Choose the Oatey 34083 if your heater permits aluminum, needs a 24-inch pan interior and suits its PVC adapter. Need more room? The 34156 has a 28-inch interior. A pan catches leaks that reach it; its drain and a shutoff do different jobs.
24-inch interior: Oatey 34083$48.74 at AmazonPrice as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
A water heater drip pan must fit the heater instructions and the planned drain. These three Oatey pans cover different fits, and tank gallons alone do not select a pan. A separate shutoff kit has its own section further down.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Interior diameter is the useful first comparison
These are pan interiors from Oatey’s specification sheets. Check outside diameter and the outlet separately before ordering.
Oatey LCS1303 and LCS1280. These bars show size, not quality or drain capacity. FloodStop is not a pan.
Each choice in detail
Each card covers fit, material, the drain connection and when to skip that pan.
Model 3408324 in. inside25 in. outsideMinimum 2½ in. deepAluminum bodyPVC adapter
Buy it if
Your heater allows aluminum and fits a 24-inch interior with the clearance its manual requires. Your drain connection matches the 34083 adapter.
Skip it if
Your heater needs a pan interior over 24 inches, the closet cannot accept the outer rim, or the route requires a different connection.
The Oatey 34083 is the first pan to check when the required interior is 24 inches. Oatey’s LCS1303 selector gives it a 25-inch outside diameter. That extra inch is easy to miss on a store page, especially when a heater sits between a closet wall and a door frame.
Its aluminum body is listed by Oatey for gas or electric heaters. That covers the pan maker’s intended application; the selected heater’s installation manual still decides the required material and clearance. A gas heater also needs its burner air path clear. Do not judge that clearance from the rim alone.
Oatey’s LCS1303 submittal and current 34083 product page describe the adapter differently. Neither pan diameter nor a short listing title settles the socket direction. Have the installer check the adapter in the box against your drain pipe before joining it. Ask Oatey to clarify any mismatch.
My call: choose 34083 for its documented fit, rather than treating every 24-inch pan as interchangeable. Ask the installer to identify the pipe and adapter before purchase. A pipe diameter printed in an Amazon title does not tell you which side of a socket receives that pipe.
Oatey specifies a minimum pan depth of 2½ inches for this aluminum family. That is the wall dimension, not a claim about usable leak capacity. The heater displaces space inside the pan, and the outlet arrangement controls how water leaves. Do not convert the empty pan’s dimensions into a flood guarantee.
Before ordering, record the heater’s outside diameter, the pan interior the manual needs and the available floor width. Then allow room for the actual fitting and service access. The 25-inch outer diameter is not the whole installation footprint because connected pipe extends beyond the pan.
It does not turn that listing into approval for your heater. Have the drain route settled before buying this pan for a finished closet or a room above living space.
Model 3415628 in. inside29 in. outsideMinimum 2½ in. deepAluminum body1 in. PVC adapter family
Buy it if
The heater manual calls for an interior larger than the 34083 provides, and the space accepts a 29-inch pan plus connected piping.
Skip it if
Your floor space is too narrow, you need CPVC at the supplied fitting, or you are choosing a larger pan only to avoid planning a drain.
The Oatey 34156 moves the usable interior up to 28 inches. The matching outside diameter is 29 inches in LCS1303. My call: use this size when the heater’s actual jacket diameter and manual lead there. A gallon rating is not a substitute for measuring the heater.
Under the cited gas manual’s requirement for a pan at least 2 inches wider than the heater, a 26-inch heater leads to a 28-inch minimum interior. That is an example from one manual. A different heater may require a different allowance, shape or arrangement, so read that manual before applying the example.
Oatey puts the 34156 in its 1-inch PVC fitting group. The selector says the fitting goes over 1-inch pipe or inside 1½-inch Schedule 40 pipe. Check the adapter in the box against your drain pipe. Do not infer the 34083’s socket direction from this different model.
The 34156 uses the aluminum family’s minimum 2½-inch depth. A tall wall does not permit water to rise against a burner opening. The cited gas manual limits accumulated water depth separately and says the pan must not restrict combustion airflow. The installer needs to satisfy both requirements.
A 29-inch rim can fit on an open floor yet fail in a narrow utility closet. Check the route used to bring the pan into the room, the floor area around the heater and the space for its outlet. Leave the service clearances required by the heater manufacturer.
Do not buy a 34156 to compensate for a drain that has nowhere to go. A wider pan can still overflow or miss water that sprays beyond its edge. No comparative leak-flow test or installed capacity measurement supports promising that this model will contain a major tank release.
Take the heater diameter and a sketch of the pipe route to the plumber before ordering. If the route is CPVC, select the correct documented CPVC model rather than assuming the supplied PVC adapter will fit.
Model 3406222 in. inside23 in. outside2½ in. deepPlastic polymerElectric heaters
Buy it if
Your electric heater manual permits this plastic pan and the heater fits its 22-inch interior with the required allowance.
Skip it if
You have a gas heater, need a larger interior, or cannot confirm the exact supplied adapter and drain connection.
The Oatey 34062 is a plastic option for an electric heater that fits a 22-inch interior. LCS1280 gives it a 23-inch outside diameter and a 2½-inch depth. It is smaller than either aluminum pan above, so the heater measurement needs to support this choice.
Oatey’s plastic specification names electric water heaters as the application. My call: keep this model out of a gas-heater shortlist. Code discussions about specially qualified plastic do not change the intended application of an ordinary electric-only pan. The pan maker and the heater maker both need to permit the installation.
The plastic sheet lists a polymer thickness of 0.0625 inch. That is a material fact, not a published weight capacity or durability test. I do not use it to claim the pan will resist every impact or support every heater. Follow the heater’s support requirements and check the pan for damage before installation.
The same document gives a Vicat softening temperature of 180°F. That lab property should not be read as a continuous operating temperature limit. It also does not approve the pan or its fitting for T&P safety discharge. Those discharge requirements belong to the heater manual and the adopted plumbing code.
LCS1280 places the 34062 in the PVC-adapter model group. Oatey’s current family page describes the 1½-inch connection as fitting over the pipe. Ask the installer to inspect the actual adapter. Do not borrow the connection drawing from the 34156 aluminum pan simply because both fittings mention PVC.
An electric heat-pump heater needs another check: routine condensate routing. The historical A. O. Smith hybrid manual I read keeps condensate separate and tells the installer not to drain it into the external pan. Use the current instructions for the exact heat-pump heater you own.
Choose this pan for a permitted electric installation with a measured fit. If either the required interior or the material is uncertain, settle that question before choosing between plastic and aluminum.
A shutoff kit to add: FloodStop FS34NPT
A pan catches water that reaches it. This kit stops the incoming supply when its sensor gets wet. It’s a different kind of product, so it isn’t scored against the pans.
FloodStop FS34NPT water heater kit: valve, controller and sensor. Product photo: Amazon.
FloodStop FS34NPT
What the kit manual says
Valve
¾ in. NPT MIP × FIP, motorized
Sensor
Wired; on the floor at the heater base, inside the pan if there is one
Power
AC adapter; four AA alkaline batteries for backup, not included
Extra sensors
In series, accessory 2007–FSAX01
Limit
Water already in the tank and hoses can still escape
Use
Water only; never on a gas line
Pick it if
Your plumber confirms the ¾-inch supply connection fits, and you want the incoming water stopped when the local sensor detects a leak.
Skip it if
You need a pan or a drain route. This kit is an added control and can’t do either job.
On Amazon
Comparison only: this kit is not in the current Amazon price feed, so it carries no price and no buy link here.
The FloodStop FS34NPT is a separate layer beside the pan. Its manual describes a ¾-inch NPT MIP by FIP motorized valve, controller and wired sensor. When the sensor detects water, the valve closes the incoming supply. The kit does not collect or drain the leak.
The limit is explicit in the manual: water already in the heater and hoses may still escape after the supply closes. My call: add this kit where a plumber confirms the connection and installation, but keep the pan and approved drainage plan. Never promise complete flood prevention from a shutoff alone.
FloodStop directs the sensor to the floor at the heater base, inside the pan if there is one. Its paper sleeve prevents contact with conductive surfaces from causing an unwanted alarm. The sensor can still detect water through that sleeve, so a metal pan is not a reason to discard it.
Where the kit does well
What to watch
¾-inch NPT MIP × FIP motorized valve
Does not remove water already in the tank
Sensor belongs inside the pan when one exists
Separate from pan and drainage compliance
AC supply with battery backup in the manual
Water only; never install on a gas line
Additional sensors can connect in series. The manual names accessory 2007–FSAX01 for that job. A second sensor may cover another likely leak path, but the placement should follow the sensor maker’s instructions. Do not move the primary sensor outside the pan just because another installation used a different detector.
The manual supplies an AC adapter and calls for four fresh AA alkaline batteries for backup; batteries are not included. It says to replace them yearly or sooner when needed. An alarm or shutoff needs ongoing attention, unlike an empty pan, so include its test and battery tasks in the household maintenance plan.
This is plumbing work on a pressurized water supply. FloodStop starts with closing the main supply and opening a nearby faucet to relieve pressure. Have a licensed plumber install the valve and follow the heater’s energy-isolation instructions. The valve is for water only and must never go on a gas line.
Confirm the fittings and access to power with the installer before ordering. Follow the manual’s caution: do not plug the AC adapter into an extension cord.
Compare the three pans and the shutoff kit
The three pan diameters are inside measurements. FloodStop controls incoming water; it has no pan dimensions.
Choice and photo
Spec score
Fit / material
Outlet or valve
Limit
Buy
Oatey 34083 24-inch interior
9.0
24 in. ID / 25 in. OD Aluminum; min. 2½ in. deep
PVC: maker descriptions differ; check boxed adapter against drain pipe
ID means inside diameter; OD means outside diameter. Amber marks a limit to check. These pan dimensions do not include the connected pipe or establish installed water capacity.
Match the heater, the floor and the drain
Use the heater’s actual outside diameter and its manual. A 40- or 50-gallon label alone does not establish the required pan size.
The cited gas-heater manual 100400765 asks for a metal pan at least 2 inches wider than the heater. That means an extra 2 inches across the full diameter, not 2 inches on every side. The table applies that particular rule to example heater measurements.
A heater that measures 22 inches across therefore needs at least a 24-inch interior under this example. The Oatey 34083 has that interior, but its outer rim is 25 inches across. Check the actual available floor area and add the outlet and pipe space before deciding it fits.
Heater diameter
Interior needed
Oatey PVC model
Outside diameter
Oatey CPVC model
18 in.
20 in.
34151
21 in.
34171
20 in.
22 in.
34152
23 in.
34172
22 in.
24 in.
34153
25 in.
34173
24 in.
26 in.
34154
27 in.
34174
26 in.
28 in.
34156
29 in.
34176
This is a fit worksheet, not a universal code formula or a list of available offers. The 34153 and 34083 share documented diameters, but Oatey’s descriptions of the 34083 adapter conflict. Check the boxed adapter against the drain pipe. Only the three pans and the FloodStop kit above have buy links.
Original measurement diagram, not to scale. The gap comes from the heater manual; the rim and outlet come from the selected pan.
Do the fit check at the lowest usable part of the pan, rather than assuming a wide top rim creates enough room at the heater base. Keep any required heater support and service openings accessible. If an existing stand changes the arrangement, ask the installer to check the heater and stand instructions together.
My call: write three separate answers on the order note. Record the required interior, the available outer footprint and the exact drain fitting. A pan that passes only the interior check can still leave you with a blocked service panel or a drain connection against the wall.
Material check
Pass only when the heater manual permits the selected pan material.
Space check
Pass only when the outer rim, actual drain fitting and required service access fit the location.
Drain check
If an approved drain destination and route are unresolved, stop before buying or moving the heater.
Choose a material the heater permits
A metal pan body and a plastic drain adapter are separate parts. An aluminum pan with a PVC outlet does not make that outlet suitable for safety discharge.
Heater or situation
Start with
Check before ordering
Gas storage heater
Maker-approved metal pan
100400765 calls for metal and clear burner airflow
Conventional electric heater
Material permitted by its manual
Oatey 34062 family is specified for electric heaters
Electric heat-pump heater
Pan plus separate condensate plan
Read that exact model’s current condensate instructions
Plastic claimed suitable for gas
Exact qualification required
Do not apply that claim to ordinary electric-only 34062
The pan body handles incidental water at the heater base. The adapter joins the pan to its drain route. T&P discharge can involve hot water under a different set of requirements. Keep those approvals separate when a package title mentions aluminum and PVC in the same line.
The cited Oatey plastic sheet lists a 180°F Vicat softening temperature, which is a material test property. It does not establish an installed system’s maximum working temperature. My call: ignore that figure when choosing T&P discharge materials; use the heater’s discharge instructions and the local code instead.
Read the socket direction as well as the size
A nominal pipe size and the words “PVC fitting” do not fully identify the joint. For 34083, the maker’s submittal and current product page describe the adapter differently; check the boxed adapter against the drain pipe.
Pan or family
Documented connection
What changes at the job
34083 aluminum
PVC adapter; submittal and current page differ
Check the adapter in the box against your drain pipe
34156 aluminum
Over 1 in. or inside 1½ in. Schedule 40 PVC
Larger option goes into the pipe
34170–34176 CPVC family
Over 1 in. CPVC
Choose the CPVC model, not a similar PVC pan
34062 plastic
PVC adapter family; current page says 1½ in. over
Inspect the shipped fitting and current sheet
FS34NPT
¾ in. NPT male × female water valve
Threaded supply joint, not a pan drain fitting
Do not connect mismatched plastic materials because they appear to slide together. Have the installer confirm the pipe material, fitting type and joining instructions before assembling the route. If solvent cement is required, follow that cement maker’s ventilation, eye protection and cure instructions; use a pro where the materials are uncertain.
The 34083 and 34153 share a 24-inch interior and 25-inch exterior in Oatey’s selector. Those dimensions do not establish identical adapters. Because the maker’s 34083 descriptions differ, have the installer inspect the actual fitting against your drain pipe. A photo of a round aluminum pan cannot settle the joint.
Keep the three water paths distinct
Pan leakage, T&P safety discharge and routine heat-pump condensate can be present at the same heater. Label each path before changing any piping.
Path
What reaches it
Instruction to follow
Pan drain
Water collected at the heater base
Pan, heater and adopted plumbing-code requirements
T&P discharge
Safety-valve discharge
Exact heater manual and adopted safety-discharge rules
Heat-pump condensate
Water produced during normal operation
Exact condensate instructions and approved receptor
The historical A. O. Smith hybrid guide 100264133 tells the installer to keep condensate and other discharge lines independent. Its completed-piping drawing says not to run condensate into the external pan. That is a useful warning against improvising, rather than a substitute for a newer heater’s own instructions.
For T&P discharge, the gas manual 100400765 specifies approved copper or CPVC able to withstand 210°F and excludes PVC and hose. Those are instructions for that safety line. They do not mean that an Oatey pan supplied with a PVC adapter is incorrectly described.
Never cap a T&P valve or its discharge pipe. If water is coming from that line, have a licensed plumber investigate instead of plugging the outlet or tying it into a convenient pan connection. A change that hides discharge can also hide the warning that the valve is providing.
Find the drain destination before buying
A pan with an unused outlet is unfinished drainage planning. A shutoff can reduce incoming water while still leaving stored tank water to escape.
Proposed route
Decision
Reason
Approved indirect receptor or floor drain
Have the installer verify the route
Outlet size, elevation and local requirements still matter
Outside termination
Check the adopted local rule
Location and termination details vary by code and site
No gravity path identified
Stop and get a drainage plan
A closed valve does not remove stored tank water
Pan outlet capped to hold a leak
Do not call this complete protection
The pan has finite space and no active outlet
Shared T&P / pan arrangement
Licensed plumber must verify
Code family and heater instructions differ
The ICC 2021 IPC training material gives a baseline pan depth of 1½ inches and a minimum ¾-inch pan drain. It describes indirect receptors, floor drains and exterior discharge. These are dated IPC provisions, not a ruling that any route is legal in your town.
The same training describes exterior termination 6 to 24 inches above adjacent ground. Before using that range, the installer must check the adopted edition and amendments.
A replacement exception in one adopted IPC text concerns a previously absent pan drain. It is not blanket permission to omit every pan or leave any new outlet capped. Ask the local authority how the adopted rule applies to the actual replacement and the risk of water damage.
My call: settle the route before moving an installed heater. If the pan outlet is lower than the proposed receptor or the route cannot be approved, the job needs a different professional plan. Do not assume a small pump intended for routine condensate is approved for every leak or discharge.
What a pan stops, and what it cannot promise
The useful question is whether the leak reaches the pan and can leave through its drain. Neither the wall height nor a valve kit supplies a universal containment guarantee.
Water reaches the pan
A properly placed pan gives collected water a route to its connected drain. Keep the outlet and approved route clear.
Water misses the rim
A fitting above the heater can send water outside the pan. Extra detection may cover another path, following the sensor instructions.
Supply valve closes
FloodStop stops incoming supply when it detects a leak. The manual warns that stored water can still escape.
Water near live equipment
Stay away from wet electrical parts. Call a qualified professional for safe isolation; do not stand in water to reach a breaker or heater control.
No installed volume or drain-flow test supports saying these pans hold a fixed number of gallons under a heater. An empty cylinder calculation would leave out the heater base, the outlet position and the connected pipe. It would also miss water that escapes outside the rim.
That is why the pan, drain and detector should each have a clear job. The pan collects water where it lands. The route carries collected water away.
The detector notices water at its sensor, and a compatible shutoff closes its valve. None of those tasks repairs the leaking heater.
Plan a safe installation or retrofit
Adding a pan under a connected heater is a plumbing job. Do not lift or tip a full heater, strain its gas line or disturb its vent to slide in a tray.
1
Record the heater and measurements
Photograph the model label and measure only from a dry, safe position. Give the installer the manual, required pan interior, available outer footprint and proposed outlet route.
2
Isolate before moving anything
Before draining or moving the heater, qualified installers turn the manual gas valve OFF for gas heaters or switch off the breaker for electric heaters, and shut the cold supply. Follow the exact heater’s shutdown procedure, including any electrical isolation for gas models. Verify power is off before electrical work.
3
Let the heater cool and drain as instructed
Hot water can scald. The installer must follow the heater’s cooling and draining procedure before movement. The cited gas manual includes a two-person lifting warning; this is not a one-person tilt job.
4
Fit the pan and approved drain
Have the installer keep the heater supported, its service access clear and the burner air path open. Match the exact pan fitting, pipe material and approved drain destination.
5
Commission the complete installation
Before restoring heat, have the installer refill and check the heater according to its manual. Check the pan connection and route; if FloodStop is fitted, run its documented sensor-and-valve test.
My call: ask for pan work in the same scope as a planned heater replacement when that is practical, rather than assuming an old heater must be replaced at a certain age. Condition, access and connection risk decide the work. I do not use an unsupported eight-year cutoff to delay protection.
For an existing installation, my water heater replacement guide explains the larger job. A pan order should not commit you to unsafe lifting or unplanned gas work. Use the plumber’s site assessment to decide the installation scope before buying parts.
When you find water in the pan
Treat a new wet pan as a reason to investigate. Emptying it without finding the source can hide an ongoing leak.
What you notice from a safe position
What to check with the professional
What to avoid
Water arriving from above
Supply fittings and visible piping
Assuming the tank itself has failed
A T&P line discharging
Heater and system conditions
Capping the line or closing a valve on it
Wet pan at a heat-pump heater
Condensate routing and the exact manual
Treating routine condensate in the pan as normal
Sensor alarm or closed supply valve
Leak source, sensor condition and kit instructions
Reopening repeatedly while water keeps appearing
Water near wiring or gas equipment
Safe shutdown by qualified personnel
Touching wet controls or disturbing gas connections
For a FloodStop alarm, the manual requires a dry sensor before the valve can reopen. Investigate the water source first. A conductive surface can also trigger the sensor if its protective sleeve is missing, but that possibility is not a reason to dismiss water visible in the pan.
Keep a note of where the water first appeared and whether the heater was running. Give that information to the plumber. Do not remove electrical covers or reach under a wet heater for a closer look. Observation from a dry position is enough to start a safe service call.
Where listings and maker documents need care
Similar names can hide different sockets or a different package. Use exact model rows rather than transferring a claim from a neighboring listing.
Listing or shorthand
Maker evidence
Use this interpretation
34083 listing: “White/Aluminum”
Oatey identifies an aluminum pan
“White” does not establish a plastic body
34083 vs 34153
Both 24 in. ID / 25 in. OD; 34083 adapter descriptions conflict
Same fit dimensions do not establish the supplied outlet
34083 current product page vs submittal
Oatey’s current page and LCS1303 describe the adapter differently
Check the adapter in the box against your drain pipe; ask Oatey about any mismatch
34156 listing: “1 In. Adapter”
LCS1303 says over 1 in. or inside 1½ in. PVC
The short title omits the larger-pipe option
34062 listing: “Bulk 22-Inch”
LCS1280: 22 in. inside / 23 in. outside / 2½ in. deep
Bulk catalog quantity is not proof of an Amazon multi-pack
Plastic sheet: “180°F Vicat”
Softening-test property, not service rating
Do not use it as T&P approval
Aluminum thickness
LCS1303 says 22 gauge; current 34083 page says .032 in.
No thickness recommendation until Oatey resolves revision difference
FloodStop kit vs separate components
FS34NPT manual includes valve, controller and sensor
A valve-only listing is not the complete kit
Questions about water heater pans
Is a pan required on a concrete garage floor?
The cited IPC baseline asks whether leakage can cause damage. Concrete alone does not answer that question if water can reach walls or nearby rooms. Have the installer check the adopted local code and the heater manual for that location.
What size pan fits a 40- or 50-gallon water heater?
Measure the heater’s outside diameter and read its manual. The cited gas manual requires a pan at least 2 inches wider across the diameter. Under that example, a 22-inch heater needs a 24-inch pan interior. Gallons alone cannot select the pan.
Does the advertised diameter mean inside or outside?
Check the exact selector row. Oatey 34083 is 24 inches inside and 25 inches outside; 34156 is 28 inches inside and 29 inches outside. Connected piping needs additional space beyond those outer dimensions.
Should I buy aluminum or plastic?
Use a material permitted by both the heater and pan makers. Oatey’s documented aluminum family covers gas or electric heaters. Its 34062 plastic family is specified for electric heaters. Do not treat a general code discussion about qualified plastics as approval for this electric-only pan under gas.
What drain pipe fits the Oatey adapter?
It depends on the model. Oatey’s LCS1303 submittal and current 34083 product page describe its adapter differently. Have the installer check the adapter in the box against your drain pipe. LCS1303 describes 34156 as fitting over 1-inch or inside 1½-inch Schedule 40 PVC.
What if there is no drain near the heater?
Get a drainage plan from a licensed plumber before buying or moving the heater. Local replacement rules can differ. A shutoff can stop incoming water, but water already inside the tank may still escape, so the kit does not settle the drainage requirement.
Can a pan be added under an existing heater?
Often it requires disconnection, draining and movement, which need a site assessment. Use a licensed plumber and follow the heater’s shutoff and cooling instructions. Never tip a full connected heater or strain gas piping, wiring or venting to insert a pan.
Why is there water in the pan?
Possible paths include a piping connection, the tank or incorrectly routed discharge. Water in the pan does not identify the cause by itself. Stay clear of wet electrical parts and have a professional find the source before repeatedly emptying the pan or resetting a shutoff.
Can T&P discharge empty into the pan?
Do not assume so. Code families and heater instructions differ. Have a licensed plumber verify the exact arrangement. Never cap the valve or discharge pipe, and do not use the pan’s PVC-adapter description as approval for a T&P safety-discharge line.
Should the FloodStop sensor go inside or outside the pan?
The FS34NPT manual directs placement at the heater base, inside the pan when one exists. Keep its paper sleeve as instructed to prevent conductive-surface contact from causing unwanted activation. Additional sensors can connect in series to cover other paths.
How I pick and why trust me
Why trust this selection
I select these pans by exact model dimensions, heater instructions and connection details. The recommendations use exact model dimensions, heater instructions and connection details. Each fit recommendation points to a named pan model and keeps the heater manual’s limits visible.
How I pick
I read Oatey’s pan selectors, the cited heater manuals and FloodStop’s kit instructions. I matched the models to Amazon offer reads dated October 20, 2026 and Oct 22, 2026, 2:42 AM EDT.
The three pans share one spec score, set out below, built from documented application and connection facts; it isn’t a leak test. The FloodStop kit is a different kind of product, so it has its own section and no score.
The spec score, check by check
The three Oatey pans get the same three checks, read from Oatey’s selectors LCS1303 and LCS1280, its product pages and the Amazon listings on Oct 20 and 22, 2026, then averaged to one decimal. Every pick has to reach 7.0.
Size isn’t in the score. The heater’s diameter and its manual pick the pan interior first; a bigger pan isn’t a better one. The score only compares what the documents say about each pan’s use and fitting. The FloodStop kit isn’t a pan and isn’t scored.
Check (weight)
How it’s scored
Heater types (⅓)
10 = Oatey lists it for gas or electric heaters (aluminum, LCS1303); 7 = electric heaters only (plastic, LCS1280)
Fitting papers agree (⅓)
10 = Oatey’s selector and product page describe the same fitting; 7 = they describe the adapter differently, so the boxed part must be checked
Listing matches maker (⅓)
10 = the Amazon listing names the exact Oatey model and size in the selector; 0 = it doesn’t
Total
Average of the checks, to one decimal
Pick
Heater types
Fitting papers agree
Listing matches maker
Score
Oatey 34083, 24 in. aluminum
10
7
10
9.0
Oatey 34156, 28 in. aluminum
10
10
10
10
Oatey 34062, 22 in. plastic
7
10
10
9.0
Check
Rule
How it affects the pick
Material
Both makers permit the application
Electric-only plastic is excluded from gas recommendations
Inside and outside dimensions
Exact selector row and heater manual
A fit recommendation remains conditional
Drain connection
Exact fitting and pipe match; resolve conflicting maker descriptions
Similar diameters cannot substitute for model identity
Offer
Genuine exact model, New, fully in stock in October 20 read
Scarce and future-date candidates were excluded
Performance claims
No comparative test data
The spec score uses maker documents only; no installed capacity or flood-duration promise
Maintenance
Follow the exact kit instructions
Sensor tests and backup batteries remain necessary
Sources
Sources
Oatey, Aluminum Water Heater Pans Technical Specification, LCS1303, 10/20, pp. 1–2. Model rows and fitting-group headings. Maker-authored sheet; distributor-hosted copy read October 20, 2026.
Oatey, current 34083 aluminum pan product page, UPC 038753340838. Aluminum application and .032-inch thickness claim; thickness differs from older selector and is not used to rank the pan.
Oatey, Plastic Water Heater Pan Technical Specification, LCS1280, 8/20, pp. 1–2. Maker-authored sheet hosted by Macomb Group; current Oatey plastic-adapter family page also checked.
A. O. Smith-hosted Residential Gas Water Heater Installation Instructions and Use & Care Guide, 100400765_2000621411, November 2025, cover and pp. 4, 14–17. This is a model-specific sizing and safety example.
A. O. Smith Hybrid Electric Heat Pump Water Heater Installation Instructions and Use & Care Guide, 100264133, April 2015, pp. 4–5, 12 and 19. Historical model-specific condensate reference; use the current manual for your heater.
IPS/FloodStop, FS34NPT Water Heater Kit Installation and Operating Manual, Install_FS_20001_FS34NPT, English pp. 1–4. Kit contents, valve, sensor, shutoff limits and testing.
ICC, 2021 IPC/UPC Essentials training presentation, February 26, 2024, pp. 30–31, IPC 504.7. Dated baseline only; adopted local code and amendments control.
Howard County adopted plumbing code, chapter 5, 504.7–504.7.2, and IAPMO 2015 UPC commentary. Local-code examples; adopted rules vary by location.
Amazon offers, October 20, 2026, 11:42 EDT, and again Oct 22, 2026, 2:42 AM EDT. Seller, New condition and stock were read at those times. Product photos come from Amazon, read 2026-10-20 12:02 EDT.