steady bead from a 10 oz cartridge.You only use squeeze tubes.

Why both putties: regular putty is the default for metal drains on porcelain, and a big tub lasts years. Stain-free costs more but is the one that’s safe on stone. Oatey’s current guide says stain-free is still not an ABS-compatible alternative, so the silicone stays in the kit too.

Oatey’s listing for 31170 says it meets military spec TT-P-1536A, is compatible with stainless steel fixtures and doesn’t stick to hands. That last point matters more than it sounds when you’re rolling a rope under a sink with one arm. The 3 lb tub is the size that sits on a service truck; the 9 oz stain-free tub covers the occasional stone job.

Dripless rates the ETS2000 at a 12:1 thrust ratio, which its thrust guide says suits silicone and acrylic. My caulk gun guide explains thrust ratios.

Putty and silicone side by side

They look like they do the same job. They don’t.

Plumber’s putty100% silicone
What it isA soft bedding compound that never cures (Oatey)An adhesive sealant that cures
Bonds the parts?No; hardware holds the fixtureYes, once cured
Wait before waterNone; test right away (Oatey)GE: water ready in 30 minutes; full cure longer
Taking it apartEasy; use fresh putty every time (Oatey)Cut and scrape it off
ABS and acrylic blendsNo (Oatey)Yes; Oatey points to 100% silicone
Granite, marble, quartzStain-free only (Oatey)Test stone first
Threads or pressureNo (Oatey)No

The core difference is cure. Putty stays soft, so it seals by being squeezed between two rigid parts and stays easy to remove. Silicone cures into a rubbery solid that grips both surfaces, so it seals gaps a flange can’t clamp, and it’s far harder to undo.

That’s why most drain and faucet makers name putty: they expect the part to come out again someday. Rims and edges get silicone because nothing clamps them.

What the fixture makers’ sheets call for

From install sheets in my files, read Oct 23, 2026. Your own fixture’s sheet beats any general rule.

SheetPartWhat it calls for
Kohler 105267-2Sink strainerA ring of plumber’s putty under the strainer body flange
Moen MT169ACenterset lavatory pop-up drainA 1/4 in. bead of putty under the drain seat; pipe joint compound on the threads
Moen INS2227Two-handle lavatory faucetPutty or other sealant in the putty groove of the upper mounting washers
Moen INS2227Pop-up drain seatPutty or other non-staining sealant under the waste seat
Oatey putty guideABS drains, ABS-core tubsNot putty; 100% silicone
Oatey stain-free sheetGranite, marble, quartz, CorianStain-free putty; not for ABS

Notice the wording: Moen’s sheet says “plumber’s putty or other sealant” and “non-staining sealant”. That leaves room for silicone or stain-free putty on a stone vanity. Kohler’s strainer guide names putty only.

Moen’s MT169A also shows the line between jobs: putty under the drain seat, pipe joint compound on the threaded tailpiece. Two different sealants on one drain, each in its own place.

Oatey’s material compatibility rules

Oatey’s current putty guide spells out where its putty can and can’t go.

MaterialOatey putty?Oatey’s guidance
PVCYesFollow the fixture and product instructions
Pure 100% acrylicYesConfirm it’s entirely acrylic, not a blend
Acrylic blendNoUse a sealant the fixture maker approves
ABSNoUse 100% silicone
ABS-core or acrylic-capped ABSNoNot compatible with Oatey putty
Granite, marble, quartz, sandstone, CorianStain-free puttyRegular oil-based putty may stain
Pipe threads, pressurized jointsNoThread sealant or tape
Toilet baseNoA caulk or sealant made for the job

The acrylic rows are the ones people miss. Oatey warns that a tub or shower base may be called acrylic even when it has an ABS core or backing. If you can’t confirm it’s pure acrylic from the tub maker’s specs, treat it as ABS and use silicone.

Black plastic drain parts are often ABS; white ones are often PVC. That’s a rule of thumb, not proof. Look for the stamp on the part.

How to apply plumber’s putty

Oatey’s steps, in order.

  1. 1
    Confirm compatibility

    Check every surface the putty will touch; no ABS, no acrylic blends.

  2. 2
    Clean and dry

    Remove old putty, dirt, wax, oil and grease, then dry fully.

  3. 3
    Knead and roll

    Work it soft, then roll a rope about 1/2 in. thick.

  4. 4
    Ring the flange

    Lay a complete ring under the flange and blend the ends; roll a longer piece instead of stretching it.

  5. 5
    Install snug

    Tighten until putty squeezes out all around; don’t crush it.

  6. 6
    Wipe and test

    Wipe the excess with a plastic putty knife and test right away; no cure time needed.

Two details from Oatey worth knowing. In cold conditions, wait 10 minutes and check whether the fixture needs another turn, because putty firms up when cold. And clean excess can go back in the tub, but never add anything to dried-out putty to revive it.

Putty also doesn’t care much about a damp hand or a cold morning the way silicone does; it just needs clean, dry surfaces to sit on. Squeeze-out all the way around is your proof of a full seal. If none appears in one spot, there’s a gap. Pull it and redo it with fresh putty.

How to set a drain or edge with silicone

  1. 1
    Clean and dry

    Silicone needs clean, dry, oil-free surfaces to bond. Remove old putty completely.

  2. 2
    Cut the nozzle small

    A small opening gives a thin, even bead under a flange.

  3. 3
    Run a continuous bead

    Under the flange, a full ring; on an edge, one steady pass.

  4. 4
    Set and tighten

    Seat the part and tighten while the silicone is wet; wipe the squeeze-out.

  5. 5
    Wait before water

    Follow the cartridge’s time. GE says its Advanced Silicone is water ready in 30 minutes; cold or thick beads take longer.

Read the cartridge for the one you buy. Cure times differ a lot between silicones, and the fast figures assume a thin bead in warm, humid air. Under a drain flange, where air can’t reach, waiting longer before heavy use costs nothing.

My silicone sealant for plumbing guide compares tubes for wet areas.

Which one, job by job

JobStart withWhy
Kitchen basket strainer, stainless sinkPuttyKohler’s strainer guide calls for it; easy to service
Strainer in a granite or quartz sinkStain-free putty or the sink maker’s sealantOil-based putty may stain stone
Bathroom pop-up drainPuttyMoen’s sheets call for it under the drain seat
Faucet base with a gasketThe gasketIt’s made for that seal
Tub drain, ABS-core acrylic tub100% siliconeOatey: no putty on ABS
Shower drain, PVC in a tile baseFollow the drain makerMany tile drains use clamping rings, not putty
Sink rim to counter100% siliconeNeeds to bond; nothing clamps it
Pipe threadsTape or dopeNeither putty nor silicone
Toilet to floorWax or wax-free ringOatey: putty isn’t for toilet bases

When the sheet is lost and the material is a mystery, silicone is the safer default for compatibility, putty the easier one for service. For a part you’ll pull every few years, like a kitchen strainer over a disposal, I lean putty on a compatible sink.

If a strainer still drips, kitchen sink leaking underneath walks through resealing it.

Faucets: gasket, putty or silicone?

Faucet sheets vary more than drain sheets. Three Moen sheets in my files show the range.

Moen sheetFaucetWhere the sealant goes
INS1620CTwo-handle kitchen, models 8242 and 8244“Sealant” under the spout base, on the upper mounting washers and under each handle hub
INS2227Two-handle lavatory“Plumbers putty or other sealant” in the putty groove of the upper mounting washers
MT169ACenterset lavatoryPutty under the pop-up drain seat; pipe joint compound on the tailpiece threads

When a sheet says “sealant” without naming one, either putty or silicone meets the wording. I use putty on porcelain and steel so the faucet comes off cleanly in ten years, and stain-free putty or silicone on stone.

Many single-hole faucets now ship with a rubber or foam deck gasket under the base. That gasket is the seal; adding putty under it can keep the faucet from seating flat. My how to install a faucet guide covers the rest of the install.

Sink rims, backsplashes and counters

Anything that isn’t clamped by a nut needs a sealant that bonds. That’s silicone’s home ground.

  1. 1
    Drop-in sink rim

    A bead of 100% silicone under the rim before you set the sink, then wipe the squeeze-out.

  2. 2
    Undermount sink

    Follow the sink and counter makers; many call for silicone between the sink lip and stone, plus clips.

  3. 3
    Faucet deck plate on stone

    Stain-free putty or silicone, or the plate’s own gasket.

  4. 4
    Backsplash joint

    A thin silicone bead, tooled smooth.

Putty never belongs on a rim or a backsplash. It doesn’t adhere, so it pulls away and collects grime. This is also where neutral-cure silicone earns its place: no vinegar smell in the kitchen, and less risk on stone and metal trim.

Give rim silicone the full time on the cartridge before heavy use. A sink full of dishes in the first hour is the usual reason a fresh rim bead lets go.

Working in a cold or damp cabinet

ConditionPuttySilicone
Cold sink or roomFirms up; Oatey says recheck the fixture after 10 minutes for another turnCures slower; give it longer than the cartridge minimum
Damp surfaceOatey says clean and dry firstWon’t bond well; dry it fully
Leaking supply nearbyFix the leak firstFix the leak first
Need water back right awayFine; no cure timeWait for the cartridge time

That last row decides a lot of real jobs. If a family needs the kitchen sink back tonight and the strainer is on a compatible sink, putty lets you test and walk away. Silicone under a flange is a next-morning job if you want to be safe.

A warm room helps both. In a cold crawl-space vanity or an unheated garage sink, warm the putty in your hands longer before rolling, and keep the silicone cartridge indoors until you use it.

Garbage disposal sink flange: putty, per InSinkErator

The disposal flange is the most common putty job in a kitchen, and InSinkErator spells it out.

  1. 1
    Clean off the old putty

    InSinkErator’s steps say to remove the old strainer and clean off the old putty around the drain opening.

  2. 2
    Roll a 1/2 in. rope

    Place a 1/2 in. rope of plumber’s putty around the drain opening in the sink.

  3. 3
    Drop the flange in and weight it

    Press the new flange into place; InSinkErator suggests setting a weight, like the disposal itself, on it, with a towel to protect the sink.

  4. 4
    Build up the mount from below

    Slide on the fiber gasket, backup flange and mounting flange, then the mounting ring and snap ring.

  5. 5
    Tighten evenly and wipe

    Tighten the mounting screws evenly and wipe the putty that squeezes out above.

InSinkErator lists plumber’s putty, about 0.1 kg, in its materials for a first-time install. That’s roughly a quarter pound, so a 3 lb tub covers a lot of disposals. Some newer disposal mounts ship with a rubber sink gasket instead; if yours does, follow that manual and skip the putty.

On a granite or quartz sink, use stain-free putty for the same steps. If the flange leaks later, see garbage disposal leaking.

Tubs and showers: where the material question bites

Oatey lists bath waste and overflow fittings and compatible shower drains as putty jobs, but the tub material decides.

Tub or basePutty?What to use
Cast iron or steel tubYesPutty under the drain flange, or the gasket supplied
Pure 100% acrylic tubYes, per OateyConfirm it’s pure acrylic first
Acrylic-capped ABS or ABS-coreNo100% silicone
Fiberglass or composite baseUnknownThe tub maker’s sealant; silicone if it doesn’t say
Tile shower with a PVC drainDepends on the drainMany use a clamping ring and membrane; follow the drain maker

A tub’s spec sheet or the label under the apron usually names the material. If it says “acrylic” with no detail, ask the maker or treat it as ABS-core, as Oatey advises.

On a waste and overflow, the putty goes under the drain flange inside the tub. The overflow plate seals with its own rubber gasket behind the tub wall, not putty. Getting the shoe and the flange to line up matters more than how much putty you use.

How much putty or silicone a job takes

JobAmountSource
Any fixture flangeA rope about 1/2 in. thick, a full ringOatey putty guide
Disposal sink flangeA 1/2 in. rope; about 0.1 kg listed for the installInSinkErator
Bathroom pop-up seatA 1/4 in. beadMoen MT169A
Strainer flangeA ring under the flange edgeKohler 105267-2
Silicone under a flangeA thin continuous beadMy call; enough to squeeze out

The test is the same for both: when you tighten, a little should squeeze out all the way around. No squeeze-out means not enough; a thick curtain means too much, and you’re wiping it for ten minutes.

Which kind of silicone for plumbing fixtures

Oatey says 100% silicone where putty can’t go. Not every tube labeled “silicone” is that.

ProductWhat it isFor fixtures?
100% silicone, kitchen and bathPure silicone, often with mildew resistanceYes; what Oatey points to for ABS
Neutral-cure siliconeReleases no acetic acid while curingGood near metal finishes and stone
Acetoxy siliconeSmells like vinegar while curingFine on many surfaces; can mark some metals and stone
Siliconized acrylic latex caulkWater-based caulk with some siliconeNot a substitute for 100% silicone under a drain

GE describes its Advanced Silicone Kitchen & Bath as 100% silicone with a low-odor, neutral-cure formula, which is why it’s the kit pick. The acetoxy and latex rows are general product categories, not a single maker’s claim; read the cartridge to see which one you have.

White or clear is a looks choice. Clear hides better on chrome and stone; white matches white porcelain and tile.

The trade-offs in one place

Plumber’s putty100% silicone
GoodNo cure; test right away; easy to remove and redo; cheap per jobBonds and seals gaps; safe on ABS and acrylic blends; waterproof once cured
BadNo ABS or blends; regular putty can stain stone; dries out in airWait before water; hard to remove; needs clean, dry surfaces
Best useMetal drains, strainers and faucets on compatible sinksABS parts, sink rims, tub edges, unknown materials

Neither is better overall. Putty is the service-friendly default where it’s allowed; silicone is the compatibility-safe choice where it isn’t. Keep both in the truck and let the fixture sheet and the material pick for you.

Storage matters for putty. Oatey says putty hardens and gets brittle after long exposure to air, so close the lid tight; its stain-free sheet gives a 1-year shelf life from manufacture.

Getting old putty or silicone off

Old materialHow to remove it
Soft puttyLift the fixture; scrape with a plastic putty knife; wipe
Hardened puttyScrape and wire-brush where the surface allows, per Oatey
Cured siliconeCut along the bead with a razor, peel, then scrape the film
Silicone film on stonePlastic scraper only; a razor can scratch polish

New silicone won’t bond well over old silicone or putty residue, so remove every trace before resealing. A caulk removal tool speeds up long tub edges. On a drain flange, a plastic putty knife does the job without scratching.

Mistakes Oatey lists, and how to avoid them

  1. 1
    Assuming every acrylic is the same

    Some “acrylic” tubs have ABS inside; confirm before using putty.

  2. 2
    Regular putty on stone

    Use stain-free putty on granite, marble, quartz and sandstone.

  3. 3
    A gap or thin spot in the rope

    Make a complete ring thick enough to squeeze out.

  4. 4
    Overtightening

    Snug and secure, not crushed.

  5. 5
    Reusing dried putty

    Use fresh putty whenever a fixture comes apart.

  6. 6
    Putty as caulk or thread sealant

    It isn’t meant for threads, pressure, toilets, windows or doors.

The ABS mistake is the costly one. Oatey says the interaction can degrade ABS and lead to product failure, and the failure shows up later as a cracked or leaking drain, not on the day you install it.

Questions people ask

Is plumber’s putty or silicone better for a sink drain?

On a compatible metal, porcelain or PVC drain, putty is what Kohler and Moen sheets call for. Use silicone if any part is ABS.

Can I use silicone instead of plumber’s putty?

Usually, if the fixture maker allows a sealant. It bonds, so the part is harder to remove later.

Can plumber’s putty be used on ABS?

Not Oatey’s. Oatey says its putty products aren’t designed for ABS and points to 100% silicone.

Will plumber’s putty stain granite?

Regular oil-based putty may, per Oatey. Use stain-free putty on granite, marble, quartz and Corian.

How long does plumber’s putty need to dry?

It doesn’t. Oatey says putty needs no cure time, so you can test right away.

How long before silicone can get wet?

Check the cartridge. GE says its Advanced Silicone Kitchen & Bath is water ready in 30 minutes.

Can I use plumber’s putty on a toilet?

No. Oatey says putty isn’t for toilet bases. Use a wax or wax-free ring.

Do I need putty on a garbage disposal flange?

InSinkErator’s steps call for a 1/2 in. rope of putty around the drain opening, unless your model ships with a rubber sink gasket.

Is clear or white silicone better for a sink?

Either seals the same. Clear hides on chrome and stone; white matches white porcelain.

Can I put silicone over old putty?

No. Remove every trace of putty and clean the surface; silicone needs clean, dry, oil-free surfaces to bond.

Does plumber’s putty go bad?

It hardens with long air exposure, per Oatey. Oatey gives its stain-free putty a 1-year shelf life from manufacture.

Can putty go on pipe threads?

No. Use thread tape or pipe dope, as Moen’s sheet does on the drain tailpiece threads.

How I put this together

Why trust me

I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia. In my 7 years of experience, these are the products I’d install. The rules come from Oatey’s current putty guide and stain-free sheet and from Kohler and Moen install sheets, read Oct 23, 2026. Where I add my own advice, it’s labeled.

How I pick

  • One item for each sealing job: regular putty, stain-free putty, silicone, and the gun to apply it.
  • Real brands with maker documents that match the listing.
  • New and in stock on Amazon on the day of the update.
  • No scores: putty and silicone are different kinds of product, so they’re listed as a kit.
  • Prices come from Amazon’s own product data with the time they were read.

Sources

  1. Oatey, “Plumber’s Putty: What It Is, How to Use It and When Not to Use It” (oatey.com blog): read Oct 23, 2026.
  2. Oatey, Stain-Free Plumber’s Putty technical specification (02/19).
  3. Kohler, sink strainer installation guide 105267-2 (techcomm.kohler.com).
  4. Moen, centerset lavatory faucet installation instructions MT169A, two-handle lavatory faucet guide INS2227, and two-handle kitchen faucet guide INS1620C (moen.com).
  5. GE Sealants, Advanced Silicone Kitchen & Bath product data as listed on Amazon by the brand.
  6. Dripless, ETS2000 product data and thrust ratio guide (dripless.com).
  7. InSinkErator, “Installing a New Garbage Disposal” support steps (insinkerator.com): read Oct 23, 2026.
  8. Amazon product data for every product named on this page, read Oct 23, 2026.