S-trap vs P-trap at a glance
Both hold a plug of water in a U-bend to stop sewer gas. The difference is what happens after the bend.
| P-trap | S-trap | |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | U-bend, then a level arm | U-bend, then a second bend straight down |
| Where the drain goes | Into the wall | Into the floor |
| Vent | A vent fitting on the arm | None |
| Water seal | Stays put: air comes in from the vent | Can siphon out behind a full basin of water |
| Code status | Required under sinks, tubs and showers | Banned: IPC 1002.3, IRC P3201.5, UPC 1004.1 [1] [2] |
| Where you see it | Homes built to a modern code | Older homes, built before codes changed (Oatey) |
| On a toilet | Toilet-maker term for a wall outlet | Toilet-maker term for a floor outlet |
The letters come from the shape turned on its side. A P-trap looks like a P lying down: the round part is the bend and the stem is the arm into the wall. An S-trap adds a second curve, so the pipe leaves the bend and dives down.
That second curve is the whole problem. It turns the pipe below the trap into a vertical column of water every time the sink empties, and nothing lets air in to break the pull.
Why an S-trap loses its water seal
A trap only works while the water stays in the bend. An S-trap gives that water a way out.
When you pull the stopper on a full sink, water fills the outlet leg and falls down the pipe as a slug. Oatey describes what comes next: the water flowing down pulls water out of the trap and can leave it dry.
Codes put a number on how much pull a trap can take. IPC 901.2 says the vent system must keep the pressure on a trap seal within 1 inch of water column (249 Pa). A trap’s seal is only 2 to 4 inches deep by code (IPC 1002.4, IRC P3201.2, UPC 1005.1), so it doesn’t take much to empty it. [1] [3] [2]
In a P-trap, the arm runs level to a vent fitting. When the water passes the vent, air rushes in from the vent pipe, the pull breaks and the bend keeps its water. That’s the job IRC P3201.3 gives the vent: protect the seal from siphonage, aspiration and back pressure. [2]
| What you notice | What it means |
|---|---|
| A gurgle or slurp after the sink drains | Possible venting or drainage problem; a gurgle alone does not prove the seal is gone |
| Sewer smell under the sink, worse in the morning | Possible dry trap or another drain-gas leak; I trace the source before deciding on a repair |
| You can’t see water when you look down the drain | The seal may be low or dry, but the drain view alone is inconclusive |
| Smell goes away after running the tap | A dry seal may have refilled; I check why it lost water |
A dry trap lets drain gas into the room. If the smell is strong or you feel unwell, leave the affected area and seek professional help. Do not stay inside to diagnose it. For a mild drain odor, I check for a dry trap and refill it with water.
Which codes ban S-traps
All three model codes used in the US name the S-trap in their list of prohibited traps.
| Code | Section | What it says | Same list also bans |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 IPC | 1002.3, item 5 [1] | “S” traps are prohibited | Bell, crown-vented, drum and moving-part traps, and partition traps that aren’t corrosion-resistant |
| 2024 IRC | P3201.5, item 3 [1] [2] | “S” traps are prohibited | Bell, drum and moving-part traps, and partition traps that aren’t corrosion-resistant |
| 2024 UPC | 1004.1 [1] | S traps and crown-vented traps are prohibited, and vent protection is required under UPC 1002.1 [1] | Moving-part traps (also 1004.2), traps with interior partitions unless corrosion-resistant [3] |
| Georgia (2026) | IPC 2024 with state amendments [1] | Uses the IPC list. Georgia left out the IRC’s plumbing chapters, so houses follow the IPC too | Same as the IPC |
The IPC and IRC are written by the International Code Council. The UPC comes from IAPMO. Your state or city adopts one of them, sometimes with its own changes, and the building department is the final word.
All three agree on the seal depth and on the reason for the vent, which is why they all land on the same answer for the S-trap. None of them treats it as a style choice.
- Bell trap
An old floor drain with a cup over the opening. Banned in the IPC and IRC lists.
- Drum trap
A round canister, often under old tubs. Banned except as a solids interceptor or on chemical waste (IPC 1002.3 exception). [1]
- Crown-vented trap
A vent tapped right at the top of the bend. The IPC bans it in 1002.3 and says no vent within two pipe diameters of the weir (909.3). [1]
- Trap with moving parts
A check valve or flap in place of water. The UPC says bladders and check valves can’t serve as a trap (1004.2). [3]
How to spot an S-trap under your sink
Open the cabinet and follow the pipe from the sink down. Three shapes tell you what you have.
| What you see after the U-bend | What it is | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| A level pipe into the wall | P-trap | Nothing to change if it drains and doesn’t smell |
| A level pipe to a tee with a cap or pipe rising from it, then down into the floor | P-trap with a vent or AAV that drains down | Check the cap is an AAV and it’s upright |
| A second bend that turns straight down into the floor | S-trap | See the two fixes below |
| A ribbed, bendy plastic tube shaped into an S | A flexible trap set up as an S-trap | Replace it with a rigid trap and a vent |
The giveaway is the piece right after the bend. On a P-trap it’s a horizontal trap arm that slides into the wall fitting. On an S-trap it’s a second U facing the other way, so the pipe heads back down.
Black or white makes no difference. Black parts are usually ABS plastic or a black finish, and “black S trap” searches are about the same banned shape.
Why plumbing codes moved to vented P-traps
Oatey gives four reasons the P-trap became the standard. Each one traces back to the water seal.
- The seal stays in the bend
A P-trap’s shape keeps enough water after each use to block sewer gas, which Oatey notes can be a health hazard as well as a smell.
- It works with a vent
The level arm gives the vent somewhere to connect, so air pressure in the drain stays balanced and the seal isn’t pulled away.
- It meets current code
S-traps are prohibited in the IPC, IRC and UPC; P-traps are what new work and renovations use.
- Older S-traps convert
Oatey describes conversion to a P-trap with an AAV or a connection to existing venting. I confirm the layout and approval before treating it as a simple parts swap.
Which trap do you have, and what should you do?
Answer four questions about the drain under your fixture. The checker names the trap and the next step.
The vent question matters most. I do not infer a correct vent from a roof pipe alone. A trap whose drain ends in the floor isn’t automatically an S-trap. If the arm runs level to a vent fitting or an air admittance valve first and only then drops, it’s a vented P-trap that happens to drain down.
“Not sure” is a common answer, because vents live inside walls. A roof vent pipe roughly above the fixture, or a pipe in the attic, does not establish how this trap is connected. I trace the connection when it is uncertain.
What “S-trap” and “P-trap” mean on a toilet
Toilet listings use the same two words for something else. That’s why search results seem to disagree.
| S-trap toilet | P-trap toilet | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the waste goes | Down into the floor | Out the back, into the wall |
| Legal? | Yes | Yes |
| What to measure | Rough-in: finished wall to the floor bolts | Height of the wall outlet from the floor |
A toilet has its trap cast into the china bowl, behind the hole you see. Toilet sellers use “S-trap” for a floor outlet and “P-trap” for a wall outlet.
So the ban on S-traps doesn’t touch your toilet. The rule is about a separate trap pipe under a sink or tub. Buy the toilet that matches where your drain already is, and measure before you order.
Do you have to replace an S-trap?
Usually not on its own. The code that bans new S-traps also protects older work that was legal and safe.
- An old S-trap that works and doesn’t smell
IPC 102.2 lets plumbing that was lawful when the code was adopted stay in use, as long as it’s kept to its original design and isn’t a hazard. [1]
- You’re remodeling the kitchen or bath
IPC 102.4 says additions, alterations and repairs follow the rules for new work. Expect the inspector to want a vented trap. [1]
- Swapping the sink or the trap parts
Minor repairs done the same way as before can be allowed if they’re not hazardous and are approved (102.4). Ask your building department. [1]
- It gurgles, smells or the trap runs dry
Gurgling, odor or a dry trap calls for prompt diagnosis. A lost water seal can let drain gas inside; I address the cause instead of waiting for a remodel.
Oatey notes that S-traps still turn up in older homes and are often replaced during remodels or inspections. I treat an inspection flag as a reason to trace the vent and plan the appropriate repair. The local authority decides how existing work is treated.
If I am assessing an existing sink, I check the vent route, drain condition and trap seal. Slow drainage or an odor needs diagnosis; neither proves siphoning on its own.
Fix 1: move the drain into the wall and add a vent
A correctly sized, conventionally vented drain is the standard route. It usually means opening the wall behind the sink and confirming the vent design with the local authority.
- 1
Find the nearest vent
Look in the attic or the wall for the vent stack serving the bathroom or kitchen. The new vent will tie into it or run out the roof.
- 2
Set a sanitary tee in the wall
Cut in a 1-1/2 in. sanitary tee (a 2 in. one for a kitchen sink where your code asks for it) at the height of the new trap arm. [1]
- 3
Run the vent up
Run the vent straight up from the tee’s top. Under IPC 905.4, a dry vent rises at least 6 in. above the sink’s flood rim before it turns sideways. [1]
- 4
Drop the old floor line or reuse it
Tie the tee’s bottom into the drain below. The old floor stub gets capped or cut out.
- 5
Fit the P-trap
Run the trap arm level into the tee with a slight fall toward the wall, then add the J-bend under the tailpiece.
The new arm has to stay within the trap-to-vent distance for its size, and the vent can’t sit below the trap’s weir (IPC 909.2). The trap arm length guide has the distances for every code and how to measure them. [1]
Adding vent piping may require a permit. I check with the building department before opening the wall; correct sizing, slope, connections and inspection still matter.
Fix 2: a P-trap with an air admittance valve
Where the code and your inspector allow it, an AAV lets air in under the sink so you don’t open the wall.
Studor specifies a −40°F to 150°F installation range. Below freezing is not a blanket exclusion for the Redi-Vent. I keep the valve accessible, upright and supplied with air; the pipe and trap still need appropriate freeze protection. Studor instructions [1]
An air admittance valve (AAV) is a one-way vent. It opens when the drain pulls a vacuum, lets room air in and closes again so gas can’t get out. The IPC allows them in section 918, with rules. [1]
To fix an S-trap this way, the trap outlet runs level for a short arm to a sanitary tee. The AAV sits on the tee’s top and the drain continues down into the floor. Now air enters before the drop, so the bend keeps its water.
| AAV rule | What it means | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Rated valve | Single-fixture and branch valves meet ASSE 1051; stack valves meet ASSE 1050 [1] | IPC 918.1 [1] |
| Height | At least 4 in. above the fixture drain it vents [1] | IPC 918.4; Studor sheet [1] |
| Access and air | Reachable, in a spot where air can get in, so never sealed in a wall | IPC 918.5 [1] |
| After the test | Installed after the drain-waste-vent test | IPC 918.2; Studor sheet [1] |
| One real vent | Each building still needs at least one vent pipe to the open air | IPC 918.7 [1] |
| Thread tape only | No primer, cement or pipe dope on the valve threads; hand-tighten | Studor install sheet |
The UPC is stricter. Studor lists its Redi-Vent under UPC section 301.2, the alternate materials route, which means the building official decides. If your area uses the UPC, ask before you buy one. [1]
An AAV can’t relieve back pressure, Studor says, and it doesn’t replace every vent. For the full trade-off, see AAV vs a regular vent.
- Good fit for an AAV
A single sink with a floor drain, an island sink or a remodel where the wall cannot be opened may suit an AAV, subject to the adopted code and local approval.
- Check first
A UPC area, a home with no roof vent at all, or a sink sharing a drain with a washer. Studor wants a 2 in. standpipe and 3 in. drain for washers. [1]
- Not a fit
A spot with no access, a cabinet you’ll seal shut, or a place outside the maker’s temperature range. Studor rates the valve for −40 to 150°F. [1]
Parts for turning an S-trap into a P-trap
These five parts serve different jobs across the two fixes for a 1-1/2 in. sink drain. I still measure for pipe, adapters and any other fittings; this is not a complete conversion package. I checked a new, in-stock offer for each original part. Prices below show when I checked the Amazon offers. [1]

Photo from the Amazon listing.
Dearborn P9703WBG P-trap
New offer sold by OHIO PRIME RETAIL. Third-party seller.

Photo from the Amazon listing.
Studor 20346 Redi-Vent
New offer sold by IPS Corp.

Photo from the Amazon listing.
NIBCO U4811 sanitary tee
New offer sold by Amazon.com.

Photo from the Amazon listing.
Oatey 39260 AAV wall box
New offer sold by Amazon.com.

Photo from the Amazon listing.
Oatey 30246 primer and cement
New offer sold by SportingDoc. Third-party seller.
I use Oatey’s polypropylene specification for the Dearborn trap body; its adapter is PVC. The Amazon title’s PVC shorthand does not describe the whole trap. Oatey identifies the 39260 as an access box with the valve sold separately. Studor’s 20 DFU headline is subject to its pipe-size table; it is not a blanket rating for every branch size. [12] [13] [14]
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
| Part | Specifications | I use it when | I choose another route when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dearborn P9703WBG | 1-1/2 in. tubular trap, polypropylene with a threaded PVC adapter, blue washers and an included reducing washer (Oatey), reversible J-bend [12] | You’re swapping the old S-bend for a P-trap on a 1-1/2 in. drain. [12] | You need a 1-1/4 in. trap body. This kit is a 1-1/2 in. trap with a reducing washer for a 1-1/4 in. tailpiece. [12] |
| Studor 20346 Redi-Vent | Maker rates the valve up to 20 DFU, subject to its branch sizing table, fits 1-1/2 or 2 in. pipe with its PVC adapter, maker lists ASSE 1051, limited lifetime warranty [5] [10] | Your inspector allows an AAV and you want the fix under the sink. | You’re in a UPC area that hasn’t approved AAVs, or the spot is sealed. |
| NIBCO U4811 tee | 1-1/2 in. PVC DWV sanitary tee, hub by hub, listing specifies ASTM D2665, NSF/ANSI 14 and 140°F max; NIBCO states a 5-year limited warranty [7] [10] | You need the tee where the arm meets the vent, in the wall or under the sink. | Your drain is ABS (black). Match the pipe material. |
| Oatey 39260 wall box | 4-1/2 x 5-3/4 in., high-impact polystyrene, fits 6 or 20 DFU AAVs with 1-1/2 or 2 in. adapters, grille cover [13] [10] | The AAV has to go in a wall and still be reachable and get air. | The valve sits in an open sink cabinet. It doesn’t need a box there. |
| Oatey 30246 handy pack | 4 oz clear PVC cement and 4 oz purple primer; DWV and pressure pipe; PVC up to 4 in. Sch. 40; apply at 40 to 110°F [8] | You’re gluing a PVC tee or pipe for either fix and your inspector wants to see primer. | Your drain is ABS. Use an ABS cement, or an all-purpose one where your code allows it. |
I choose each part for a different job: a trap, a vent valve, a tee, an access box or PVC joining supplies. These are separate parts, not a complete universal conversion kit.
The Dearborn listing calls the trap PVC, but Oatey, which owns Dearborn, says these tubular traps are polypropylene with a PVC adapter. The adapter is the part you glue. For more trap choices, see the best P-trap replacements.
Swapping an S-bend for a P-trap under the sink
The trap parts are slip-joint, so the swap is hand work. The vent is the part that needs thought.
- 1
Put a bucket under it
Loosen the slip nuts by hand and drain the bend into the bucket.
- 2
Take off the S-bend
Remove the J-bend and the down-turned piece that goes into the floor.
- 3
Set the tee and vent first
Glue the sanitary tee onto the floor stub so its side outlet faces the trap, then fit the AAV or vent on top.
- 4
Fit the J-bend and arm
Slide on nuts and washers, connect the J-bend to the tailpiece and the arm into the tee. Keep the arm level with a slight fall.
- 5
Test it
Fill the sink, pull the stopper and listen. Check every joint for leaks while draining a full basin. A quiet drain alone does not prove the vent is correct; I check the trap seal and have uncertain venting inspected.
Hand-tighten slip nuts. Plastic threads strip if you crank them, and the blue washers seal by squeezing.
Don’t use a corrugated flexible trap to fake the shape. The flexible P-trap guide covers where they’re allowed and where they aren’t.
Mistakes that turn a P-trap back into an S-trap
| Mistake | Why it fails |
|---|---|
| Arm runs downhill steeply into the floor | The total fall goes past one pipe diameter (IPC 909.2), so the arm acts like the S-trap’s down leg [1] |
| AAV hidden in a sealed wall | IPC 918.5 needs access and air; a sealed valve can’t open [1] |
| AAV mounted sideways or with pipe dope | Studor says vertical, thread tape only; dope voids the warranty |
| Vent tapped right at the top of the bend | A crown vent, banned in IPC 1002.3 and 909.3 [1] |
Most of these come from trying to save a fitting. A short level arm to the tee, then the drop, is cheaper than a callback.
S-traps on tubs, showers and laundry sinks
The ban covers any separate trap, not only kitchen and bath sinks.
| Fixture | Where the trap is | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Tub or shower | Under the floor, below the drain | From the basement or crawl space, see whether the pipe leaves the bend level to a vent |
| Laundry sink | Under the tub, like a kitchen sink | Same as a sink; a washer on the same drain needs its own rules |
| Floor drain | Below the slab | Needs approved trap-seal protection to keep the seal; see when a trap primer is required |
| Toilet | Inside the bowl | Nothing to change; S-trap and P-trap are outlet styles |
Tub and shower traps are harder to reach, so a smell from a tub drain is often the first sign. Check for a wet vent before you assume there’s none. The IPC lets fixtures in up to two bathroom groups share a horizontal wet vent (912.1). [1]
Questions people ask
Why is an S-trap illegal?
Which is better, a P-trap or an S-trap?
A P-trap, because its vent keeps the water seal in place. An S-trap can lose its seal when a full sink drains.
Can I use an S-trap instead of a P-trap?
Not in new work under sinks, tubs or showers. An old S-trap that was legal when installed can stay if it isn’t causing trouble (IPC 102.2), but remodel work follows new-work rules (102.4). [1]
What is the difference between an S-trap and a P-trap?
After the bend, a P-trap’s pipe runs level into the wall to a vent. An S-trap’s pipe turns down into the floor with no vent.
Is an S-trap toilet legal?
Yes. On toilets, “S-trap” means the waste goes into the floor and “P-trap” means it goes into the wall. The trap is inside the bowl either way.
Can I convert an S-trap to a P-trap without opening the wall?
Often, with an air admittance valve on a tee under the sink, where your code and inspector allow it. The IPC covers AAVs in section 918; the UPC leaves them to the building official. [1]
How do I know if my trap is siphoning?
Listen for a gurgle after a full sink drains, and check for a sewer smell or a trap with no water in it. Running the tap refills the trap for a while, which is why the smell comes and goes.
Does a home inspector fail an S-trap?
A home inspector will usually note it as not to current code. Oatey says S-traps are often replaced during inspections and remodels, so expect a buyer to ask about it.
Is a black S-trap different?
No. Black usually means ABS plastic or a black finish. The shape is what’s banned, whatever the color.
How I put this together
Why trust me
I’m Isaac Daniels, a licensed journeyman plumber in Georgia. I start with the drain route and vent connection before choosing a trap. The code references below identify the model-code rules; the adopted local code and building official determine what applies to the job.
How I pick
- One part for each job in the two fixes: the trap, the vent valve, the vent fitting, a wall box and the glue.
- Specs and install rules from the maker first (Studor’s spec and install sheets, NIBCO’s product page, Oatey’s trap guide and product page), then the listing.
- I found a new, in-stock Amazon offer for each original named brand and model. I check the seller and exact model before choosing the part.
- The parts are a kit with no shared score, because each does a different job.
- Prices come from Amazon’s API with the time they were read.
Sources
- International Code Council, 2024 International Plumbing Code: sections 102.2, 102.4, 901.2, 905.3, 905.4, 909.1 to 909.3, 918.1 to 918.7, 1002.1, 1002.3 and 1002.4 (codes.iccsafe.org). Read Oct 20 and Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- International Code Council, 2024 International Residential Code, sections P3201.1 to P3201.6 (codes.iccsafe.org). Read Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- IAPMO, 2024 Uniform Plumbing Code, sections 1004.1, 1004.2 and 1005.1 (epubs.iapmo.org). Read Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- Georgia Department of Community Affairs, Georgia State Amendments to the International Plumbing Code (2024 Edition), revised Jan 1, 2026, and Georgia State Minimum Standard Codes (dca.georgia.gov). Source document
- IPS Corporation, Studor Redi-Vent specification submittal sheet (20346) and Redi-Vent installation sheet. Source document
- Oatey, “What’s the Difference Between a P-Trap and an S-Trap?” (oatey.com blog). Read Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- NIBCO, 1-1/2 in. PVC DWV sanitary tee 4811 product page (nibco.com). Read Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- Oatey, Regular Clear Cement and Purple Primer Handy Pack, part 30246, product page (oatey.com). Read Oct 22, 2026. Source document
- ICC plumbing fixture and integral trap rules; floor-outlet and wall-outlet toilets use a trap formed into the fixture. American Standard toilet outlet drawings
- Amazon listing titles, new-condition offers, sellers, prices and product images for the five original parts, checked November 15, 2026.
- The original page’s October search notes are historical. No new search-volume or difficulty claim is made in this guide.
- Dearborn P9703WBG maker specifications
- Oatey 39260 wall box specifications
- Studor Redi-Vent 20346 sizing and specification sheet
- Isaac Daniels, owner experience statement and Georgia journeyman plumber credentials, supplied for this guide.

