The color is a clue. Read it, then check whether it’s hot, cold or both, and one faucet or the whole house. Those answers point to the cause and the fix.
From one of my jobs: an electric tank water heater. When only the hot water runs brown, the tank is the first place I look.
The short answer
Cloudy water that clears from the bottom up is trapped air. [2] Brown or yellow cold water is usually sediment stirred up in the city main, and it usually clears within a few hours. [2][3]
Brown hot water only points to the water heater. [2] Blue-green stains mean copper, and black means manganese. [1]
Test anything that keeps coming back.
Cloudy, clears in a minute
Air. Harmless.
Brown or yellow, cold taps
Sediment from the city main. Usually clears in a few hours.
Brown or red, hot water only
The water heater. Flush it and check the anode.
Blue-green stains
Copper coming off your pipes. Test it.
Black or dark brown
Manganese. Test it if it keeps coming back.
Pink ring
A bacteria film. Clean it.
How I read discolored water
Discolored water is alarming, but the color is a clue, and most causes are either harmless or fixable. The trick I use is to read three things: the color, whether it is hot, cold, or both, and whether it is one faucet or the whole house. Those three answers point straight at the cause. Here is how to decode it. If your water also smells off, pair this with why your water smells like rotten eggs.
First, run this quick test
Before anything, fill a clear glass and ask: Does the cloudiness clear from the bottom up after a minute? Then it is just air, harmless. Is it hot water only? Look at the water heater. Cold only or both? Look at the main or your pipes. One faucet only? The problem is local to that fixture or its line. Whole house? It is your supply, your main, or city work upstream.
Utilities use the same split. Richmond’s water department says brown, red or yellow water across the cold faucets likely comes from a disturbance in the city’s mains, while discoloration only in the hot water may be the water heater itself. [2]
Decode it by color
What each color usually means
Color
Most likely cause
Safe?
First move
Cloudy / milky white that clears bottom-up
Dissolved air (pressure/temperature)
Harmless
Wait a minute; nothing to fix
Cloudy that does not clear
Fine sediment or hardness
Usually fine; filter helps
Sediment or under-sink filter; test hardness
Brown / yellow / rusty
Rust or sediment, from the main, water heater, or old pipes
Unpleasant, generally not harmful short-term
Check the cold tap every hour or so; it usually clears in a few hours
Reddish (hot water)
Corroding water-heater tank or anode
Flush; may signal aging heater
Flush the tank and check the anode
Blue / blue-green
Copper corrosion (acidic water)
Test; high copper is a concern
Test for copper and pH
Bright blue, right after the water was shut off
Blue toilet-tank cleaner pulled back into the pipes
Do not drink it until it runs clear
Run the cold taps; stop using in-tank cleaners
Green tint from every tap
Algae in the river or lake that supplies the city
Ask the utility
Call the water utility
Black or dark brown, black stains
Manganese
Cosmetic at low levels; test if it persists
Test for manganese
Pink ring in toilets and sinks
Harmless airborne bacteria (Serratia)
Cosmetic, treat if persistent
Clean it; filter or treat if it keeps coming back
The EPA lists the colors metals give water: iron shows up as a rusty color with reddish or orange staining, manganese as black to brown water with black staining, and copper as blue-green staining. At those secondary-standard levels the EPA treats them as taste, color and staining problems, not a health risk. [1] Copper is the one to take seriously at higher levels, which is why blue-green gets a test. [4]
Cloudy or milky water
Nine times out of ten, cloudy water is air, tiny bubbles from pressure or temperature changes, common in winter and after work on the line. Fill a glass and watch it clear from the bottom up; if it does, ignore it.
Richmond’s utility says the same thing: cloudy or white water is typically trapped air, likely in cold water, and it can also come from construction and maintenance work. [2]
This is rust or sediment. Pin it down: if it is hot water only, your water heater is shedding rust or its anode rod is spent, flush the tank and check the anode. If it is cold or both and house-wide, it is often disturbed sediment in the city main (after a hydrant flush or a water-main break).
Run one cold tap for a minute or two, check it again every half hour to an hour, and it usually clears within a few hours. [2][3]
If it keeps returning, your own galvanized pipes may be corroding. One faucet only points to that fixture’s supply line or aerator.
Portland’s water bureau describes stirred-up main sediment as anything from a yellow, tea-colored tint to a brown coffee color. [3]
Here is the routine both utilities give while you wait. [2][3]
1
Run one cold faucet for 1 to 2 minutes, then turn it off. If it’s still colored, check again in a half hour to an hour.
2
Don’t let the water run nonstop. It won’t clear any faster.
3
Go easy on hot water so the sediment doesn’t get pulled into your water heater.
4
Hold off on light-colored laundry so it doesn’t stain.
5
Once the cold water runs clear, run each cold faucet for a minute or two, then clean any aerator screens clogged with sediment.
6
Toilets take longer to clear, because the tank doesn’t empty all the way on each flush.
Portland also suggests bottled water for drinking and cooking until the color is gone. [3]
When only the hot water is discolored
If the cold taps run clear and the hot side is brown or red, the problem is most likely in your water heater. [2] Sediment and minerals build up at the bottom of the tank over time, which is why Richmond’s utility says routine flushing is important. [2] After a city main event, some of that colored water can end up in your tank too, so the hot side can stay colored after the cold side clears. [3] Portland’s options: wait a few hours for it to settle, move the colored water out by running a shower, or have the tank flushed. [3]
If the hot water stays rusty after a flush, the anode rod may be spent or the tank itself may be rusting from the inside. My anode rod replacement guide covers checking and swapping the rod. A tank that keeps shedding rust is getting near the end.
Blue-green, black, or pink
Blue-green water or staining means copper is leaching from your pipes, usually from acidic (low-pH) water, worth a water test because high copper is a health concern and the acidity also drives pinhole leaks.
The EPA ties blue-green staining to copper and corrosive water. [1] Under the EPA’s Lead and Copper Rule, a city system has to act on corrosion when copper tops 1.3 ppm in more than 10% of the homes it samples. [4]
Bright blue water right after a shutoff is a different problem: if you use a blue cleaner in the toilet tank, Richmond warns, the shutoff can siphon tank water back into the house plumbing. [2]
Run the cold taps until it’s gone, and don’t drink it until then.
A green tint at every tap, on the other hand, can be algae in the city’s source water, so call the utility. [2]
Black or dark brown water, or black stains on fixtures, points to manganese. [1]
It’s mostly a staining problem, but test it if it keeps coming back.
Pink rings in toilets and sinks are usually a harmless airborne bacteria (Serratia); clean it and, if persistent, filter or treat.
Orange staining is more likely iron, the same metal behind rusty water. [1]
When to call a plumber or test the water
Give it a few hours first and check the cold tap now and then; a lot of discoloration is temporary and clears itself. [3]
Call a plumber or test your water if: brown water keeps coming back after flushing, you see blue-green (copper) staining, hot water is persistently rusty (aging heater), or the discoloration comes with a bad smell or sudden pressure change. A simple home water test kit for lead, iron, and copper tells you whether it is cosmetic or a real contaminant. If the whole neighborhood has it, call your water utility, it may be their main.
Product photo: Amazon
HOVIRAN 8-way heavy metals test strips
Best for a quick home check on iron, copper and lead
Best for
Brown or blue-green water keeps coming back and you want to know whether it’s iron, copper or something worse before you call anyone.
Skip it if
You need a lab number for lead on a well or for a baby in the house. A mail-in lab kit is the better call; my water test kit picks cover those. The strips don’t test manganese, so black water needs a manganese test.
Specs
125 dip strips; 8 readings per strip: iron, mercury, copper, lead, chromium, magnesium, cadmium and calcium (from the Amazon listing)
The colors and causes come from the EPA’s secondary drinking water standards, which list the color each metal gives water, and from two city water departments’ discolored-water guides (Richmond and Portland). The routine for brown water follows those utilities’ steps. Picks follow the method in How I pick: maker documents, parts availability and fit, never commission rates.
In my 7 years of experience, these are the products I’d install.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my water cloudy or milky?
Almost always it is dissolved air, harmless tiny bubbles caused by pressure or temperature changes, common in cold months or right after work on the water line. The easy test: fill a clear glass and watch it; if it clears from the bottom up within a minute, it is just air and perfectly safe. If it stays cloudy, you likely have fine sediment or hard-water minerals, which a sediment or under-sink filter and a softener can address.
Why is my water brown or yellow?
Brown, yellow, or rusty water is rust or sediment. If it is only in the hot water, the culprit is usually the water heater, sediment in the tank or a spent anode rod, so flush the tank. If it is in the cold or all water and house-wide, it is often stirred-up sediment in the city main after a hydrant flush or main break; run one cold tap for a minute or two, check it again every half hour to an hour, and it usually clears within a few hours. If it keeps returning, your own galvanized pipes may be corroding.
Is discolored water safe to drink?
It depends on the color. Cloudy-from-air water is completely safe. Brown or rusty water is unpleasant and best not consumed, but rust itself is generally not harmful for a short exposure, let it clear before drinking. Blue-green water signals copper leaching, black can indicate manganese, and pink can indicate bacteria, all worth a water test. When in doubt, do not drink discolored water, run it clear first, and use a home test kit or call your utility if it persists or comes with odor.
If your goal is the cleanest possible drinking water, distillation removes nearly all dissolved solids and metals. Here are my picks for the best home water distillers.
Why is my water yellow?
Yellow is usually the light end of the same problem as brown: iron, rust or manganese stirred up in the pipes. Utilities group brown, red and yellow water together. If the cold taps are yellow, the city main is the likely source; if only the hot water is yellow, look at the water heater.
How long does brown water last after a water main break?
Typically a few hours, while the sediment settles back to the bottom of the main. Check once an hour by running one cold faucet for 1 to 2 minutes, then turn it off. Running the water nonstop won’t clear it faster. Until it clears, go easy on hot water so the sediment doesn’t get pulled into your water heater, and hold off on light-colored laundry.