Product photo from AmazonMoen’s Brecklyn is my top pick, and I’ve used it. It’s a single-handle pullout with a lever handle and a spray head that docks into the end of a low spout.
Fit is the reason to pick it. Moen’s spec sheet says it’s designed to install through 1, 2, 3 or 4 holes of 1½ inches, so it covers an old four-hole sink with a side sprayer as easily as a single-hole one. [source]
It stands 10-5/32 inches tall on Moen’s drawing, with the spout outlet 6-11/16 inches above the counter and a 9¼-inch reach. That low profile is what lets a pull-out fit under a window sill that a high-arc pull-down would hit. [source]
The pullout spray runs on a 59-inch braided hose. It uses Moen’s Power Clean spray and works in stream or spray mode whether it’s pulled out or docked, per the sheet. [source]
Flow is limited to 1.5 gpm at 60 psi. Moen lists third-party certification to ASME A112.18.1/CSA B125.1, including NSF 61/9 and NSF 372, and says it meets CalGreen and Georgia SB370. [source]
It has Moen’s 1255 Duralast cartridge, a 100-degree handle arc for temperature, and a spout that rotates 120 degrees. Moen gives the maximum deck thickness as 2½ inches. [source]
The warranty is lifetime limited against leaks, drips and finish defects to the original homeowner, 10 years in a multifamily install and 5 years commercial, per the sheet. [source]
Its spout outlet sits 3/32 inch lower than the Method’s (6-11/16 against 6-25/32 inches), close enough that the two pull-outs leave the same room for pots. [source] [source] [source]
Where it lost points: the 59-inch hose scored 8 against the Essie’s 68 inches, and the 120-degree spout scored 7 against a full turn. [source] [source] [source]
My call: on a double-bowl sink, set the faucet behind the divider. A 120-degree swing covers both bowls from the middle but not from the end. [source]

Product photo from Amazon