Upflush toilet vs sewage ejector pump

Which one fits your basement, by the floor, the lift and the fixtures.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site earns

Updated November 15, 2026

About Isaac · How I chose

Red Lion sewage basin system with pump and cover

Quick answer

Pick a sewage ejector if you can cut the slab. Fixtures drain into a basin below the floor and a 2 in. pipe lifts it all; the linked ejector here is the Red Lion RL-WCS50TA kit, with the Liberty P382LE51 shown for comparison. If the slab has to stay whole, a Saniflo SaniPLUS upflush runs a full bath from on top of the floor.

Reference (not linked): Liberty P382LE51 Shown for comparison only. The linked picks are the Red Lion RL-WCS50TA kit and the Liberty ALM-2 alarm.
On this page
  1. 1The picks
  2. 2What each asks of the floor
  3. 3Saniflo SaniPLUS
  4. 4Saniflo Sanibest Pro
  5. 5Saniflo Sanicompact
  6. 6Liberty P382LE51
  7. 7Red Lion RL-WCS50TA
  8. 8Side by side
  9. 9Compare the picks
  10. 10How high each can pump
  11. 11What can drain into each
  12. 12How each is vented
  13. 13Discharge pipe rules
  14. 14Room, weight and power
  15. 15Power cuts and alarms
  16. 16Upkeep
  17. 17When to pick each
  18. 18Where sources disagree
  19. 19How to choose
  20. 20Questions
  21. 21How I compared

Two ejector systems and three upflush units

Figures come from the makers’ own sheets, not the listings.

Reference (not linked)

Liberty P382LE51

Shown for comparison only.

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA sewage basin system with pump and cover
Best for a narrow pit and lifts up to 15 ft

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA

$450.45 at Amazon
Check it on Amazon
Price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
Details ↓
Reference (not linked)

Saniflo SaniPLUS bundle

Shown for comparison only.

Reference (not linked)

Saniflo Sanibest Pro bundle

Shown for comparison only.

Reference (not linked)

Saniflo Sanicompact 023

Shown for comparison only.

Best for a narrow pit and lifts up to 15 ft

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA 14942749 sewage basin system, ½ hp cast-iron pump, 18 × 30 in. basin

14942749, basin system kit
$450.45
Check it on Amazon
in stock · price as of Nov 22, 2026, 9:30 AM EST
8.4Spec scoreHow it’s scored
Lift at code flow6
Kit completeness7
Solids handling10
Warranty9
Listing match10

Buy it if

Your total lift is 15 ft or less, you want a narrow 18 in. hole in the slab, and you don’t mind assembling the kit.

Skip it if

Your lift is more than 15 ft, or you want a system that arrives assembled. Look at the Liberty P382LE51 below.

Pros

  • Basin, pump, cover and 2 in. check valve in one kit
  • About 28 gpm at 15 ft, per Red Lion’s table
  • Passes 2 in. solids
  • Narrow 18 in. basin

Cons

  • About 8 gpm at 20 ft, so 15 ft is the working limit
  • You assemble it
  • No high-water alarm in the kit
  • 2-year warranty
½ hp, 9 A, 115 V5,600 gph at 0 ft22 ft shut-off2 in. FNPT discharge18 × 30 in. basinOn 17.5 in., off 7.5 in.10 ft cord

The RL-WCS50TA is Red Lion’s complete sewage basin kit, item 14942749. In the box you get an 18 by 30 in. polyethylene basin, a ½ hp sewage pump with a cast-iron base and impeller, a tethered piggyback float switch, the cover and its hardware, a 2 in. PVC discharge pipe that runs from the pump to the cover, and a 2 in. full-flow check valve.

Red Lion is a Franklin Electric brand.

Red Lion’s product table lists the pump at 9 A on 115 V with a 10 ft cord and a 2 in. FNPT discharge. It rates flow at 5,600 gallons per hour at 0 ft of lift, 4,920 at 5 ft, 3,720 at 10 ft, 1,680 at 15 ft and 480 at 20 ft, with shut-off at 22 ft.

Divided by 60, that’s about 28 gpm at 15 ft, above the 21 gpm the plumbing code asks of a pump on a 2 in. line, and about 8 gpm at 20 ft, well under it. Treat 15 ft of total dynamic head as the working limit.

The float turns the pump on at 17.5 in. and off at 7.5 in., per the same table. Red Lion’s manual sets the float 4 in. above the pump discharge on a 3.5 in. tether, clear of the pump, the pipe and the basin wall, and says to install the check valve level or at less than 45°.

The cover takes a 4 in. inlet, the 2 in. discharge and a vent through Adaptaflex flanges.

The score reflects that mix. It gets full marks for passing 2 in. solids and for a listing that matches the maker’s model, a 7 for kit completeness because the check valve is included but there’s no high-water alarm and you assemble it yourself.

Lift gets a 6 because the curve drops off past 15 ft. Warranty gets a 9 because the manual’s limited warranty runs 2 years from purchase. Add a float alarm, such as Liberty’s ALM-2 covered below, before you rely on it.

What each one asks of your floor

The biggest difference is where the work happens: on top of the slab, or down inside it.

Upflush: all above the floor pump shower raised base rise first, then ¼ in. per ft fall 1½ in. open vent Base under a shower or tub: 6 in. for the SaniPLUS, 8 in. for the Sanibest Pro. Pipe: ¾ or 1 in. rigid. Vent: 1½ in., no air admittance valve. Ejector: a basin in the slab 4 in. inlet check valve full-open valve 2 in. pipe vent 24 to 30 in. into the slab Liberty Pro380: 24 in. deep, about 24 in. across. Red Lion kit: 30 in. deep, 18 in. across. Pipe: 2 in. minimum. Vent: no smaller than the pipe. Upflush: all above the floor pump shower raised base rise first, then ¼ in. per ft fall 1½ in. open vent Base under a shower or tub: 6 in. for the SaniPLUS, 8 in. for the Sanibest Pro. Pipe: ¾ or 1 in. rigid. Vent: 1½ in., no air admittance valve. Ejector: a basin in the slab 4 in. inlet check valve full-open valve 2 in. pipe vent 24 to 30 in. into the slab Liberty Pro380: 24 in. deep, about 24 in. across. Red Lion kit: 30 in. deep, 18 in. across. Pipe: 2 in. minimum. Vent: no smaller than the pipe.
Side views drawn from the makers’ figures. Sources: Saniflo SaniPLUS and Sanibest Pro spec sheets and SaniPLUS install manual; Liberty Pro380 system specifications (R05/2026) and manual 7225000; Red Lion catalog and RL-WCS50TA manual; IPC 2024 sections 712.2 and 712.3.2.

An upflush unit sits on the floor behind or beside the toilet. Nothing goes into the slab. The catch is height: a shower or tub has to drain down into the pump’s side inlet, so its base sits 6 in. up for the SaniPLUS and 8 in. for the Sanibest Pro.

An ejector flips that. The basin goes into a hole in the slab, so every fixture sits at floor level and drains down into it by gravity, through pipe run under the slab.

The hole is real work. Liberty’s basin is 24 in. deep and about 24 in. across, and the Red Lion’s is 30 in. deep and 18 in. across. Liberty says to backfill with pea gravel or crushed stone and set the basin lip level with the finished floor.

Code sets the smallest pit at 18 in. across and 24 in. deep, with a gastight cover no more than 2 in. below the floor (IPC 712.3.2). Both basins here meet it.

Upflush units, set on top of the floor

Reference (not linked)

Saniflo SaniPLUS bundle

Saniflo SaniPLUS 002 macerating pump with 087 elongated bowl and 005 tank

SaniPLUS 002, elongated bowl 087, tank 005

Pros

  • Full bath with no slab cutting
  • Lifts 15 ft or runs 150 ft
  • Bundle includes Saniflo’s bowl and tank
  • Two 2 in. inlets for a sink and a shower
  • 53 dBA or less at 3 ft, per Saniflo

Cons

  • One toilet per unit
  • No kitchen sink, dishwasher or washer
  • Shower or tub base raised 6 to 7 in.
  • No wipes or sanitary products
  • Don’t use it in a power cut
½ HP, 4.5 A15 ft lift, 150 ft run¾ or 1 in. discharge1½ in. vent, no AAV3 gal tank18 lb pump

The SaniPLUS 002 is Saniflo’s ½ HP macerating pump for a full bathroom. This bundle pairs it with Saniflo’s 087 elongated bowl and 005 tank.

Saniflo rates it to lift 15 ft or push 150 ft sideways. Its sheet gives 17 gpm at 15 ft and 27 gpm at 3 ft, with a shut-off head of 30 ft. The pump runs about 10 to 12 seconds a cycle and holds 3 gal.

The toilet has to be Saniflo’s own 1.28 gpf rear-outlet model, which this bundle includes. The 087 bowl has a 16¾ in. seat height and is ADA compliant, per Saniflo. Two 2 in. side inlets with built-in check valves take a sink, a shower or tub, or a urinal.

Anything draining in must sit high enough to fall into those side inlets. The spec sheet says to raise a shower or tub base at least 6 in., and the 2010 install manual says 7 in. Build to 7 in. and both are met.

Waste leaves through ¾ or 1 in. rigid pipe. The manual says the pipe rises first, then falls ¼ in. per foot, and never climbs again once the horizontal run starts. It counts 3 ft of lift as 30 ft of run, and about 3 ft of lift lost per 90° turn.

It still needs a real vent. The 1½ in. port on the lid ties into an open vent, and Saniflo says air admittance valves and mechanical vents are not permitted. In many basements, that vent is the hardest pipe on the job, so find your route before you buy.

The limits are firm. The manual allows one toilet per unit and bars kitchen sinks, dishwashers and clothes washers. It also bars wipes, pads, tampons and swabs, and says not to use the system in a power cut. Saniflo lists noise at 53 dBA or less at 3 ft.

Reference (not linked)

Saniflo Sanibest Pro bundle

Saniflo Sanibest Pro grinder pump with elongated bowl and tank

Sanibest Pro 013, elongated bowl, tank

Pros

  • Lifts 25 ft or runs 150 ft
  • Grinder takes sanitary products and floss
  • Washer allowed through a laundry sink
  • Service panel on top
  • Bundle includes bowl and tank

Cons

  • Louder: up to 63 dBA
  • Shower or tub base raised 8 in.
  • 28 lb, heavier than the SaniPLUS
  • Don’t use it in a power cut
  • Vent still can’t be an AAV
1 HP, 9 A25 ft lift, 150 ft run¾ or 1 in. discharge1½ in. vent3.2 gal tank28 lb pump

The Sanibest Pro is Saniflo’s 1 HP grinder pump, part 013, for heavier work than the SaniPLUS. This bundle adds Saniflo’s elongated bowl and tank.

It lifts higher. Saniflo rates it for 25 ft up or 150 ft across, with 19 gpm at 25 ft and 38 gpm at 3 ft, and a shut-off head of 38 ft. That’s 10 ft more rated lift than the SaniPLUS, and 38 gpm against 27 at 3 ft.

The grinder is the big change. Saniflo’s sheet says it handles condoms, sanitary napkins, cotton swabs and dental floss, the items the SaniPLUS manual bars. It’s rated for homes and commercial use.

It also takes more fixtures. The sheet lists a sink, a shower or tub, a urinal and a washing machine, with the washer draining first into a laundry sink. The SaniPLUS manual bars washers outright.

The trade-offs are noise and height. Saniflo lists the Sanibest Pro at 63 dBA or less, against 53 for the SaniPLUS. A shower or tub base has to sit at least 8 in. off the floor, so plan a step up into the shower.

Discharge is the same ¾ or 1 in. rigid pipe, with the same rise-first rule. The vent is the same 1½ in. open vent, and Saniflo bars air admittance valves on it. A service panel on top lets you reach the inside without pulling the unit out.

It draws up to 9 A, weighs 28 lb and holds 3.2 gal. Saniflo’s warranty terms are the same as the SaniPLUS: 2 years from purchase, or up to 4 if you register online within the first year. Vitreous china parts carry 1 year.

Reference (not linked)

Saniflo Sanicompact 023

One-piece macerating toilet, dual flush

Sanicompact 023, one-piece, dual flush

Pros

  • Toilet and pump in one piece
  • Ventless, per Saniflo
  • Dual flush, 1.28 or 1.0 gal
  • Takes one sink through a 1¼ in. inlet
  • 53 dBA, per Saniflo

Cons

  • Only 9 ft of lift
  • No shower or tub
  • Run figure differs: 100, 120 or 150 ft
  • 64 lb to carry in
  • Needs power to flush
9 ft lift1 in. discharge1¼ in. sink inlet7.2 A, 120 V18½ × 14½ × 21½ in.64 lb

The Sanicompact 023 is a one-piece toilet with the macerator built into its base. It’s for a half bath: a toilet and one sink.

Saniflo’s page calls it ventless, and its older sheet says it works as a forced main that doesn’t need a vent. That can save the hardest pipe on a basement job. Ask your inspector first: IPC 712.1 wants sumps vented, while 712.4.1 sends macerating toilets to the maker’s instructions.

Its lift is the lowest here, 9 ft. The run figure depends on the document: 120 ft in the headline, 150 ft in the spec table and 100 ft on an older sheet. Plan for 100 ft and every figure covers you. The older sheet gives 13 gpm at 9 ft.

The one inlet is 1¼ in., for a sink. No shower or tub can drain into it. The older sheet lists a dual flush of 1.28 or 1.0 gal from a push button on the bowl, with the motor running about 10 to 15 seconds.

It’s 18½ in. high, 14½ in. wide and 21½ in. deep, and weighs 64 lb. It discharges through 1 in. pipe. Saniflo lists 53 dBA, 7.2 A and 120 V, and the older sheet recommends a ground-fault (GFCI) outlet.

The documents disagree on the motor too: 0.5 hp on the current page and 0.3 HP on the older sheet. The figures that matter for the install, the 9 ft lift, the 1 in. pipe and the 1¼ in. sink inlet, match in both.

It’s certified to ASME A112.3.4 and CSA B45.9, the standard IPC 712.4.1 names for macerating toilets. Saniflo’s page lists a 4-year limited warranty, and its warranty terms say registering within the first year is what takes it past 2 years.

Liberty P382LE51, a 24-inch basin

Sewage ejectors sit in a basin set into the slab. That’s a different kind of system from the upflush units above, so the two ejectors aren’t scored against them.

Liberty P382LE51 Pro380 sewage pump system in a black 24 inch basin
Liberty Pumps P382LE51 Pro380 simplex sewage system, ½ HP, 24 in. basin. Product photo: Amazon.
P382LE51What the maker says
Specs½ HP, 12 A · 24 × 24.38 in. basin · 41 gal · 2 in. discharge · 4 in. inlet · 64 lb
Pick it ifYou can cut the slab and want a full basement bathroom, maybe with a bar sink, with everything at floor level and lift to spare.
Skip it ifThe slab can’t be cut. The SaniPLUS does a full bath from above the floor.
On AmazonReference (not linked)

The P382LE51 is Liberty’s Pro380 simplex system: a ½ HP sewage pump already set in a basin, with floats, cover and discharge pipe. Liberty Pumps is a pump maker in Bergen, New York.

The basin is 24 in. tall and 24.38 in. across and holds 41 gal, per Liberty. That clears IPC 712.3.2, which asks for a pit at least 18 in. across and 24 in. deep. Liberty lists an optional 8 in. basin extension.

Fixtures drain in by gravity through a 4 in. no-hub inlet in the basin wall. Liberty’s drawing puts the inlet’s centre 14.75 in. up from the basin bottom. So the toilet, sink and shower all sit at floor level, with their drains run under the slab to the basin.

Does wellWatch for
Ships assembled in a 24 in. basinSlab cut and a 24 in. deep hole
About 90 gpm at 15 ft on Liberty’s curveNeeds a vent at least 2 in.
Floats lift out without pulling the pumpNo wipes, pads, floss or swabs
Every fixture stays at floor levelNo alarm with this model number
3-year warrantyDraws 12 A

Waste leaves through 2 in. Schedule 80 PVC, already fitted. Reading Liberty’s LE50 curve, I get about 90 gpm at 15 ft and 55 gpm at 20 ft, with flow stopping near 24 ft. IPC Table 712.4.2 asks 21 gpm of a pump on a 2 in. pipe.

Service is easy for a basin pump. Liberty’s QuickTree holder lets the floats lift out without pulling the pump, and a separate access cover gives a way in. The sales sheet says the system ships completely assembled, with an anti-flotation collar.

Liberty’s manual sets the rest of the pipe: a union just above the cover, then a check valve, then a gate or ball valve. The vent can’t be smaller than the discharge, so plan a 2 in. vent. Backfill with pea gravel or crushed stone, not sand or the dirt you dug out.

It draws 12 A at 115 V on a 10 ft cord. Liberty limits it to human waste and toilet paper: no wipes, pads, floss, swabs or grease. The warranty is 3 years, and the manual quotes the UPC rule that sewage systems need an audio and visual alarm.

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA, an 18-inch basin

Red Lion RL-WCS50TA sewage basin system with pump and cover
Red Lion RL-WCS50TA 14942749 sewage basin system, ½ hp, 18 × 30 in. basin. Product photo: Amazon.
RL-WCS50TAWhat the maker says
Specs½ hp, 9 A · 18 × 30 in. basin · 2 in. FNPT discharge · 4 in. inlet · 22 ft shut-off · On 17.5 in., off 7.5 in.
Pick it ifYour lift is 15 ft or less, you’d rather cut a narrow hole, and you don’t mind putting the kit together.
Skip it ifThe lift is more than 15 ft, or you want it assembled. The Liberty P382LE51 has more head to spare.
On AmazonCheck it on Amazon

The RL-WCS50TA is Red Lion’s sewage basin kit: an 18 by 30 in. basin, a ½ hp cast-iron pump, cover, discharge pipe and a 2 in. check valve. Red Lion is a Franklin Electric brand.

The basin is narrower and deeper than Liberty’s: 18 in. across and 30 in. deep. That’s exactly the IPC 712.3.2 minimum width, with 6 in. more depth than code asks. A narrower hole means less slab to cut, though you dig deeper.

Red Lion’s catalog gives flow in gallons per hour: 5,600 at 0 ft, 4,920 at 5, 3,720 at 10, 1,680 at 15 and 480 at 20, with shut-off at 22 ft. That’s about 28 gpm at 15 ft, above the 21 gpm code asks of a pump on a 2 in. pipe.

Does wellWatch for
Basin, pump, cover and 2 in. check valve in one kitYou assemble it
About 28 gpm at 15 ftAbout 8 gpm at 20 ft, under code’s 21
Narrow 18 in. hole in the slab30 in. deep hole
Passes 2 in. semi-solids2-year warranty
No alarm in the kit

At 20 ft it falls to about 8 gpm, well under that 21 gpm floor. So treat 15 ft of total dynamic head as the working limit for this kit. Total dynamic head is the vertical lift from the basin to the highest point of the discharge plus the friction loss in the pipe, valves and fittings, so a long or twisting run leaves less room for lift. Size the pump from the flow you need at your total head.

The pump passes 2 in. semi-solids, which lines up with the 2 in. solids IPC 712.4.2 asks of a pump that takes a toilet. Its piggyback float turns it on at 17.5 in. and off at 7.5 in., per the catalog. The base and impeller are cast iron.

It’s a kit, so you assemble it. The manual sets the float 4 in. above the pump discharge on a 3.5 in. tether, clear of the pump, pipe and basin wall. The check valve goes in level or tilted no more than 45°.

The cover takes a 4 in. inlet pipe, the 2 in. discharge and a vent through rubber Adaptaflex flanges. The pump draws 9 A at 115 V on a 10 ft cord. Red Lion’s manual gives a 2-year limited warranty from the date of purchase.

My call: it’s a good ejector for a basement bath with up to about 15 ft of total dynamic head, and the check valve is already in the box. Pick the Liberty for more lift, or if you’d rather not assemble anything.

Upflush and ejector side by side

Figures from the five picks’ maker sheets and the 2024 IPC. Scroll sideways on a phone.

CheckUpflush (Saniflo)Sewage ejectorAhead
Slab workNone; sits on the floorCut and dig a pit 24 to 30 in. deepUpflush
Shower or tub heightBase raised 6 to 8 in.At floor levelEjector
ToiletSaniflo’s own rear-outlet bowlA standard floor-outlet toiletEjector
Toilets per unitOne (SaniPLUS manual)Set by pump and basin sizeEjector
Discharge pipe¾ or 1 in. rigid2 in. minimum (Liberty)Upflush, smaller pipe to run
Flow at 15 ft17 gpm (SaniPLUS)28 gpm (Red Lion) to about 90 (Liberty)Ejector
Highest lift9 to 25 ft ratedFlow stops at 22 to 24 ftClose
Kitchen sink or washerNot on the SaniPLUSNot barred; Liberty bars greaseEjector
Wipes and sanitary productsSanibest Pro onlyNo (Liberty)Sanibest Pro
Vent1½ in., no AAV; Sanicompact ventlessNot smaller than the dischargeUpflush
Published noise53 to 63 dBANot publishedCan’t compare
In a power cutDon’t use itDrains into the basin until it fillsEjector
Warranty2 years, up to 4 registeredLiberty 3 years, Red Lion 2Close

Neither wins everywhere. The upflush wins on floor work and venting. The ejector wins on what it can take, how much it moves and how normal the bathroom looks once it’s done.

The five units compared

From each maker’s own sheet. Scroll sideways on a phone.

PickSpec scoreTypeLiftDischargeVentShower or tubWarrantyBuy
Liberty P382LE51None (ejector)Ejector, 24 in. basinFlow stops near 24 ft2 in.2 in. or moreAt floor level3 yearsReference (not linked)
Red Lion RL-WCS50TA8.4 (ejector)Ejector, 18 × 30 in. basinFlow stops at 22 ft2 in.Through the coverAt floor level2 yearsCheck it on Amazon
Saniflo SaniPLUS, Macerator, full bath15 ft rated¾ or 1 in.1½ in., no AAVBase up 6 to 7 in.2 years, 4 registeredReference (not linked)
Saniflo Sanibest Pro, Grinder, bath and laundry sink25 ft rated¾ or 1 in.1½ in., no AAVBase up 8 in.2 years, 4 registeredReference (not linked)
Saniflo Sanicompact, One-piece toilet, half bath9 ft rated1 in.Ventless, per SanifloNot allowed2 years, 4 registeredReference (not linked)

How high each one can pump

Lift is the height from the pump to the highest point of the discharge pipe. More lift means less flow.

Feet of vertical lift Saniflo Sanicompact highest lift Saniflo rates 9 ft Saniflo SaniPLUS highest lift Saniflo rates 15 ft Saniflo Sanibest Pro highest lift Saniflo rates 25 ft Red Lion RL-WCS50TA shut-off head: flow stops 22 ft Liberty P382LE51 shut-off head, read from the curve 24 ft Blue: upflush units, the highest lift Saniflo rates. Grey: ejectors, the height where flow stops. Code asks an ejector for 21 gpm in a 2 in. pipe; at 15 ft the Liberty still moves about 90 gpm and the Red Lion 28. Feet of vertical lift Saniflo Sanicompact highest lift Saniflo rates 9 ft Saniflo SaniPLUS highest lift Saniflo rates 15 ft Saniflo Sanibest Pro highest lift Saniflo rates 25 ft Red Lion RL-WCS50TA shut-off head: flow stops 22 ft Liberty P382LE51 shut-off head, read from the curve 24 ft Blue: upflush units, the highest lift Saniflo rates. Grey: ejectors, the height where flow stops. Code asks an ejector for 21 gpm in a 2 in. pipe; at 15 ft the Liberty still moves about 90 gpm and the Red Lion 28.
Saniflo: the highest lift each spec sheet or product page rates. Ejectors: shut-off head, where flow stops (Red Lion catalog; Liberty Pro380 curve for the LE50, my reading, rounded).
LiftSaniPLUSSanibest ProSanicompactRed LionLiberty (read from curve)
3 ft27 gpm38 gpm16 gpmNot listedNot listed
5 ftNot listedNot listedNot listed82 gpmAbout 140 gpm
9 to 10 ftNot listedNot listed13 gpm at 9 ft62 gpm at 10 ftAbout 120 gpm at 10 ft
15 ft17 gpmNot listedOver its rating28 gpmAbout 90 gpm
20 ftOver its ratingNot listedOver its rating8 gpmAbout 55 gpm
25 ftOver its rating19 gpmOver its ratingPast shut-offPast shut-off
Flow stops30 ft38 ftNot listed22 ftAbout 24 ft

Red Lion’s figures are its gallons per hour divided by 60. Sanicompact flows are from Saniflo’s older sheet. Green: above the 21 gpm IPC Table 712.4.2 asks of a pump on a 2 in. pipe. Amber: below it.

The two sides are rated in different ways, so read the chart with care. Saniflo prints the highest lift it backs for each unit. Ejector makers print a curve, and the shut-off head is where the curve hits zero. You never want to run an ejector near that point.

Code gives the ejector side a floor. A pump on a 2 in. pipe has to move at least 21 gpm (IPC 712.4.2).

That floor is why I’d hold the Red Lion to about 15 ft of total dynamic head (lift plus pipe friction): it moves about 28 gpm there and only 8 at 20 ft. The Liberty still moves about 55 gpm at 20 ft on my reading of its curve.

Upflush units get their own rule. A macerating toilet serving one toilet can discharge through ¾ in. pipe (IPC 712.4.2, exception 2), and no gpm floor applies to that size.

Long runs cost lift. Saniflo’s SaniPLUS manual counts 3 ft of lift as 30 ft of horizontal run and takes about 3 ft off the rated lift for every 90° turn. Liberty says to keep the line short with few turns, and to go up a pipe size on long runs. Add your elbows before you settle on a model.

What can drain into each one

From the makers’ own lists. “Not listed” means the maker’s sheet doesn’t name it; ask the maker before you plan on it.

Fixture or itemSaniPLUSSanibest ProSanicompactLiberty P382LE51Red Lion
ToiletSaniflo rear-outlet, one per unitSaniflo rear-outletBuilt inStandard floor-outletStandard floor-outlet
Bathroom sinkYes, 2 in. inletYesYes, 1¼ in. inletYesYes
Shower or tubYes, base up 6 to 7 in.Yes, base up 8 in.NoYes, at floor levelYes, at floor level
UrinalYesYesNot listedNot listedNot listed
Washing machineNoYes, through a laundry sinkNot listedNot listedNot listed
Kitchen sink or dishwasherNoNot listedNot listedNot listed; no greaseNot listed
Toilet paperYesYesYesYesYes
Wipes, pads, floss, swabsNoYesNot listedNoNot listed
Groundwater, or a drain that collects itNo, by codeNo, by codeNo, by codeNo, by codeNo, by code

Sources: SaniPLUS install manual and spec sheet; Sanibest Pro and Sanicompact spec sheets; Liberty manual 7225000 (“human waste and toilet paper is permitted”; no grease); Red Lion catalog. Groundwater row: IPC 1101.3 and 1111.1.

The SaniPLUS list is the shortest, and it’s where most upflush complaints start. Wipes and pads jam a macerator, and the manual bars them by name. Keep them out of every system here. The Sanibest Pro’s grinder is built for heavier work, but that is not a reason to flush them.

Ejectors take more fixtures but are just as strict about wipes. Liberty bars feminine products, wipes, towels, floss and swabs in its non-grinder systems. For those, look at my sewage grinder pump guide.

Keep groundwater out of both. IPC 1101.3 bars storm water from a sewer meant only for sewage, and 1111.1 sends subsoil drains to their own sump. A perimeter drain, or a floor drain that collects groundwater or storm water, gets a sump pump, not the ejector. A sanitary floor drain is different: find out what the drain receives and ask your local code official where it may discharge. My sewage ejector vs sump pump guide covers the difference.

How each one is vented

Both kinds push air out as they fill and pull air in as they empty, so both need a real vent.

Pump flow (gpm)1½ in. vent2 in. vent3 in. ventWhich picks
Up to 40160 ftNo limitNo limitSaniflo units (38 gpm at most)
Up to 10025 ft97 ftNo limitRed Lion (about 93 gpm at 0 ft)
Up to 150Under 10 ft44 ft370 ftLiberty (about 140 gpm at 5 ft)

Longest vent run allowed by pump flow, excerpted from IPC 2024 Table 906.5.1. The length includes an allowance for fittings; code assumes 50% of the pipe length if you have no better figure. Check the full table for your exact flow.

Saniflo is clear about its units: a 1½ in. vent from the lid to an open vent, and no air admittance valves or mechanical vents. The SaniPLUS sheet calls for a two-way vent, because air has to move both ways. The Sanicompact is the exception; Saniflo sells it as ventless.

Ejectors follow the same thinking. Liberty’s manual says the vent can’t be smaller than the discharge, so its 2 in. pipe needs at least a 2 in. vent. IPC 918.8 bars air admittance valves on sumps unless an engineer designed the vent. My AAV vs vent guide explains why a sealed pit needs a vent that lets pressure out.

The vent can join the building’s vent system or run on its own to the outdoors, per Liberty. Plan that route first. In a finished basement, it’s often the hardest pipe to fit.

The discharge pipe rules for each

From IPC 2024 section 712 and the makers’ manuals.

RuleUpflush (Saniflo)EjectorSource
Pipe size¾ or 1 in. rigid2 in. minimum for a non-grinderSaniflo sheets; Liberty manual; IPC 712.4.2
Pipe materialRigid, not flexibleCopper, CPVC, ductile iron, PE or PVCSaniPLUS manual; IPC 712.3.3.1
ValvesNon-return valve in the elbow, plus a full-port valve and a unionUnion, then a check valve, then a full-open valve, above the coverSaniPLUS manual; Liberty manual; IPC 712.2
RouteStraight up first, then ¼ in. per foot of fallAs short as possible, with few turnsSaniPLUS manual; Liberty manual
Tie-inAn approved wyeA wye into the top of the pipe, 10 pipe diameters from a stack baseSaniPLUS manual; IPC 712.3.5

The check valve is what stops the pipe draining back after each cycle. Saniflo builds a non-return valve into the SaniPLUS discharge elbow. On an ejector, IPC 712.2 wants a check valve and a full-open valve, reachable, above the cover. The Red Lion kit includes its 2 in. check valve. My check valve guide covers how they’re fitted.

The full-open valve after the check valve lets you shut the line to clean the check valve or pull the pump, as Liberty’s manual puts it. A union just above the cover lets the pump come out without cutting pipe.

The tie-in rule matters on both sides. Ten pipe diameters from a stack base is 30 in. on a 3 in. drain. Keep the wye on top of the pipe, never the side.

How much room and power each one needs

ItemLiberty P382LE51Red LionSaniPLUSSanibest ProSanicompact
Hole in the slabAbout 24 in. across, 24 in. deepAbout 18 in. across, 30 in. deepNoneNoneNone
Shower or tub baseFloor levelFloor level6 in. (sheet), 7 in. (manual)8 in.No shower
Weight64 lbNot listed18 lb pump28 lb pump64 lb
Current12 A, 115 V9 A, 115 V4.5 A, 120 V9 A7.2 A, 120 V
Cord10 ft10 ft47½ in.Not listedNot listed
OutletNot statedNot stated15 A GFCI, 40 in. from a tub or showerNot statedGFCI recommended

Basement fixtures that can drain to the sewer by gravity shouldn’t go to the pump. IPC 712.1 says that in new work, a sump can’t take drainage from piping that could flow to the sewer on its own. So upstairs fixtures stay on the gravity drain, and only the basement fixtures go into the basin or the macerator.

The SaniPLUS cord is under 4 ft, so the outlet has to sit close behind the toilet. Saniflo wants it on a 15 A GFCI circuit at least 40 in. from a tub or shower. The ejectors carry 10 ft cords, so the outlet can sit on a nearby wall above the slab.

Check your local electrical code for the outlet; the makers’ figures here are the minimum.

Power cuts and high-water alarms

Neither kind pumps without power. What happens next is different.

Upflush in a power cut

Saniflo’s SaniPLUS manual says not to use the system during a power loss. With no power, the pump can’t empty its tank.

Ejector in a power cut

Fixtures still drain into the basin until it fills. Liberty’s holds 41 gal in total.

A dripping faucet on an upflush

The SaniPLUS manual says a constant drip can trip the motor’s thermal overload, and the unit can flood.

An alarm on either

A high-water alarm sounds before the tank or basin overflows. Liberty’s manual quotes the UPC rule that sewage systems need one.

For a Saniflo unit, Saniflo’s Sanialarm is the high-water alarm the SaniPLUS sheet recommends.

For an ejector, Liberty’s ALM-2 is a float alarm on a 20 ft cord, the alarm Liberty’s /A2 models ship with. Check it on Amazon.

The P382LE51 and the Red Lion kit come without an alarm, so add one. A full basin backs up through the lowest drain in the basement. My sump pump alarm guide covers more alarm types.

What upkeep each one needs

TaskUpflush (Saniflo)EjectorSource
Routine cleaningClean once a year, no bleach; Saniflo recommends its descalerKeep grease, wipes and sand outSaniPLUS manual; Liberty manual
Toilet tankNo bleach blocks in the tankNot statedSaniPLUS manual
Floats or switchMembrane switch inside the unitLiberty floats lift out on the QuickTree; Red Lion float on a 3.5 in. tetherLiberty; Red Lion manuals
Check valveBuilt into the discharge elbowShut the full-open valve and clean itLiberty manual
Cold roomsWinterize with plumber’s antifreezeNot stated by either makerSaniPLUS manual
Leaks at fixturesFix drips; they can trip the overloadNot statedSaniPLUS manual

Neither maker publishes a lifespan in the sheets I read. What they do publish is the warranty: 2 years for Saniflo, up to 4 if registered in the first year, 3 years for Liberty and 2 for Red Lion. Treat any lifespan figure without a source as a guess.

When to pick each one

Full bath, slab can be cut

Ejector. The Liberty P382LE51 for the most lift, or the Red Lion up to about 15 ft.

Full bath, slab stays whole

Upflush. The SaniPLUS, with a shower base raised 7 in.

Bath and a laundry sink

The Sanibest Pro, or an ejector if the slab can be cut.

Lift over 15 ft

The Sanibest Pro (25 ft rated) or the Liberty (about 55 gpm at 20 ft).

Half bath only

The Sanicompact: toilet and sink, 9 ft of lift, ventless per Saniflo.

Kitchen sink or bar with a dishwasher

Not the SaniPLUS or Sanicompact. An ejector, kept free of grease.

Where the documents disagree

Five places the makers’ own papers, or the web, don’t match, and which figure to plan on.

TopicOne source saysThe other saysPlan on
SaniPLUS shower baseSpec sheet: 6 in. minimum2010 install manual: 7 in.7 in.
Sanicompact horizontal runHeadline 120 ft; spec table 150 ftOlder sheet: 100 ft100 ft
Saniflo warrantyProduct pages: 4 yearsWarranty terms: 2 years, up to 4 if registered in year 1Register it
Sanicompact ventSaniflo: ventlessIPC 712.1: sumps are vented; 712.4.1 defers to the makerYour inspector’s call
How long they lastPump-maker blog: upflush 10 to 15+ years, no sourceSaniflo, Liberty and Red Lion sheets: no years figureThe warranty

The shower-base gap is the one that costs a rebuild. An inch short and the shower drains slowly or backs up into the pan. Framing to 7 in. meets both Saniflo documents.

On the vent, the inspector decides. Some will pass a ventless Sanicompact under 712.4.1 and its listing; others will want a vent. Ask before the walls close.

Should you pick an upflush or an ejector?

QuestionIf yesIf no
Can the slab be cut and dug 24 to 30 in.?Ejector is on the table; keep goingUpflush
Will a kitchen sink, dishwasher or washer drain in?Ejector, or the Sanibest Pro for a washer via a laundry sinkKeep going
Is the lift over 15 ft?Liberty or Sanibest ProAny pick fits
Is there a shower or tub?Ejector, SaniPLUS or Sanibest ProSanicompact is enough
Can you run a vent to the outdoors or the building vent?Any option, if its lift rating covers your runSanicompact, if your inspector accepts ventless
Will wipes or sanitary products get flushed?Stop that first; no system here is meant for themAny option, if its lift rating covers your run

If you can cut the slab, I’d go ejector for a full bath. It takes a standard toilet, the shower sits at floor level, and nothing in the bathroom looks unusual.

If the slab can’t be cut, the SaniPLUS is the full-bath pick, and my best upflush toilet guide compares more macerating units. For more ejector pumps on their own, see my sewage ejector pump guide.

Questions people ask

Is an upflush toilet or a sewage ejector better for a basement?

An ejector, if you can cut the slab: a standard toilet, a shower at floor level and a 2 in. pipe. An upflush, if you can’t: it sits on the floor, but showers need a raised base and the SaniPLUS bars kitchen sinks and washers.

Can a sewage ejector pump handle toilet paper?

Yes. Liberty’s manual says human waste and toilet paper are permitted. It bars wipes, feminine products, towels, floss and swabs in its non-grinder systems. A grinder pump, like the Sanibest Pro on the upflush side, is built for those.

What are common problems with upflush toilets?

The SaniPLUS manual names the big ones: wipes and sanitary products jamming the macerator, a dripping faucet tripping the thermal overload and flooding, and no use during a power cut. Saniflo also says to clean it once a year, without bleach.

Can I use a sewage ejector pump as a sump pump?

No. IPC 1101.3 bars storm water from a sewer meant only for sewage, and 1111.1 sends subsoil drains to their own sump. Groundwater, and floor drains that collect it, get a separate sump pump. A sanitary floor drain is different; ask your local code official where yours may discharge.

How long does a sewage ejector pump last?

Liberty, Red Lion and Saniflo don’t publish a lifespan in the sheets I read. Their warranties are the figures they stand behind: Liberty 3 years, Red Lion 2, Saniflo 2, or up to 4 if registered in the first year.

Does an upflush toilet need a vent?

The SaniPLUS and Sanibest Pro do: a 1½ in. open vent from the lid, and Saniflo bars air admittance valves. Saniflo sells the Sanicompact as ventless. Ask your inspector, since IPC 712.1 calls for sumps to be vented.

Does a sewage ejector basin need a vent?

Yes. IPC 712.1 calls for a tightly covered, vented sump, and Liberty says the vent can’t be smaller than the discharge. IPC 918.8 bars an air admittance valve on a sump unless an engineer designed the vent.

How high can an upflush toilet pump?

Saniflo rates the Sanicompact at 9 ft, the SaniPLUS at 15 ft and the Sanibest Pro at 25 ft of lift. Each 90° turn takes about 3 ft off, per the SaniPLUS manual.

Can you put a shower on an upflush toilet?

Yes, on the SaniPLUS or Sanibest Pro. The shower or tub has to drain down into the side inlet, so its base sits at least 6 in. up for the SaniPLUS (7 in. per its manual) and 8 in. for the Sanibest Pro.

What size pipe does each one use?

Saniflo units use ¾ or 1 in. rigid pipe, which IPC 712.4.2 allows for a macerating toilet serving one toilet. Ejectors that take a toilet use 2 in. pipe, and Liberty sets 2 in. as the minimum for a non-grinder.

Do I need a check valve on a sewage ejector?

Yes. IPC 712.2 calls for a check valve and a full-open valve after it, above the cover and reachable. Liberty adds a union just above the cover. The Red Lion kit includes a 2 in. check valve.

Can a washing machine drain into an upflush?

Not into the SaniPLUS; its manual bars washers. The Sanibest Pro takes a washer that drains first into a laundry sink. An ejector basin isn’t limited by either ejector maker’s sheet.

How I compared them

Why trust me

I compare the system requirements with the installation you have planned. Code text comes from the 2024 IPC; figures from Saniflo’s, Liberty’s and Red Lion’s own sheets and manuals.

How I compared

  • Only figures the makers and the IPC publish, read Oct 21, 2026.
  • The three upflush units and the Liberty are shown for comparison only, so they carry no score. The Red Lion’s spec score averages five criteria from Red Lion’s own sheets and the listing match. Warranty scores 10 for 3 years or more, 9 for 2 years, 8 for 1 year and 5 when the maker’s sheet doesn’t print it.
  • Liberty flows are my reading of its printed curve, rounded; Red Lion’s are its gallons per hour divided by 60.
  • Commerce links go to Amazon.

Sources

Related guides