Water pooling around the base of a toilet, or a faint sewage smell that will not go away, almost always means one thing: the wax ring under the toilet has failed. It is the cheap doughnut of wax that seals the toilet to the drain flange, and when it gives out, every flush weeps a little water (and gas) onto your floor. Replacing it is a genuine half-day DIY job, the part costs a few dollars, and doing it now saves you from rotting out the subfloor. This is different from a tank or supply-line drip, if your toilet is running or leaking from the tank, that is a separate fix.
First, Confirm It Is the Wax Ring
Before you pull the toilet, rule out the impostors. Wipe the base bone dry, then watch where water shows up. Water that appears only when you flush, seeping from under the base, is the wax ring. Water that drips between flushes usually comes from the tank-to-bowl bolts, the supply line, or condensation on the tank, none of which need the toilet pulled. A wax-ring failure also often brings a sewer smell, because the seal is what blocks gas.
What You Will Need
A new wax ring (buy one with a plastic horn for a better seal), a set of closet bolts, a putty knife, a sponge and bucket, and rags. If your closet flange is cracked or sitting below the finished floor, grab a flange repair ring and a wax ring extender too, that is the most common surprise on this job.
How to Replace the Wax Ring, Step by Step
- Shut off and drain. Close the supply stop, flush, and hold the handle to empty the tank. Sponge out the last water in the tank and bowl, a wet/dry vac is faster.
- Disconnect. Unscrew the supply line, then pop the caps and remove the two closet-bolt nuts at the base.
- Rock and lift. Straddle the bowl, rock it side to side to break the old wax seal, and lift straight up. Set it on a towel or cardboard, it will be heavy and the bottom will be waxy.
- Scrape the old wax. Put a rag in the drain so gas does not escape, then scrape every bit of old wax off the flange and the bottom of the toilet with a putty knife. Clean it to bare surface.
- Check the flange. The flange should sit on top of the finished floor. If it is cracked, set a metal repair ring over it; if it sits low, use an extender or a thicker wax ring. New closet bolts go in the flange slots now.
- Set the new ring. Press the new wax ring onto the flange (or onto the toilet horn, either works, manufacturer’s preference). Pull the rag out of the drain.
- Reset the toilet. Lower the bowl straight down over the bolts, sit on it to compress the wax evenly, and do not rock it once it is seated, that breaks the seal. Hand-tighten the nuts alternately, snug, never gorilla-tight or you crack the china.
- Reconnect and test. Reattach the supply, open the stop, and run several flushes while watching the base. Dry for a day means you nailed it.
The Pro Mistakes to Avoid
Three things ruin this job. Rocking the toilet after it is set (breaks the wax, guaranteed re-leak). Over-tightening the bolts (cracks the base, now you need a new toilet). And ignoring a flange that sits below the floor, stacking two wax rings is a band-aid; an extender ring is the right fix. Take the extra ten minutes on the flange and this seal lasts 20-plus years.
When to Call a Pro
Most homeowners can do this. Call a plumber if the closet flange is broken off or below a tiled floor (that can mean cutting into the drain), if the subfloor under the toilet is soft or rotted from a long-running leak, or if you simply cannot lift the toilet safely. A rotted flange or subfloor is a bigger repair than the wax ring itself, and worth a pro’s eyes.
Before you pull the toilet, make sure the wax ring is actually the culprit — see water around the base of your toilet to rule out loose bolts, the tank gasket, or condensation first.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my toilet wax ring is bad?
The classic signs are water seeping out around the base of the toilet right after a flush, a persistent sewage smell in the bathroom, and sometimes a slightly rocking or loose toilet. If the base stays dry between flushes but weeps when you flush, the wax ring is almost certainly the culprit. Water that appears between flushes is more likely the tank bolts or supply line, not the wax ring.
Should I use a wax ring or a wax-free seal?
Both work. Traditional wax rings are cheap and proven, but you only get one shot, set the toilet wrong and you start over. Wax-free rubber or foam seals cost a bit more, let you reposition the toilet without ruining the seal, and do not melt in a hot attic bathroom. For a first-timer, a wax-free seal forgives mistakes; for a pro who sets it once, classic wax is fine.
Can I replace a toilet wax ring myself?
Yes, it is one of the more doable plumbing jobs, plan about two hours. The hard parts are lifting the toilet without dropping it and getting the flange right. The two rules that prevent a repeat leak are: do not rock the toilet once it is seated on the new ring, and do not over-tighten the bolts or you will crack the bowl. If the flange or subfloor is damaged, that is when to call a plumber.
Fix the 12 Most Common Plumbing Problems Yourself — Free Plumber’s Handbook — including the toilet fixes plumbers charge $150+ for
Step-by-step fixes for the 12 most common problems — and exactly when to call a pro. Free and instant, from a licensed plumber. Save hundreds on calls you didn’t need.