
How to replace a TOTO toilet flapper
Match the tank and valve before choosing a part.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
On this page
Quick answer
Korky 2021 fits listed G-Max tanks. A lifting tower needs its own seal, such as TOTO’s THU407 (or THU474 on an ST403U). TOTO’s own THU500S flapper is a reference here, shown for comparison only; choose it only after matching your tank model and installed flapper to TOTO’s parts instructions.

Check the tank wall and the moving part
A chain lifts a rubber lid off the flush opening. Check the tank model, original part and THU500S instructions before choosing the replacement.
A center assembly lifts instead of a rubber lid swinging on side ears. A THU500S flapper does not replace the gasket on that tower.
Record the tank-wall code and photograph the valve. Stop the fit decision until the model and the installed assembly agree.
Read the code inside the tank, usually on the back wall. TOTO’s current FAQ says the tank number may be stamped in black ink or appear on a sticker. Copy the letters after the digits too: ST743S and ST743E are different entries in parts information.
Do not use the number under the tank lid as your tank model. TOTO now warns that this number identifies the lid. If the tank-wall stamp has faded, a photo of the whole toilet and the installed flush valve is more useful than guessing from the lid.
On a conventional flapper assembly, the rubber part pivots on attachments beside the overflow tube. A tower assembly has a separate moving center and seal. Leave the tank-to-bowl bolts alone during this identification check; taking the tank off is outside a simple flapper swap.
Test whether the flush valve leaks
- 1Fill the tank normally
Flush and let the fill valve stop. Mark the water level inside the tank with a pencil. This mark belongs to the leak test, not the THU500S closing-level adjustment later.
- 2Close the water supply
Shut off the valve behind the toilet before the test. If the valve will not shut off, leaks at its stem or feels seized, stop and have a plumber make the supply safe. Do not force it.
- 3Leave the toilet unused
TOTO’s current FAQ gives a 4–6 hour wait in one diagnostic answer. Keep the supply off and do not flush during that wait. The same FAQ gives 2–4 hours in another answer; both compare a full tank with the supply isolated.
- 4Compare the level with your mark
A significant drop points toward the flush valve or its seal. A nearly unchanged level points toward the fill valve instead. Check for water outside the tank too; an external leak is a separate repair.
A falling level identifies a leak path, not one guaranteed failed part. On a flapper tank, inspect the rubber, chain and valve seat. On a tower tank, identify its seal. Do not assume every running TOTO needs THU500S.
If the water stays near your pencil mark but the toilet runs again after the supply is restored, follow the fill-valve diagnosis. TOTO fill valve replacement covers that different part. Replacing the flapper cannot correct a fill valve that will not shut off.
If a new flapper still leaks, repeat the isolated-water check before changing another part. A chain can keep the seal off its seat, and TOTO’s installation manual specifically says to check for a tangled chain and an incorrectly positioned flapper arm. Start with those visible checks.
Replace a hinged flapper with the water off
- 1Record the original setup
With the tank accessible, note the model code, chain attachment and any adjuster position. Use the THU500S package chart for the exact model. Keep the ceramic lid on a stable protected surface away from the work.
- 2Isolate the supply and empty the tank
Close the toilet shutoff, then flush. TOTO’s servicing instructions begin with shutting off the water. Sponge out remaining water if needed for access. Stop if the supply keeps refilling the tank or water appears at a connection.
- 3Remove the old flapper
Unhook its chain from the trip lever and release the flapper from its side attachments. Keep the stationary flush valve in place. If the hinge mounting is broken or the valve seat is damaged, a rubber-only replacement may not solve the leak.
- 4Seat the correct new flapper
Fit both side attachments to the matching valve mounts. Let the rubber rest evenly over the opening. For Korky 2021, use your tank model’s Chain Link # in its illustrated instructions. For THU500S, use its own chain setting. A taut chain can hold the flapper open.
- 5Apply the model-specific settings
For THU500S, match the arrow, chain length and lever hole to your model’s row. If that row is starred, insert the flapper plug as directed by the sheet’s starred note. Korky 2021 has its own model-specific Chain Link # chart; THU500S settings do not apply to it.
- 6Restore water and check operation
Open the supply and let the tank refill. Flush several times. Check that the handle returns, the chain clears nearby parts and the flapper drops back onto its seat. Look for water outside the tank before replacing the lid.
These steps cover the accessible hinged flapper, not tank removal, an in-wall tank, a pressure-assisted vessel or an electronic flush mechanism. Stop for a leaking shutoff, cracked china or a broken fixed valve mount. Cracked china ends the repair conversation: at that point the money goes further on a replacement TOTO toilet than on more parts. A licensed plumber can assess those repairs.
Parts for flapper and tower tanks


TOTO THU407 tower seal gasket
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
| Part | Key specs | Pick it if | Skip it if |
|---|---|---|---|
| TOTO THU500S flapper (reference, not linked) | THU500S, 3-inch flapper, Model-specific setup | Your actual flapper assembly and TOTO parts information call for THU500S or a documented superseded part. | Your tank uses a tower seal, a 2-inch flapper or an unidentified valve. |
| Korky 2021 red flapper | Korky 2021 / 2021BP, 3-inch opening, Five-year maker warranty | Korky’s 2021 fit list names your tank and you have its matching flapper valve. | Your tank is on Korky’s exclusion list, has a tower, or still needs identification. |
| TOTO THU407 tower seal gasket | THU407, Seal gasket, 1 piece, Tower-type drain valves, 10-pack: THU370 | Your tank has a vertical flush tower, its code ends in T, and TOTO’s parts list for your model names THU407. | Your tank has a hinged flapper, or its parts list names a different seal or none. |
Reference (not linked): the TOTO THU500S, shown for comparison only
The valve inside your tank decides which part you need, so none of the three parts on this page is scored. Links go to listings sold by Amazon.com.
Choose THU500S when TOTO’s parts information names it for the flapper assembly actually in your tank. It is the starting point for a confirmed hinged-flapper repair, rather than a reason to assume every TOTO has the same valve. The maker’s parts store lists it as a 3-inch universal toilet flapper.
That store lists THU175S, THU138S and THU331S among the older parts it replaces. An old THU175S number therefore does not mean you must find old stock with that same number. Match the replacement instruction sheet to the tank model before you discard the original chain arrangement.
The fit decision has another limit on the Drake CST743S. Its PD-00237 parts manual illustrates both flapper-type and tower-type assemblies. Seeing CST743S on the china is useful evidence, yet you still need to look inside. A hinged flapper and a lifting tower are different repairs; THU500S covers only the matched flapper.
Where it does well
- Replaces older THU175S, THU138S and THU331S references
- Named in the Entrada CST243EF / CST243EFR parts manual
What to watch
- Does not replace a lifting tower’s gasket
- Arrow, chain and lever-hole setup depend on the model
The Entrada CST243EF and CST243EFR parts manual is more direct for the illustrated assembly: it names THU500S as the flapper with chain and hook. Use that full model reference and compare the illustrated valve with the one installed. A similar-looking tank or a shared marketing family name is weaker evidence than the parts diagram.
THU500S also needs setup after it is attached. Its instruction sheet gives an arrow setting, chain length and lever hole for each listed toilet. Starred model rows also require insertion of the flapper plug. Match all applicable settings instead of choosing the dial position from the color of the old rubber.
Keep the package instructions until the tank passes both a normal flush check and the isolated-water test. A flapper that opens can still fail to close correctly. If the tank loses water after the chain clears and the flapper sits flat, inspect the stationary seat and verify the valve assembly before replacing another rubber part.
Korky 2021 for listed G-Max tanks
Korky 2021 is a useful alternative when its own fit list names your G-Max tank and the installed valve still uses the matching hinged flapper. Keep its brand clear. This is a Korky part with a published TOTO fit list, rather than an unidentified listing that merely repeats a TOTO part number.
Korky lists the 2021 as a replacement for THU138S, THU175S and THU331S. It names ST743S and ST744S among the compatible tanks. That gives you two things to check: the original flapper reference and the full tank suffix. An S-to-E change is enough to require another look at the compatibility list.
The exclusions are especially useful. Korky says this red 2021 flapper does not fit ST743E, ST744E, ST754E, ST784E or ST794E. It also excludes CST853, CST853E, CST854 and CST854E. Do not read “fits TOTO” in the listing title as permission to ignore those model-specific limits.
Where it does well
- Korky names compatible and excluded tank models
- Includes a stainless steel chain
What to watch
- Excluded from ST743E and several other E-suffix models
- Three-inch diameter alone does not confirm fit
For the matched valve, the part has an oversized sealing surface for a 3-inch opening and includes a stainless steel chain. Korky describes the rubber as chlorine resistant. That material claim does not make tank-cleaning tablets acceptable: TOTO warns against in-tank bowl cleaners because concentrated chlorine can damage tank fittings.
Korky publishes a five-year warranty for 2021 and lists 2021BP among its alternate package numbers. Keep the receipt and package identification if that warranty matters to your decision. A warranty term does not establish that an excluded tank fits, and it is not a prediction of how long your particular seal will last.
Use the model-specific Chain Link # chart in Korky’s illustrated 2021BP instructions to attach its chain. The THU500S adjustment table does not apply to this part. After fitting the Korky chain, watch the handle return and flapper closure. If the tank has a lifting tower or a different fixed valve, identify that assembly first.
TOTO THU407 for a tower tank
THU407 is the pick when the moving part in your tank is a vertical flush tower, not a hinged flapper. TOTO lists it as a one-piece seal gasket. In the Drake CST743S parts manual, PD-00237, it sits beside the THU440-A flush tower and the THU443.10B-A drain valve for tower type, while THU500S is listed as the flapper with chain.
TOTO’s installation manual 0GU048Z has its own parts table for the flush tower type drain valve. It names THU407 as the seal gasket for tower tanks including ST743S(B)T, ST743E(B)T, ST744ET, ST754ET and ST784ET. TOTO’s parts manuals mark that last T as the drain valve tower, so read every letter on the tank wall.
The same gasket appears in TOTO’s parts manuals for the Eco Ultramax (MS853113E), the Ultramax II (MS604114CEF) and the Drake Transitional (CST786CE), where it’s called the flush valve seal gasket. TOTO also lists THU370 as a 10-piece pack for the same job. This listing is the single gasket.
Where it does well
- Genuine TOTO part, named in TOTO’s parts manuals
- Listed for many tower tanks, from Drake to Ultramax
- Replaces the seal only, not the tower
What to watch
- Won’t fit a hinged-flapper tank
- The tower comes out to fit it
- ST403U lists its own gasket, THU474
TOTO’s manual shows the tower routine for its ST453U and ST403U tanks. Shut off the supply, flush, and sponge out what’s left. Unclip the trip lever gear box and set it aside, then rotate and pull up on the flush tower. The grey rubber gasket comes off the tower for a rinse under running water before it goes back on.
That rinse is worth doing first. If the tank still drops below your pencil mark with the supply off after the gasket is cleaned and the tower is snapped back in, a new THU407 goes on in its place. Your own model’s sheet still decides the steps, because tower housings differ.
Know what THU407 doesn’t cover. It won’t fit a hinged-flapper tank, and it isn’t the tower itself. TOTO lists the tower and the drain valve as separate parts. In that table, ST403U shows no separate flush tower (N/A) but lists its own seal gasket, THU474, so don’t substitute THU407 there.
My call: When the tank code ends in T, TOTO’s parts list names THU407 for your model, and the leak test points at the flush valve, the seal gasket is the part to check before buying a whole tower. A T suffix is a clue, not a fit rule.
Compare the two flapper options
| Part | Use | Checked fit evidence | Trade-off | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
TOTO THU500S | Listed TOTO 3-inch flapper tanks | Replaces THU175S / THU138S / THU331S and other listed references | Requires the correct model settings; no tower-seal fit | Reference (not linked) |
Korky 2021 | Listed G-Max flapper tanks | Korky lists ST743S and ST744S; stainless chain included | Excludes ST743E / ST744E and other named models | Check price on Amazon |
TOTO THU407 | Listed TOTO tower-type tanks | Named in TOTO’s tower parts table and parts manuals | Tower tanks only; the tower comes out to fit it | Check price on Amazon |
TOTO flapper replacement chart: model plus assembly
Use this chart as a checkpoint, then compare the valve in your tank with its parts drawing. The Drake example matters: one current parts sheet can list both a flapper and tower components. Check the moving seal before choosing THU500S, even when the tank code appears in a compatible model list.
| Tank or original part | Documented route | Physical check before choosing |
|---|---|---|
| ST743S / CST743S Drake | PD-00237 illustrates flapper-type and tower-type assemblies | Hinged flapper: check THU500S. Tower: identify the gasket instead. |
| ST743S(B)T, ST744ET, ST754ET and other T tanks | TOTO 0GU048Z tower table: THU407 seal gasket | Confirm a vertical tower, then check the gasket on it. |
| CST243EF / CST243EFR Entrada | PD-00758 item 6: THU500S flapper with chain and hook | Confirm the illustrated hinged-flapper valve is still installed. |
| ST743S or ST744S, with the matching G-Max flapper | Korky 2021 names both tanks | Confirm the old flapper reference and the actual valve match. |
| ST743E / ST744E / ST754E / ST784E / ST794E | Korky 2021 expressly excludes these | Use exact-model TOTO parts information; do not choose 2021 by size. |
| THU138S / THU175S / THU331S on the original part | TOTO THU500S supersession list; Korky 2021 replacement list | Read the tank suffix and both parts’ fit limits before choosing. |
| THU140S / THU299S / THU253S / THU277S | TOTO’s THU500S supersession list | Do not extend Korky 2021’s narrower list to these numbers. |
| THU347S / THU275S / THU332S / THU369S / THU499S | TOTO’s THU500S supersession list | Confirm a flapper assembly and use its current instruction sheet. |
| A lifting tower or a 2-inch flapper | Outside these two flapper recommendations | Use the matching parts manual; no flapper-to-tower substitution. |
The table does not say that every tank bearing one family name has the same internal parts. If the valve has been changed since installation, its present hardware also needs identification. Record the model, the moving part and the old part number together.
Why the last letters matter
ST743S appears on Korky 2021’s compatibility list; ST743E appears on its exclusion list. That is a direct maker distinction, even though both codes start with ST743. Keep the final letter in a phone photo or written note. Searching only “Drake flapper” loses the distinction you need.
The same caution applies to ST744S and ST744E. Korky names the S model and excludes the E model for 2021. Do not assume its red rubber and 3-inch size give it the broader coverage of the adjustable THU500S. The part number and model list decide that.
If your model is absent from the chart, that is a reason to read its own parts sheet. The chart covers the checked examples and older flapper references shown here. It is not a complete list of TOTO tanks, and a missing model is not proof of compatibility.
| Information to keep | Example | What it prevents |
|---|---|---|
| Full tank-wall code | ST743S rather than only 743 | Losing the S/E distinction |
| Actual moving seal | Hinged rubber lid or vertical tower | Confusing a flapper with a tower gasket |
| Original flapper reference | THU175S, if present | Treating all 3-inch rubber parts as identical |
| Present valve photograph | Wide view plus hinge or tower close-up | Assuming the original valve is still installed |
Set THU500S from its own chart
The THU500S sheet gives an arrow setting, chain length and lever hole for each listed model. Match the whole row. Starred rows also require the flapper plug. Copying only the arrow number can leave a required plug out, even when the replacement is the correct 3-inch size.
For Korky 2021, find the tank model in the illustrated 2021BP instructions and use its Chain Link #. That chart belongs to the Korky part; do not copy a THU500S chain setting. Check that the chain lifts the flapper and lets it close after attachment.
Use minimal chain slack as the THU500S instructions direct. TOTO’s toilet installation manual also says to make sure the chain is not tangled and the flapper arm is positioned correctly. Watch those parts through a complete flush after reconnecting them; a free handle at rest is only the first check.
For an unidentified model, the THU500S sheet gives a closing-water-level method. With the water off, flush and mark the tank level when the original flapper closes. Install the new flapper with minimal slack, restore the supply and let the tank fill. Flush again and compare the new closing level with that mark.
| Setup check | Instruction to follow |
|---|---|
| THU500S model row | Match the arrow, chain length and lever hole. |
| Star beside a THU500S setting | Insert the flapper plug as directed by the starred note. |
| Korky 2021 / 2021BP | Use the model-specific Chain Link # in Korky’s illustrated instructions. |
| THU500S closing-level result | Maker’s adjustment direction |
|---|---|
| New flapper closes with water below the original mark | Move the arrow to a lower number. |
| New flapper closes with water above the original mark | Move the arrow to a higher number. |
| Original flapper will not close normally | Its closing level is not a dependable baseline. Identify the model and use the correct instructions. |
| The replacement is Korky 2021 or a tower seal | Do not apply this THU500S adjustment method to a different part. |
The closing-level mark measures the point where the flapper shuts during a flush. The earlier leak-test mark measures a full tank at rest. Keep these checks separate; changing the fill level is not the THU500S arrow adjustment.
Where broad product names need a closer check
| Listing or short description | Maker’s more specific information | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| THU500S: “Select TOTO 3 Inch Flush Valve Tanks” | TOTO’s store calls it universal but gives a specific supersession list. PD-00237 also lists a tower and seal. | Use THU500S only for the confirmed flapper assembly. |
| Korky: “Fits TOTO” in the Amazon title | Korky 2021 names compatible tanks and explicitly excludes several E-suffix tanks. | Apply those exclusions, including ST743E, before buying. |
| Two red 3-inch flappers | Korky 2021 lists THU138S / THU175S / THU331S; TOTO THU500S has a longer supersession list. | Color and diameter do not make their coverage identical. |
A shared THU175S replacement reference does not make the two fit lists identical. Do not infer equal coverage from the shared THU175S reference, or claim that one rubber material seals better without a check on the actual valve.
If the new flapper still leaks
| What you see | Check next | What to avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Flapper held slightly open | Chain slack, lever return and a chain caught on another part | Shortening the chain until it pulls the seal up at rest |
| Flapper drops but tank loses water | Correct model fit, clean seating surface and fixed valve condition | Assuming a second rubber part will repair a damaged seat |
| Water stays at the test mark with supply off | Fill-valve diagnosis when the supply is restored | Treating every refill sound as a flapper leak |
| Tower moves vertically | Its model-specific sealing gasket and valve diagram | Attaching a hinged THU500S in place of a tower seal |
| Water appears outside the tank | Shutoff, supply connection, tank bolts or cracked china | Continuing the flush test while an external leak spreads |
Keep the work limited to the component you identified. A tank-to-bowl gasket seals a different joint from the flapper seat, and the Drake parts sheet lists those parts separately. If water is outside the tank, close the supply and locate that external leak before another flush.
Avoid in-tank bowl-cleaner tablets. TOTO’s installation manual warns that high concentrations of chlorine or chlorine-related products can damage fittings and cause leakage. Korky’s chlorine-resistant rubber claim does not override the toilet maker’s cleaning rule. Do not add chemicals to try to make a mismatched flapper seal.
Use a plumber for a shutoff that cannot isolate the supply, damaged china, or a repair that needs removal of the fixed valve or tank. This flapper procedure does not cover those joints. It also does not cover wiring or the internal parts of an electronic TOTO system.
The supply isolates, the valve mounts are intact and the new flapper matches the tank and assembly. Finish with normal flushing and the isolated-water check.
A missing tank suffix, a tower or changed valve hardware makes the fit unresolved. Identify that hardware before selecting a rubber part.
Keep the supply off if you can safely isolate it. Do not force a seized stop or work on leaking or cracked china. Have a licensed plumber assess the repair.
Questions about TOTO flapper fit
What replaces a TOTO THU175S flapper?
TOTO’s parts store lists THU500S as a replacement for THU175S. Korky also lists 2021 for that older flapper reference, subject to its tank-model fit list and exclusions. Confirm that your installed valve is a hinged-flapper type before choosing either.
Which flapper fits a TOTO ST743S?
TOTO’s current FAQ names THU500S for ST743S. Korky lists ST743S for 2021 too. However, TOTO’s PD-00237 parts sheet also illustrates a tower-type assembly, so check which assembly is physically installed before choosing a flapper.
Can Korky 2021 fit a TOTO ST743E?
No. Korky specifically excludes ST743E from 2021’s fit list. ST743S is listed, but that does not extend coverage to the E-suffix tank. Use the exact tank model and its present valve assembly to identify the correct part.
Is THU500S a universal replacement for every TOTO?
No. TOTO’s store describes THU500S as a 3-inch universal flapper and names the older flappers it replaces. It is not a replacement for a tower’s separate gasket or a 2-inch flapper. The tank and installed valve still need to match.
Where is my TOTO tank model number?
TOTO’s current FAQ says to look for the sticker or black-ink stamp on the inside back wall of the tank. Keep the full letters and digits. It warns against using the number under the lid, because that identifies the lid rather than the tank.
Why does my TOTO still run after replacing the flapper?
First check whether the chain is tangled or holds the flapper open, and confirm the part matches your valve. Repeat the water-level test with the supply off. A significant drop points to the flush-valve side; a nearly unchanged level points toward the fill valve.
Which flapper does the Entrada CST243EF use?
TOTO’s PD-00758 v.09 parts manual lists THU500S as item 6 for CST243EF and CST243EFR. Confirm that the illustrated flapper assembly is the one still installed in your tank.
Do I need to remove the tank to change the flapper?
For the accessible hinged flapper covered here, the replacement is inside the tank at the valve mounts and chain. Tank removal is a different repair. Stop if the fixed mounting points or valve seat are damaged, or the supply will not shut off.
Does chlorine-resistant rubber allow in-tank cleaners?
No. TOTO warns against in-tank bowl cleaners because concentrated chlorine-related chemicals can damage fittings and cause leaks. Korky’s chlorine-resistance claim for 2021 does not change that toilet-care instruction.
How we pick and why trust us
Why trust us
Isaac Daniels is a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia. For this TOTO repair, we use the tank parts sheets and the replacement makers’ fit limits. The recommendation depends on the tank suffix and valve assembly, a checked part-number match.
How we pick
We checked TOTO’s parts information, its current FAQ and Korky’s 2021 compatibility list. For the THU407 tower seal we read TOTO’s tower parts table and four of its parts manuals. We re-read the No-name listings are excluded. We do not assign scores to parts whose fit depends on the installed valve.
On Oct 22, 2026, 12:06 PM EDT, CPSC’s recall search listed no TOTO recalls.
| Fit check | Rule used here |
|---|---|
| Tank identification | Keep the full tank-wall model and suffix. |
| Assembly identification | Separate a hinged flapper from a lifting tower. |
| Replacement reference | Use TOTO’s supersession list and the exact parts sheet. |
| Aftermarket fit | Apply Korky’s named exclusions as well as its compatible models. |
| Recommendation limit | No performance ranking or assumed compatibility from diameter alone. |
Sources
- TOTO USA, Product FAQ, sections on running toilets, flapper replacement and model-number location; read October 20, 2026.
- TOTO Parts Store, THU500S 3-inch universal flapper and superseded-part list; read October 20, 2026.
- TOTO, PD-00237 v.10, CST743S / ST743S Drake parts manual, December 2021, page 1.
- TOTO, PD-00758 v.09, CST243EF / CST243EFR Entrada parts manual, April 2025, page 1.
- TOTO, THU500S instruction sheet, copyright 2017, model setup and closing-level procedure; maker document hosted by Unilog.
- TOTO, 0GU008Z 1.6 GPF toilets installation manual, English pages 6–7, chain checks, water shutoff and in-tank cleaner warning.
- Korky, Large 3-inch Fits TOTO Red Toilet Flapper, part 2021, specifications and compatible/excluded models; read October 20, 2026.
- Korky, 2021BP illustrated installation instructions, model-specific Chain Link # chart; read October 20, 2026.
- TOTO, 0GU048Z installation manual, flush valve maintenance steps (ST453U and ST403U tanks) and the flush tower type drain valve parts table; PD-00159 (MS853113E Eco Ultramax), PD-00640 (MS604114CEF Ultramax II) and PD-01371 (CST786CE Drake Transitional) parts manuals, THU407 and THU370 seal gaskets. Read Oct 22, 2026, 12:06 PM EDT.
- Amazon product listings for the flappers and seal gasket named on this page, read Oct 27, 2026.
- CPSC recall search (saferproducts.gov), Oct 22, 2026, 12:06 PM EDT: TOTO 0 recalls.

